Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Mumsnet isn't any better than Tattle life?

218 replies

DebbieDowner101 · 08/01/2021 17:38

The site claims to be "commentary and critique of people who chose to monetise their lives as a business and release it to the public domain"

From my time on the site I've found it to be just that. Honest, and well measured critique of someone who has chosen to market themselves and/or their families online.

The threads I've seen via Instagramers claiming to be bullied has just been people giving a perfectly reasonable negative opinion on them, or something they have done. Surely if you are putting yourself online to gain followers you accept the good and the bad, and that not everything negative is bullying, still just an opinion?

Mumsnet on the other hand claims to be a resource of support for parents, but I regularly see posters jumped etc usually on a perfectly reasonable post.

AIBU to think Mumsnet isn't any holier?

OP posts:
Bigbrowedbetty · 12/01/2021 18:32

This is just proof of how desperate they are for content

To think Mumsnet isn't any better than Tattle life?
catchabreak2020 · 12/01/2021 15:27

[quote Nonameslob]@grenlei I've just had a look at the most recent thread on Mrs Hinch and there isn't one mention of advertising or breach of asa standards etc. However I did see the following:

  1. Attention seeking boring basic bitch
  2. Calculating twat
  3. Useless duck lipped twat
  4. A c**t who doesn't look after her child properly and is abusing him
  5. Why has she chosen to have a 2nd baby when she clearly feels nothing for the first.
  6. Her breasts look like spaniels and she looks like a horse
  7. I hope she's getting him (her son) appropriate help. For what?!

I've attached a few screenshots, one being a comment from a so called paediatrician.
I don't agree with putting children on a public Instagram account and I don't have a problem with inappropriate behaviour regarding advertising being discussed but that isn't what tattle is about.
How do you justify these comments?[/quote]
There are LOTS of legitimate complaints on the Hinch threads, I’ve seen many people complain about her not claiming ads. But I think with her, way so more than other eg Stacey Solomon and PTWM, the people are particularly vicious. These people can be infuriating with stuff they do but some people take it too far. Just because their life is hard/they’re going through crap it’s nothing to do with an influencer 😂

IHaveBrilloHair · 12/01/2021 14:11

Nah, not buying it, she wants the money and that's why she stays.
Fair play, but she knows what happens, and did so before she "accidentally", became famous. yeah right
Oh and the vlogger I didn't name is a guy, Tim Tracker, so no, its not just women.
The only reason I didn't name him is because I didn't think anyone would have heard of him.

ElspethFlashman · 12/01/2021 13:36

@BlackBucketOfCheese

The Fleur De Force situation probably wouldn’t have come to light without Tattle:
No question about it. She fucked off to Dubai on 26th December from Tier 3, and then posted content as if she was having a quiet Christmas at home.

And even worse, she filmed a "What I Got Got For Christmas" video that very morning from her 120 acre Georgian mansion, saying it was going to be strange not to see family, blah blah. Whilst she literally had her suitcases packed for Dubai and was about to head to the airport.

Tattle posters spotted a comment from someone on her latest IG post saying "I think I was sitting behind you at a kids show today but was scared to say hi!" and it was posted by a fan who lives in Dubai.

Soon Fleur was deleting comments as fast as she could. From Dubai.

Eventually she had to admit it. But if it weren't for someone on Tattle picking up in that comment, nobody would ever have known. She thought she had hidden it well.

Tattle does expose shadiness, no doubt about that.

plg21 · 12/01/2021 13:20

Sorry, double negative, not environmentally friendly..

plg21 · 12/01/2021 13:17

For the record, I don't have an issue with women making money from social media. Good for them.

It's that grey area where influencers are being paid to promote a product and on a regular basis, don't disclose their ads as such (which is required by the ASA). Mrs Hinch is guilty of being rather lax on that front. Clearly they make their money from selling things, which again is fine, but you see ladies posting their cupboard crammed full with 40 bottles of Zolfora etc and do wonder whether it's got a bit out of hand.

I'm also not a big fan of her constant "Hinch hauls", comprising of a pile of things she's bought in B&M and on EBay. I'm no Greta but it's not terribly environmentally unfriendly to keep replacing perfectly good things you own and it's a bit insensitive at the moment when some families are wondering how they will pay their rent or their bills.

Personally I would hate to post my family life on Instagram, no matter what the financial rewards.

Grenlei · 12/01/2021 13:07

Making a comment about someone's appearance or saying you don't like something they've done or said, or calling them out for Covid breaches and failing to declare Ads isn't bullying or trolling.

There are plenty of examples of trolling, especially on memorial type sites set up by grieving parents after the death of a child, where the family end up being subjected to absolutely vile online abuse. Where people are told to kill themselves, and sent suggestions of how to do it. That is trolling. Not suggesting someone should for example tone down their relentless consumerism in the midst of a pandemic when we are approaching the worst recession in 50 years...!

Plenty of male bloggers/ influencers face similar criticism for similar behaviour - FOD, Chris Ingham (and lots of the other 'family' blog types), Alfie Deyes, the Scottish cleaning guy (Mario?), Sean Pratt, many of the male weight loss accounts (mostly for sending pervy DMs to women/ girls whilst presenting a facade of being happily married). That's just some of the ones I've seen or read.

I know it won't suit your 'they're all trying to tear down women' narrative but it simply isn't true men aren't criticised. However the blogger/ influencer world in the UK is more female dominated, and the number of subscribers or followers generally higher, hence there will be more threads on females and families than purely on men.

Quaagars · 12/01/2021 12:26

,if this stuff bothered her, surely she could take the money and disappear from social media?

Why would should anyone just be bullied off social media by sad trolls?
Wow.
Stay in your place, women.
(How is it that it's the "yummy mummies", the women who dare to have a public persona that get most of this shit?)
You don't really see Dad parenting blogs getting the same kind of pile on as the women ones do.

IHaveBrilloHair · 12/01/2021 11:32

Mrs Hinch must have made a fortune, if this stuff bothered her, surely she could take the money and disappear from social media?
She chooses to still be on it, wonder why?

IHaveBrilloHair · 12/01/2021 11:29

An influencer whose vlogs I used to watch was caught out with racist tweets.
Him and his wife have been shown to be huge liars too, I'd have had no idea.
Jack Monroe is another one I learned a lot about.
Some of these people are totally shameless.

Leftontheboaty · 12/01/2021 10:12

Some posters here are being disingenuous posting a few comments totaly out of context.Hmm

Ultimately tattle is a force for good and balances out the wild west of social media. No it's not perfect, but no forum or social media is and there will always be a few that go too far on every platform.

The worst I've seen is someone talking about a child's appearance and posting a right move listing. Both times it was deleted pretty quick. People do call out comments that aren't acceptable.

Before it there was no record of the lies told and was easy to brush things aside like racist old tweets. I can see why influencers and those that dream of being an influencer hate it!

plg21 · 12/01/2021 07:26

I happened to read some of that thread, In fairness, some of the comment you've screenshotted on the left is taken out of context.

It was in response to a poster's comment that all Tattlers are (in their words) "dole dossing, single yummy mummies...they are jel their benefits money doesn't give them the amazing life stave, Sophie and the others live".

The poster is referring to their job and this quote. And other posters made it clear that being a single mum or on benefits wasn't something to be ashamed of, nor mock.

Not so nice either, right?

And, while I don't condone comments on people's appearance, you have to expect that not everyone will like you if you live your family life on Instagram. In my opinion, Mrs Hinch is fairly disingenuous as far as her account goes but we're all entitled to a different view.

Beefcurtains79 · 12/01/2021 06:49

One could easily make a scrapbook of nasty comments on this site though couldn’t they? The insults on here might be more middle class but are just as malicious.

Nonameslob · 12/01/2021 05:09

@grenlei I've just had a look at the most recent thread on Mrs Hinch and there isn't one mention of advertising or breach of asa standards etc. However I did see the following:

  1. Attention seeking boring basic bitch
  2. Calculating twat
  3. Useless duck lipped twat
  4. A c**t who doesn't look after her child properly and is abusing him
  5. Why has she chosen to have a 2nd baby when she clearly feels nothing for the first.
  6. Her breasts look like spaniels and she looks like a horse
  7. I hope she's getting him (her son) appropriate help. For what?!

I've attached a few screenshots, one being a comment from a so called paediatrician.
I don't agree with putting children on a public Instagram account and I don't have a problem with inappropriate behaviour regarding advertising being discussed but that isn't what tattle is about.
How do you justify these comments?

