Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remind you that you cannot use your au pair for childcare all day every day

111 replies

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 06/01/2021 08:59

Its modern slavery unless you plan to pay them minimum wage for the hours.

I know several people doing this with children under 5 - using au pair for 10 hours a day all day. When they are only paid £80 a week.

I know people are struggling but its doesnt make it ok to abuse another person - please pay your au pairs appropriately if you are asking them to do full time.

OP posts:
IceIceBebe · 06/01/2021 14:37

I don't know anyone in real life with an au pair. In fact I didn't think they were a thing since Mary Poppins!!

Mary Poppins was a nanny not an au pair, and lots of people have au pairs. As you can see, it doesn't cost very much!

SchrodingersImmigrant · 06/01/2021 14:26

I don't think it's that much niche since there is around 100k au pairs every year. At keast it was few years ago.

DayBath · 06/01/2021 14:22

Wow. Mumsnet is such a niche site isn't it. I don't know anyone in real life with an au pair. In fact I didn't think they were a thing since Mary Poppins!! This website must skew to the more well off in society.

oakleaffy · 06/01/2021 14:21

@atotalshambles

Well said, OP. Over the years I have seen many families who have used au- pairs in a nanny role. It is really unfair . These are normally very young people who haven’t been necessarily developed the skills to push back against adults’ requests. Looking after young children is emotionally and physically exhausting. I would actively advise my kids to never become an au pair - I have seen so many young people taken advantage of.
Spot on!

It is extremely unfair . Husbands leering at them, and doing nanny type jobs with a fraction of the pay and conditions.

It is exploitation.

SharonasCorona · 06/01/2021 14:20

I was an English assistant in my early 20s in France with the British Council in the early 2000s. 'Taught' 12 hours a week for that I got room and board and €800pm. Bliss.

Fallox · 06/01/2021 14:14

@JustFrustrated

I dont think that she was trying to say all APs are exploited just that some people have unreasonable expectations of somethings like work hours. I've certainly seen them being recommended on mumsnet for fulltime child care for peanuts.

It's the same with any job, the pay should fit the job. If they are only providing a few hours wrap around care for older children that's very different to full time with a baby with limited realistic opportunities to leave the house.

It's a bit like a car wash. Not all people working for a car wash will be exploited, some will chose to work there for the right wage, but that doesnt diminish the other places where passports are held, and people are trapped by awful conditions

middleeasternpromise · 06/01/2021 14:12

The au pair scheme fits a very specific legal position - the financial contribution is seen as pocket money, paying more than the scheme recommended amounts means the host and/or au pair may have to pay TAX and NI. The scheme is meant to be a cultural and language exchange arrangement with light duties as part of the swap - it should never replace a child care need that is in excess of a that description.

Cocomarine · 06/01/2021 14:12

Not a single person who would shamefully exploit their au pair would take a damn bit of notice of your entreaty.

You’re still right, though.

MoreLikeThis · 06/01/2021 14:09

Yanbu

Lots of au pairs are taken advantage of by cheapskate families.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 06/01/2021 14:08

Just want to add that @JustFrustrated either has some chip on a shoulder or misunderstood the op...
It's not saying ALL aupairs are treated badly and exploited. Bit of an overreaction.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 06/01/2021 14:07

And this notion of them being poor? Wow you judge Europeans badly.
I took the "poor" as not financially but as the other meaning.
Poor girls and boys can't really afford to go on these programs

TheGoodEnoughWife · 06/01/2021 14:06

I think, as often happens, because some people are aware of situations where an au pair is being exploited then there are sweeping statements about how awful au pairing is.

Plenty of au pairs have a great experience! Plenty are treated well. As with many many other situations there are some incidences of bad experience but it can and does work well in many cases.

IceIceBebe · 06/01/2021 13:59

And this notion of them being poor? Wow you judge Europeans badly

Is that a joke?

aharddaysnight · 06/01/2021 13:58

I completely agree. I would expect someone doing 40+ hours of childcare to be paid a proper wage, not £80 per week.

As 40 hours of childcare means that they are not really an au pair rather a live-in nanny, they should be paid 40 hours * £6.45 (assuming aged 18-20) minus the maximum accommodation offset of £8.20 per day. This would equal £200.60 per week as an absolute minimum if my maths is correct.

Obviously, it's different if the Au Pair is genuinely only doing light housework and childcare, and are treated as one of the family.

