Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
YerWanIsGettinNotions · 05/01/2021 19:53

I went to a school that was (and still is) a boarding school, but not a private or fee paying school and I wasn't a boarder. And for all that, very socially mixed in attendance and outcome.

My husband was privately schooled and between going to college in a city and meeting him I definitely noticed the social divide between us rural kids and the city class system (as you would see it through the Pres boys, CBC, Scoil Mhuire and Aloysius in Cork and the Dublin ones -Loreto, Gonzaga, Belvedere, Mounties). I was nearly in my 20s before I really noticed the class system in Ireland but I figured it really is more to be found in urban centres.

I now work in a role in the UK where a large amount of my colleagues are privately schooled and oxbridge educated, and it's very othering - you don't notice as much until you realise that the most prized graduate schemes have spaces for your Duke of Edinburgh's and your extra curricular achievements when nothing like that ever formed a part of a rural Irish education unless your parents were knowledgeable and motivated enough to seek it out for you. Which as mine were generationally farmers, they mostly didn't even know about let alone think would be possible for their child to do - "it was far from such and such you were reared". So I went from thinking class didn't exist, to didn't matter that much except to city kids, to having it be a huge chasm between me and my colleagues in London.

I notice it even more now the kids are in school. We moved to the best area near the best schools that we could afford to do - because postcode differences matter here for the school catchment - and now we are siloed in a suburb of middle class professionals who are just like us, who are our age and education level and in professional jobs just like ours. I never meet or interact with someone from a different social class much because between work and the house/school, I don't go anywhere.

I tried to explain it once to my extended family (her a local solicitor, him a builder) but I didn't do it very well and I don't think they really got it either.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 05/01/2021 19:48

Something worth noting with all the different schools talk is that all Irish teachers are trained in the same curriculum, methodologies and best practice so there's an equality built in. This is surely the same in the UK? So I worked in a fee paying school where pupils paid eye watering fees to be in my class and then I left for a designated disadvantaged school, where the children got the same teaching from me but, as I mentioned, better funding and grants. I also taught in an ET where, amazingly, I used the same approaches and techniques. So it makes me laugh when people rave about a particular type of school, it doesn't work like that. My friend paid for a fee paying school, pronouncing her children's reading phenomenal but a year later when my child started in a national school, his reading was better just as good. There's no magic pill but small class numbers are the game changer.

MadameMiggeldy · 05/01/2021 19:42

Educate together is non-denominational . They are not fee paying

If memory services they are also sponsors for an Academy chain in Bristol.

TeaEgg · 05/01/2021 19:26

[quote Cacacoisfarraige]@Hatstrategicallydipped

We played Hockey but we all did Fencing too 😀

We did have nuns, but they encouraged us all to go to college and have careers,

They taught everything except (birth control methods - apart from natural method and abstinence) but they left the school one afternoon and a local doctor came in and spoke to our year about STD’s and birth control)

We also learned coding (back in the 80’s). It wasn’t a few paying school. Probably just well run.[/quote]
Yes, in defence of the nuns who taught me mostly in primary school, as there were few teaching nuns, apart from the Head at my secondary I think they, or some of them, were the first feminists I ever encountered.

In a state that was still enthusiastically making contraception difficult to come by, and which had landed WC married women like our grandmothers and mothers with potentially enormous families, and where the marriage bar was still in place during my early years at school, they were certainly voices firmly in favour of female careers and financial independence.

Cacacoisfarraige · 05/01/2021 19:13

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Cacacoisfarraige · 05/01/2021 19:12

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MarDhea · 05/01/2021 19:09

@Apileofballyhoo

All the Irish ever did was to fight for freedom from occupation. They never raided or invaded anywhere else. I dunno, the poor old Picts might not agree, but we'll never know seeing as their language and culture didn't survive.
Beat me to it, ballyhoo Grin

Hats you're coming out with some factually inaccurate bollocks that is guilty of exactly the same historical ignorance that you're criticising British posters for. Please stop.

Apileofballyhoo · 05/01/2021 19:05

All the Irish ever did was to fight for freedom from occupation. They never raided or invaded anywhere else. I dunno, the poor old Picts might not agree, but we'll never know seeing as their language and culture didn't survive.

LizzieAnt · 05/01/2021 18:57

You're getting a bit overwrought there Hatstrategicallydipped.

Coislaoi · 05/01/2021 18:56

I laugh when I read about class here. It just doesn't happen in Ireland, as others have said, you'd be shot down with having notions or other similarly sarcastic replies. I do think the education system in Ireland is far superior to UK

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 18:52

That's not true. The Welsh were as bolshie as resistant to English rule as anyone, with rising after rising after being annexed, and it was only with the Tudors (that united English and Welsh royal lines) that things really quietened down. And even then, the Cornish kept giving the Tudors trouble as they weren't too keen on tile from London either.

By the time Cromwell was over here, Wales didn't have a voice as a country any more. Just as individuals, and who knows what they thought.

It is true. They stood by and did absolutely nothing.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 18:51

@TeaEgg

I think the topic and conversations around it aren’t nuanced enough - that is the problem. There are so many identities to take into account in UK history. It isn’t one homogenous environment when viewed historically which is one of the problems when teaching it. There isn’t ‘one’ narrative and certainly most historians I know would suggest we need to break down this idea that there is. Some of the media however like to push that and some people who have a very simplified understanding of how it works there.

A good example is the issue of whether we are subjects (of the Crown) or not. Historically, we were (as opposed to being citizens of the State).

