Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 07/01/2021 00:00

@mathanxiety

I was quoting another poster regarding girls/nursing/boys/ag college.

We just have such a range of school types in the UK that there is so much variation in standards/curriculum/ now. Free schools/academies/private/public/church/comprehensives and I don’t think we have the same consistency across the board with methodologies/training - I think the training varies.

mathanxiety · 06/01/2021 20:13

I went to a 'state school', (a 'Community School') way back in the late 70s, early 80s, then on to university.

University was not the choice of most of the kids at the school at the time and still isn't, but I am not sure this is an appropriate way to measure the performance of a school. As an example of a non-university route to a satisfying career, I can show you this example, featuring a guy I went to school with:
www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/people/first-encounters-dylan-bradshaw-and-paul-foley-1.1638557

The school I went to has changed quite a bit in the almost 50 years since. Of my friends who still live in the catchment, I can't think of any who have sent their own kids there. There are a few reasons for this, including preference of partners for another school and ease of getting kids to school in the morning if the trip to work is in another direction. However, it isn't what it used to be academically. That being said, about a quarter of students head off to university or the equivalent every year. (Including one student to the Royal College of Surgeons two years ago, Hatstrategicallydipped - I was impressed because it is hard to get into).

Way back then, we had very little sex education, but we definitely had some. Two girls from my year got pg before leaving school. A few who didn't go to university had babies a year or two after the Leaving Cert but had been involved in relationships with their partners for a few years by that point. Most are still with their partners, have homes of their own, families..

From what she’s told me the boys from Blackrock all think they’re god’s gift to mankind.
LOL, YYY, twas ever the case. Clearly, 'plus ça change'.
(Though the girls I knew in university from Mount Anville and Alex were among the nicest.)

@LadyfromtheBelleEpoque, I agree much was known about the camps and the Holocaust, but at government level only; the general public were not informed, hence the shock of the soldiers who stumbled upon the camps. One of those soldiers was an uncle of mine who was a nephew of an Irish government minister of the time. My uncle was an officer, an engineer. He retired from military service after his military experience ended a few km south of Bergen Belsen.

I know that the common narrative around education is that Irish is best. Tbh, I am sick of this. I don’t think we compare like with like as there are so many good UK institutions that exist outside of the cities that few in the Irish communities really experience.

I completely disagree with the idea that good schools outside of Dublin are few and far between. This may have been true back in the 1960s but it isn't now. I also disagree with your contention that girls study nursing and boys go to an ag college and then back to the farm, that that this is the expected route for most boys and girls.

I disagree because it is clear that somebody is applying for and being admitted to over 40,000 third level places offered in Ireland annually, and those places are not all in nursing or ag (though I also take issue with the implied disparagement of the ag area, in which there are enormous opportunities, all requiring some specialised ed).
In 2019, 57k students sat the LC, and 50k were offered third level places.

I also disagree because the 2018 PISA rankings objectively disprove your opinion.

The key findings of the 2018 assessments include:

  • Ireland ranks 4th out of 36 OECD countries and 3rd out of 27 EU countries for reading literacy

  • Ireland ranks 8th out of 77 countries/regions involved in PISA 2018 for reading literacy[1]

  • in reading, Ireland has significantly fewer low-performing students (11.8% below level 2) and significantly more high performers (12.1% at levels 5 and 6) than the OECD average

  • PISA results show the difference in performance between schools in Ireland is lower than the OECD

  • in Ireland, the difference between schools in student performance in reading literacy is less than half of what it is, on average, across OECD countries[2]

  • post-primary schools in Ireland can therefore be considered relatively equitable, as well as having above average performance in the three assessment domains

  • Ireland has a lower percentage of low-performing students in all three domains than on average across OECD countries

  • girls perform better than boys in reading, with a difference of 23.2 score points[3]

  • Ireland’s performance in science and mathematics has remained relatively stable – above the OECD average scores – between 2015 and 2018 cycles

  • girls perform slightly better than boys in science but the results are not considered statistically significant

  • in science, students ranked 17th out of 37 OECD countries, 11th out of 28 EU countries and 22nd out of 78 participating countries/regions

  • Ireland has a lower than average number of low performing students in science

  • in mathematics, Irish students ranked 16th out of 37 OECD countries and 21st out of 78 participating countries/regions

  • Ireland has a lower than average number of low performing students in maths

www.gov.ie/en/press-release/f6e114-major-international-study-finds-irelands-students-among-top-performe/

Cacacoisfarraige · 06/01/2021 20:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 06/01/2021 19:58

Schools offered Gaeltacht? As in, paid for it?? Thta was pretty amazing. I went but yes myself and one other that summer, not widespread. Many wouldn't have gone near it tbf.

MarDhea · 06/01/2021 19:45

I'm Irish and have worked at Irish and overseas universities for years, but I remember when I came back to work at an Irish university after years working in England that I realised my phone manner when dealing with HR or payroll etc had become more formal and demand-focused, and that, while I was being perfectly polite, I was saying hello and moving immediate to whatever I needed and appeared unfriendly by the norms of the institution, and had to consciously adjust my approach. Sometimes someone who is either from somewhere else, or just used to the style of somewhere else, needs a nudge towards local norms I certainly did.

Oh this in spades! Took me a while to click back into Irish norms of roundabout chit chat before you move onto whatever work issue made you pick up the phone or call into an office. It's important to ask about Mary's day and discuss the amazing/atrocious weather; and (if you're talking face to face) maybe ask about her daughter and is she finished her nursing placement yet and sure the commute must be hard on her...Grin

Irish culture is pretty indirect and implicit, in some ways the polar opposite of the very direct Dutch culture.

choli · 06/01/2021 19:28

I had heard that in Australia experience trumps all whereas here it's qualification first and then experience. Australia makes more common sense really but that's our system, as such.
I no longer live in Ireland but when I did it seemed to be who you know first, all else second.

NothingICanDo · 06/01/2021 19:18

Gaeltacht summers are probably quite a middle class thing
Definitely not. We would have gone to school in a very working class(poor if you like) area and every school offered three weeks in the gealtacht.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 06/01/2021 19:11

Yes I have heard that about orphans or children from the laundries Sad

I had heard that in Australia experience trumps all whereas here it's qualification first and then experience. Australia makes more common sense really but that's our system, as such.

Cacacoisfarraige · 06/01/2021 19:09

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

drsambeckett · 06/01/2021 19:09

My mother would have said this about her convent school. The poor girls that couldn’t afford uniforms or to pay for their lunches had to clean the classrooms after lessons had finished as payment. So much for charity.

Cacacoisfarraige · 06/01/2021 19:03

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LadyEloise · 06/01/2021 19:03

My grandaunt told me that as a child of small farmers she was looked down on by the townies, at school in a small country town.
It really impacted her confidence.
Thankfully she rose above it and did well materially in life. She was a very kind and generous woman and shared what she had.
There was a real sense of knowing your place in society. I'm not sure that has been eliminated but it has been minimised somewhat.

choli · 06/01/2021 18:53

Class is a thing in Ireland but a different type of thing to England. My mother (from a poor Catholic family) clearly remembers that the kids of the more well-off, “respectable” families sat up the front of class, got treated as favourites by the nuns teaching her.
I'm in my 50s and this was a definite thing in my small country town in both primary and secondary schools. The children of farmers were treated a lot better than the children from the council houses.

Danu2021 · 06/01/2021 18:32

Education is valued here that is for sure. As another person (like the Australian mentioned upthread) I've struggled to find jobs with just experience and no degree. I feel it's really haunted me. I don't think ''be more Irish'' would be serious advice to an Australian though. I'm sorry but I think that was misconstrued. There is racism but you're certainly allowed to be Australian. The competition for jobs is fierce though. Maybe that woman was up against somebody who had the qualifications and the experience. I've always been told quite bluntly there were better candidates.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 06/01/2021 18:18

Ha ha, I would love to have a base cois farraige Wink but yes can see the downsides!

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 06/01/2021 18:17

Absobleedinlutely! It comes across as making a point of not getting in touch. I have had this with my Bil and his wife. They're dead to me now.

Cacacoisfarraige · 06/01/2021 17:53

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LadyEloise · 06/01/2021 16:55

".... if people don't acknowledge a death it is seen as a v personal slight."

I agree.
My dsis is in a small Whatsapp group and a death in the family was not sympathised with by one of the group. Nothing, nada was said. No text, card etc.
That person is now persona non grata to dsis. Smile

SionnachRua · 06/01/2021 16:09

@SunniCameHomeWithAVengeance

On the funerals thing, Irish funerals happen very quickly after a death and are usually well attended. When I lived in England a colleague's mother died. I tried to organise a wreath and who was going but found that it wasn't the done thing and no one asked if the colleague was ok when she came back. The death just wasn't acknowledged. This happened frequently over my years there, death and funerals and grieving is very much behind closed doors. In Ireland the chief mourners are pampered and turned out looking well because all and sundry turn up to shake your hand and express their condolences (pre covid). Then theres generally an 'afters' in a local pub where theres soup and sandwiches put on and teas and coffee. Family members and friends and neighbours who might not have seen each other in years swap stories, often of youthful mischief. People will stop the bereaved on the street to sympathise if they didn't make it to the funeral. Ask how they are, if they've lost someone in similar circumstances will mention it and generally no one is really just left to it.
And absolutely anyone and everyone can/will turn up at the funeral or the removal. I remember my Junior Infant teacher appeared at my Granny's funeral! I was 20 years out of her class at that stage!

