Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remind you that you cannot use your au pair for childcare all day every day

111 replies

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 06/01/2021 08:59

Its modern slavery unless you plan to pay them minimum wage for the hours.

I know several people doing this with children under 5 - using au pair for 10 hours a day all day. When they are only paid £80 a week.

I know people are struggling but its doesnt make it ok to abuse another person - please pay your au pairs appropriately if you are asking them to do full time.

OP posts:
WhatTiggersDoBest · 06/01/2021 19:07

It’s not “spare money” as you said in your previous quote, it’s the money which having an au pair enables you to earn, and even on relatively low wages it could make sense if (big if I know) you happen to have a suitable spare room.
This ^^
In my line of work, with no childcare (we just moved and have no nursery place) I can earn about £600 a month. With childcare, I can earn £4-6k a month. But that doesn't fit the narrative.
As an aside, we've just moved to Ireland and I believe we have to pay full minimum wage as a PP said, regardless of extras. I approve of this wholeheartedly and think everyone should be paid fairly, and that the age related minimum wage in the UK is a fucking joke given how much is asked of younger people in the workplace.
I always thought that it was mental to leave your most precious babies with someone who you're not even paying minimum wage to and treating like shit. I'd never want to pay an aupair less than what they were worth.
There are plenty of other seasonal "travel abroad" jobs where young people are being exploited, and permanent "get a foot in the door" jobs where natives are exploited too and work all hours but can't live off what they are paid (I had a lot of jobs like this in my early career). But that doesn't make it right, it just shows we need to change all of it.

FindHungrySamurai · 06/01/2021 17:21

@DayBath

Yeah sure. Free childcare hours mean anything to you? I know so many parents who work part time as by the time they've paid school clubs it's not worth it. I've come to the realisation that on MN everyone is way above minimum wage to have these sorts of views.
It’s not “spare money” as you said in your previous quote, it’s the money which having an au pair enables you to earn, and even on relatively low wages it could make sense if (big if I know) you happen to have a suitable spare room.

The difference between a full time job and a 25 hour part time job on minimum adult wage is £4,860 after tax, which would cover minimum au pair pocket money, so the sums do stack up.

Where it really becomes worthwhile is if you can’t find a suitable part time job, so an au pair is the difference between working and not, or if all the better paying jobs are full time only so being able to go full time might get you 40 hours at 10 quid an hour rather than 25 (or a zero hour contract) at 8.72.

The sums are all different if universal credit is in the equation of course.

cheesebubble · 06/01/2021 17:01

@underneaththeash she's 23 and genuinely such a lovely girl! I feel like it's more of an au pair relationship we have rather than a nanny if that makes sense as she's very much part of the family aka eating with us and spending a lot of time with us.

littleloopylou · 06/01/2021 16:54

@2magpies1pigeon Is that addressed to me?

Unfortunately, I can see that there will be loads of competition for the limited number of au pairs that will exist, and my home and lifestyle are relatively modest. I also can't really afford a load of extra visa and health insurance fees.

Au pairing was a really fabulous and relatively easy option for my family as I use my au pair as a sort of mother's helper and treat her as a member of the family. (Plus with European au pairs it has been relatively low commitment prospect as it's easy for them to come for a short time or move home if they don't like au pairing or whatever). The red tape and extra expense involved with the new system, combined with the competition there will be for the few potential au pairs, are somewhat off-putting.

WhatHaveIFound · 06/01/2021 16:35

@2magpies1pigeon

Oh fuck. I wonder whether it will still be possible for UK people to aupair in the EU? I was hoping that would be open to my DC, now that Erasmus has gone. This seems to be the only possibility in terms of having an aupair in the UK, unless they're prepared to stay with you and help out without being paid: The UK Au Pair scheme now comes under Tier 5 Youth Mobility Scheme and only nationals from the following countries are eligible to apply for visas under the scheme:

Australia
New Zealand
Canada
Japan
Monaco
Taiwan
Republic of Korea
Hong Kong
NO OTHER NATIONALITIES ARE CURRENTLY ELIGIBLE.

