Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
HeyGirlHeyBoy · 04/01/2021 15:20

I think the pp means an Sna in a lot of classes perhaps. The Irish primary curriculum is Child-centred, holistic, process over product, depth over width of learning. Lots of experiential and project work. 3h of the arts per week say. I do love the variety we have in teaching. Standardised tests annually but that's one week and it's not a public situation as parents are informed privately wrt ranking and it's a percentile rank.

SionnachRua · 04/01/2021 15:18

The high representation of private schools in Trinity would be explained a lot by those achieving higher points coming from educated intelligent parents perhaps where a focus may have been more on their academics than on their ability to play Gaelic for their county.

Honestly as someone who worked in a private school we had our fair share of the dim and lazy. Difference was mainly that the parents were able to pay for expensive grinds (and in some cases bought their kids way out of Irish with an exemption from a dubious Ed Psych).

Hatstrategicallydipped · 04/01/2021 15:17

Correction - I did 9 at Junior Cert level/GCSE

Hatstrategicallydipped · 04/01/2021 15:16

I don't know how many subjects are usually studied at GCSE level in the UK? In Ireland we do 9 or 10. So I did 10 for e.g.
Irish
English
Maths
French
History
Geography
Science
Business Studies
Home Economics (Domestic Science in the UK?)

For Leaving Cert I did
Irish
English
Maths
French
Physics
Chemistry
Biology

At uni I studied Business (despite my 3 sciences!) and have worked in Business all of my life.

SionnachRua · 04/01/2021 15:15

As an Irish teacher I absolutely agree that the Irish system is superior. For kids and staff alike, much healthier and happier approach to learning. I wouldn't touch working or schooling my own kids in England (particularly England, rest of the UK seems more tolerable) with a barge pole.

However...

I can - whilst the classes are still 30 (mine are in a national school), there is a teacher and an assistant in every class

This is very rare in Irish schools ime. Well, not the 30+ bit but an assistant in each class isn't common.

scubadub · 04/01/2021 15:12

I'll put it to you this way OP. I went to an average state secondary in Ireland-
Out of my close friends we have
3 primary teachers (a well paid job here)
2 nurses
A psychiatrist
A CEO Of an international company
A dog groomer- own business
A microbiologist
An orthopaedic surgeon
A barrister

The rest of my year are similar-
A lot of nurses and teachers- most work abroad though - UAE etc
A few went into business and did really well in Dublin/London
A lot went into science degrees- environmental, pharmacy etc
One is in media here in Ireland- well enough known.
And business was a popular choice for my year too...

I know this mostly through word of mouth(that's the Irish for ya 🤣)...Facebook etc

Danu2021 · 04/01/2021 15:11

A levels would suit my son better than the LC. He has no gift at all for languages. If he could just do maths, applied maths and physics he'd be flying but having to figure out strategies to scrape a D in english and irish are a challenge.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 04/01/2021 15:09

In general I just really prefer the Irish school system because of the broader range of subjects. I definitely see the appeal of A levels because it allows you to follow your interests, but I think it's too young to focus on three subjects.

I think it shows a lot with English people. They can be highly educated, but their knowledge is very limited in scope.

Danu2021 · 04/01/2021 15:07

@Hatstrategicallydipped

I find that English people try to pigeon hole the Irish as they can't tell much from an accent or an education, so we baffle them. A lot of my English colleagues thought I came from money. I didn't correct them Grin
This is true. They cannot read us. Not sure they're trying!!
NothingIcando · 04/01/2021 15:07

I get the impression it was to look good on the schools application form. She said all the kids in dc's class have Irish names so I'm thinking it's a subtle MC marker?!
Yes my sister expressed regret after she named her child a non Irish name and then put childs name down for Irish school. She said all the other kids would have better sounding Irish names..Hmm she gave her next child a VERY Irish name..

Danu2021 · 04/01/2021 15:06

Yes, it was definitely a thing in about 1984. They may have decided to cut costs and drop it as neither of my DC went through this.

