Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 04/01/2021 17:12

@WildIrishRose1

Ireland is viewed as an adjunct to Britain- no she wasn’t -shoe was simply using her own knowledge of the UK system as a base to assess another system - we all do that.

Are you seriously telling me that you think you don’t?

partyatthepalace · 04/01/2021 17:11

Huh?!? There are loads of private schools in Ireland, but most if not all get state funding like state schools, and just charge fees on top so it’s much much cheaper for parents.

There is absolutely a middle class in Ireland, and in Dublin at least a significant portion of people are very aware of status re houses, cars, holidays etc (no different to UK.)

It’s a much smaller and significantly less well off country than the UK overall, and was obviously much poorer than it is now in the recent past, so it’s true the different levels of ‘MC’ (both in terms of money and varied tribes) aren’t as great.

Schooling standards I don’t have personal experience of, but what colleagues who’ve moved their kids from UK to Ireland or vv have said is that Irish education is more middling - without the highs and lows of the UK.

I love Ireland and work there a lot and have done for years to be clear, but your sis in law is throwing a rosy glow there.

OchonAgusOchonO · 04/01/2021 17:10

@tttigress

Do you actually have any figures on the Irish private school situation? I don't but the Irish professionals I know all attended private schools, so I would have thought it is fairly wide spread.

Did a bit of googling, and apparently 30% of Trinity College Dublin's intake is from a private school background: www.universitytimes.ie/2020/01/fee-paying-students-are-three-times-more-likely-to-attend-top-universities/

So I doubt Irish state schools are utopian.

There are a reasonable number of private schools in Dublin but very few elsewhere in the country. However, there are grinds schools where students can do the senior cycle (A Level equivalent in the cities). Some students do the full senior cycle there but a lot also just repeat the leaving cert if they don't get the uni course they want.

Overall, the public system is very good and seems better than the english one from what I have heard from friends.

So I doubt Irish state schools are utopian. Meow.

ganivet · 04/01/2021 17:07

I went to TCD. Try telling anyone who came through the Trinity Access Programme that Ireland doesn't have a class system. Try going to college debating with a North Dublin accent, and see how people react...

WildIrishRose1 · 04/01/2021 17:04

@WildIrishRose1 however, this is what has really pissed me off. OP is trying to add to her existing knowledge of education and comparing it to the one she knows - I really hate this aggressive sniping towards anyone English who discusses something Irish from anything other than an Irish perspective. It is alarmingly ignorant.

@LadyfromtheBelleEpoque you are perfectly entitled to your opinion. What I find ignorant, however, is the manner in which Ireland is viewed as an adjunct to Britain. My comment wasn't meant to be passive aggressive or sniping; I was quite clear in my view.

CP26 · 04/01/2021 17:00

I went to a south Dublin private school. There was definite exclusivity and snobbery - pretty much everyone continued to mix predominantly with other private school kids once we got to University and throughout our 20’s. Now in our 30’s many of us are married to someone else who went to private school. That said I don’t think anyone really thought about it in terms of ‘class’ in the way they do in the UK but more to do with American style status markers like money, looks, prospects. Some families had judges and barristers going back generations whereas others were first generation wealthy - it didn’t really matter.

I think there’s far more social mobility and fluidity in Ireland in general. I suppose as we were under British rule for so long an Irish ‘upper’ class didn’t really develop in the same way?

choli · 04/01/2021 16:45

@FoodieToo

I find the way you talk about 'class' on here really strange . People just don't do that in Ireland. You would be laughed at ! In fact when I read threads on here such as 'what class am I if I shop in M and S ?' etc. I am always waiting for someone to come along and take the piss totally but it doesn't happen !!
Class may not be discussed in public, but it is definitely a thing in Ireland, it's just unspoken.
LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 04/01/2021 16:35

I have read this whole thread and have been hesitant to post but here goes...

I think people are deluded to think class is not a concern in Ireland. I actually find it a far more class obsessed place than London where I grew up. In the UK we have acknowledged the role class plays in achieving success whereas in Ireland I find that (as someone astutely pointed out) your awareness/lack of awareness depends on your own position.

I worked in a CofI private boarding school. I like this

‘girls study nursing, have a few wild years and then marry well, the boys go to Agricultural College and take over the farm.’

and think they have it sussedWink

A lovely community who on the whole made me feel very welcome. I really liked the set up of the school and the pupils were great. There was a strong Christian presence there which obv is not for everyone.