In the 80s, Margaret Thatcher pushed through Parliament a statute that altered this so technically, we are citizens. It is a very nuanced point as some traditionalists hold onto it and I think some don’t see it as significant as it was not felt to make much difference to ordinary life.

That’s the kind of thing I think causes heated discussions, creates confusion and imv, needs to be taught well across the board but we just don’t have that civics culture in state schools to the extent you have in Ireland (where you look at European democracy/forms of government/, etc).

I ‘ve derailed again to illustrate my point but I am trying to avoid topics that are contentious.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 18:50

Sometimes I use Britain and sometimes I refer specifically to the English.
It depends on the context.
If my boyfriend murdered someone innocent tomorrow and I was present and did nothing - would I be charged with anything?

MarDhea · 05/01/2021 18:50

@Hatstrategicallydipped

Wales never stood up to the United Kingdom and said 'hang on a minute - give the Irish a break'. It's like someone who was present at a murder - they may not have committed the actual act, but they were present and complicit. You could have said 'No'. But you chose not to.
That's not true. The Welsh were as bolshie as resistant to English rule as anyone, with rising after rising after being annexed, and it was only with the Tudors (that united English and Welsh royal lines) that things really quietened down. And even then, the Cornish kept giving the Tudors trouble as they weren't too keen on tile from London either.

By the time Cromwell was over here, Wales didn't have a voice as a country any more. Just as individuals, and who knows what they thought.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 18:47

All the Irish ever did was to fight for freedom from occupation. They never raided or invaded anywhere else. They just wanted to be left alone. Yet ALL of the UK let us be tortured, plundered, pillaged, starved, forced into exile etc. etc. etc. et fucking cetera.

The Welsh didn't stand up for us!

HarrietPotterska · 05/01/2021 18:46

Thanks to everyone who's replied to me and shared their thoughts and experiences with me. I'm sorry that the thread has become a bit derailed, but I for one have found it really educational and enlightening. I learned nothing about Irish history and the disgusting genocide of Irish people by the English, so, I for one always want to learn as much as I can.

Not sure what I'm saying really but that I guess I know someone said they didn't see the point in the thread, but for me it's really helpful x

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 18:44

All of 'Great' Britain allowed the Irish to be massacred and decimated.

6 million Jews were murdered. We remember that.

2 million Irish were starved to death. We're supposed to forget this.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 18:43

Wales never stood up to the United Kingdom and said 'hang on a minute - give the Irish a break'.
It's like someone who was present at a murder - they may not have committed the actual act, but they were present and complicit.
You could have said 'No'. But you chose not to.

jewel1968 · 05/01/2021 18:39

My attempt at humour has fallen flat. Of course I know the history of the suppression of the Irish language. One of the saddest things I think happened was having ensured we no longer spoke it in the home it was up to schools to teach. I am old enough to remember Irish being taught in let's just say an overzealous way. I think this approach (in my youth) turned lots and lots of people off the language.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 18:39

@MarDhea

Where did Hat say that Britain lacked culture?? Been reading the thread, and went back and looked, but can't find it.
I did say it.
Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 18:37

And as for @Hatstrategicallydipped's trolling about how the British lack culture.... hmm "Britain" has 2000 years of culture at least as a collective, but by additionally denying Scots/Welsh specific culture (traditions, language, customs, folk tales, dances, songs, poems) aren't you doing exactly the same thing you complain that people are ignorant about Irish culture?

I'm not trolling. Is that your defence to anything disagreeable to you?

Unfortunately, I do in my head align all of Great Britain as they never stood up and were counted when atrocities were committed in Ireland. Maybe you were not the perpetrators, but you certainly never intervened. You still align yourself with England and your so call 'United' Kingdom, so yes, you're all cut from the same cloth as regards how I feel about you.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 18:35

@Apileofballyhoo

Yes, that is pretty much it. Smile

It is based on my experience growing up there and from teaching. The UK educational system in general (let alone the English) is so varied.

MarDhea · 05/01/2021 18:31

Where did Hat say that Britain lacked culture?? Been reading the thread, and went back and looked, but can't find it.

thevassal · 05/01/2021 18:19

@IceIceBebe

It wasn't the UK that tried to eradicate the Irish language

It was.

Stop saying 'the UK' when you mean 'England.' Not that I want to english-bash either but how could the Welsh possibly be accused of collaborating in eradicating the Irish language when our own language was subject to at least the same amount of systematic eradication if not more - read about the 'welsh not' for example.

And as for @Hatstrategicallydipped's trolling about how the British lack culture.... Hmm "Britain" has 2000 years of culture at least as a collective, but by additionally denying Scots/Welsh specific culture (traditions, language, customs, folk tales, dances, songs, poems) aren't you doing exactly the same thing you complain that people are ignorant about Irish culture?

MarDhea · 05/01/2021 18:06

Returning to the OP....

I agree with your friend that the Irish school system is better than the English school system. I have extensive experience of both systems, as a parent and from a professional perspective, and - while there are individual gems of schools in England that would be considered great in any country - there are large differences at a systemic level. In brief, relative to Ireland, the English school system has an age-inappropriate national curriculum that leaves a large proportion of children behind, too much focus on testing that is tied to school and teacher reward and causes enormous stress in children, rigid age-cohort admissions rules that enormously disadvantage summer-born children, and an unfortunate cultural relic that means more than half young people still leave formal schooling at 16.

Gaelscoileanna are great if you're keen on the Irish language and believe it's a valuable cultural endeavour to increase the number of Irish speakers after years of enforced and then neglected decline. I would have sent my kids to one of my oldest hadn't been too old to start when we moved back from the UK. They're not academically better than other schools apart from the Irish-language teaching, though.