B33Fr33 · 06/01/2021 13:57

So you like your underpaid staff to be grateful for your condescension.

JustFrustrated · 06/01/2021 13:54

Pretty sure my APs have all been happy with us.

Wrap around care of primary aged kids (apart from currently, and she's now on 30 hours)

All day trips paid for, all snacks, treats. Gets paid more than I have in disposable each week. Can have friends and family visit and stay when they want (obviously not currently). And good friendships made.

Ohhh but of course you lot know the truth and that I'm exploiting them all....despite the fact every single one still visits us/calls/sends presents.

In fact I can screenshot the message from our current girls mom? Where she's thanking us?

And this notion of them being poor? Wow you judge Europeans badly.

All bar three have come from very very rich families. But sure y'all know better.

DailyCandy · 06/01/2021 13:45

In London I've always paid £150 a week, it's just a joke not to.

lyralalala · 06/01/2021 13:42

We had an au-pair a few years ago when my youngest was tiny and she was genuinely surprised by what we expected from her as her previous family had taken the piss so massively.

Three times we ended up with a friend of hers crashing in her room for a couple of nights when they either had to leave because things got so bad with their host family.

People don’t respect childcare professionals in this country anyway (you see all the time people whinging about the cost and the sound of parents who are regularly 15/20 minutes late to collect their child is unreal) and that’s even more prevalent with au pairs.

You see it in the threads when people are genuinely surprised they’re struggling to find an au pair when they live in the middle of nowhere, are offering the lowest salary and the least extras. The lack of respect screams through.

ShellieEllie · 06/01/2021 13:40

Have you made a safeguarding alert to the local authority if you know this is happening?

CorianderBlues · 06/01/2021 13:38

@Rhiannon13

Would you work for £4.28 per hour?

OP, you're appealing to people who also think it's perfectly ok to pay a qualified and registered adult £5 or less per hour to look after their children, and who then often feel that they're being 'fleeced' by their childminder because they have to pay 'so much'. When I worked in this field I felt a distinct lack of respect and I'm sure it was because, despite many qualifications and years of experience, I wasn't seen as a professional due to being paid so little. A vicious circle.

The resonates with me. I feel for the (often young) girls working in private nurseries. They get paid peanuts, and no holiday/sick pay either. And no furlough, because nurseries aren't being ordered to close...
Iknowwhatudidlastsummer · 06/01/2021 13:33

Government guideline might be £80 but I don't know any au-pair paid any less than £150 a week (usually more!) with added language lessons, transport obviously. Fair enough it's pocket money, but come on!

Some families are REALLY taking the piss.

Leannethom85 · 06/01/2021 13:29

Imagine Scamming a young woman to look after your kids all the time for 80quid a week, it doesn't matter if she gets free meals, board and use of a car, she's looking after your child because for whatever reason you can't see able to, that's worth more than 80 quid and if anything it's slave labour. pay these young lassies the wages they deserve and if you can't then look after your own children.

littleloopylou · 06/01/2021 13:25

Don't worry, the government hasn't provided for any legal means of getting au pairs post Brexit anyway

Jobseeker19 · 06/01/2021 13:22

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

Andcallofchridtmas: Allowing even £50 a week to reflect doom and board (I dont believe HMRC's even allows that much) that would be £150 a week for 35 hours work. Would you work for £4.28 per hour? And disallowing a notional amount for the accomodation and food its even less.
I think this shouod be highlighted for childcare apprenticeships in a nursery.

They are paid less than this and have to work a full week often without their studyday.

After a few weeks they are treated like full time staff and expected to do the same duties.

After a year they can then recieve minimum wage and the nursery managers act like they are doing you a favour and giving you a big pay rise.

bogoffmda · 06/01/2021 13:13

Completely agree OP - my experience of au pairs is mixed - 4 - some brill some dire ( lasted a week)

I paid £100pw, mobile phone, own car fully insured for school runs and their own use, petrol to cover school runs, free board and accommodation, tube pass for 20 hours per week and paid extra to babysit when needed. That covered school drop off and pick up 3.5 days a week ( from me leaving the house to me getting home) and a few extra hours here and there.

When done properly and not abusive it is not a cheap option - when I looked at expenses it was £700+ per month. ( the car being a killer but essential)

Swipe left for the next trending thread