I love the Irish culture around funerals tbh, I feel it's one of the things we get really right.

PenelopePunt · 06/01/2021 15:23

@caperplips See, we’ve experienced the opposite in reverse. I’ve been here seven years, my friend ten years, and have not seen any of the Irish socially outside of work. Certainly other non-Irish colleagues, and the year before last it was a big topic across our Christmas table; with 12 people, seven nationalities and mostly non academic, very few had been invited to an Irish persons home or could call an Irish person a good friend. We came to the conclusion that if you’re in your native country, you already have a social network of family and friends so often don’t have the need or time for new members. An immigrant of course does as they’re trying to build a new network, often from scratch, so needs and expectations are already out of balance. So it’s not a criticism of only the Irish as everyone can easily be guilty of it. Plus I’m aware towards the end of my time in the U.K. I just got tired of making friends with new arrivals as I expected they would move on to another new country, and I just didn’t feel like investing my time and energy anymore.

One aspect I definitely admire is the Irish approach to funerals. I do feel uncomfortable attending when I’ve never met the deceased, but it feels like a cloak of love and understanding is wrapped around the family and loved ones. I’ve really felt for people not being able to grieve and receive the same love and community during the pandemic.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 06/01/2021 14:34

I have to say I feel so much for people who haven't been able to grieve in that way this year.. We had what my dc calls 'Granny' s Goodbye Party*, people queued at our door to come in, people take days off work and travel etc, it means so much. The meal and chat afterwards all so supportive to the grieving family. Likewise, if people don't acknowledge a death it is seen as a v personal slight.

SunniCameHomeWithAVengeance · 06/01/2021 14:19

On the funerals thing, Irish funerals happen very quickly after a death and are usually well attended. When I lived in England a colleague's mother died. I tried to organise a wreath and who was going but found that it wasn't the done thing and no one asked if the colleague was ok when she came back. The death just wasn't acknowledged. This happened frequently over my years there, death and funerals and grieving is very much behind closed doors. In Ireland the chief mourners are pampered and turned out looking well because all and sundry turn up to shake your hand and express their condolences (pre covid). Then theres generally an 'afters' in a local pub where theres soup and sandwiches put on and teas and coffee. Family members and friends and neighbours who might not have seen each other in years swap stories, often of youthful mischief. People will stop the bereaved on the street to sympathise if they didn't make it to the funeral. Ask how they are, if they've lost someone in similar circumstances will mention it and generally no one is really just left to it.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 06/01/2021 13:53

Another success story for a Syrian refugee in Ireland here

www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2020/0917/1165718-suaad-alshleh/

If anyone knows anything about medicine - the Royal College of Surgeons is virtually impossible to get into. To get a bursary?

So there is good and bad in Ireland. Definitely. And I hate admitting that. But we could do better I think.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 06/01/2021 13:48

There are two sides to Ireland I think. I wish we were all lovely, but unfortunately we're not.

A success story.

www.irishtimes.com/news/education/student-who-came-to-ireland-from-syria-with-little-english-gets-602-leaving-cert-points-1.3990071

Something we should be ashamed of

www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/fire-breaks-out-again-at-proposed-leitrim-asylum-centre-1.3790373

I am so proud of being Irish, but sometimes we seem like the backwards idiots that we've been stereotyped as being.

caperplips · 06/01/2021 13:33

@PenelopePunt your observations are v interesting to me as I work with academics from both universities & institutes of technology in Ireland. I am Irish. I have sat on interview panels but have not encountered discrimination regarding where graduates have attended college.

I too echo @Eggcorns thoughts that your friends have been unlucky. In my experience Irish universities are v multicultural & I have numerous friends & colleagues who are from other countries. One such US academic friend relocated to Ireland from the UK with his partner & adopted child & is so happy here & v accepted (gay couple, child different ethnicity) so much so that they've bought a house & are planning to settle here. They left the UK city they'd been living in as they were experiencing a lot of homophobia & latterly racism with their dc. And that surprised me.

I have spent time working in academia in Australia. It was a relatively short time as was for a specific research project. During this time I invited a number of people I'd met through the university to dinner in my apartment including a South American professor from another department. I introduced him to a number of his colleagues from other departments & was surprised that although they'd overlapped & knew each other to see they'd never actually spoken.
He told be afterwards that although he'd been working there over 2 years by that stage he'd never been invited to anyone's house in that time & he was v appreciative to have been invited by me since I didn't know him that well. To me it was perfectly normal but he was so grateful! So I guess you find these sorts of experiences wherever you go.