Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Mumsnet isn't any better than Tattle life?

218 replies

DebbieDowner101 · 08/01/2021 17:38

The site claims to be "commentary and critique of people who chose to monetise their lives as a business and release it to the public domain"

From my time on the site I've found it to be just that. Honest, and well measured critique of someone who has chosen to market themselves and/or their families online.

The threads I've seen via Instagramers claiming to be bullied has just been people giving a perfectly reasonable negative opinion on them, or something they have done. Surely if you are putting yourself online to gain followers you accept the good and the bad, and that not everything negative is bullying, still just an opinion?

Mumsnet on the other hand claims to be a resource of support for parents, but I regularly see posters jumped etc usually on a perfectly reasonable post.

AIBU to think Mumsnet isn't any holier?

OP posts:
Holdingontonothing · 10/01/2021 09:38

@Jobconfused

I agree the Sarah Akwisombe thread, whilst not perfect, was and is important in helping women getting back their money. This woman is now setting up a YouTube channel for her coaching scam and will be trying to do it again. Tattle was the only place her former clients could come together, after being silenced and blocked on other platforms.
And that's where Tattle can be so good. Yes there's lots of bitchy threads, but that one has been a real force for good as it has helped people get money back, cut off her subsequent activities and also put people in touch with investigative journalists who have done a great job covering the story, hopefully warning off other women from her in the future.
Beefcurtains79 · 10/01/2021 09:16

The alcoholism thread on tattle is amazing, full of supportive posters really trying to help each other and sharing experiences.
It’s a wonderful support if you have a family member or friend struggling.

TopBants · 10/01/2021 08:51

@Mumsn0t Have you considered posting in flouncer's corner? Keeps your flounce for posterity, so you can find it again easily when you return to our little viper nest.

Have a nice day. Smile

Mumsn0t · 10/01/2021 08:47

I don't actually like mumsnet. Infact I think today is the day I work out how to unsubscribe from the emails. I'm not technologically minded.

Every time I spend any time on here I wish I hadn't bothered. When I've finished reading threads I always conclude that while I've always thought most people are actually decent, mumsnet has exposed to me tto the fact that actually, judging by the posts and responses on here (not necessarily individual posters but also situations about friends/family/neighbours/colleagues) then it seems that most people are nasty little cunts who I would have nothing to do with in RL.

I find mumsnet a depressing reminder of the people my children, who it seems I've mistakenly brought up to be nice, will have to battle with their whole lives.

Yep, it's definite. I dislike people very much and it was my limited time on mumsnet rather than a lifetime of experience that has made me feel like this

I'm off, yer fuckers!

stillhappytohelp · 10/01/2021 08:20

If they don't want the minutiae of their lives dissected don't post it all over the gram!

But it’s so much more than that. Fair enough, say you find the fact that somebody does loads of undeclared ads corrupt and manipulative. Whatever. But they go so much further than that about such young women. DD showed me a thread about one of her favourite Youtubers who is in her late teens. Grown women were calling her things like ‘so ugly it makes me sick’, saying ‘I bet she fucking stinks she’s so disgusting’, ‘her face and nose is so fat she looks like a pig.’

Anyone who says this is just a one off and the vast majority of posters wouldn’t do that are kidding themselves. After DD showed me I had a scroll through the pages of a few other big Youtubers. All were being called fat, ugly, smelly, ‘trampy’, with incredibly descriptive results referring to specific parts of their body. One girl had shared a photo of her pedicure on her instagram story and her feet were being called sickening, fat, disgusting etc.

I actually can’t look on there since then or think about it too much because it freaks me out and makes me sad. I’d understand if these girls had committed serious violent crimes but as a PP said, they’re just a bit annoying and post too many ads. If you want to make Youtubers answer for their abuse of the ad system, fair enough keep it factual and do that. But don’t make up horrible nicknames for their children or insult their breasts in horrific detail or spend hours looking for their personal info on the internet.

Jobconfused · 10/01/2021 07:59

I agree the Sarah Akwisombe thread, whilst not perfect, was and is important in helping women getting back their money. This woman is now setting up a YouTube channel for her coaching scam and will be trying to do it again. Tattle was the only place her former clients could come together, after being silenced and blocked on other platforms.

Frownette · 10/01/2021 07:45

I haven't really read it, just had a look at celeb section and there's a thread on PH and MM which is far too vicious, that wouldn't happen here.

I'm not really into influencers so that would go over my head. I'll have a read of the rest.

squeezeapplesmakejuice · 10/01/2021 07:42

@squeezeapplesmakejuice

I've never heard of tattle life
Don't think I'm missing much though Grin
squeezeapplesmakejuice · 10/01/2021 07:41

I've never heard of tattle life

wonderup · 10/01/2021 07:23

There was an IG "boss babe" influencer, Sarah Akwisombe, who scammed nearly a million pounds from people

My friend who is a teacher & is the online safety lead (something like that) teaching it to tweens/teens. She actually uses tattle & similar to research stuff because one aspect of online safety is teaching kids that influencers are not your friends, only there to make money from you & that image presented on SM is often not reality.

wonderup · 10/01/2021 07:15

Messaging piers local council to say he's broken a lock down rule

Tbf the DM ran an article about this & he received a lot of abuse in the comments. I'm sure people will claim, Ive heard presenters say viewers complain about their clothes.

Nonameslob · 10/01/2021 06:46

Of course you won't get anyone being horrible to you on tattle, you're all united in being horrible to other people. If you have anything remotely positive to say you get banned.
I've seen comments on the Hinch thread saying she doesn't love her son, he hates her, putting him in a baby grow that was a tiny bit small was tantamount to child abuse. Others suggesting he was stimming so must be autistic. The comments about her current pregnancy are awful. I thought they were all children/teens when I first had a read as it was all so childish but there are women with grown up children on there!

Holdingontonothing · 10/01/2021 00:36

There is some shocking content on Tattle for sure, but then there's also some really good things happen too. There was an IG "boss babe" influencer, Sarah Akwisombe, who scammed nearly a million pounds from people over the summer and tattle was the only place they could connect without being blocked. The media picked up on it and there's been lots of coverage, but more importantly, experts have stepped in, helping victims of the scam claim back through court as well as cutting off some of the brand partnerships that she used to get credibility to help with the scam. So not all bad.

Quaagars · 10/01/2021 00:24

There's plenty of people I dislike- say piers Morgan. He's a wanker. If he comes up in conversation I might be like "oh what a wanker' but what I don't do is hate watch gmb every morning, go on a forum to post the minutae of piers Morgan misendevours, the blueprint of his house etc. Messaging piers local council to say he's broken a lock down rule, or not home educated his kids. That's obsessive, stalkerish behaviour and quite frankly unhealthy

Exactly. There's a big difference.

Maybe83 · 10/01/2021 00:09

@Liftmusic how do you decide if you have an interest to join or post on a site if you don't read it? Unless of course I am supposed to have some sort of physic abilities I just don't know about.

No what is bizarre is going to the trouble of getting someone who you dont know house plans and posting them online.

Really how little must someone in their life to do something like that.

Liftmusic · 09/01/2021 23:49

I don’t get the Hinch obsession either. I do think there is a fair amount of hypocrisy on this thread as not sure all the posters preaching are always as kind online as they insist others should be.

Heartlantern2 · 09/01/2021 23:46

There is literally months and months and months worth of hate on there for Mrs hinch.

I don’t understand how they are not bored of slating the same person after so long!

Liftmusic · 09/01/2021 23:45

@Maybe83

I think tattle is the cesspit of the internet.

From reading threads on there it is filled with jealous, insecure miserable people who's pass time it is stalking people online.

They are the epitome of school yard bullies. I have yet to see a thread that I dont read and think what miserable and pathetic lifes those people have.

It stems from pure jealousy and misery if you ask me. Wrapped up in some moral crusade.

I have seen some awful awful posts on there with lots of your so right clap on the backs.

It seems you can say whatever you want if its targeted externally, but god help you if you even attempt to disagree with the pack mentality. The moderation is shocking.

I dont think its comparable to mumsnet.

