Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remind you that you cannot use your au pair for childcare all day every day

111 replies

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 06/01/2021 08:59

Its modern slavery unless you plan to pay them minimum wage for the hours.

I know several people doing this with children under 5 - using au pair for 10 hours a day all day. When they are only paid £80 a week.

I know people are struggling but its doesnt make it ok to abuse another person - please pay your au pairs appropriately if you are asking them to do full time.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
aliatalia · 27/12/2022 10:18

Hi

Lucyccfc68 · 08/01/2021 19:33

@blueluce85

Put into a little perspective.... But this isn't knowing the person's position, if they have no expenses, they are £80 clear a week.... That's between £320/400 clear a month, not many people have that much free cash after house, bills and food are paid for. They will pay no tax because they don't earn enough (whereas we have to pay tax before paying for food and rent) I think it's a good deal esp for a young person.

You can pay just over £2 an hour for a young apprentice......

It’s £4.15 an hour for a first year apprentice, however where I work we pay them a minimum of £6.72 an hour for those doing a level 3 qualification and those doing a degree apprenticeship start on £18k plus no debt from doing a degree.

There is no comparison between an au pair and an apprentice.

Saz12 · 08/01/2021 19:00

I agree with original OP comment- au pair isn’t a “job” intended as full time childcare. It’s an outdated way for an over-protected young person to do a bit of light work for a bit of pocket money whilst living in a safe, cosy, family environment.

I’m staggered that anyone has the gall to underpay on the basis that “it’s a great opportunity to live with my amazing family in my amazing house to experience the amazing culture of British middle-class suburbia”.

PinkPandaBear · 08/01/2021 18:18

@blueluce85

Put into a little perspective.... But this isn't knowing the person's position, if they have no expenses, they are £80 clear a week.... That's between £320/400 clear a month, not many people have that much free cash after house, bills and food are paid for. They will pay no tax because they don't earn enough (whereas we have to pay tax before paying for food and rent) I think it's a good deal esp for a young person.

You can pay just over £2 an hour for a young apprentice......

Apprentices are paid £4.15 an hour and earn a level 2/3 qualification.
Sloelydoesit · 08/01/2021 13:43

I have an au pair who definitely does not have a hard time. In fact I'm pretty soft on her. She only does childcare every other week but gets paid every week. Usually wrap around care only.
At the moment as I'm WFH I don't actually need her but love having her here. It's like having an older daughter.
However, before restrictions I frequently had a house full of au pairs who came to stay at weekends because their host families weren't great. But now we can only have European au pairs with pre settled status there will be plenty of competition and host families will have to up their game!
Traditional childcare wouldn't work for me due to timings

amispeakingenglish · 08/01/2021 13:33

Agree that aupairs should never be used as nannies, it is wrong on so many levels, agree many too young to stand up for themselves etc. Should be a crime.

amispeakingenglish · 08/01/2021 13:32

atotalshambles
My youngest had a wonderful time at 18 in Spain, 3 families related all got aupairs, introduced them on FB before arriving, took them to wonderful places, meals, theatre their country homes with vast pools. They had a great time. I did get the odd tearful call but she grew up a bit and was only gone for about 6 weeks. You can speak to the people and see them nowadays before your child goes. Years ago I met a guy (70s) who was aupair for Harrison Ford, he said he was lovely. Don't dismiss out of hand. She went through Au Pair World

Justbrutallyhonest · 08/01/2021 13:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PinkPandaBear · 08/01/2021 11:23

@WhatsAParlay

It's not £80 per week though is it? Au Pairs are also provided with accommodation and all meals.

The contract I had with my Au Pair was the above in return for 25 hours' work. I also provided a car as I needed her to do school runs, but she was free to use the car for her personal use, all expenses paid. I don't agree with asking them to do more than these hours but do consider the full extent of their remuneration.

That’s only £3.20 an hour to look after your DC. What jobs did she do? How much would rent be in your area to have 1 bedroom and shared kitchen and living area? Maybe around £100? Even if you paid her minimum wage (£8.72) and subtracted rent, she would still be entitled to more than £80. How much would a non-live in nanny be paid for 25 hours?
SchrodingersImmigrant · 08/01/2021 09:09

@nannykatherine

Also I can’t imagine girls from NZ or AUS come if here to be au pairs .. They come here too nanny and know the difference so will not be exploited ..personally I’m sad that girls from EU can’t come .. but I don’t like to hear of them being exploited .. I was chatting to a au pair last night who is not being fed .. family won’t let her eat their food ... she feels awful sneaking a sand which .. this is inBristol .. so if it’s you .. 😡
If you are aware if someone being exploited, don't just leave them there! There is help and if she is from EU it's very cheap to leave back to her family.

People in this situation need help even if it's just a simple encouragements to leave and offer to help google a plane or bus ticket, not just a sumpathetic nod.

nannykatherine · 08/01/2021 08:56

Also I can’t imagine girls from NZ or AUS come if here to be au pairs ..
They come here too nanny and know the difference so will not be exploited ..personally I’m sad that girls from EU can’t come .. but I don’t like to hear of them being exploited .. I was chatting to a au pair last night who is not being fed .. family won’t let her eat their food ... she feels awful sneaking a sand which .. this is inBristol .. so if it’s you .. 😡

nannykatherine · 08/01/2021 08:49

Au pair schemes are now illegal under Brexit

Greenmandm · 08/01/2021 00:56

@middleeasternpromise

The au pair scheme fits a very specific legal position - the financial contribution is seen as pocket money, paying more than the scheme recommended amounts means the host and/or au pair may have to pay TAX and NI. The scheme is meant to be a cultural and language exchange arrangement with light duties as part of the swap - it should never replace a child care need that is in excess of a that description.
That's in theory... many things are agreed beforehand and when you get here....nothing. I was not even told I should register with a GP or where is it. I was promised to be enrolled in an English course but it never happened as they said I have to pay for it. And my so called "pocket money" £55/week couldn't pay for that.
Greenmandm · 08/01/2021 00:39

I was an au pair 15 years ago when I came to this country and in the contract it was specified that I have to do "light housework", child minding, school run, cooking dinner for the kids, walk the dog etc. all in 25 hours/week. I was promised £55/week, food and accommodation and I was told I will be registered to an English course too. After I arrived here, things were a bit different. I had to clean their whole 4 floor house, iron all dad's shirts, wash their clothes, dishes, barely spent time with the kids and no way I was registered for an English course. I was new here and they took advantage of me because I couldn't speak very well English and didn't know what to do. One day I got the flu from one of the kids and after I recovered the lady said to me that "I DIDN'T EVEN APOLOGISE FOR BEING SICK" even though I offered to do the work like that but they didn't want me around them.
Many au pairs are treated unfairly and are taken advantage off.

lyralalala · 07/01/2021 21:06

@blueluce85

Put into a little perspective.... But this isn't knowing the person's position, if they have no expenses, they are £80 clear a week.... That's between £320/400 clear a month, not many people have that much free cash after house, bills and food are paid for. They will pay no tax because they don't earn enough (whereas we have to pay tax before paying for food and rent) I think it's a good deal esp for a young person.

You can pay just over £2 an hour for a young apprentice......

If they are treated properly it can be a good deal. If they're not, and many are not, then it's an awful deal.
Streamside · 07/01/2021 20:04

Surely the first objective of good childcare is safe and age appropriate care. I've two young people who could act as au pairs and they wouldn't have a clue how to look after a child. I'm incredulous that anyone would be happy for their child to be looked after a poorly paid student.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 07/01/2021 19:42

@blueluce85

Put into a little perspective.... But this isn't knowing the person's position, if they have no expenses, they are £80 clear a week.... That's between £320/400 clear a month, not many people have that much free cash after house, bills and food are paid for. They will pay no tax because they don't earn enough (whereas we have to pay tax before paying for food and rent) I think it's a good deal esp for a young person.

You can pay just over £2 an hour for a young apprentice......

It's not a good deal if you are doing 10 hours a day...
blueluce85 · 07/01/2021 19:40

Put into a little perspective.... But this isn't knowing the person's position, if they have no expenses, they are £80 clear a week.... That's between £320/400 clear a month, not many people have that much free cash after house, bills and food are paid for. They will pay no tax because they don't earn enough (whereas we have to pay tax before paying for food and rent) I think it's a good deal esp for a young person.

You can pay just over £2 an hour for a young apprentice......

Ericag21 · 07/01/2021 19:35

Your children are your most precious possessions or should be. Many will spend large amounts on hair and nails but don’t want to spend out for good quality child care!

Bilboard · 07/01/2021 05:21

It was 20 years ago, she got £45 a week

Bilboard · 07/01/2021 05:17

I know of an au pair who looked after 4 children for a family, they all went to school but the mum was also a child minder, she had 2 under two all day, plus a child with ADD on different days of the week, plus another child who used to do the wrap around care for.
The mum was getting money for this children and the au pair was looking after them plus the housework. Mum was busy on the phone, drinking tea and smoking in the back garden.
Only day off for this young person was Saturday evening and Sunday, after doing all the ironing.
When the au pair left, feeling extremely guilty, the family wasn't very happy and found fault with everything she did. The mum vouched never to have an au pair again, but she changed her mind, and guess what, new au pair left after a few weeks, in a hurry.
Honestly some people are just piss takers.

WeLovePeaSoup · 06/01/2021 23:49

Is it still £80 for a week? 20 years ago I was paid £80 , I was certain it’s much more now. Oh well... Though I was very happy with that money and my family was nice. I worked all day M-F 7.30-6.30pm and looked after toddler twins and a little girl who I just needed to pick up from school.

Hyvsvaar · 06/01/2021 19:31

Urgh

She was paid £100 s week

Hyvsvaar · 06/01/2021 19:30

My au pair 15 years ago worked 830 until 4 min to Friday and only looked after my 2 year old
No chores-absolutely nothing
Plus spending money to do activities with DD
Anything she wanted from weekly shop

Therefore she loved our dd and family and she still visits us in the uk and we have met up abroad for holidays all this time later

Icenii · 06/01/2021 19:20

When I was 18 I was an Au Pair in the US. A 3 month old baby. 0730 - 1800. Not much money. Year before Louise Woodward I think.

Not sure it would be allowed now? Honestly, from socialising with the other au pairs, no way would I use one. Some were good, some appeared good, but you wouldn't want them in your house.