Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let DH talk DS out of applying to Durham Uni?

258 replies

cruddled · 08/01/2021 17:48

I grew up local to Durham University but never considered applying back in the late eighties because I had a stereotyped view of it as being 'posh' and filled with 'Oxbridge rejects' from private schools. Whether or not it was true at the time, it was certainly a widespread view. My DH grew up in Yorkshire and had the same negative opinion of it. We were both first-generation university applicants and both ended up at other Russell Group universities in the north of England, then moved to Greater London for work, which is where we met and have lived ever since.

Now our DS1 in year 12 is thinking of putting Durham as one of his UCAS choices and seems quite keen on the idea. DH is less keen and has privately suggested we talk him out of it, but only because of his past prejudice. I disagree. I know there was a very negative story in the news recently because some students certainly did live up to the stereotype (www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/north-east-durham-university-students-19131519), but I'm generous enough to assume they are in the minority and that the university has otherwise moved on a bit.

Please tell me I'm right and that Durham is now at least comparable with other 'top' universities for inclusivity.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
a8mint · 01/08/2021 14:22

DC applied to Durham this year and had to rank all 17 colleges in order of preference. Quite difficult when you’ve never set foot in the place!
That must be new for this year then

roseteathecatsandme · 23/07/2021 10:07

My DC applied to Durham this year and had to rank all 17 colleges in order of preference. Quite difficult when you’ve never set foot in the place!

I think there is one particular college - Hatfield - that still has a ‘rah’ image. Perhaps by asking them to rank all 17 colleges now, they are trying to mitigate against public school students ending up in Hatfield because that’s the one they put as their first choice. I think they want to get away from this pattern of state school pupils choosing certain colleges to avoid perceived “rah ness” and so on. If they can give people their 3rd or 6th choice college, this gives more flexibility.

We did actually get up to visit Durham more recently. DC was concerned about the reputation, even coming an independent school. We sat in a cafe and people watched. No, the intake is not as diverse as say, a London uni, but there are definitely a good number of international students (from China by the look of it). A few young men wandering round who look like super sporty types, but the vast majority just look like young people you would see anywhere. The contact DC had with the college (a Bailey college) was fantastic - super friendly and down-to-earth. We really liked it. So much character and the river is gorgeous.

WoolieLiberal · 23/07/2021 08:54

I went to Durham!

Yes it has the posh contingent of Ox-bridge rejects but they’re just a (large) minority.

It’s diverse enough and is a brilliant university.

Don’t be put off- a Durham degree is highly respected.

Auntienumber8 · 23/07/2021 08:42

Let DS choose, all Universities have their tribes. Both DH and myself were involved with widening participation programmes within the respective Universities we worked in. The RG University I worked in at the time had almost 40% of students from privately educated backgrounds whilst only around 7% of children overall attend private school.

DH went to Oxbridge he belonged to an exclusive drinking club all members had gone to a few select private schools. I went to a state school and we met when junior members of staff at a RG University. Stuff like those drinking clubs are tackled these days and banned.

On a lighter reading the word rah which I have not heard for years reminded me of the University Challenge episode of The Young Ones, stereotypes abound.

Nengineer · 23/07/2021 07:12

It wasn't a very exciting one I'm afraid. He was one of two.

shallIswim · 23/07/2021 05:46

@a8mint

These days, they have to rank all 17 colleges in order of preference. Do they DD is a first year and didn't do that- she only had to name one.

Objectively overall the average OXbridge student is more academic than the average Durham student, but there is a massive overlap

5 years ago now but DD only had to select one college. Straightforward choice - want catered, a guaranteed single room and modern feel so went for Van Mildert!
Notwavingbutdrowing3 · 23/07/2021 00:20

I'm poor, I got full grant. I went to Durham uni 30+ years ago to one of the posher colleges.
Best years of my life,

My DS is at Durham uni now too. We are poor (albeit I have an amazing professional career) . All state educated, he's at a hill college (much to 'Pick my old college you traitor' teasing !! 🤣 ) He didn't even mention his mum had been to Durham

It is a fantastic university, the teaching and experience is phenomenal, and it's a highly respected uni. DS and I were Oxbridge rejects and thank god we were as I know Durham suited me better.

I am still friends with my Durham uni group (some private educated some state) and we're godparents to each other's children) . It's a different experience to going to a large urban uni but one that suited me and suits DS well. I did my postgrads elsewhere (due to courses I needed) and by far my time at Durham was all round more fun, more thrilling and more cosy.

Yanbu to ask your DH not to put his prejudice onto DS. Quite right to let DS choose without pressure. It may help him hugely to experience different backgrounds.
I know my DS appreciates it and so did I.

a8mint · 22/07/2021 23:55

These days, they have to rank all 17 colleges in order of preference. Do they DD is a first year and didn't do that- she only had to name one.

Objectively overall the average OXbridge student is more academic than the average Durham student, but there is a massive overlap

Prairielake · 22/07/2021 20:51

A lot of stereotyping on this thread. Not all private school children are ‘rah’ as you put it. Not all state school children are down to earth. My child is at a state school. Objectively she is privileged and more so than many children at private schools. Boarding school may be posh but it can also be very tough for children there at times. I went to one and would have had a far easier run at a middle class secondary school with both parents alive and the other not working away.

ShitPoetryClub · 22/07/2021 20:36

One of ours was due to start at Durham in 2020 but backed out last minute after being offerred a degree apprenticeship. Four of his friends went, all from the same state school in the Midlands. None of them are particularly well off but they are all loving it.

Notebooksarefabulous · 22/07/2021 19:48

Check out Jack Edwards channel on you tube - hes finished uni now but he was at Durham and had a fabulous time. Hes a state school boy from somewhere "in the south" - so not posh and not northern either. Loads of his videos a couple of years ago were about how he was getting on at uni.

shallIswim · 22/07/2021 18:36

Gosh and I remember the 'what school did you go to?' question at my (concrete) university. It was only ever asked by students who went to a small group of private schools who were trying to find their tribe. I suppose I should be flattered I was ever asked!

shallIswim · 22/07/2021 18:34

It's worth noting that the Oxbridge reject moniker doesn't always work in that some students (my DS!) get into Oxbridge (Fenland Poly in his case) and get rejected by Durham.
So careful with that old stereotype!

zlk02 · 22/07/2021 18:09

“the state intake erected” - sorry, not sure where “erected” came from!

zlk02 · 22/07/2021 18:08

I think Durham has possibly changed since some MN posters went there? Didn’t it used to be the case that you would write your top College choice only on the application? These days, they have to rank all 17 colleges in order of preference. What this means is a much more balanced state / independent cohort across all the colleges, it’s no longer the case that the Bailey colleges are more “rah” than the Hill colleges for this very reason. They balance out the sporty ones, the science-types, the potential “rahs”, the state intake erected etc across colleges in an attempt to minimise the OPs concerns.

Also, so what if many / most are “Oxbridge rejects?” About 80% of those who have the grades to apply to Oxbridge will be rejected and this is a matter of fact. They all have to go somewhere! They will obviously still go on to get top grades at other unis. The fact they are “Oxbridge rejects” at Durham means one thing - a university intake with all A* / A grades! What’s bad about that? Would you rather be at a uni that attracts those with more mediocre grade profiles and where nobody had resilience to apply to Oxbridge in the first place?

There will be just as many Oxbridge rejects at Imperial, LSE etc too. Hardly does them any harm!

The fact is, Durham often comes third or in the top 5 for most subjects in the uni league tables. This is why it’s popular and why it attracts many students who, on another day and with a fair wind blowing, might have been accepted to Oxbridge. It’s hardly an exact science!

There will be Oxbridge rejects at other unis too such as Bristol, Bath, Manchester, Warwick, UCL, Exeter etc etc. So what? A uni with less or no Oxbridge rejects only suggests that it’s less appealing to the most able students.

It’s a very pretty, historic town and very peaceful. Could be considered a bit too small for some.

TonTonMacoute · 22/07/2021 17:43

Well, is your DH expecting your DS to live and work for ever in some sort of strange existence where he will never meet anyone who went to public school?

Thought not.

Let him apply and visit and make his own mind up.

emilylily · 22/07/2021 17:21

@Bialetti

I went to Edinburgh where there was a big yah (or rah) contingent. They all seemed to have nicknames like Bobo and Roly, and hung out together in a huge clique. I’ll never forget meeting a few in Fresher’s‘ week and one asking me ‘What school did you go to?’ I can still picture her expression of pity and horror when she realised I had been to a …. gasp … comprehensive Grin But there were all sorts of folk at Edinburgh, each to their own! Had the best time ever and met all kinds of interesting people from every sort of background. I’m sure it would be the same at Durham.
I did too and I thought I remembered them being called 'Yahs' rather than 'Rahs'!
newnortherner111 · 22/07/2021 16:57

Do you think your DS will be happy with less daylight in winter and slightly lower temperatures? Same applies if he has considered other universities further north of Durham.

shallIswim · 22/07/2021 16:47

@Nengineer

My sister went to a rah university and slept with someone who went on to be prime Minister. It's been useful at times as she stayed it touch.
You can't leave us hanging.. at least tell us the name of the PM!!
WhoKnew19 · 22/07/2021 16:41

Honestly, your DS would be fine at one of the hill colleges, as others have said if wanting to avoid the 'rah' contingent. OTOH, isn't it useful to experience living and studying with people from all walks of life?

Carrysymons · 22/07/2021 15:17

Your husband should keep his prejudices to himself and let your son decide. Inverted snobbery

LittleGwyneth · 22/07/2021 15:00

I can't imagine how you could want to compromise your child's education on the basis that you regard a university as 'too posh'. He'll be applying to five places. Don't try and drag him back into his 'place' because you've got prejudices about a place.

Maggiesfarm · 22/07/2021 14:44

Well that is a result, Nengineer :-).

Nengineer · 22/07/2021 13:14

My sister went to a rah university and slept with someone who went on to be prime Minister. It's been useful at times as she stayed it touch.

Skysblue · 22/07/2021 09:30

It’s up to him I guess. I wouldn’t make him feel he isn’t posh enough to go.

That said it is definitely a preferred choice for ‘rah’ families who didn’t get into Oxbridge. I would be a bit disappointed if my son chose Durham, I think there are better unis but his call. Maybe explore wirh him what he likes as about it.