I've a colleague from Donegal and she thought it was an oooo la la thing that we had elocution lessons, but it was just an ordinary national school. I remember the lady gave out to me for picking my nose, so I switched off after that. That learned her :-p Wine

AbsentmindedWoman · 04/01/2021 15:06

My schools were excellent, Catholic but religion was not rammed down our throats. There were two or three school masses a year. 'Religion class' consisted of talking about what was going on in the world, and discussing a diverse range of issues broadly located in psychology or sociology.

My impression is that UK Catholic schools are a lot more religious.

In general I just really prefer the Irish school system because of the broader range of subjects. I definitely see the appeal of A levels because it allows you to follow your interests, but I think it's too young to focus on three subjects.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 04/01/2021 15:04

I find that English people try to pigeon hole the Irish as they can't tell much from an accent or an education, so we baffle them. A lot of my English colleagues thought I came from money. I didn't correct them Grin

SkylightAndChandelier · 04/01/2021 15:04

Can anyone say in what way the schools are better in ROI? Sounds interesting!

I can - whilst the classes are still 30 (mine are in a national school), there is a teacher and an assistant in every class, the classrooms are purpose built (so that's a lovely big warm room, with plenty of light and high ceilings for each class, with toilet per class). The school (which admittedly is known as a very good school) is super hot on special needs and other provision so each child genuinely has the support they need, and the teachers are communicative and care about all the children. The only bad thing I can say about the school mine go to is for some reason they eat their lunch in the playground rather than having a proper lunch hour (and it's all packed - no provided dinners).

What comes as a shock if you're coming from the UK is the amount of involvement you are expected to have, and how proscriptive it can be - eg buying all the kids school books, parental contribution, specifying what kind of bag they should bring, and supervising daily homework, which seems more involved than at the UK school my kids went to, or the international schools they were at.

When it gets to secondary, I think it's likely we will send the kids private - but it should be mentioned that it's 1/3rd of the price of a UK school, so much more achievable for normal people.

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 15:02

The lady in question has also given her kids Irish names spelt in a ridiculous way (not the normal way the names are usually spelled). I get the impression it was to look good on the schools application form. She said all the kids in dc's class have Irish names so I'm thinking it's a subtle MC marker?!

OP posts:
TeaEgg · 04/01/2021 14:59

[quote Danu2021]@TeaEgg there is variance though. It's not one box ''Middle Class''.

I did have elocution lessons when I was young.

When I was in the UK, a friend of mine told me I had a strong Irish accent. I had to bite my tongue![/quote]
Come to think of it, my school enforced compulsory elocution lessons! But in a completely ordinary parish primary in the late 70s/early80s, in an area which was then overwhelmingly working-class, so certainly not any kind of middle-class frill in our case.

To be honest, I quickly learned to discount what a particular subset of English person said about accents, after I realised that quite a number genuinely believe they don't have an accent at all.

Danu2021 · 04/01/2021 14:59

@Wolfff my family c of I but very culturally catholic imo. I have c of I friends who had to teach me not to push away my plate and say ''i'm stuffed'' and to instead say ''i've had an elegant sufficency'' but in my family all the obsessions were very traditional. Work hard! Be polite to teachers. Be respectful to OUR friends. do Well! Don't have Sex! Don't get Pregnant! Don't draw attention to yourself!!! Don't have notions!!

My mother is very pro life as well.

Argh no wonder I ran for the hills! My family is just my family and not the ambassor for any category of Irish society!

My son is at an ET as well, my mother hates how scruffy they look. Hoodies, blue hair, dreadlocks on the white kids. I find it relaxing as well. He started off in a primary school where everybody had a perfect life and I found it hard to be a single mother in that environment. My own issues which I've worked through, but still...........

Hatstrategicallydipped · 04/01/2021 14:58

The difference with uni in Ireland and the Uk though is that if you don't get the grades, you don't get in. Simple as that. You are allotted points based on 6 Leaving Cert Subjects (your higher 6). Therefore, if you're a bogger from Carlow, or a knobhead from Dalkey, if you ain't got the brainpower, you ain't getting in. The high representation of private schools in Trinity would be explained a lot by those achieving higher points coming from educated intelligent parents perhaps where a focus may have been more on their academics than on their ability to play Gaelic for their county.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 04/01/2021 14:55

Good lord, Northern Ireland is the most passremarking place I have ever been to (I grew up there) and the subtle markers of class and religion make the English look like amateurs. To start with you’ve got the whole Protestant/Catholic thing - you don’t go to your local school if it’s the “wrong” religion, and if you want to see cars as an ostentatious display of wealth, Belfast is the place to go! There is also a narrow window of things considered acceptable- the tribe mind is alive and well.

