Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Mumsnet isn't any better than Tattle life?

218 replies

DebbieDowner101 · 08/01/2021 17:38

The site claims to be "commentary and critique of people who chose to monetise their lives as a business and release it to the public domain"

From my time on the site I've found it to be just that. Honest, and well measured critique of someone who has chosen to market themselves and/or their families online.

The threads I've seen via Instagramers claiming to be bullied has just been people giving a perfectly reasonable negative opinion on them, or something they have done. Surely if you are putting yourself online to gain followers you accept the good and the bad, and that not everything negative is bullying, still just an opinion?

Mumsnet on the other hand claims to be a resource of support for parents, but I regularly see posters jumped etc usually on a perfectly reasonable post.

AIBU to think Mumsnet isn't any holier?

OP posts:
underneaththeash · 09/01/2021 20:57

I've had a quick look and it seems to be full of the same people who would actually follow influencers.

Why?

They are clearly paid to market product and you don't know them, so wht on earth would you trust their opinion?

Circumlocutious · 09/01/2021 20:52

@DishedUp

Well yes because it was a 5 paragraph post about everything you hate about Mrs hinch not a disagreement of my post?

There are rave threads but they have about 1/10th of the engagement of the negative threads. And that still doesn't change the fact that if you disagree with a poster on a negative thread your post will get deleted. The rule is you must post hate on a hate thread, if you do not you get deleted and eventually banned. The threads are insanely moderated!

It's partly the overarching census and endless nods of approval there that I find off-putting. And apparently everyone there is 'nice' and 'not mean' to each other...duh.

The main thing I look for in a forum is diversity of views. So of course, MumsNet has its share of wealth braggers and snobs, but you'll find disagreement and challenge at every turn. I remember a thread where OP declared that anyone without a pension was foolish and stupid, and like virtually every thread here, it result in a mix of views: some in agreement, others pointing out the utter cluelessness of OP to the working circumstances of many people.

But I wouldn't glorify this place either, and yes its user interface is beyond outdated.

Quaagars · 09/01/2021 20:43

Well yes because it was a 5 paragraph post about everything you hate about Mrs hinch not a disagreement of my post?

Exactly lol, how was it a disagreement? It was just an excuse for a rant.

What isn't tolerated is posters moderating threads, and frankly MN could learn from that
People have said that you cannot disagree or post anything supportive on the threads.
When the IG threads on here have been in full swing, people realllllly don't like it if you question them or say something that they don't want to hear.
Maybe you like a little toxic echo chamber where mods boot any different opinions, but here it's good that other views can be heard too.

pringlebells · 09/01/2021 20:31

TL is nicer than mumsnet.

DishedUp · 09/01/2021 20:29

Well yes because it was a 5 paragraph post about everything you hate about Mrs hinch not a disagreement of my post?

There are rave threads but they have about 1/10th of the engagement of the negative threads. And that still doesn't change the fact that if you disagree with a poster on a negative thread your post will get deleted. The rule is you must post hate on a hate thread, if you do not you get deleted and eventually banned. The threads are insanely moderated!

chillibeansauce · 09/01/2021 20:27

@RolandSchitt

There are a few eye opening tattle threads. I can't say the name of one person or it seems to invoke their presence. But it was a person I knew I had weird feelings about, and seeing it all put together rmade it clear I wasn't alone.
I think I know who you mean, worse than Beetlejuice as you don't even have to say their name thrice Grin
Grenlei · 09/01/2021 20:23

Is it a 'rant' because I disagree with you? What a patronising turn of phrase.

If you've been on Tattle you should know there are many rave threads too about influencers etc. It's disingenuous to say you can't disagree, of course you can and people do. What isn't tolerated is posters moderating threads, and frankly MN could learn from that.

NotABridezillaToBe · 09/01/2021 20:16

I think tattle depends on the threads. The hinch ones seem a bit insane, the Meghan ones just vile, but the Jack Monroe ones are hilarious. It’s no different to MN, some corners attract a better quality of poster than others!

DishedUp · 09/01/2021 20:08

@Grenlei but here you go again, writing a rant about a total stranger. Most people really don't care.

There's plenty of people I dislike- say piers Morgan. He's a wanker. If he comes up in conversation I might be like "oh what a wanker' but what I don't do is hate watch gmb every morning, go on a forum to post the minutae of piers Morgan misendevours, the blueprint of his house etc. Messaging piers local council to say he's broken a lock down rule, or not home educated his kids. That's obsessive, stalkerish behaviour and quite frankly unhealthy.

One of the rules of tattle is you are not allowed to disagree. You aren't allowed to post positive comments on a negative thread. Anything combative gets deleted. Its an echo chamber of hate. You aren't 'calling anyone out' or doing any kind of public service

BlackBucketOfCheese · 09/01/2021 19:56

And the formatting + lack of edit button on MN is prehistoric.

BlackBucketOfCheese · 09/01/2021 19:55

It's like an ethical dilemma. Which is less virtuous..
Earning money through a public image?
or
Spending hours tearing apart the minutiae of a stranger's life, looks and family?
To most people it's obvious where the moral compass would land but Tattlers skew to the opposite.

It’s an ethical dilemma. Which is less virtuous...
Raising your children on the internet without their permission or consent (from birth), exposing their entire life to millions of people and then profiting from their potential sexuality or gender confusion.

Or

Questioning if filming your children every day of their life and then making money from it to buy fancy cars to sell for a huge loss and emotionally abuse your children, is fair and right?

namechangetheworld · 09/01/2021 19:44

I enjoy reading Tattle, but have never posted there. Most of the posters seem respectful of each others points of view, and you don't see any of the sneering nastiness that is often found on here (and no, it isn't just restricted to AIBU.)

Gossiping about celebrities (and I use that term loosely) who have chosen to live their lives in the public eye for profit is arguably more morally sound that ripping apart some poor single mother who has posted for advice under the guise of "being honest."

Quaagars · 09/01/2021 19:33

You despise someone you've never met?
Why?
That mentality is completely beyond me. sorry.

SabrinaMorningstar · 09/01/2021 19:32

Surely the question is would you like your content to put money into your own pocket and the coffers of Youtube?
Or would you like your content to make women less likely to participate in public life and put money into the coffers of persons unknown? Hmm

truetuesdays · 09/01/2021 19:31

I love tattle

But I do despise Mrs Hinch and a lot of the other influencers they tear to shreds in any case!

Grenlei · 09/01/2021 19:28

If by sales you include any MLM type stuff then I absolutely wouldn't consider that either legitimate or a career either.

SabrinaMorningstar · 09/01/2021 19:27

It's like an ethical dilemma. Which is less virtuous..
Earning money through a public image?
or
Spending hours tearing apart the minutiae of a stranger's life, looks and family?
To most people it's obvious where the moral compass would land but Tattlers skew to the opposite.

I also find it interesting that they never turn that scrutiny on the people behind Tattle. I mean if your publicly proclaimed reason d'etre is to call for more transparency from everyone on the internet, why is Tattle shrouded in misinformation and disinformation about its founder?

Grenlei · 09/01/2021 19:26

Being an Instasham influencer is not a career. If you think it is, presumably you'd be happy if your teenager said actually I'm not going to uni/ seek a job, I'm going to stay at home and build my following on Insta/YouTube etc?!

I highly doubt it.

Quaagars · 09/01/2021 19:22

It is an honest living. At least the same as working in PR, advertising, sales, promotions etc. Just because you don't like it doesn't make it not honest or a career

This

Quaagars · 09/01/2021 19:20

Someone posted the blueprint of Mrs Hinch's house plans today

Jeez
However much people protest "it's just being worried about the ads, are they being displayed properly, this next level shit underneath is what it's really all about.

Circumlocutious · 09/01/2021 19:19

@Grenlei

I've never received a single unpleasant comment on Tattle, I feel far more community on there. On MN I've previously been called a liar, fantasist, mentally disturbed, slutshamed and worse. I actually stopped posting entirely for a few years as a result. I post a lot less frequently now and stick to certain threads.
Well obviously, if you’re part of the clique you’re ‘safe’ aren’t you? It’s not hard to understand. You’ve established an ‘in-group’ and you have a clearly defined, external target. I don’t see that as in inherent virtue of any community. Would much rather that it’s self-reflecting and is capable of critically interrogating its own practices and traditions.
kurtrussellsbeard · 09/01/2021 19:18

Doesn't make it not honest that should read

kurtrussellsbeard · 09/01/2021 19:17

Of course there's a sense of community on Tattle. Everyone is united in hatred and jealousy. That shit takes hold of insecure people deeply.

Why would anybody be googling companies house to get these peoples' addresses. That is VERY disturbing behaviour.

It is an honest living. At least the same as working in PR, advertising, sales, promotions etc. Just because you don't like it doesn't make it honest or a career.

Saoirse7 · 09/01/2021 19:16

@Quaagars

From obtaining copies of their birth certificates to contacting local businesses to try and obtain info about her or cancel appointments she’s made. Shock Not surprised though as from the IG threads on here before some of them got pulled people were doing the exact same type of shit like publishing addresses etc, it's insane
Someone posted the blueprint of Mrs Hinch's house plans today. 🤯

I completely agree with outing these instahuns for advertising crap without using the correct tags etc. However, some of what I read is so beyond the pale.

Grenlei · 09/01/2021 19:11

I've never received a single unpleasant comment on Tattle, I feel far more community on there. On MN I've previously been called a liar, fantasist, mentally disturbed, slutshamed and worse. I actually stopped posting entirely for a few years as a result. I post a lot less frequently now and stick to certain threads.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread