Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Mumsnet isn't any better than Tattle life?

218 replies

DebbieDowner101 · 08/01/2021 17:38

The site claims to be "commentary and critique of people who chose to monetise their lives as a business and release it to the public domain"

From my time on the site I've found it to be just that. Honest, and well measured critique of someone who has chosen to market themselves and/or their families online.

The threads I've seen via Instagramers claiming to be bullied has just been people giving a perfectly reasonable negative opinion on them, or something they have done. Surely if you are putting yourself online to gain followers you accept the good and the bad, and that not everything negative is bullying, still just an opinion?

Mumsnet on the other hand claims to be a resource of support for parents, but I regularly see posters jumped etc usually on a perfectly reasonable post.

AIBU to think Mumsnet isn't any holier?

OP posts:
Saoirse7 · 09/01/2021 10:53

[quote wonderup]@Saoirse7 why do you read them?[/quote]
Curiosity I suppose.

There's a couple of threads about local bloggers that are tame and I find interesting. I also like to read the threads on the more famous people I follow on Instagram to see if I agree with any of their assertions. I just find the obsessiveness and nastiness of some posters a bit unsettling.

Sparklingbrook · 09/01/2021 10:50

Is Tattle/Tattle life moderated at all?

wonderup · 09/01/2021 10:47

@Saoirse7 why do you read them?

longwayoff · 09/01/2021 10:34

Ohhhhh. Schoolgirl obsessions.

Saoirse7 · 09/01/2021 10:28

Tattle is fierce.

The Mrs Hinch threads so so unsettling. The last 3 threads absolutely annihilate Mr Hinch for apparently having a nose job, ripping him to shreds for his old nose. They come up with theories and run with them. They take screenshots and analyse them and compare to ones from months ago they must keep on their phone. The behaviour and time spent by some posters is unhealthily obsessive.

They claim to be nice people, that's only to each other. They are so vicious and nasty about instagrammers it is unreal.

year5teacher · 09/01/2021 10:06

I’ve also seen people lay into a YouTube soon after her dad died for things like having bad lip fillers/veneers. Like - whatever you think she’s done, it’s nowhere near as scummy as what you’re doing right now.

Sparklingbrook · 09/01/2021 09:43

The two sites sound so dissimilar I’m not sure why the comparison at all.

Meepmeeep · 09/01/2021 09:41

If you dare to say anything even slightly supportive in support of the topic of the thread they’ll come for you. One thread I quite enjoyed they criticised the woman for showing off new make up she’d bought but one of them decided it wasn’t new she was just showing off things to brag so they all jumped on that bandwagon to slate her. I happen to be a big fan of the brand and knew the item had been released just that week so mentioned that. Definitely no way she would have been gifted it - not a chance. Anyway I was torn apart for sticking up for her to the point I was accused of being her - all for saying it was indeed new make up. They are obsessive weirdos in a lot of cases.

wonderup · 09/01/2021 09:31

I've read plenty of unpleasant and unsavoury comments on here about people in the public eye - politicians, royals, to give just 2 examples.

Yes & Ive participated.
I've never used Tattle just know of it from here & I don't use insta anymore.
I have noticed on MNs though that SM is seen more favourable eg humble bragging is fine which is odd since MN posters can be very judgey about what you call pudding.
I think a lot of people like to be influenced or want to become one 🤷‍♀️

kurtrussellsbeard · 09/01/2021 09:03

It's truly horrible. There's a local influencer here and it's a total pile on about how much fatter she is in real life etc etc.

It's just jealous arseholes. What is it to anyone else how they choose to earn a living. All the faux concern over monetising children is laughable.

SabrinaMorningstar · 09/01/2021 01:56

I looked at Tattle when they kept starting their stalkerish threads over here. It's a site that doesn't help anyone. It's bitchy, nasty and stalkerish. And even though it claims to be about exposing influencers, it seems to actually focus on tearing apart women in the public eye. It's a cesspit of misogyny.

AIBU is the place where trolls and gfs descend on MN. It isn't representative of the rest of the site.

Across the rest of MN, lots of posters receive excellent advice and support every single day.

Quaagars · 09/01/2021 01:38

All of these things have nothing to do with calling out bloggers for shady behaviour which is what people say tattle is for

Exactly
As my earlier comment said - Instagram threads are a "genuine concern, just worried about if they're displaying their advertising correctly" but when you scratch further, it really isn't.
I know that sounds tin foil hatty but it's true lol

Quaagars · 09/01/2021 01:35

If your teenage daughter made relentless fun of another girl’s appearance, then said ‘well she shouldn’t be flaunting pictures of herself on social media if she can’t take it’, I doubt people would be as sympathetic.

Exactly.
There's no difference.

WRT Hinch, personally I'm much more offended by her blatant breaches of Covid guidelines, manipulation of her sheep, exploration of her child, and claims that her fame just happened when in fact it was carefully engineered by her and her husband from day 1. Oh and all her cleaning tips were stolen from other people/ sites. Much like her mate Stacey Solomon nicked all her craft ideas from Pinterest

Breach of Covid guidelines - you what? Where?! Genuinely interested (admittedly, haven't watched IG stories as much this past week or so due to Christmas, but haven't seen anything like that!)
"Manipulation of her sheep" - again, what? Grin Are you referring to sometimes she'll advertise something and people buy it on the back of that?
Not done so myself if so but what's wrong with people buying something they think they'll like Confused

grassisjeweled · 09/01/2021 00:59

Sounds awful

Grenlei · 09/01/2021 00:57

I've read plenty of unpleasant and unsavoury comments on here about people in the public eye - politicians, royals, to give just 2 examples. Why is that acceptable and tattle isn't? Where's the difference?