I don’t have a huge experience of down South but it does seem to not be particularly kind to “tall poppies” - to paraphrase pp said, if you’ve got a nice life, let us cut you down to size. If that’s not about keeping people in their place in just the same way as ideas about class, what is?

Yes, class is very much a thing in England but it’s far more accepting to outsiders.

actiongirl1978 · 04/01/2021 14:54

The Irish schools are often paid for schools so private to an extent. But much cheaper than here. So a couple of thousand a year instead of twenty thousand.

Also all Irish schools require you to pay for all books, paper, pens etc. Several hundred pounds a year from when they are little.

In my experience the Irish middle classes are well observed at the rugby or horse racing.
Lots of cashmere coats, 'country' hats and amazing leather boots (women) and to a man, cord trousers, brown brogues and thick country jackets.

Pop into the Shelbourne Hotel pre match to spot them in their happy environment.

My friend lives 'down country' and spots this type at her horse meets. There is a lot of wealth but it is is less flaunted and people are generally nicer to each other in my experience.

TeaEgg · 04/01/2021 14:53

And it's not to deny that appalling poverty and inequality still absolutely exist in Ireland, even now that it ranks so high on the UN Development Index, which ranks countries on life expectancy, income, education, literacy etc -- it's just that this poverty and inequality has a more nebulous relationship to social class as it is understood in the UK.

One of the good things about Ireland is that schools are more socially mixed and generally offer a good education, rather than middle-class children being hived off into private schools, and university fees are nowhere near the scale of England and Wales. And were free until not so long ago, so that is still circulating in terms of a good education being available freely to all classes.

What I also never hear in Ireland is what I often see on Mn 'Oh, my child isn't academic', and I also don't think there's the same suspicion of anything perceived to be 'intellectual'.

rattusrattus20 · 04/01/2021 14:51

Not so drastically different.

Ireland is a more unequal place than, say, the Scandinavian countries, but not as bad as the UK, nowhere near as bad as say the USA.

The Trinity College/30% privately educated stat referrenced above is probably as good a yardstick as any - the [very crudely] Irish of Oxbridge is about 70% state educated, whereas, in the UK, Oxbridge is about 60% state educated.

NothingIcando · 04/01/2021 14:50

That's funny you should mention the Irish speaking schools. The lady is was speaking about has her kids in one, they had their names down from birth
Both her & her DH laugh about the fact that neither of them speak the native language but love the school.. I wouldn't be able to cope not knowing the language. They're very brave!

Yes this is my sister. Had her kids names down from the birth and even had the children baptised despite not believing in god or having any faith (at the time it was a requirement to get into an irish school. I dont think this is the case anymore though). But it was all for 'the look' the school is miles away.
They are in long hours wrap around care and get home very late because of the distance. It makes life so difficult for them but sure...they look the part,dont they?

Hatstrategicallydipped · 04/01/2021 14:50

I grew up across the road from a very very very wealthy farmer. Was in the same class in school as one of the sons - though they kept to themselves to be honest. Anyway, said son tragically died a number of years ago and Michael O'Leary (of Ryanair notoriety) and Albert Reynolds (former Taoiseach) were at the funeral! We were definitely aware that they were in a different 'class' to us growing up.

Wolfff · 04/01/2021 14:48

Interesting.

I am married to a man who is of the remnants of the Anglo Irish ‘class’. Very snobby relatives who consider themselves above the ordinary. Their community of seem to like displays of wealth, posh cars, boats, horses, hunting, holiday homes etc.

Most of my kids cousins went to private school. Probably worse in many respects to the state schools my kids attended in the UK. e.g. emphasis on sports and not arts, very white and not diverse.

I used to go out with someone who was a typical Dublin 4. Reminds me in hindsight of the Ross O’Carroll Kelly books. Fluent in Irish, public school, Trinity, profession etc. But saw himself as downtrodden Irish.