My DD has just gone to au pair in Europe. She went just before the New Year so that she could apply for a visa over there. If she'd waited until 2021 she would have had to apply for her visa here in the UK and the embassies were in places she couldn't travel to until the lockdown is over (London & Edinburgh).
DayBath · 06/01/2021 16:24

Yeah sure. Free childcare hours mean anything to you? I know so many parents who work part time as by the time they've paid school clubs it's not worth it. I've come to the realisation that on MN everyone is way above minimum wage to have these sorts of views.

2magpies1pigeon · 06/01/2021 16:20

Can you get in contact with an agency in Japan or Taiwan, and try to encourage an application from there?
I've done a quick check and it's possible for UK young people to be an aupair in the EU, subject to conditions set by each country for non EU citizens. But it'll be un uphill struggle I imagine, as it will be loads more hassle for the family that it has been in the past. Oviously higher expenses are involved.

BlairCorneliaWaldorf · 06/01/2021 16:17

I feel for the (often young) girls working in private nurseries. They get paid peanuts, and no holiday/sick pay either.

@CorianderBlues as employees of course they will be entitled to holiday and sick pay. Unless they are at term time nurseries and paid a set number of hours per year to exclude holidays, like teachers are.

And they will be entitled to at least statutory sick pay if they are employees.

littleloopylou · 06/01/2021 16:08

@2magpies1pigeon

And only a very small number of youth mobility visas are issued each year, and obviously many of these people won't be interested in au pairing.

I have basically accepted that my life (as a FT working professional who is also a single mother) is ruined.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 06/01/2021 16:06

Sorry that was to DayBath

Respectabitch · 06/01/2021 16:06

Most families can't magic up a spare 4k a year!

Most families are paying a lot more than 4k a year for childcare until the child is in school. After-school and breakfast club probably runs at nearly £80 a week of you use it 5 days.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 06/01/2021 16:06

That's why she said "lots of people have au pairs", not "all"🤷🏻

Emeraldshamrock · 06/01/2021 16:06

It is crazy unless you can giving them extras.
You must pay an au pair minium wage per hour in Ireland under the W.R.C it stops them being over worked but unfortunately makes them unaffordable for most people.

DayBath · 06/01/2021 16:04

Presumably as well as the extra money you would also need room to house them so a decent size house with spare room? Not necessarily millionaires but you're all doing nicely for yourselves then. Even if I could manage up the money, the au pair would have to sleep in the shed!

DayBath · 06/01/2021 16:01

@IceIceBebe

I don't know anyone in real life with an au pair. In fact I didn't think they were a thing since Mary Poppins!!

Mary Poppins was a nanny not an au pair, and lots of people have au pairs. As you can see, it doesn't cost very much!

You're showing your privilege there. Most families can't magic up a spare 4k a year! Yep, defo only an option for the well off then.
2magpies1pigeon · 06/01/2021 15:57

Oh fuck. I wonder whether it will still be possible for UK people to aupair in the EU? I was hoping that would be open to my DC, now that Erasmus has gone.
This seems to be the only possibility in terms of having an aupair in the UK, unless they're prepared to stay with you and help out without being paid:
The UK Au Pair scheme now comes under Tier 5 Youth Mobility Scheme and only nationals from the following countries are eligible to apply for visas under the scheme:

Australia
New Zealand
Canada
Japan
Monaco
Taiwan
Republic of Korea
Hong Kong
NO OTHER NATIONALITIES ARE CURRENTLY ELIGIBLE.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 06/01/2021 15:50

Isn't it possible for an EU person to be an aupair anymore? Why not?

Brexit. It appears au pairs were quite, completely, forgotten.

2magpies1pigeon · 06/01/2021 15:49

Isn't it possible for an EU person to be an aupair anymore? Why not? It's possible for other young people (from outside the EU)? I imagine there's some paperwork to sort though. The same for UK young people wanting to aupair abroad.
I remember looking for an aupair job in France as a student, and I was offered one looking after a 2 year old for 10 hours a day while the parents were at work, and would then be encouraged to speak English to the parents. The pay was 20 pence per hour.

underneaththeash · 06/01/2021 15:26

@cheesebubble as long as she's under 24, that's fine. Min wage is £8.72 and you can offset £57.40/week as you're paying accommodation.

I thought most potential au pairs had got wise to the fact that they may get exploited. There's very few out there at the moment and they can pick and choose. It's been a few years since I've heard of one of my au pair's friends being exploited.

We've had au pairs for several years. They had their own flat and car, gym membership, worked around 27 hours a week and we paid £118/week (which is the max you can pay without having to register as an employer.)

cheesebubble · 06/01/2021 15:06

We have a live in junior nanny but she only works 3 days a week, works from 9-5 whilst and DS sleeps from 12:30-02:30, I wake him and she takes over at 3 once I prepared the snack as I'm 100% WFH and it's all very flexible, so actual time with DS is about max 6h, usually less. There have been days where we asked to help out until 6 if work was super busy but that's rare.

No cooking, no cleaning required, I do all of that. She gets £50 a day, £150 a week + I cook a nice meal every evening and she eats with us, basically the same rate we pay the childminders. My friend hired her and pays her £10 an hour as a live out nanny & she teaches two kids her native language locally which she gets £50 for for two hours.

She was an au pair before in New Zealand for 12 months - 3 children, 3 months, 2 & 4, after that she was an au pair, then she was an au pair again in England for a 3 months old for 1 1/2 years (obvs the children get older whilst she's there) + 4 teenage kids.

She then moved onto the junior nanny role with us but has a large double room, I cook a nice family meal every night for all of us etc and we're all very happy with the situation. We chatted about money very openly beforehand. As I am pregnant, we decided it's best for her to leave mid /end of February to find a full time live out nanny role because she's very able and I personally think that's best for her and us. I won't need full time care and done need someone in the house 24/7 as I'll be at home and also need the extra space.

She even said she'll probably worse off given that she will have to rent a room in London which is probably going to be £700-800 + bills, she loves food (same as me and we spend a good £500 on food every months for 3 adults and a toddler) + she'll have to travel to work.

I know I'm not paying her loads of money but this was discussed beforehand and we were all happy with the situation and still are, get on really well. It's been a good and happy experience for all of us. DS will move to the childminders 4x a week rather than 2x a week from when she leaves. She knows that once she's gone, we would love for her to help out with babysitting etc whereas then we'll pay her the standard hourly rate given that she's no longer live in.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 06/01/2021 14:55

It can be exploitative, but it can also be really great and valuable experience. It really depends on the family. Some are horrible, some are just normal and some can afford lots of extras. Like everything in life it can be bad or good.

I remember most of the girls and guys having issues found families themselves. I went through agency for extra security.

crosstalk · 06/01/2021 14:54

My gps had lots of DC of French friends coming to stay to learn English (not as au pairs) and they would help as any DC would but not with children. Even back in the Sixties GPs put up several fleeing au pairs whom their guests had met at language classes who were being mistreated. Plus ca change ....

GoldenLabbie · 06/01/2021 14:53

@DayBath

Wow. Mumsnet is such a niche site isn't it. I don't know anyone in real life with an au pair. In fact I didn't think they were a thing since Mary Poppins!! This website must skew to the more well off in society.
Me neither! It sounds really exploitative to me.
Theredjellybean · 06/01/2021 14:44

My dd thought about au pairing.. I was shocked at jobs basically wanting a nanny.
Many many adverts with three or more under fives, and it was full time sole care.
One even wanted overnight care as both parents worked away once a week.

Respectabitch · 06/01/2021 14:42

It's much more of a thing in cities, obvs. Especially London (because young people from other countries want to live here for a bit and experience it; they're a lot less inclined to live in a rural area). I haven't used one myself (although I do have a nanny, and pay her properly) but have met/encountered several on the school run.

And before we get more of a chorus of Not All Au Pair Employers, nobody has said that all au pair arrangements are exploitative, but many are, and since most au pairs are young people living in a foreign country without own accommodation and speaking a non-native language, they are vulnerable to exploitation.