Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
Amammi · 07/01/2021 17:07

@Hatstrategicallydipped

That was the blooming Catholic Church stayathomer. Thankfully, we're out from under their thumbs now too! It was utterly appalling and something every Irish person should be ashamed of. I certainly am. It's a horrible part of our history. Disgraceful and shameful. But look, it's done now and we can try to do better in future.
Have you seen the conditions in direct provision? The nuns didn’t land in Ireland from the moon - they were Irish as were their staff and most of the poor women and children were forced to attend their institutions. We are no better now.
Hatstrategicallydipped · 07/01/2021 17:01

Re entry to the Royal College of Surgeons, entry isn't particularly harder than other unis for medicine. It's fee paying though, so to get in, you need rich parents plus the points OR to get a bursary (extremely difficult).

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 07/01/2021 16:43

Another thing is that education is greatly valued here, not by all maybe, but across the social classes, by and large. My privileges above, and I also spent time in France, were because of sacrifices I now see my parents made. They didn't go on holidays themselves for example. Education and opportunity for us was first, always.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 07/01/2021 16:32

That was fantastic you were offered that. I went to Coláiste Pheig Sayers and later Coláiste na bhFiann, an-strict! Wink

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 07/01/2021 16:31

Yes of course hat, but I'm wondering in what context she uses her IL's address for?

Hatstrategicallydipped · 07/01/2021 16:28

@NothingICanDo

That's insane! It would have been around 2002 when I went. We definitely didn't pay even a fraction of that.
Did you get an A in Irish at least? Grin

My parents paid for my older brother to go to a thing called Eurolanguages - for French for 3 weeks. Similar to Gaeltacht - just spoke French all the time.
For me they paid for nada
They paid for the Gaeltacht for my younger sister.

Not remotely bitter about that

NothingICanDo · 07/01/2021 16:17

That's insane! It would have been around 2002 when I went. We definitely didn't pay even a fraction of that.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 07/01/2021 16:09

@NothingICanDo

HeyGirlHeyBoy Schools offered Gaeltacht? As in, paid for it?? Thta was pretty amazing. I went but yes myself and one other that summer, not widespread. Many wouldn't have gone near it tbf

If I remember correctly we just had to pay the train fare and a small contribution to the Bean an tí. I'm not sure how the rest was funded Confused But you always got the chance to go, at the end of 2nd year and 5th year.

It wasn't a popular thing. I'd say out of 100 students in each year.. about 12-15 would choose to go.

It's about 1200 for the 3 weeks nowadays. Only the rich could afford it back in my day. There was no funding unless your parents were willing to cough up (which mine were not).
Hatstrategicallydipped · 07/01/2021 16:07

To anyone reading who is not Irish, they constructed I think 4 tower blocks of flats in Ballymum (council), but put absolutely no facilities in such as schools/parks etc. It was deemed to be the way of the future initially, but it became a complete ghetto, riddled with drugs and crime. The 80's was an awful time for heroin in Ireland. Tony Felloni was responsible for a lot of the heroin, even getting his own daughter hooked on heroin. I, spoke to him a few times in my job after his release from prison as my boss was his solicitor lol. He became good friends with Gilligan in prison too (also our client!).

NothingICanDo · 07/01/2021 16:02

HeyGirlHeyBoy
Schools offered Gaeltacht? As in, paid for it?? Thta was pretty amazing. I went but yes myself and one other that summer, not widespread. Many wouldn't have gone near it tbf

If I remember correctly we just had to pay the train fare and a small contribution to the Bean an tí. I'm not sure how the rest was funded Confused But you always got the chance to go, at the end of 2nd year and 5th year.

It wasn't a popular thing. I'd say out of 100 students in each year.. about 12-15 would choose to go.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 07/01/2021 16:02

I remember coverage of the towers in Ballymun constantly on the news - that was one failure of city planning! It was rife with heroin in the 80's.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 07/01/2021 16:00

@HeyGirlHeyBoy

What does she use her IL's address for?! Google maps means it's probably closer to Ballymun than Finglas iykwim, that was the case when I lived in Drumcondra, it was closer to Phibsboro..
Surely you must know the negative reputation Ballymun has?
Hatstrategicallydipped · 07/01/2021 15:59

Have any of you seen a film about a little mixed race girl who was in an orphanage run by the nuns? It is NOT an easy watch. They used to scald her, beat the shit out of her, leave her standing in the cold all night long. Absolutely heartbreaking. She's now a nurse in England. I can't remember the name of the film and have tried to find it to watch again (horrible though it is) as I feel it's my duty to be reminded often of the horrors of the 'religious'. evil cunts

Apart from achieving independence from Britain, our greatest achievement has been opening our eyes to the absolute scandalous, abhorrent cruel ways of the Catholic 'church'.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 07/01/2021 15:57

What does she use her IL's address for?! Google maps means it's probably closer to Ballymun than Finglas iykwim, that was the case when I lived in Drumcondra, it was closer to Phibsboro..

Hatstrategicallydipped · 07/01/2021 15:53

That was the blooming Catholic Church stayathomer. Thankfully, we're out from under their thumbs now too! It was utterly appalling and something every Irish person should be ashamed of. I certainly am. It's a horrible part of our history. Disgraceful and shameful. But look, it's done now and we can try to do better in future.

stayathomer · 07/01/2021 14:39

My mum said in her convent that there were some orphans and they were treated so badly. She still feels shame she didn’t say anything but how could she have protected them when she was only a child

Irish history rivals only the worst in the world in how it treated its children, teenagers and lower classes. I love being irish but I'm ashamed of our history in that respect

PenelopePunt · 07/01/2021 12:57

Sorry, I feel I’ve taken this a bit far off topic. I do think there is a class system in Ireland, but it’s not as entrenched or obvious as perhaps the U.K. The higher education system is certainly one marker, the city / culchie (sp?) is another, and in Dublin, certainly the Northside / Southside divide followed by the suburb. One Irish friend (we do have some!) uses her ILs Glasnevin address rather than her own address as while most address systems record her as living in Finglas, Google maps puts her estate in Ballymun.

Eggcorns · 07/01/2021 12:54

[quote PenelopePunt]@Eggcorns It’s a bit of a running joke in our expats group that “Let’s catch up for coffee” is Irish for goodbye It isn’t that the locals (and I’m not just talking about the university environment) are rude or unfriendly, they’re just disinterested. Another friend did her Masters here, and said her classes were about 45% Irish / 55% foreign, and she made one Irish friend and half a dozen non Irish friends. I think it can depend somewhat on your nationality too, as some are seen as less desirable than others. Americans are very popular.[/quote]
That was absolutely my experience in village England (though not in Oxford or London, where I also lived longterm, and where I made English friends, though those friendships took longer than friendships with fellow-foreigners), where I felt everyone was dug into the same friends they had made at school, and weren't interested in incomers.

Are you in Dublin? Because my personal experiences of foreign postgrads/academics integrating very thoroughly and permanently and/or marrying Irish people (and me making foreign-born friends) have been in Galway and Cork, though the recently-arrived friend who has already made lots of friendships is in Dublin.

PenelopePunt · 07/01/2021 12:40

@Eggcorns It’s a bit of a running joke in our expats group that “Let’s catch up for coffee” is Irish for goodbye It isn’t that the locals (and I’m not just talking about the university environment) are rude or unfriendly, they’re just disinterested. Another friend did her Masters here, and said her classes were about 45% Irish / 55% foreign, and she made one Irish friend and half a dozen non Irish friends. I think it can depend somewhat on your nationality too, as some are seen as less desirable than others. Americans are very popular.

mathanxiety · 07/01/2021 08:36

Your own stats demonstrate that your school was far from average! Unless you're suggesting that most Irish school pupils will go on to be barristers and suchlike, with practically no-one left to empty the bins, ort work in retail, care, gardening, transport...etc.?

Your stats indicate the demographic of students attending the school (middle class, with engaged, interested parents) rather than anything spectacularly different about Irish education.

My list of non-fee paying schools is directed @HavelockVetinari

My own community school year saw about one third of the students who started out with me leave after the Inter Cert, with two thirds doing the LC. A really striking proportion of those who went to university ended up with PhDs and staying in academia, but there are many with science, engineering, business, and arts degrees, and two doctors.

mathanxiety · 07/01/2021 08:12

From www.joe.ie/life-style/top-performing-fee-paying-non-fee-paying-schools-ireland-575368

Non fee-paying schools with the highest percentage of students in third level from 2009-2016.

Coláiste Íosagáin (Dublin) - 100%
Laurel Hill (Limerick) - 99%
Coláiste Eoin (Dublin) - 99%
Cólaiste an Phiarsaigh (Cork) - 98%
Jesus and Mary Secondary School (Galway) - 98%
Coláiste an Spioraid Naoimh (Cork) - 98%
Ard Scoil Iognáid Rís (Limerick) - 97%
Coláiste na Coiribe (Galway) - 97%
St Kieran's (Kilkenny) - 97%
St Gerald's College (Mayo) - 97%
Tempeleogue College (Dublin) - 97%
St Macartan's (Monaghan) - 96%
Muckross Park (Dublin) - 96%
Presentation Secondary School (Kerry) - 96%
Knocklyon Community School (Dublin) - 95%
Ursuline Secondary School (Tipperary) - 95%
Tralee Community School (Kerry) - 95%
Loreto Convent (Wexford) - 95%

Some of these schools are single sex and privately run by religious orders. Some are community schools.

Funding of secondary schools in Ireland is a funny old bird.

MadameMiggeldy · 07/01/2021 07:11

We just have such a range of school types in the UK that there is so much variation in standards/curriculum/ now. Free schools/academies/private/public/church/comprehensives and I don’t think we have the same consistency across the board with methodologies/training - I think the training varies

I can’t directly compare the pedagogical input across all of the teacher training colleges - but I will say ROI doesn’t have the massive idealogical differences between school types (most primaries - broadly similar, most secondaries - broadly similar). AFAIK there is no school type where there is no actual requirement to have a qualified teacher in the room. That’s quite different to England where cover supervisors , unqualified staff, HLTAs are established grades. Open to correction but I don’t think there is a legal requirement to have a teacher (ie QTS) in Academies or Free Schools.

mathanxiety · 07/01/2021 06:32

Wrt RCSI admission -

in 2020 Irish Leaving Certificate or equivalent points (for students who successfully entered the RCSI Medicine programme) ranged from 554 to 625 and HPAT-Ireland scores ranged from 168 to 207. The combined HPAT and points score required for admission to the Undergraduate Medicine programme in 2020 was 733.

For UCD:
The minimum points at which anyone was admitted were 555 (which required HPAT of at least 186)
The minimum HPAT score at which anyone was admitted was 171 (which required at least 621 points)

The RCSI admitted a lot of foreign applicants in decades past, perhaps making it harder for Leaving Cert applicants to get in.

www.rcsi.com/dublin/undergraduate/medicine/fees-and-funding
Fees ^

sammylady37 · 07/01/2021 05:38

I’m surprised at people saying the Royal College of Surgeons is hard to get into. When I was a medical student in a different college, over 20 years ago, the standing joke was that the medical degree from RCSI was purely a receipt as all you needed to do to get it was pay the high fees as it didn’t have the same points requirement as the other colleges. I thought that it had since become part of the CAO system and that those fees were abolished, but I’m out of the loop really do could be wrong on that.

Eggcorns · 07/01/2021 00:09

@MarDhea

I'm Irish and have worked at Irish and overseas universities for years, but I remember when I came back to work at an Irish university after years working in England that I realised my phone manner when dealing with HR or payroll etc had become more formal and demand-focused, and that, while I was being perfectly polite, I was saying hello and moving immediate to whatever I needed and appeared unfriendly by the norms of the institution, and had to consciously adjust my approach. Sometimes someone who is either from somewhere else, or just used to the style of somewhere else, needs a nudge towards local norms I certainly did.

Oh this in spades! Took me a while to click back into Irish norms of roundabout chit chat before you move onto whatever work issue made you pick up the phone or call into an office. It's important to ask about Mary's day and discuss the amazing/atrocious weather; and (if you're talking face to face) maybe ask about her daughter and is she finished her nursing placement yet and sure the commute must be hard on her...Grin

Irish culture is pretty indirect and implicit, in some ways the polar opposite of the very direct Dutch culture.

Exactly this! I was retrospectively mortified at what have must come across as rude over-directness but I had to consciously settle myself back into the conversational approach to asking someone to do something. And I had a Dutch doctoral student who needed a few pointers about her ‘directness’ in seminars...

I’m still surprised at @PenelopePunt’s experience of not making Irish friends at Irish universities. I have had no less than four overseas doctoral students marry Irish people and settle here, and lots of my foreign-born Ireland-based friends arrived as junior academics or postgrads. More recently, a friend took up an academic job here just this year and was taken aback at all the invitations, offers of practical help etc from colleagues and neighbours.