I also worked as an assistant examiner for the state exams and in order to qualify had to sit a specialist exam on the Irish education system (there is a very good book I will try and link to for anyone who wants it).

I really think it is important to emphasise that in Ireland the whole country will take the same exam for Jc/lc but in the UK we have different exam boards (and I think trad they have differed quite significantly). I don’t think the impact of this should be underestimated.

I know that the common narrative around education is that Irish is best. Tbh, I am sick of this. I don’t think we compare like with like as there are so many good UK institutions that exist outside of the cities that few in the Irish communities really experience. The comparison has been shaped imv, on behaviour and criticisms Irish in the 80s had over their qualifications not been deemed equal in the UK.

It is complex but I have to say that most Irish I speak to privately criticise the rote nature of a system exceptionally easy to game, grinds and /paying for sharing essays are behind a lot the grade achievement, I think and finally qualification produced a table comparing exams -a leaving cert grade ‘A’ is equivalent to a ‘C’ at A’level - the difference is how broad the lc is with students having to study 6 subjects 16-18. And subjects you might not find complement your abilities such as languages (Eng/Irish) when you are arty or maths-/science inclined.

@WildIrishRose1 however, this is what has really pissed me off. OP is trying to add to her existing knowledge of education and comparing it to the one she knows - I really hate this aggressive sniping towards anyone English who discusses something Irish from anything other than an Irish perspective. It is alarmingly ignorant.

Danu2021 · 04/01/2021 16:26

@Hatstrategicallydipped yes of course they are Irish.

harrietm1987 · 04/01/2021 16:26

Oh and re trinity and the private school stats, a lot of posh brits send their children there. I worked with an OE who went there having missed out on an oxbridge place, so that could influence the numbers - it’s not just for Irish people.

Danu2021 · 04/01/2021 16:23

I wouldn't have thought that many people today would rule out Trinity because many, many years ago it was protestant. People clever enough to get in aren't that stupid! As we all know, you get in if you have the POINTS for the course you choose. My daughter has to have her CAO in by 1/2 and she has courses for both universities down, in order of how much she would like to do the courses. She would like to go to Trinity but UCD is nearby.

harrietm1987 · 04/01/2021 16:19

In NI anyway there are only a few private schools and they’re for rich kids who can’t pass the transfer test. Beckett famously referred to one of them as for the cream of Ulster - rich and thick. The fees though are tiny compared to the English private schools.

Having lived in NI, ROI and the UK I think that the differences in education have a massive impact on the influence of class later in life. In the UK a private education can buy you entry to certain social circles, universities and then careers. I was born in NI in a working class area to a single mother on benefits but went to a top grammar school, top university and now work in an elite profession. Much, much more difficult for someone with my background to do this in England say.

Also agree that the Irish in general look down on people with “notions”, especially those who lose the run of themselves!

TheMethodicalMeerkat · 04/01/2021 16:18

@Hatstrategicallydipped

But one middle class group that stays strong is the Church of Ireland farming family.

Ye, but they're not really Irish are they?

Seriously Hmm?
Hatstrategicallydipped · 04/01/2021 16:15

But one middle class group that stays strong is the Church of Ireland farming family.

And that group is actually considered upper class on all fronts.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 04/01/2021 16:14

But one middle class group that stays strong is the Church of Ireland farming family.

Ye, but they're not really Irish are they?

SionnachRua · 04/01/2021 16:11

Yes, Irish schools categorically do not have such a thing as a Teaching Assistant, however, any student requiring extra assistance will have a dedicated SNA (Special Needs Assistant).

Not exactly. It used to be that individual students were granted a certain amount of SNA hours. Now the model has changed so that schools get an allocation of SNA hours to be deployed among students as they see fit. Schools can appeal if they don't have enough SNA hours to meet their needs.

Was supposed to start this year but due to Covid they've pushed it back a year. I hate it personally, it's a cheap money saving move from the Government.