Why read there then? Bizarre.
Maybe83 · 09/01/2021 23:41

I think tattle is the cesspit of the internet.

From reading threads on there it is filled with jealous, insecure miserable people who's pass time it is stalking people online.

They are the epitome of school yard bullies. I have yet to see a thread that I dont read and think what miserable and pathetic lifes those people have.

It stems from pure jealousy and misery if you ask me. Wrapped up in some moral crusade.

I have seen some awful awful posts on there with lots of your so right clap on the backs.

It seems you can say whatever you want if its targeted externally, but god help you if you even attempt to disagree with the pack mentality. The moderation is shocking.

I dont think its comparable to mumsnet.

Liftmusic · 09/01/2021 23:33

Hmm there are some horrible characters on this site too.

I read the Jack Monroe thread and found it very funny and it was nice to see that other people had realised some shady behaviour had been going on.

The other insta stuff I don’t generally take much notice of but I thought it was about calling out the deceitful hidden ads and swipe ups?

There seems to be a lot of knowledge about it from people who allegedly hate the place though...

wonderup · 09/01/2021 23:32

It is an honest living

Is it? I think that's questionable

DynamoKev · 09/01/2021 23:32

@Quaagars

You despise someone you've never met? Why? That mentality is completely beyond me. sorry.
I despise Trump. I don’t need to meet the fucker for that.
OuiOuiKitty · 09/01/2021 23:24

I know the coma thread mentioned by someone, I was there and no people weren't being vile towards her. I think there were one or two people wondering if the statement posted on her insta had been exaggerated. While that's not my view, when someone is known for lying and being deceptive on social media it's understandable that when the truth is for once being told they don't believe it.

So you don't think it is awful to say that a young mother who is a lying in a coma caused it herself? That her being overweight is the reason she is in a coma and her boy was born prematurely. Completely ignoring the fact that they have no fucking idea about her medical history or what is happening in that hospital. If someone here said their wife was in a coma with covid after delivering their child prematurely do you think anybody here would say well it's her own fault because she is fat? Accusing her of exaggerating being in a fucking coma because she didn't get enough attention when her boy was born?

If you think that is OK and you clearly do as you are making excuses for the people who have spouted this shit then you have problems.

If the thread was so wholesome why did it get locked? Anyone who thinks that a young mum in a coma separated from her premature son is anything but an absolute bloody tragedy is not a nice person and that is being polite about it.

plg21 · 09/01/2021 22:37

And that still doesn't change the fact that if you disagree with a poster on a negative thread your post will get deleted. The rule is you must post hate on a hate thread, if you do not you get deleted and eventually banned.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion on Tattle, as you are. Respectfully, the above has not been my experience. Within the thread I follow, there's often a difference of opinion which I wouldn't see if these posts were deleted. Equally, Tattle is a website influencers can choose to look at or ignore, it's not posted on their Instagram feed. And, as with Mumsnet, there is a community spirit; in the last few months I've read posts from tattlers about miscarriages, bereavements, cancer treatment and financial issues and they been supported by other posters.

I agree that personal comments about physical appearance are unnecessary. But, as with people who put themselves in the public eye, people are allowed to have a negative opinion of posts on Instagram. If you post photos of your lounge and say "what do you think guys?", you can't call anyone who doesn't like it a troll or a bully.

They're selling their lifestyle and their family life as a product. It's not quite like putting a crushing review of a company on Trustpilot but most of the Insta influencers are sales people and have to accept the criticism that goes with this, as well as the revenue they earn. I don't have an issue with them earning money from being an influencer but I'm not sure all their followers see through the fairly superficial facade of "we're all friends in this together" (with another swipe up).

NotABridezillaToBe · 09/01/2021 21:10

They are clearly paid to market product and you don't know them, so wht on earth would you trust their opinion?

I suppose the point is that it isn’t immediate obvious to some people and that’s the problem.

I don’t think normal savvy people need to worry about instagrammers, but vulnerable and impressionable people in society need to be protected.

Holding people to account for bad behaviour is fine, but some of the assassination for unrelated issues is way OTT.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread