Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish Nicola Sturgeon was Prime Minister.

358 replies

NellyJames · 04/01/2021 14:18

Just listening to her statement to the Scottish Parliament. I don’t want to debate her wider politics or the question of Scottish independence because that’s for the Scots to decide.
I’m just so impressed by her leadership and how clear and concise she is. There’s no waffle, no bluster. She’s just said Scotland is 4wks behind London so the time to act is now before they’re in the same position.

Her manner is just so factual and informative and if I was Scottish or lived in Scotland whether I agreed with her SNP politics or not, I’d be very glad she was my FM. She makes BJ look like an uneducated idiot who is neither responsible nor has the balls to take decisions before the effects are smacking him on the face.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
GreenlandTheMovie · 07/01/2021 10:20

This whole thread reads like bad fan fiction, as is usual with SNP supporters. Cf attacking anyone viciously (they think cleverly) who disagrees with them, the purpose being to silence debate and analysis. Often resort to misquoting particular parts of previous posts and making wild accusations that other people are evil, etc.

What I'm interested in is the SNP's attitude towards human rights. The SNP is very cagey about whether an independent Scotland would be a signatory to the European Convention on Human Rights. In fact, the White Paper on the last independence referendum went out of its way to state that an independent Scotland would only have a "Scottish version" of the ECHR.

For some reason, a lot of SNP supporters get very upset when the ECHR is mentioned now (one of my colleagues keeps an informed watch of social media posts from political factions within Scotland).

It remains a mystery why those in power in Scotland don't think Scottish people deserve to be protected by the actual ECHR but, unlike any other European country, would need a special version, with no guarantee of what it would cover.

The SNP led Scottish Government also objected to the EU led extension of Freedom of information rights to environmental concerns. Although fortunately they were overruled by the UK Government (and the EU would also have taken enforcement action).

So I'd really like to know why the supposedly wonderful Nicola Sturgeon wants to create a country which would be both outwith the EU and not a signatory to the ECHR, and how on earth that would be anything other than recessive for Scottish people? As it would enable less transparency of government reporting on health and education statistics and unregulated use of state funds, to name just two concerns.

Sinful8 · 07/01/2021 02:15

@C0NNIE

"How dreadful, to have a leader fixated on something that they strongly to believe to be in their countries best interests. Whether she is right or wrong is yet to be seen."

I have some German friends who might caution you on this view

@Sinful8 Godwin’s Law means that you lose this debate.

People who glibly and inappropriately suggest that someone is like Hitler need to think a little harder about the Holocaust.

Who mentioned Hitler?

Theres more than one German leader you know

Hollyoakswatcher · 06/01/2021 14:41

I have to disagree, yes she looks good when compared to Boris, that isn’t exactly a glowing reference, I think Joe Bloggs could do a much better job than Boris.

CakeRequired · 06/01/2021 14:11

@Sinful8 Godwin’s Law means that you lose this debate.

People who glibly and inappropriately suggest that someone is like Hitler need to think a little harder about the Holocaust.

Yeah damn, I don't like Sturgeon, but comparing her to Hitler? Confused She's focusing on one thing only (independence) and neglecting education and health, she hasn't started killing people. She's misguided perhaps. Not even slightly comparable. You should maybe re read what actually happened, Sinful8 that is.

WouldBeGood · 06/01/2021 08:37

The independence thing is more the desire of the other wing of the party, the Cherry/Salmond axis.

Though they all keep banging on about it. I don’t have strong views on it now, but I really feel that this year is not the time for more bitter debate and uncertainty, more than already exists.

Let’s get through Covid and see what fresh hell Brexit brings, then fair enough. But not now.

C0NNIE · 06/01/2021 04:57

"How dreadful, to have a leader fixated on something that they strongly to believe to be in their countries best interests. Whether she is right or wrong is yet to be seen."

I have some German friends who might caution you on this view

@Sinful8 Godwin’s Law means that you lose this debate.

People who glibly and inappropriately suggest that someone is like Hitler need to think a little harder about the Holocaust.

ShetlandWife · 06/01/2021 04:52

I have some German friends who might caution you on this view

Lol! Not quite sure that self-determination for our own little country is quite in the same league as Hitler's goal, but I take your point!

ShetlandWife · 06/01/2021 04:47

How come no one wanted her fired for breaking the covid rules?

Because she made the kind of mistake that any one of us could and have. A momentary lapse is entirely forgivable. It's hardly the same thing as a calculated and deliberate breaking of the rules!

Sinful8 · 06/01/2021 03:52

@ShetlandWife

I think she would make a great leader, however she is so obsessed with Scottish independence she can't seem to make a significant impact on other issues enough to be a contender

How dreadful, to have a leader fixated on something that they strongly to believe to be in their countries best interests. Whether she is right or wrong is yet to be seen.

What a welcome contrast to Boris, who was fixated on pursuing Brexit due to the fact that its in his own best interests financially despite never being in the best interests of the country.

(yes, before anyone states the obvious, that is merely my opinion, but I've yet to see any benefits but I see a lot of negatives)

"How dreadful, to have a leader fixated on something that they strongly to believe to be in their countries best interests. Whether she is right or wrong is yet to be seen."

I have some German friends who might caution you on this view.

Sinful8 · 06/01/2021 03:49

How come no one wanted her fired for breaking the covid rules?

Cummings does it and the forum is full off well I'm not following rules amy more if they're not"

Sturgeon does it and the place it happenedhas been boycotted and threatened because another customer reported it.

Santagetinmybubble · 06/01/2021 03:40

I can’t believe when I see English people saying this when her and her party do nothing but stoke hatred against them! I don’t understand it. Have a look at her constituency, seriously. She’s done nothing for them it’s shameful. She gets her face on telly at every opportunity though. Any question she is asked is answered with a sharp tongue and eye rolls like a huffy brat. The divide in this country (Scotland) since the SNP took hold is horrible. I feel people only like her because she’s anti-Boris. I can’t wait to see what comes out re Salmond etc

PastaPins · 06/01/2021 02:47

Absolutely! Boris is a joke!

WouldBeGood · 06/01/2021 02:04

And a random screenshot/ oops!

WouldBeGood · 06/01/2021 02:03

The college of party training

To wish Nicola Sturgeon was Prime Minister.
To wish Nicola Sturgeon was Prime Minister.
To wish Nicola Sturgeon was Prime Minister.
WouldBeGood · 06/01/2021 02:02

I’m in Scotland and do not like her. She’s part of the misogynistic wing of the party and has failed to defend women in her own party subjected to abuse and threats for gender critical feminist views.

She’s also supporting a Hate Crime Bill encouraging people to report supposed “hate crimes”, ie expressing views contrary to what they deem acceptable, including committed by family members in their own homes.

She’s a career politician married to the chair of the party and they exert tight control over members. No contrary views are allowed no matter what. They even have an online college to train members in the party line.

The drug deaths are much worse than elsewhere, and Scotland has the worst rates of poverty, and very low life expectancy in its poor areas.

She sounds better than Boris, but has kept us in lockdown for months and months here, to no avail as our death rates are amongst the highest in the world.

There’s a lot more to Ms Sturgeon and her party than you think, @NellyJames and it’s not good.

blalalala · 05/01/2021 15:49

I'd just like a competent Prime Minister. There must be most of the Tory MPs who could do the job adequately. I struggle to think of any Prime Minister worse than this one- Lord North perhaps?

chergar · 05/01/2021 15:42

I haven't read all the comments on this thread but have skimmed through a few.

I like Nicolas Sturgeon, many of the points raised here (power mad, micron a aging, centre if attention) are actually just her being a leader, the buck stops with her. Giving the speeches and updates herself lessens the mixed messages that can arise when many people take the podium.

She has a plan and follows it through, they may not be popular but she is doing what is best for the country with the limited powers she has - she cannot close international borders, she cannot borrow large sums of money, Westminster has to borrow on Scotland's behalf, all the furlogh money and business grants are still paid for by Scotland, we just don't get a say in how much we can borrow or the terms of the loan.

Drug deaths - drugs are a reserved matter, Nicola Sturgeon cannot roll out the plans she wants as Westminster control the Drugs Act and welfare budget, so the SNP are expected to solve the drug problem but are being denied the tools needed to do it.

As for independence of course that is her goal, why wouldn't it be? Yes I believe independence is the way forward, we cannot continue as we are.

Independence does not mean Nicola Sturgeon and SNP being in charge, in fact SNP will no longer need to exist if independence goes ahead, at which point any party could be voted in, a right wing government, left wing or mixture. SNP are a means to an end that's all.

Norwayreally · 05/01/2021 08:03

Totally agree. She is clear, concise and to the point. Far from the bumbling buffoon we’re lumped with.

ShetlandWife · 05/01/2021 07:51

@Mally2020 ah, interesting you made such a quick judgement and thought it appropriate therefore to make a personal attack.

Based on that alone, I'm not going to bother further. There are other, more obvious, reasons that she would never be PM. But pointing that out would be entirely missing the point of the thread.

Hi2021 · 05/01/2021 07:38

London subsidises the rest of the UK in terms of taxes raised etc , not England subsidising Scotland. As I understand Scotland raises more taxes than most parts of rest of UK outwith London.

Mally2020 · 05/01/2021 05:23

Also she herself has stated she only has an interest to be Scotland's leader and not the Uk leader so she has essentially ruled herself out.

Mally2020 · 05/01/2021 05:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ShetlandWife · 05/01/2021 05:09

@happystone not a chance!

ShetlandWife · 05/01/2021 05:09

She isn't 'beating him' to anything. Her decisions don't affect England in the slightest. Look at the exams being cancelled - Scottish exams were cancelled in October and December. English ones today. Was that her 'beating him to it' too?

For some reason he always makes announcements later in the day. He could change that if he wanted to make announcements earlier than we get ours. He clearly isn't bothered, so why should anyone else be?

Pillowaddict · 05/01/2021 03:20

I've met her several times through work, and she is astonishingly professional, bright and engaged - everything BJ is not. I'm ashamed to be associated with him, and his predecessors to be fair, therefore never have and never will describe myself as British.

I respect her as an individual- unlike other figureheads who have bought their way into power without the ability to string a sentence together