DressingGownofDoom · 04/01/2021 16:10

@Norfolker

The lady in question has also given her kids Irish names spelt in a ridiculous way (not the normal way the names are usually spelled). I get the impression it was to look good on the schools application form. She said all the kids in dc's class have Irish names so I'm thinking it's a subtle MC marker?!
Not the way they're usually spelled in England you mean?! That doesn't mean the spelling is ridiculous.
Sgtmajormummy · 04/01/2021 16:10

I’m English (nominally Protestant family) but I spent age 11-22 in Ireland. I went to the local State Catholic all girls secondary and TCD. I left Ireland in 1990 but still keep up with friends who have turned out to be graduate professionals (one TV celebrity!), a Maths professor, teachers, nurses, shop assistants and SAHMs.

There have been huge social changes since then, with the Green Tiger economy and a general increase in living standards. The Catholic Church has lost so much influence and Ireland is a European country in a way the UK never was.

But one middle class group that stays strong is the Church of Ireland farming family. They send their children to private secondary schools, where they meet more of their own kind. The girls study nursing, have a few wild years and then marry well, the boys go to Agricultural College and take over the farm. Thus perpetuating the line. Plenty of “mixed marriages now, of course. Rugby, cricket, canoeing clubs are the place to find them at play.

DressingGownofDoom · 04/01/2021 16:08

@scubadub

The other thing I think that I notice here is that rurally you couldn't really tell by size of house what "class" (for want of a better word) someone is. On my road I Have some quite large houses...and some smaller cottages, bungalows etc. One of the larger ones was built by a postman and his wife who works part time in retail. It's feckin huge...🤣 they also have 3 dc. One of the cottages (it is an old gate lodge and FAB) is owned by a doctor. A new large house (5bed) across from me was built and lived in by two teachers- they have 4 dc.

Just saying...🤣

Yes and a lot of the bigger newer houses have been built by someone who was left a field by their parents (often farmers if they're handing down land) and are able to direct a self build because they're a tradesman of some description. They wouldn't fit into the English middle classes but they've certainly got the means for the lifestyle if they wanted to choose it.
TheMethodicalMeerkat · 04/01/2021 16:05

I think it’s very difficult to compare as in my experience people in Ireland don’t tend to define themselves or others so much by class, at least not in the way that people in the UK tend to.

It’s not so much that class doesn’t exist but in Ireland any discussion of “middle class” in the media or politics is around income and income disparity whereas in the UK there seem to be all kinds of (often bloody ridiculous) middle class markers that appear to be very important to people, yet income isn’t necessarily one of those markers.

There’s certainly snobbery and “keeping up with the Joneses” in Ireland of course as well as poverty and social issues so it’s not some kind of utopia but people don’t have the seemingly firmly held views that WC = this and MC = that which you see so much of on MN.

stayathomer · 04/01/2021 16:02

Tainting and I apologise for all the grammar issues, my hands are so cold I can't type properly!!

Hatstrategicallydipped · 04/01/2021 16:01

@HeyGirlHeyBoy

In my case my grandfather was a plumber and my grandmother stayed at home. Yet they had a nanny and all 7 children went to private Inc boarding school for the girls. Find it hard to get my head around that.
One of my cousins is a plumber and rolling in it.
stayathomer · 04/01/2021 16:01

Tbf Trinity college is considered fairly elite, so isn't necessarily a good example. My dc go/went to UCD and consider Trinity as being very posh.
And every place I've worked or the two universities I went to didn't rate Trinity at all, they're all about theory and very little practical. A lot just end up lecturing there apparently! We're told here we have ome of the best education systems but I dont know, it's apples and nd oranges isnt it? We do a lot more subjects for our final exams than you do in Britain so I dont know if you have a better education as more specific. As for class, I know a fair few well off people but you wouldn't know it the way I guess you might in Britain?( again tv and media might be taunting my image of what happens there!!!!)

Hatstrategicallydipped · 04/01/2021 16:01

[quote SionnachRua]@SkylightAndChandelier I think the pp who said that it's probably an SNA was right. SNAs are usually only meant to work with their individual child - maybe a group if they're supporting more than one - but many will help as needed around the class. A good SNA is worth their weight in gold.

Anyway, sounds like a good school![/quote]
Yes, Irish schools categorically do not have such a thing as a Teaching Assistant, however, any student requiring extra assistance will have a dedicated SNA (Special Needs Assistant).

Spidey66 · 04/01/2021 15:58

I've only known class to be an issue on MN!