To think Mumsnet isn't any better than Tattle life?
To think Mumsnet isn't any better than Tattle life?
Holdingontonothing · 11/01/2021 22:53

If it hadn't been for Tattle, this wouldn't have been possible:

www.thewotpod.com/article/new-beginnings-2021

All the scam victims of Sarah Akwisombe's fake million hustle used Tattle as their "hub", and it was from there that the journalists from the WOTPOD made contact to research the excellent 3 piece series linked from the article above.

Yes, there's some crazy baiting of influencers on there, but there's also some incredible threads where people come together to help each other, so there's also real value in the site.

rooella · 11/01/2021 15:12

I was reading Sam frairs thread the other day and someone was proudly showing a private message they sent her about being abroad. I've seen it on fopperholic thread too.

NotABridezillaToBe · 11/01/2021 14:46

I looked at Mrs Hinch’s Instagram once to see what all the fuss is about. It was ridiculously tedious. Anyone crazy enough to follow it and comment on it though 100 odd threads on Tattle really has no life at all.

Grenlei · 11/01/2021 13:49

@Saiorse that simply isn't true.

Sending direct messages to Instagrabbers isn't tolerated on Tattle, as you'd well know if you'd been on there enough to have observed all of the above. Some tattlers do comment on IG feeds but those comments are usually to highlight a breach of ASA standards, or generally asking something the 'influencer' doesn't like - so they delete that comment and block the person who then can't comment again.

A lot of those on IG who cry troll either send themselves the messages they complain about, or cry about someone asking them a genuine question (but one which highlights something they've done wrong - like travelling abroad during Covid restrictions as many of them have - so they don't like it)

Frownette · 11/01/2021 13:38

@Whiskyinajar I didn't see those ones on MN. I remember a thread quite recently but it was more about the podcasts they put out, I think. Can't remember now!

Food & drink on tattle sounds good

Saoirse7 · 11/01/2021 13:21

@Beefcurtains79

They are calling out lots of celebs and influencers for going on holiday over Christmas and lying about it. I don’t think there is anything ‘unkind’ about that.
I would say it depends on the thread. I find the way some instagrammers are targeted for their looks really disturbing.

Rebecca Lamb gets called a fat bitch on a daily basis she had a great figure and would be around a size 10-12. She gets some really savage comments.

Mrs Hinch is a saleswoman and completely knows how to work her audience. I applaud all those who call her out on her poor adherence to advertisement standards. The other side of the coin is the personal attacks she receives about herself and her family.

*Her son's physical development has been pulled apart with some 'experts' claiming he has undiagnosed autism or other developmental issues.
*Being told her son clearly doesn't love her and he has complete distain in his eyes
*Mocking at Jamie having a nose job, constant references to his weight and appearance.

  • The constant comparisons to Stacey Soloman and trying to figure out ways that Stacey has 'thrown shade'. While not the nastiness it is so petty.

It doesn't stay on tattle either. There are lots of people who proudly post the things they have sent to her directly.

Whiskyinajar · 11/01/2021 12:45

@Frownette

I haven't really read it, just had a look at celeb section and there's a thread on PH and MM which is far too vicious, that wouldn't happen here.

I'm not really into influencers so that would go over my head. I'll have a read of the rest.

It DID happen here...the threads here were horrible.

I think MNHQ have stepped in and banned them now. Tattle hasn't but you don't need to read or post on those threads. Food and Drink thread there is lovely, plenty of nice threads.

truetuesdays · 11/01/2021 11:47

@Beefcurtains79 100%

Why should they be exempt from the rules?

Beefcurtains79 · 11/01/2021 11:02

They are calling out lots of celebs and influencers for going on holiday over Christmas and lying about it.
I don’t think there is anything ‘unkind’ about that.

BlackBucketOfCheese · 11/01/2021 10:18

The Fleur De Force situation probably wouldn’t have come to light without Tattle:

ichifanny · 10/01/2021 09:52

Totally agree about the Sarah Akwisombe thread on tattle , it was that thread that made people sit up and notice what was going on with regards of a person who had barely run a business in her life charging people for business coaching while having no intention of delivering content . There was no other platform for people to voice their concerns prior to that . Once exposed on tattle her air of credibility completely dissolved and it’s helped people try get their money back . I doubt she will be able to scam anyone ever again after this . Instagram is a unregulated harmful thing in some ways and I think tattle calls it out in that way. The woman is trying to start it all up again and tattle is keeping tabs on that . It’s interesting stuff .

l have no time for the threads like mrs hinch .. tearing how influencers look or their parenting down but it has shone a light on some harmful practices and stopped a lot of bullshit in its tracks. .

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread