Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 16:52

I’ll leave you be, guys. You make everything so fucking difficult. It was a discussion about different systems that I have some experience so I thought I could contribute but I’m out.

TeaEgg · 05/01/2021 16:51

The one thing my relative said when she heard we were moving here (she was a primary school teacher in Ireland before she retired) was not to send them to an educate together - they don't have a great reputation, although I don't really know why. There are tales of 'Winterval' rather than Christmas etc. which I don't think are true

You don't think there might be the teensiest bit if bias going on if she was a retired teacher from a much more regimented and uniformed environment? Grin

I have an aunt who is in her late 70s now, also a retired French teacher from a convent secondary, and she can't get past the fact that the children at ET schools call the teachers and Head by their first names. That to her is 'disrespectful', as if the lack of the kind of horrifying royal-blue gabardine pinafore, blouse and tie we were forced into in the 80s.

And the 'Winterval' thing is just the same tired old guff that used to go on annually in the UK about 'Muslims cancelling Christmas'.

NothingICanDo · 05/01/2021 16:47

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque I am Irish. I was being sarcastic.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 16:47

I apologise for steering too much of topic but some of this is unnecessary.

What is unnecessary exactly?

SkylightAndChandelier · 05/01/2021 16:46

Can someone please explain what transition year is please. Also the education together primary schools. Are these fee paying? How do education together compare to the Irish speaking schools? Are they as desirable & as good academically as the Irish language schools?

No, not fee paying - although you pay for schoolbooks and normally make a yearly contribution (I pay about 400/year contribution, and about 200/year in schoolbooks).

The one thing my relative said when she heard we were moving here (she was a primary school teacher in Ireland before she retired) was not to send them to an educate together - they don't have a great reputation, although I don't really know why. There are tales of 'Winterval' rather than Christmas etc. which I don't think are true, my feeling it that they just don't do the religious stuff like confirmation that the catholic ones do (my friends tell me even the non-catholic kids get involved with confirmation at their catholic schools).

The Irish medium schools are another thing all together - I'm afraid I don't know if there are Irish medium Educate Together schools.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 16:45

@NothingIcando

Yes but as we've learned today...it was all about expansion and progress hmm

I am of Irish descent. At no point did I say I thought this.

IceIceBebe · 05/01/2021 16:45

Can someone please explain what transition year is please
It's a year between junior cert (GCSE level ish) and Leaving cert (ALevel ish) where you do less academic work and more work experience, civic and social education, group projects etc. Its meant to make for a more well rounded person.

Also the education together primary schools. Are these fee paying?
No, they are non-denominational

How do education together compare to the Irish speaking schools? Are they as desirable & as good academically as the Irish language schools?

Yes, they are great. All schools are pretty great, we don't have the hierarchies of schools like in the UK where some are terrible and some are fantastic. Its more about ethos but to be honest, the days of catholic nonsense running through everything is long gone in most national schools, which are nominally catholic.

TeaEgg · 05/01/2021 16:44

@Norfolker

Can someone please explain what transition year is please. Also the education together primary schools. Are these fee paying? How do education together compare to the Irish speaking schools? Are they as desirable & as good academically as the Irish language schools?
Educate Together schools aren't fee-paying. It's an alien notion to me and a very anxious, culturally-English, Ofsted-report thing to be even thinking in terms of whether their education is 'better' than gaelscoileanna.

They're secular, state, non-parish-based, co-ed schools. No God, no uniforms, often a mildly hippy child-centred ethos. Started in the 70s with one school in suburban Dublin founded by parents.

Someone up the thread described them as targeted by socially-aspirational parents, but I genuinely don't see that at DS's school, which has a real social and ethnic mix. I like its ethos, I like the lack of fuss about uniform, I like the fact that the children can show up with blue hair and dressed like Helena Bonham Carter if they feel like it.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 16:43

@Norfolker

Can someone please explain what transition year is please. Also the education together primary schools. Are these fee paying? How do education together compare to the Irish speaking schools? Are they as desirable & as good academically as the Irish language schools?
Transition year is a year after Junior Cert (GCSE) where students study core subjects, but they also explore things like Media, Drama, Techie Stuff, put together a mini-business enterprise, make drones, do work experience, all that sort of shite. It's a year for them to explore their interests outside of academia and before they knuckle down to the final 2 years studying for their Leaving Certificate.

Educate together is non-denominational . They are not fee paying.

Irish language schools tend to attract a better sort of student, but they are non fee-paying too.

Academically, I have no idea - I suspect that there is little difference between traditional, ET or Gaelgoir schools.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 16:43

There are lots of people in the UK who will say they learned history in the UK that doesn’t explore things in the way that, for example Irish history in Ireland does. We don’t even have that connection to our own history as so much of it about Tudors, etc - we are taught, on the whole a very dry, removed curriculum (imv).

I apologise for steering too much of topic but some of this is unnecessary .

NothingICanDo · 05/01/2021 16:43

If you studied it properly you should know that there was actually no famine. A famine is where there is no food, there was plenty of food, it just was kept from the people who needed it, purposefully. British landowners continued to have a rich and varied diet as their tenants starved to death outside, and they continued to export vast quantities of food

Yes but as we've learned today...it was all about expansion and progress Hmm

caperplips · 05/01/2021 16:42

Can't your sister in law explain all of these things @Norfolker? I'm not entirely sure of the actual purpose of this thread anymore. Or indeed from the very start

Apileofballyhoo · 05/01/2021 16:41

I wonder how many people in Ireland have inherited generational wealth going back centuries.

SkylightAndChandelier · 05/01/2021 16:41

As far as I can tell from talking to British people, Ireland is not mentioned on the UK curriculum.

TBH, I took history at GCSE (ie. we could give it up at 14 if we wanted). Prior to that, history for me (30 years ago) was more about vikings/exciting stuff in primary, then 'the victorians', 'the feudal system' and 'major inventions'. I think I did something on WW1 in English Lit. but history was both very focused, rather than general knowledge, and concentrated more on teaching us research skills (sources, writing essays etc.) rather than actual history.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 16:38

To be honest, we're not the only nation that the UK doesn't learn about.
Hopefully they will soon forget that Ireland even exists - they've pretty much done that with the part that they own!

Norfolker · 05/01/2021 16:37

Can someone please explain what transition year is please. Also the education together primary schools. Are these fee paying? How do education together compare to the Irish speaking schools? Are they as desirable & as good academically as the Irish language schools?

OP posts:
IceIceBebe · 05/01/2021 16:35

I am talking about knowledge/history of Ireland in UK as it is delivered through the curriculum

As far as I can tell from talking to British people, Ireland is not mentioned on the UK curriculum.

SkylightAndChandelier · 05/01/2021 16:33

What I loved about primary school growing up in Ireland was that everyone got along. It didn't matter if you were the daughter of a doctor or someone who had been unemployed all their lives, you could still be the best of friends.

This is absolutely the case at our school - we have everything from a Tesla to 15 year old bangers doing drop off, playdates with anyone. The only thing I've noticed compared to the international schools the kids went to in other countries is that DS1 has had a harder time finding proper friends as there is more expectation that boys will play with boys, and that will be football (admittedly it's a small school, and his class has a certain group culture that his little brother's one doesn't). But TBH that was also a thing in Italy, and the school here absolutely noticed unlike in Italy, and have made some efforts to help him out (whilst also being a bit at a loss about the idea of a boy that doesn't know anything about sports). And I do note that Ireland is extremely hot on promoting sportswomen just as much as sportsmen.

To be fair, I don't know much British history either, and I've had to explain to people here (and people from lots of other places) how the UK fits together - there's a certain amount of that anywhere I've been, forgetting that the UK isn't just England.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 16:31

[quote LadyfromtheBelleEpoque]@IceIceBebe

Yes, I know An Gorta Mor is the correct term - but the term famine is also used in Ireland. And the Corn laws/repeal issue - I do know Irish history.

I cannot understand why someone thinks this is arrogant- I am talking about knowledge/history of Ireland in UK as it is delivered through the curriculum. There was an issue years ago about not teaching the Falklands war - we don’t teach about things within a certain time period - and that has raised many a concern.[/quote]
Here lady.

Keep it on topic. Can you do that much? We don't care about your curriculum!!! We. do. not. care. We're doing brilliantly without your expansionist progressive notions thank you very much!

TeaEgg · 05/01/2021 16:30

@Hatstrategicallydipped

And here we have Exhibit A - LadyfromtheBelleEpoque

A lady from the British Empire who apparently studied Irish history at third level.

And you, the jury question whether the Irish education system is better than that of the UK?

I hereby conclude my closing argument.

QEfuckingD

Grin

Now, now, play nice -- she's just being 'discreet' about her knowledge. For some reason that isn't fully apparent.

The 900 yoyo star-patch shearling sleeves, now...

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 16:29

@IceIceBebe

Yes, I know An Gorta Mor is the correct term - but the term famine is also used in Ireland. And the Corn laws/repeal issue - I do know Irish history.

I cannot understand why someone thinks this is arrogant- I am talking about knowledge/history of Ireland in UK as it is delivered through the curriculum. There was an issue years ago about not teaching the Falklands war - we don’t teach about things within a certain time period - and that has raised many a concern.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 16:28

And here we have Exhibit A - LadyfromtheBelleEpoque

A lady from the British Empire who apparently studied Irish history at third level.

And you, the jury question whether the Irish education system is better than that of the UK?

I hereby conclude my closing argument.

QEfuckingD

caperplips · 05/01/2021 16:27

What do you mean by 'I know full well how discreet some people choose to be'?

You are really not doing yourself any favours on this thread @LadyfromtheBelleEpoch Sad

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 16:25

Some do, though - Africa was partitioned by European countries. South America by Spain and Portugal. These are historic facts.

This is a thread about the class system in Ireland??? Wtf have Spain or Portugal got to do with the price of chips?

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 16:23

Wow! And that’s why people don’t discuss it, I guess.

I don’t for a second think expansion and progress were valid reasons to take over others land and identities - what on earth made you think I would?

Some do, though - Africa was partitioned by European countries. South America by Spain and Portugal. These are historic facts.

I am of Irish descent - I grew up in London and know full well how discreet some people choose to be.