Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remind you that you cannot use your au pair for childcare all day every day

111 replies

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 06/01/2021 08:59

Its modern slavery unless you plan to pay them minimum wage for the hours.

I know several people doing this with children under 5 - using au pair for 10 hours a day all day. When they are only paid £80 a week.

I know people are struggling but its doesnt make it ok to abuse another person - please pay your au pairs appropriately if you are asking them to do full time.

OP posts:
TheGoodEnoughWife · 06/01/2021 12:58

Just for a balanced view. My daughter is currently an au pair in America. She is on her second family year (she can only do two years before she has to come back) and it is absolutely fantastic and I would encourage any young person to do the same.

She lived for a year in one state. Lovely family. Lovely children. Light duties. Been paid over what is recommended and so has had money to travel.
She is now experiencing a new state. Again fab family. Goes with them on trips. Lovely children. Light duties.
We are British so no language barrier which helps a lot I am sure.
Apart from the hassle sorting a visa and that I miss her there hasn't been any negatives at all.

1980sMum · 06/01/2021 12:54

Wow, makes me realise how lucky I was when I was an au pair many years back (20+). I was paid £30 then (so £80 doesn't seem much) plus bed/board (had my own room and, virtually, bathroom). I helped the kids to get ready in the mornings i.e. breakfast, pack bags, then had the day free (for language lessons etc) and was then back at home to prepare tea and help with homework etc. Then I had the evenings off unless I was baby sitting which was 1-2 times/week max. So I must have done a lot less than the max ceiling of 30 hours. I didn't have a driving licence so didn't need to do drop offs/pick ups. Reckon the family got a bum deal ;)

SchadenfreudePersonified · 06/01/2021 12:50

@Rhiannon13

Would you work for £4.28 per hour?

OP, you're appealing to people who also think it's perfectly ok to pay a qualified and registered adult £5 or less per hour to look after their children, and who then often feel that they're being 'fleeced' by their childminder because they have to pay 'so much'. When I worked in this field I felt a distinct lack of respect and I'm sure it was because, despite many qualifications and years of experience, I wasn't seen as a professional due to being paid so little. A vicious circle.

THIS ^

A friend is a childminder - years of experienced council checks etc. And people still begrudge paying the very low rate childminders charge - especially if they decided to (say) go away for a month - they didn't want to pay even half rate to have their place kept, even though my friend could have filled her places three times over.

It always astonishes me that people who will happily pay £50 for a bottle of wine begrudge paying a decent rate to get the most precious things in their lives cared for properly.

GoldGreen · 06/01/2021 12:46

@laidbacklife why bother having any employment laws then. Just leave to employer and employee? We don’t because we recognise there is a power imbalance and employees need protecting. It absolutely should not be left to an unscrupulous family. The whole area needs far better regulation and checks.

(I should add I have friends who have had au pairs and they very much act in the spirit of the scheme, but I would say the majority don’t. I have a friend who has just decided to send her au pair back as she’s got a key worker place at school and she doesn’t want the au pair around while she and her husband work from home).

Brefugee · 06/01/2021 12:42

The contract I had with my Au Pair was the above in return for 25 hours' work. I also provided a car as I needed her to do school runs, but she was free to use the car for her personal use, all expenses paid. I don't agree with asking them to do more than these hours but do consider the full extent of their remuneration.

but a large part of her advantage (if not all) of having use of the car is irrelevant now because she has nowhere to go. So there must be some compromise to be had to give her more money or something, surely?

happystone · 06/01/2021 12:42

Yes as per neutral rich pricks tacking advantage of the poor what a fucking surprise.

laidbacklife · 06/01/2021 12:32

It's really between the au pair and the family. The au pair should receive pocket money (circa £100 a week), with all main living expenses covered - ie. all food, board, expenses relating to the children or activities with the family. Then the au pair can also receive free gym membership (ok, not so useful right now!), use of car, petrol paid for etc. We have also paid for English lessons before. But besides all this there is the enrichment experience that it is hard to put a value on. We always take our au pairs on days out, visits to London and other cities, ensure we spend a good amount of free time with her and that we're actively encouraging her to talk and get involved. All this helps build English language proficiency, which is generally the purpose of the stay.
We've never requested more than 20-25 hrs au pair help a week and would offer extra pay at our babysitter's rate if we were to. But, I can imagine at the moment that there are a lot of bored au pairs out there and if he/she is happy to help out in their free time then that is their call.

uninvitedcat · 06/01/2021 12:25

A friend of mine is currently an au pair in London - the children's parents are WFH so she's looking after the kids (two five year olds) for about 12 hours a day, every weekday. They expect her to work on weekends too. It's awful.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 06/01/2021 12:17

I have never known an au pair to put a child in danger... It happens obviously but I strongly disagree with the "often" part.
And, obviously they will have poor language skills. You don't normally go to be an aupair if you are fluent. You go to learn the language and experience the culture.

I do agree though that people do use them in a way they shouldn't and do want certified nanny and more for pennies.

Maray1967 · 06/01/2021 12:17

I was an au pair 30 years ago. I had decent pocket money plus all board etc, trips, holidays, treats with family. I did morning cleaning and helped to prepare cooked meal at lunchtime (but employer did most of it) occasionally ran an errand in the afternoon which employer asked but did not expect me to do and I very occasionally babysit ( kids were at their dads EOW). My employer did longer cleaning jobs herself eg window cleaning and did big weekly shop herself. Kids were both at school. One was a young teen. I helped with kids’ English homework and learned as much of their language as I could. The whole family treated me so well - I went to a family wedding and ladies of the family put on a lovely birthday tea for me. I stayed for Christmas and it was wonderful. That is how an au pair should be treated.