And why is it acceptable for someone to monetise their child? Isn't that exactly something that person should be held to account for? Christ there are posters on here who get upset if a family member shares their child's photo with another relative, how do you square that with someone sharing their child's image on a daily basis with millions, and using that child as a cash cow? (this applies to all the parents on there who are at this, they're all as bad as one another). Where are the child's rights in all of that?

Sinful8 · 09/01/2021 00:44

I'm in favour of sites like tattle, over time they will be quite useful for building a database of future stalkers.

Circumlocutious · 09/01/2021 00:26

@Grenlei

What's despicable about it?

WRT Hinch, personally I'm much more offended by her blatant breaches of Covid guidelines, manipulation of her sheep, exploration of her child, and claims that her fame just happened when in fact it was carefully engineered by her and her husband from day 1. Oh and all her cleaning tips were stolen from other people/ sites. Much like her mate Stacey Solomon nicked all her craft ideas from Pinterest.

Right. I’ve noticed that people on Tattle don’t like to talk about their behaviour and prefer to simply deflect. The implicit defence is ‘we’re bad, but the Instagrammers are much much worse’.
OuiOuiKitty · 09/01/2021 00:20

No. There was a thread about an intstagrammer/YouTuber who had to deliver her baby early due to having covid who was then put into a coma the next day(and as far as I know is still in a coma over a week later) and some posters decided it was still OK to slate her. That isn't OK, a 30 year old first time mum fighting for her life and a premature baby without his mum beside him. There is a time and a place and that wasn't the time or place.

Another example I have seen is of a blogger who says she suffers from mental health problems continually being called fat, lazy, disgusting. Her body constantly criticised, her 'fat fingers' being called disgusting, being called greedy.

All of these things have nothing to do with calling out bloggers for shady behaviour which is what people say tattle is for. I've seen the tattle huns patting themselves on the back for so supportive of each other as they compare how difficult their lives are to whichever blogger they are slating. Maybe they are supportive to each other but if they think a lot of their posts aren't nasty and serve any purpose other than to amuse themselves they are kidding themselves.

kurtrussellsbeard · 09/01/2021 00:19

@Grenlei

You've just illustrated beautifully what's despicable about it.

All that stuff about her child hating her? Makes my skin crawl.

It's an appalling site.

Grenlei · 09/01/2021 00:13

What's despicable about it?

WRT Hinch, personally I'm much more offended by her blatant breaches of Covid guidelines, manipulation of her sheep, exploration of her child, and claims that her fame just happened when in fact it was carefully engineered by her and her husband from day 1. Oh and all her cleaning tips were stolen from other people/ sites. Much like her mate Stacey Solomon nicked all her craft ideas from Pinterest.

africanantelope · 09/01/2021 00:13

Hold on a minute. Have the people who decide to talk/post negatively about other people on any site never been taught 'if you've got nothing nice to say, don't say anything at all' surely to live in a live and let live world would be nicer? Why do they have the right to say negative things just because somebody wants to post something about their life or their family online? Just scroll on by or block if you don't like it surely?

kurtrussellsbeard · 09/01/2021 00:07

The hinch stuff is despicable.

So is some of the stuff about much lower level influencers.

It strikes me as a bunch of nasty, jealous, arseholes to be honest.

Circumlocutious · 09/01/2021 00:07

Have just clicked on a random thread in the IG section, 30 seconds, see this post. Completely unhinged. The consensus on MumsNet is that Health Visitors should be taken with a pinch of salt and can say all sorts of rubbish at times. But you have posters handwringing and espousing extreme opinions that they probably don’t believe in, just to keep tearing into an Instagrammer.

To think Mumsnet isn't any better than Tattle life?
Grenlei · 09/01/2021 00:07

Some of the MIL threads would be pretty identifiable to any family members.

I don't think anything on Tattle is bullying. Saying for exampl that someone who's had (but denies) multiple plastic surgeries looks terrible is honest comment. I've certainly never seen any comments about children's looks on there and anything like that isn't tolerated. One idiot influencer who's currently on holiday with her sunburnt baby has been called out for not keeping her out of the sun, but no one has said anything about how the baby looks (only that she's bright red, because she is).

If any bullying goes on, it mostly comes from influencers themselves...encouraging their followers to abuse and doxx anyone who dares criticise them, to write to those people's employers, involve their families, make the same comments they're bleating about.

And these influencers aren't in the public eye because they're an actor, singer or sportsperson. They don't need an Instagram page. Why the need to share with everyone what you do all day? (Other than that it's an easy way to make a living if you can't be bothered to get a proper job Hmm)

Circumlocutious · 08/01/2021 23:57

It’s highly unsavoury to be an adult woman incessantly bitching about another woman’s appearance, age and mannerisms. I suspect Tattle posters know that; which is they a) like to pretend they’re undertaking a purely noble cause, or b) admit that it’s a guilty pleasure that they would never confess to.

If your teenage daughter made relentless fun of another girl’s appearance, then said ‘well she shouldn’t be flaunting pictures of herself on social media if she can’t take it’, I doubt people would be as sympathetic.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread