Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
YerWanIsGettinNotions · 05/01/2021 17:46

@SunniCameHomeWithAVengeance

You wouldn't want to be getting notions.
You called, Sunni?! Grin
Apileofballyhoo · 05/01/2021 17:45

[quote LadyfromtheBelleEpoque]@caperplips

It was directed at the people who were responding a certain way to my posts.

@Apileofballyhoo

Which I am sure you are well aware of.

I’m sorry @Pile but I don’t quite understory post.[/quote]
I'm not sure I understand yours! Seemed to me you were explaining that some British people have no knowledge of British history as it relates to Ireland, some British people have a knowledge of same but don't talk about it, and some British people have a knowledge but don't think there is anything wrong with that history. None of which apply to you. Some posters seemed to take it that you were in the last group, I was saying you didn't say that. I don't think you're wrong either, judging by the ignorance I've seen regarding Ireland and Irish/British history. I sometimes can't be bothered punctuating for shortish posts, sorry if it threw you.

TeaEgg · 05/01/2021 17:38

[quote LadyfromtheBelleEpoque]@Hatstrategicallydipped

Not on my part, Hat I can assure you. You have made so many assumptions there.

And finally, and as clearly as I can possibly say it, at no point did I say or indicate that I personally thought expansion and progress were valid reasons.[/quote]
But given that you say you are continually 'being told off or shouted down' by Irish people, wouldn't you say that it's highly unlikely to be other people perpetually misinterpreting you, and hence you might want to look at how you come across, in person as well as online?

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 17:37

God forgive me for swearing Wink but one of my dc goes to a Church of Ireland secondary school. I'm ashamed of myself. I will go to confession on Saturday.

Religion really isn't too much of a big deal in Ireland - maybe because most of us have the same religion I guess, but in day to day life? Nobody really goes to Mass or otherwise.

MarDhea · 05/01/2021 17:35

@SkylightAndChandelier

Can someone please explain what transition year is please. Also the education together primary schools. Are these fee paying? How do education together compare to the Irish speaking schools? Are they as desirable & as good academically as the Irish language schools?

No, not fee paying - although you pay for schoolbooks and normally make a yearly contribution (I pay about 400/year contribution, and about 200/year in schoolbooks).

The one thing my relative said when she heard we were moving here (she was a primary school teacher in Ireland before she retired) was not to send them to an educate together - they don't have a great reputation, although I don't really know why. There are tales of 'Winterval' rather than Christmas etc. which I don't think are true, my feeling it that they just don't do the religious stuff like confirmation that the catholic ones do (my friends tell me even the non-catholic kids get involved with confirmation at their catholic schools).

The Irish medium schools are another thing all together - I'm afraid I don't know if there are Irish medium Educate Together schools.

IMO, the only people who think that ET schools are somehow lesser the other types of school are either:

(a) very traditional types who think all kids should have the exact same school experience that they had (i.e, in a catholic school, possibly single sex) because "it never did them any harm", or

(b) racist bigots who don't want their kids sharing a classroom with kids of other colours and religions, because ET schools tend to be more diverse than the catholic schools in the same town. (Rural catholic schools can be as diverse as ET schools because everyone goes there; but when there's a choice between ET schools and regular catholic schools, the ET tends to be more diverse).

Really, all the schools are great. ET schools and multi-denominational gaelscoileanna are for people who oppose or just don't care about religion being taught in schools. Catholic schools (regular national schools or gaelscoileanna) are for people who want or don't mind Catholicism in all aspects of the school day.

Some catholic schools are pretty secular in reality, lip service only to religion, but you need local knowledge to know that.

Pinkandwhiteblossom · 05/01/2021 17:34

Deliberately avoiding the history debate except to say this: I was educated partly in the UK and partly in Ireland and studied history in both. It was an early lesson in the subjectivity of the topic. And the ability of people in the UK to ignore the less savoury portions of their history.

Small point regarding the Educate Together schools. They’re not non-denominational as such. They were originally described as multi-denominational and now engage in what is as described as an ethical curriculum where they teach about all religions, but not that one is superior to the others as a belief system which is the same way they taught when I went to one in the ‘80s.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 17:34

In the main, Irish schools have a Catholic ethos. Hence the new rising of Educate Together schools to cater for immigrants and indeed Catholics who categorically do not want their children having a religious upbringing. It's a type of ethos which has grown organically and as a need became apparent.

TBH, you can't beat a nativity though, so I'd send mine to Catholic schools again just to get to whinge at them on-stage lol. I am that superficial

TheKeatingFive · 05/01/2021 17:25

Are the Irish schools all Catholic?

No. There are schools of other denominations and non religious schools too.

Norfolker · 05/01/2021 17:23

Are the Irish schools all Catholic? My brother's children have had communion & we have been sent photos of them dressed for nativity plays over the years

OP posts:
HollyCarrot · 05/01/2021 17:19

Ah, thanks. As far as I remember we just got an email asking if our kid would be making communion and that classes could be arranged. I assumed by the school bit maybe not. I didn't pay much attention as mine was going to be doing it.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 17:18

I didn't choose an Irish school for dc as I was more interested in location, class sizes and how inclusive they were of different races.
I wouldn't peg one above the other.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 17:18

@Hatstrategicallydipped

Not on my part, Hat I can assure you. You have made so many assumptions there.

And finally, and as clearly as I can possibly say it, at no point did I say or indicate that I personally thought expansion and progress were valid reasons.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 17:15

It's amusing that an English person would come on and say that they A. identified with NI Protestants and B. that we make everything 'so fucking difficult' and C. tell us that colonialism was expansion and progression and expect to be welcomed somehow! Extraordinary arrogance and ignorance. Extraordinary to see it in real life.

Norfolker · 05/01/2021 17:15

@caperplips

Can't your sister in law explain all of these things *@Norfolker*? I'm not entirely sure of the actual purpose of this thread anymore. Or indeed from the very start
My sil thinks nothing compares to the Irish language schools so I don't think she can speak for all the parents in IrelandHmm I asked on here for other opinions Hmm
OP posts:
TeaEgg · 05/01/2021 17:10

@HollyCarrot, at DS's ET school, it's up to parents who want their child to have religious instruction to arrange classes the school will provide them with a room after school hours, cover insurance etc, but because it's not part of school provision, parents have to organise it. So I know because one of the children is DS's friend -- that the parents in DS's class who wanted their children to make their first communion organised after-school instruction to prepare them. If any other faith wanted to do similar, the school would likewise offer a room. There are Hindu and Muslim kids in his class, too, but from what I understand, their religious education takes place centrally at the temple/mosque, so they don't need school input.

wellthatsunusual · 05/01/2021 17:07

@LadyfromtheBelleEpoque

I like the daily edge piece too. Will have to start following them.

I can’t work out the Irish humour. I always feel I am being told off or shouted down or that I am being argued with just because I am English then people say it’s humour yet if I do it back there is rage and fury.

I think it is definitely that thing of not taking yourself seriously whereas in the UK I always feel I have to work hard to be taken seriously. The people I prob clicked with most were NI Protestants I met at college but that tended to change once they found out I was RC!

Where did you go to college? I'm amazed at Northern Protestants who are at college taking against an English Catholic once they discover their religion. The insular won't-be-friends-with-a-Catholic type are generally not at college. They are either the people who have lived a tough life and are afraid to explore beyond their small local area where they feel safe, or else they are the ultra religious types who mostly won't be at college either.
HollyCarrot · 05/01/2021 17:06

@SkylightAndChandelier

Can someone please explain what transition year is please. Also the education together primary schools. Are these fee paying? How do education together compare to the Irish speaking schools? Are they as desirable & as good academically as the Irish language schools?

No, not fee paying - although you pay for schoolbooks and normally make a yearly contribution (I pay about 400/year contribution, and about 200/year in schoolbooks).

The one thing my relative said when she heard we were moving here (she was a primary school teacher in Ireland before she retired) was not to send them to an educate together - they don't have a great reputation, although I don't really know why. There are tales of 'Winterval' rather than Christmas etc. which I don't think are true, my feeling it that they just don't do the religious stuff like confirmation that the catholic ones do (my friends tell me even the non-catholic kids get involved with confirmation at their catholic schools).

The Irish medium schools are another thing all together - I'm afraid I don't know if there are Irish medium Educate Together schools.

In my daughter's ET school they had organised extra curricular classes in religious prep in communion year. I thought that was a good thing. Although I suppose you could turn that on its head and say why don't they do the same for kids of all other religions! Love the ETs we've dealt with, so much better than my experience in Catholic schools.
LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 17:04

Understand

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 17:04

@caperplips

It was directed at the people who were responding a certain way to my posts.

@Apileofballyhoo

Which I am sure you are well aware of.

I’m sorry @Pile but I don’t quite understory post.

caperplips · 05/01/2021 17:01

@LadyfromtyeBelleEpoch was that a collective 'you'..as in 'you Irish' make everything so fucking difficult?..nice!

Or were you directing that at one particular poster?

Apileofballyhoo · 05/01/2021 16:59

Belle I understood you to be talking about why some British people don't have or pretend not to have or have but think it's fine view of British history. You didn't say that was your own opinion.

IceIceBebe · 05/01/2021 16:57

I’ll leave you be, guys. You make everything so fucking difficult. It was a discussion about different systems that I have some experience so I thought I could contribute but I’m out

Well you started off by saying that English people knew loads of Irish history but pretended not to....so it was never going to go well after such bollocks!!

IceIceBebe · 05/01/2021 16:56

was not to send them to an educate together - they don't have a great reputation, although I don't really know why. There are tales of 'Winterval' rather than Christmas etc. which I don't think are true, my feeling it that they just don't do the religious stuff like confirmation that the catholic ones do (my friends tell me even the non-catholic kids get involved with confirmation at their catholic schools)

Yeah, none of that's true. ET schools are great, oversubscribed and have a great reputation, Winterval is not a thing, and there are loads of non-Catholics in catholic schools who don't do any of the sacramental gubbins

TeaEgg · 05/01/2021 16:56

@LadyfromtheBelleEpoque

I’ll leave you be, guys. You make everything so fucking difficult. It was a discussion about different systems that I have some experience so I thought I could contribute but I’m out.
I can’t work out the Irish humour. I always feel I am being told off or shouted down or that I am being argued with just because I am English then people say it’s humour yet if I do it back there is rage and fury.

@LadyfromtheBelleEpoque, this is you apparently genuinely wondering why you couldn't 'work out Irish humour' from earlier on the thread. In the nicest possible way, it's not a clashing sense of humour that's at fault here. You need to read the room, listen and be less arrogant. If you come across like this in person, I'm not surprised you're consistently met with negativity.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 16:55

@LadyfromtheBelleEpoque

I’ll leave you be, guys. You make everything so fucking difficult. It was a discussion about different systems that I have some experience so I thought I could contribute but I’m out.
Go n-eirí an bóthar leat!