Gwenhwyfar · 06/01/2021 12:14

I'm on the continent and where I am it's common to register nannies at au pairs as a tax dodge. The nannies are getting a lot more money than a real au paid would be getting.

Wherehavetheteletubbiesgone · 06/01/2021 12:07

Absolutely right OP the term Au Pair is quite often used to describe what a qualified Nanny should do on the cheap. They affect the wages of all childcare workers and from stories of what i hear from Nanny friend downright dangerous at times. Often with very poor langauage skills in English and with non UK working practices often causing them them to get the children in their care into dangerous situations.

Personally i would change the law that everyone should be entitled to minimum wage with no car deduction/accommodation in lieu of payment. And actually enforce they have contracted hours and if they are expected to be on call they are paid an additional on call rate like in any other industry.

The people who employ them are often exploiting the most venerable and often jeopardising the safety of their own children. It is the middle class version of slavery and drives down the wages of decent qualified childcare providers.

Rhiannon13 · 06/01/2021 11:59

Would you work for £4.28 per hour?

OP, you're appealing to people who also think it's perfectly ok to pay a qualified and registered adult £5 or less per hour to look after their children, and who then often feel that they're being 'fleeced' by their childminder because they have to pay 'so much'. When I worked in this field I felt a distinct lack of respect and I'm sure it was because, despite many qualifications and years of experience, I wasn't seen as a professional due to being paid so little. A vicious circle.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 06/01/2021 11:33

They usually do about 25 hrs a week, or 35 for au pair plus (ie paid more). They get their “pocket money” - about £100 per week - plus accommodation, food, access to English lessons etc We always used to pay for travel too and a UK phone.

Many families don't pay for the other bits. Most people I know paid their own phone, travel (unless car was part of the deal) and many paid their English lessons. We were very envious of the lucky ones who got lessons paid😁

SchrodingersImmigrant · 06/01/2021 11:30

I don't agree it's good that Brexot made it hard (actually impossible, since there is no provision). It was such an invaluable experience. So it's really a shame. Great way to learn actual functional English.
It should be much more watched and regulated though!

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 06/01/2021 11:27

Andcallofchridtmas:
Allowing even £50 a week to reflect doom and board (I dont believe HMRC's even allows that much) that would be £150 a week for 35 hours work. Would you work for £4.28 per hour? And disallowing a notional amount for the accomodation and food its even less.

OP posts:
AndcalloffChristmas · 06/01/2021 11:23

(Ours were for wraparound care for primary school kids as a pp has mentioned)

AndcalloffChristmas · 06/01/2021 11:22

They shouldn’t have continuous sole care of children under two. They can go and play with them for a bit while a parent is in the house.

They usually do about 25 hrs a week, or 35 for au pair plus (ie paid more). They get their “pocket money” - about £100 per week - plus accommodation, food, access to English lessons etc We always used to pay for travel too and a UK phone.

It’s not a bad deal really! Although I’m guessing their cultural experience is going to be a bit rubbish in lockdown. You can’t put them in sole charge of kids all day every day though, no. They’re not a substitute parent.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 06/01/2021 11:21

Yes yes to previous posters.

The amount that can be taken into account for provision of accommodation is very low where minimum wage is concerned. It's a factor in why live in staff are not common, it's not much of a saving to provide accomodation.

OP posts:
IceIceBebe · 06/01/2021 11:21

There have always been posts on here about someone needing full time childcare and endless posters suggesting an au pair, completely inappropriately. I suspect there are a lot of underpaid, over used, exploited au pairs and I'm glad that Brexit will be removing most of the opportunity for that since au pairs are most often EU citizens.

GoldGreen · 06/01/2021 11:18

Absolutely OP. We have always had Nannies, which has cost us a lot. That is meant we didn’t have much money spare when they were little. The number of friends who got au pairs instead and then expected them to be a Nanny is outrageous. They also would complain when the au pair wanted to be with the family at a weekend.

Apparently brexit has made getting an au pair very hard. To be honest I think it’s a good thing. It was an unregulated scheme which was abused by many families.

FindHungrySamurai · 06/01/2021 11:14

YANBU.
Au pairs can be a brilliant mutually beneficial solution for eg someone who needs wrap around care for a six year old, but they’re so easily exploited by unscrupulous and/or desperate parents who are unwilling/unable to bear the huge costs of employing someone legally to look after their infants for 50 hours a week.

It’s rarely talked about when we discuss modern slavery - people normally talk about childcare related MS in terms of wealthy Middle Eastern families bringing over nannies from Asia. But naice British MN types can definitely veer towards extremely exploitative behaviour and justify it to themselves because they feel they have no affordable legal choice.

Almostslimjim · 06/01/2021 11:02

I agree.

Thankfully I don't know anyone doing this. I do know some people who have asked if the au pair will do some additional childcare due to lockdown, and are paying them appropriately.

MessAllOver · 06/01/2021 10:42

Completely agree, OP. Pay for a nanny and pay them properly.

The trouble is that lots of au pairs are conscientious, responsible young people who want to be helpful and so they have trouble saying no. They are also living with a strange family in a different country and so are in a vulnerable situation.

Parents need to treat them as they would like their own young adult children to be treated. Just because you can exploit someone doesn't mean that you should Hmm.

Alexandrite · 06/01/2021 10:23

Does sound like these young people are being exploited