Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
Danu2021 · 05/01/2021 23:04

Am I hallucinating or are the schools not going back until 1st February now. Give me strength. And wine.

Eggcorns · 05/01/2021 23:03

@wewillmeetagain

I went to school in the uk with a very large amount of Irish children and lots of Irish teachers as well ( catholic school). I can tell you now there is most definitely a class system among the Irish and the vast amount of inverted snobbery that goes with it!!!
Why is your experience in the UK relevant to a discussion of class in Ireland?
Eggcorns · 05/01/2021 23:02

Agree with the last two posters. And I think people treat funerals far less formally and funeral-going is a far more ordinary and regular event for most Irish people, so I don’t think your relatives getting a blow dry is particularly ordinary. I’m certainly always taken aback with the soul-searching on Mn about what to wear, how to behave etc, whether to bring children.

wellthatsunusual · 05/01/2021 23:01

In N Ireland (or certainly the part I live in) school finishes at 2pm for the first three years, and after that it moves to 3pm. I've never heard anyone even query it, so it was a shock to me when I first started using Mumsnet and saw that people expected their 4 year olds to do full days at school.

wewillmeetagain · 05/01/2021 22:57

I went to school in the uk with a very large amount of Irish children and lots of Irish teachers as well ( catholic school). I can tell you now there is most definitely a class system among the Irish and the vast amount of inverted snobbery that goes with it!!!

switswoo81 · 05/01/2021 22:49

My junior infants go home at 1:30. So that's probably what you saw. Plenty of time for an education. I can't understand how the kids in the UK stay in so late mine are wrecked by one and they are all 5 turning 6.

Cheeeeislifenow · 05/01/2021 22:46

@justajot my son's secondary finishes at one in a Wednesday. The idea is that any planned sporting matches can be done and not affect the academic week. Junior infants and senior infants finish at 2.10. other primary is 3.10 secondary usually finished at 3.45 to 4.00 pm.

Never ever heard of anyone getting a blow dry for a funeral. I think uk funerals are more formal. Most people don't wear black only very immediate family.

Justajot · 05/01/2021 22:25

I've visited Ireland a fair bit and the things I've noticed are:
Children coming out of school at 1.30 and really long school holidays. I'm not sure if this is an accurate observation or something like the schools in the UK that don't have school one afternoon a week. If it is a general thing, then I've no idea how they fit in all the education, but they do seem to.

More obvious nepotism than in the UK middle classes. I know it's rife in UK upper classes, old boys network etc, but not in the circle I have access to in the UK. Where as people in equivalent circumstances to me in Ireland seem to need to know the right people to get jobs. Again, may just be the subset of people I mix with.

Greater interest in grooming - or example I was really surprised to find that people went for a blow dry before a funeral in Ireland. Again, a one off observation on the Irish side and maybe I don't go to the right funerals in the UK.

I'd be interested to know if these are really Irish things.

Piglet89 · 05/01/2021 22:21

Just hopping on the thread to give a Northern Irish perspective. Like everywhere, NI has a wee class structure, so it does. Even the capital city has different classes!

Paddy Raff (a comedian from working class Catholic BT11, West Belfast) takes it off very well with his character of Protestant Nigel from BT9 (Lisburn and Malone Road - posh areas).

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 22:14

@YerWanIsGettinNotions

The interesting thing for me was that IBM facilitated this for Germany - the book details how. IBM America wanted to distance itself from events in Europe once they knew reports were coming out internationally and pressure was on them to maintain their public image so they set up a subsidiary arm, IBM Europe to deal directly with Germany.

In order to write the book, the author must have used the IBM archives.

LoveFromDeauville · 05/01/2021 22:10

My sister in law grew up in Dublin and has told me some funny stories about the legendary bitchiness of the girls from Alexandra and Mount Anville. From what she’s told me the boys from Blackrock all think they’re god’s gift to mankind. So entertaining to hear her stories.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 22:04

Sorry Ireland 4000

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours
LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 21:59

@YerWanIsGettinNotions

There is another site that details how so much info was intentionally kept out of the public sphere so yes, propaganda at work certainly but I do think there were plenty of diplomatic figures that knew and some tried to work their best within their sphere of influence (the Japanese ambassador who arranged passports), the Scandinavian countries that sent their Jewish communities to a boat off the coast of Norway?. I think Bulgaria refused to disclose the information Germany needed to identify their Jewish population.

The book I referred to is archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/first/b/black-ibm.html

IBM and the Holocaust. It details precisely the process that Hitler employed to build the Wannsee document. He ordered teams to go through census records, church records, etc across Europe building family trees. Many families had converted generations before - some didn’t know they had Jewish ancestry. It was forensic work and he laid out a complex system for each person to identify exactly where their ancestors came from. He wanted to take Judaism out at the ‘root’ - as he saw it. The book details how this background work really was undertaken. He identified how many Jewish people in each area then wrote it up into a list known as the Wannsee conference document. Each country with its number next to it. Ireland 2000 Jews, I think it said. It is when you see that document you get a sense of how this was intentional, known and only possible with the compliance of others.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 21:47

Here is the best link I can find atm

auschwitz.org/en/history/informing-the-world/the-role-of-the-polish-government-in-exile

YerWanIsGettinNotions · 05/01/2021 21:47

@LadyfromtheBelleEpoque thanks, please do share, that sounds really interesting. (I am inclined to half-agree as I think one of the greater disparities between pre- and post-Vietnam conflicts was the involvement of the media and just how much information was widely disseminated to the public. Some people knew, of course they did, because the information got out along with the messengers, but that is not the same as "widely known" and a huge amount was kept under wraps at the time. I don't suppose Churchill was at a podium with a bunch of flowcharts and data every night during the crisis!)

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 21:37

Polish giveaways should say Polish government

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 21:36

@LadyEloise that sounds interesting

@YerWanIsGettinNotions
Not to mention of course that the British didn't go to war for the Jews. They didn't even know what was happening in German concentration camps until the camps were liberated at the very end of the war. That's a facetious argument and another display of ignorance.

I would dispute this. The Polish giveaways exiled in London and wrote an open letter to all allied governments mentioning Germany’s specific treatment of the Jewish people. It was known, imv, well before Attenborough’s team discovered the first camp.

There is an excellent book about what was also known in the US about the camps. I’ll try and get the name if anyone is interested.

LadyEloise · 05/01/2021 21:21

Her name was Maureen Sweeney and she worked at Blacksod Bay weather station.
Google : How an Irish Weather Woman helped win the war.

LadyEloise · 05/01/2021 21:18

I think DeValera was speaking out of both sides of his mouth as it were.
Allied airmen who were dropped into the Free State as it then was, were safely brought across the border.
Yes, there was a bit of the usual "England's difficulty is Ireland's opportunity" but in reality we weren't quite neutral.
Remember the young female meterological worker in Mayo, keeping a very close eye on the incoming weather as it crossed the Atlantic.
Her information was of great benefit to the Allies as they prepared for the DDay landings.

YerWanIsGettinNotions · 05/01/2021 21:15

Yes @twoofusburningmatches especially if you can moderate your accent a bit!

I have a fairly neutral accent - just Irish enough to be obvious if you know what sounds you're listening for, but my accent isn't obvious enough that other Irish people can work it out easily unless I make it very broad (I've been asked if I'm Canadian/Dutch/Russian/Swedish/Belgian!)

On the other hand when I'm at home snd I ever have to ring up a person or a business and ask for something, I make my accent and voice/mannerisms much more Irish. In the UK a regional accent is looked down on; at home it sounds way more friendly and a posh/neutral accent is more likely to get people's hackles up.

twoofusburningmatches · 05/01/2021 21:06

Can’t deny there is some sort of social system in Ireland, but there is also so much more social mixing in my experience - at least in the countryside. In school, everyone from the doctor’s children to those who came from families that have been drawing the dole for decades played together. Now, we’re older my friends include a social worker married to a guy who didn’t even get his junior cert and does odd jobs. I know a person with a postgrad and professional job married to a lorry driver. That isn’t strange in ireland. But in over a decade in the UK, I’ve found that there is much less social mixing. And people seem to be pigeon holed so much more quickly. I work in a fairly exclusive industry and many of my colleagues went to Oxbridge. There is some weird unwritten divide between the brits who went to private schools and oxbridge and those who didn’t. It’s painful but fascinating to watch. They can’t place Irish people, which can very much be to our advantage as a very smart, older and posh Irish lawyer once told me.

YerWanIsGettinNotions · 05/01/2021 20:46

Actually, that is a particularly vile and ignorant viewpoint and I will explain why:

  1. there was a civil war that the Irish were very recently fighting on home turf (the republic of Ireland as it is today was born in 1937 out of the Irish Free State - just before war broke out on the continent) and they just could not justifiably raise an army at the time, and

  2. 50.000 Irishmen and women still felt strongly enough about WWII that they did go over to Great Britain to sign up as soldiers in the British army and work as nurses, despite any overt political neutrality from the capital and in some cases at great personal cost, and

  3. there are Irish grandparents alive today who came to Ireland in the 40s as child evacuees and never went home, and

  4. Allied planes were permitted to land and refuel in Ireland despite "neutrality" and were facilitated to give them every advantage.

Not to mention of course that the British didn't go to war for the Jews. They didn't even know what was happening in German concentration camps until the camps were liberated at the very end of the war. That's a facetious argument and another display of ignorance.

The role Ireland played in WWII was not a loud one, but considering how recently it had clawed back its independence it still played a significant role, even if politically it kept its nose out. De Valera's response to Churchill's VE Day speech was very gracious considering the level of spite they faced, i thought.

thevassal · 05/01/2021 20:30

@Hatstrategicallydipped

All of 'Great' Britain allowed the Irish to be massacred and decimated.

6 million Jews were murdered. We remember that.

2 million Irish were starved to death. We're supposed to forget this.

Just the utter gall of using Jews murdered by the Nazis to make your point about Irish subjugation when the Taoiseach of the time literally signed the book of condolence for Hitler's death and met with the German ambassador to express his condolences in person (was the only leader of any Western European country to do so). Wow.
thevassal · 05/01/2021 20:23

@Hatstrategicallydipped

All of 'Great' Britain allowed the Irish to be massacred and decimated.

6 million Jews were murdered. We remember that.

2 million Irish were starved to death. We're supposed to forget this.

Yeah the Irish really helped those 6 million Jews, and all the other victims of WW2, didn't they. What with their position of neutrality and refusal to support the allies. FFS.

Why didn't the Irish help the Welsh when we were being invaded in the 12th century if you're going to start twatting around like this. Or you could get over yourself and your victimhood and look forward not back.