Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
PenelopePunt · 06/01/2021 13:02

I think you’re right. The Irish have been historically the outsiders and have had to conform or been discriminated against. It’s natural that when they have the opportunity to create, establish or maintain their own hierarchical structure, they will hold on to it and defend it.

Eggcorns · 06/01/2021 13:02

The wife of a friend, who works at a different university, was told “You need to be more Irish if you want to move forward”.

Given that it's an impossibility for someone who isn't Irish to 'turn Irish', might that not have been a clumsily expressed or misunderstood piece of advice about a clashing work 'manner'?

Xenophobia, alas, is everywhere.

I'm Irish and have worked at Irish and overseas universities for years, but I remember when I came back to work at an Irish university after years working in England that I realised my phone manner when dealing with HR or payroll etc had become more formal and demand-focused, and that, while I was being perfectly polite, I was saying hello and moving immediate to whatever I needed and appeared unfriendly by the norms of the institution, and had to consciously adjust my approach. Sometimes someone who is either from somewhere else, or just used to the style of somewhere else, needs a nudge towards local norms-- I certainly did.

And I think your colleagues have been very unlucky -- Irish universities in my experience are cultural mixing-pots. An English friend of mine who arrived at the start of this academic year has been overwhelmed at how ready to help her and socialise her new colleagues were, even in Covid times. She had several Christmas invitations from people she met for the first time in September.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 06/01/2021 12:28

Or emigrants even Hmm

Hatstrategicallydipped · 06/01/2021 12:26

PenelopePunt

Thanks for that.
I value input from 'outsiders' on us Irish as it sometimes paints a different picture. Being a native, we probably have different experiences of Ireland than the casual outside perspective where they can judge us objectively.

I have no doubt that immigrants have a different experience of life in Ireland than the Irish born and bred.

Immigration into our country is relatively new for us. We are more likely to be emmigrants.

PenelopePunt · 06/01/2021 12:03

I’m an Australian living in Dublin and work in one of the universities as a researcher / mid level management role. I certainly see an element of snobbery. I’ve been present at interview boards and heard colleagues pick apart applicants for being from the wrong place or having the wrong university name on their CV. One applicant had a First in his Honours degree from Cork Institute of Technology but was passed over in favour of a less experienced applicant with a Pass degree from UCD as ‘an IT degree isn’t a real degree, it’s the same as a Dilpoma’ and no amount of information from HR would change the board’s opinion. The wife of a friend, who works at a different university, was told “You need to be more Irish if you want to move forward”. We lived in Coolock for a while and were asked if we saw the guards every night in our estate. Few of our colleagues have friends that aren’t Irish, it’s almost like we’re the token foreigners if we’re invited to anything. I’ve had to speak up when I’ve heard derogatory comments about Eastern European’s only being good for cleaning or working in Lidl. I think programmes like Room to Improve feed a certain snobbery which encourages some but not all to perceive themselves as being part or not part of a class. But the pursuit of education is definitely a big marker in supporting the arrogance. My cousin was an EA who supported VPs and CEOs in Australia and London (for very well known companies like Microsoft, Telstra and Barclays) but couldn’t get a high level role here as she had started as an office junior and worked her way up. She didn’t have a degree, just two decades of experience. They’re back in Oz and she’s an EA again at Channel 9. Growing up in an ‘Aussie Battler’ environment, it’s funny but horrible.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 06/01/2021 11:22

Teachers I mean.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 06/01/2021 11:21

We got sex ed, early 90s, in primary and secondary. Totally understand a blow-dry before a funeral but never heard of it as a thing. I remember my mum commenting on our cousin's 'lovely coats' at their mum's funerals and I made sure I dressed well at hers... I would say, generally, behaviour maybe better in Irish schools? Don't know if that's right or wrong. Friends I know who've worked in the UK have not liked it.

MadameMiggeldy · 06/01/2021 11:04

Got mine done before particularly tricky funeral. Armour. Between the removal and the service you’re ‘on display’ to potentially hundreds. I felt I could compose myself better if I felt I looked ok.

fairycakes1234 · 06/01/2021 10:51

Sorry I agree, I am Irish, and maybe not as much with the younger people but I know a lot of older women would get their hair blow-dried before a funeral, including my own mam, not because she is anyway vain, she just isn't great at doing her hair and at a funeral you meet so many people you haven't seen in years and then everyone usually goes back to a hotel or pub so she would want to look her best, I don't really see anything wrong with it, whatever makes you happy.

LadyEloise · 06/01/2021 10:39

I have seen "chief mourners" in my local hair salon getting a blow dry before the funeral. Pre covid obviously.
Possibly the days before the funeral have been fraught and they want to scrub up well and do the deceased proud and if it helps them through their grief......

MarDhea · 06/01/2021 10:10

Children coming out of school at 1.30 and really long school holidays.

Primary school days are fixed nationally as 5 hours and 40 mins, and can be an hour shorter for infant classes (first 2 years of primary) if the school wishes. One school might run from 9:20 - 3pm (2pm for infants) while another might run from 8:30 - 2:10 (1:10 for infants). You could see 5-6 year olds leaving school at 1:10 if the school keeps those hours.

Secondaries don't have fixed hours but generally run from around 9-4 with a half day once a week, or some have no half day but keep shorter hours like 8:45 - 3:30.

The school year in primary has a fixed number of days, where summer holidays last from end June to end Aug in primary, and start June to end Aug in secondary.

More obvious nepotism than in the UK middle classes. I know it's rife in UK upper classes, old boys network etc, but not in the circle I have access to in the UK. Where as people in equivalent circumstances to me in Ireland seem to need to know the right people to get jobs. Again, may just be the subset of people I mix with.

Not my experience. I have seen it happen in small family companies from the building / construction trade to accountancy firms, where family members fill openings, but not in most companies or the public sector.

I would say that there is a general cultural preference for personal over impersonal contacts. For example, all else being equal, a job applicant that is known in some way (and comes across well) will often have the edge for shortlisting over an applicant that is only known via the application. It might just be a case of having met the person a few months ago, or them having phoned to ask questions about the job, etc.: any personal contact is better than none. It wouldn't apply to jobs advertised in huge companies but is common enough in other domains. It's an informal referencing system - people want to know if someone is sound, a decent human being, etc. when considering them for a job.

In my experience, compared to the UK, phone/WhatsApp calls and talking to people face to face is much more important for getting things done than emails or other remote contacts. This holds for everything from navigating officialdom and arranging medical treatment to applying for jobs and finding someone to cut your lawn.

Greater interest in grooming - or example I was really surprised to find that people went for a blow dry before a funeral in Ireland.

I've never heard of this and I've been to a lot of funerals in Ireland (as most Irish people have).

In fact, you'd get some funny looks if you turned up to a funeral having obviously just stepped out of a salon.

I'd be interested to know if these are really Irish things.

Not really, apart from some of the school stuff.

Eggcorns · 06/01/2021 09:52

@Norfolker

How much homework do Irish schools give? I have a P4 & a P2, standard state school & they get reading, spellings & 5 maths questions every night. 20 to 30 minutes maximum
We moved back to Ireland from England mid-year, so DS moved from the middle of Year 3 at a C of E village school to the middle of second class at an ET. Other than starting Irish from scratch, the big difference was homework. At his old school, other than an expectation that they would read at home regularly and a weekly spelling test, the only homework was set at weekends, whereas at his new school, there was homework in English, Irish and Maths nightly, except for weekends.
Yazoop · 06/01/2021 09:45

Class is a thing in Ireland but a different type of thing to England. My mother (from a poor Catholic family) clearly remembers that the kids of the more well-off, “respectable” families sat up the front of class, got treated as favourites by the nuns teaching her. Obviously it’s a lot different in schools now, but roots of what class means in Ireland can be traced back to the post-independence era where it was about how close you were to the Catholic Church, your standing in the community etc. A time in which people could be publicly shamed by the local priest - and sometimes were, such as a story from my grandparents about individuals being called out on Sundays for bringing home “french letters” from the UK.

It is not like that now but there are some “class”markers still based on the family you come from, how respected you are in the area, have ties to the local GAA club, donates to local institutions, the age of the car you drive. It isn’t based on old aristocratic markers but more on material wealth. Different to the UK where it is more based on an almost ingrained snobbery based on a hierarchy everyone seems to know instinctively. I love both countries but both have had different issues in this regard.

There is much more expectation for kids from whatever background to go onto third level education. The class hang ups about schools and unis isn’t there. Universities are far fewer in number but are pretty much all great, and the ITs are fantastic for more practically minded third level education. Unis are very active in their local areas. Unlike UK where Oxbridge is the aspiration, all unis are pretty much well regarded. TCD is the oldest and has a more “elite” badge internationally, but outside Dublin I don’t see it as being aspired to in the same way by the most academic kids who are just as likely to put UCC, UCG, UCD etc as their first choices (which are also excellent) - a lot of it is judged by specific course and location (and a lot opt for the uni most local to where they come from), which I think is a lot better than the pressure to get to a Russell Group uni or whatever.

School was, and still remains, strict - I remember getting yelled at in front of everyone for not having a cover to protect my coursebook! - and you have to buy all your books which can be a struggle for poorer families at secondary level (although sometimes you can get donated second hand ones). I remember getting lines as punishment for “forgetting” an expensive science course book, when I was actually too embarrassed to say in front of everyone that we were waiting for my mum’s payday to buy it.... The points system, for its benefits, is also unforgiving and puts a lot of pressure based on final exams that can dictate the course of your young adult life. I know more than one person who broke down in their first exam due to the pressure. Not a lot of that has changed per my younger relatives.

There was pretty much zero sex education (that could’ve changed since the 90s, though) and a relatively high number of kids (considering it was a small school) in my year got pregnant. I have fond memories and was educated well, but also remember more negative sides of the system too.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 06/01/2021 08:15

That sounds similar. Rule of thumb for me is 2nd class 20mins, 3rd class 30 mins etc.

Norfolker · 06/01/2021 06:28

How much homework do Irish schools give? I have a P4 & a P2, standard state school & they get reading, spellings & 5 maths questions every night. 20 to 30 minutes maximum

OP posts:
HollyCarrot · 06/01/2021 04:56

@Justajot

I've visited Ireland a fair bit and the things I've noticed are: Children coming out of school at 1.30 and really long school holidays. I'm not sure if this is an accurate observation or something like the schools in the UK that don't have school one afternoon a week. If it is a general thing, then I've no idea how they fit in all the education, but they do seem to.

More obvious nepotism than in the UK middle classes. I know it's rife in UK upper classes, old boys network etc, but not in the circle I have access to in the UK. Where as people in equivalent circumstances to me in Ireland seem to need to know the right people to get jobs. Again, may just be the subset of people I mix with.

Greater interest in grooming - or example I was really surprised to find that people went for a blow dry before a funeral in Ireland. Again, a one off observation on the Irish side and maybe I don't go to the right funerals in the UK.

I'd be interested to know if these are really Irish things.

Don't mean to be rude, but this comes across as someone coming over observing the natives and taking notes with amusement. We are who we are, we make no apologies for it, no matter how odd or different or quaint anyone else might find it. And to be perfectly honest, English (I'm assuming) people really shouldn't make assumptions about us unless they have direct experience. And even then, not really. We're not all the the same, like London Vs Manchester.
HollyCarrot · 06/01/2021 04:44

@Justajot

I've visited Ireland a fair bit and the things I've noticed are: Children coming out of school at 1.30 and really long school holidays. I'm not sure if this is an accurate observation or something like the schools in the UK that don't have school one afternoon a week. If it is a general thing, then I've no idea how they fit in all the education, but they do seem to.

More obvious nepotism than in the UK middle classes. I know it's rife in UK upper classes, old boys network etc, but not in the circle I have access to in the UK. Where as people in equivalent circumstances to me in Ireland seem to need to know the right people to get jobs. Again, may just be the subset of people I mix with.

Greater interest in grooming - or example I was really surprised to find that people went for a blow dry before a funeral in Ireland. Again, a one off observation on the Irish side and maybe I don't go to the right funerals in the UK.

I'd be interested to know if these are really Irish things.

I have no idea if it's 'an Irish thing' but as it happens I did get my hair done before my father's funeral. I hadn't got it done for about a year beforehand. Is that ok or still worthy of looking down on? What a load of utter shit.
Apileofballyhoo · 06/01/2021 00:54

@InsertRudeWord

Sorry OP. IABU, ignore me.
Hope you're ok. Flowers
InsertRudeWord · 06/01/2021 00:26

Sorry OP. IABU, ignore me.

InsertRudeWord · 06/01/2021 00:17

We are in the middle of a pandemic, is this all you have to worry about?

Brissiegirl · 05/01/2021 23:53

Through my work I have dealt with many high end managers and CEOs of foreign companies who relocate to Ireland - mainly north america or asian who virtually all say they rate the Irish education system as one of the best for the broad education offered. All who sit the leaving cert exam have a good knowledge range of at least 6 different subjects studied at either ordinary or higher level. I know that I wouldn't have been happy for any of my children to give up core subjects at 15/16 to concentrate on just 3 subjects for A level. As they natured, they changed their study preferences and interests that they would have cut off many university courses if they had taken the English route imo.

2 of mine went to gaelcholaiste having previously gone to english language primaries. It wasn't snob or class based decision - it was recommended by teachers & they benefited from the extra academic challenge. They both had special needs kids in their year - as well as new immigrates. The idea that parents are using gaelcholaiste as a means to avoid certain types of student is certainly not true in my case.

The extra points in the leaving cert are not sufficient to persuade someone to study through Irish if it's not your first language imo. The extra points are only in certain subjects, and you only get the extra points as a sliding scale percentage of missed points - eg if u get 75% in the exam, you can get a small percentage boost of the 25% u missed. Secondly, studying higher maths or physics is hard in any language but trying to find qualified teachers is extremely difficult so many students are having to virtually study through english textbooks and then translate for the purposes of their exams. A few extra points are justified I feel.

Interesting thread.

Clearoutre · 05/01/2021 23:26

Danu2021

When I was in Belfast to see the titanic exhibition a few years ago, I saw so many people with either a tricolor or a union jack as a phone cover. I thought, wow, tell the world you're working class why don't you! :-p

Danu, Whereabouts are you from?

HollyCarrot · 05/01/2021 23:11

@wewillmeetagain

I went to school in the uk with a very large amount of Irish children and lots of Irish teachers as well ( catholic school). I can tell you now there is most definitely a class system among the Irish and the vast amount of inverted snobbery that goes with it!!!
Not to be rude but it's a bit cheeky to be telling actual Irish people who've been born and raised here about our snobbery. We can figure it out for ourselves like. And FWiW, I went to a fancy enough (although outside of Dublin, not fee paying) school and my daughter went to school in Dublin 4 for a while (Dublin 4 being pretty much the poshest place in the country). I can't ever recall being treated worse than the next guy who was a professor at university.
Danu2021 · 05/01/2021 23:07

@Piglet89

Just hopping on the thread to give a Northern Irish perspective. Like everywhere, NI has a wee class structure, so it does. Even the capital city has different classes!

Paddy Raff (a comedian from working class Catholic BT11, West Belfast) takes it off very well with his character of Protestant Nigel from BT9 (Lisburn and Malone Road - posh areas).

When I was in Belfast to see the titanic exhibition a few years ago, I saw so many people with either a tricolor or a union jack as a phone cover. I thought, wow, tell the world you're working class why don't you! :-p
Eggcorns · 05/01/2021 23:05

@Danu2021

Am I hallucinating or are the schools not going back until 1st February now. Give me strength. And wine.
Looks like it.