Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
CayrolBaaaskin · 04/01/2021 18:33

I think each society has different issues and they are not directly comparable. I would note though that it’s not like private schools are actually all that common in the UK - over 90% of pupils go to state schools.

WildIrishRose1 · 04/01/2021 18:12

@HeyGirlHeyBoy

Really wildrose? I'm surprised, I wonder why they don't get tax relief/funding for their tax paying agents like every other school?! That's not publicised. Who is making up the massive shortfall?
Don't know; I'll have to explore further, as that is the extent of my knowledge on this matter. It could have changed in recent times...
caperplips · 04/01/2021 18:10

Interesting thread. My experience v closely mirrors @TeaEgg's.
I grew up in the Midlands in an economically depressed town, from a working class background. I attended a regular national school & the only girls secondary in town (convent). There were 5 classes of approx 25 each in my year & a mere handful of us from the top stream made it to university. Lots went on to work in areas like hairdressing, nursing, care work, catering, army (non officer), supermarkets, shops & factories.
Many had children v young.
I was the 1st in my family to go to university & I went to Trinity to do an 'elite' course with 15 places allocated per year at that time (90's)
I came from a Catholic, provincial, non farming, non private education background. I had not had access to expensive hobbies - sailing, horse riding etc
But for me the absolute wonder & joy of bring in TCD was getting to mix with the most diverse group of people - it blew my mind! There were students I knew from Anglo aristocracy, from famous theatrical families to other 'country kids' like me to some from v deprived inner city areas who were on scholarships. And we were all there on our own merit because we earned the points to be there.
I'm sure I was marked as being from the background I was from by those who cared about such things but I was largely unaware of it.
I thew myself into life there & loved it. I did a post grad in another Irish university & was pretty shocked by how strict the social parameters were & how readily people wanted to place you in one category or another. I was genuinely surprised as TCD had more of a reputation for being 'snooty' but my direct experience was the very opposite.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 04/01/2021 18:06

Really wildrose? I'm surprised, I wonder why they don't get tax relief/funding for their tax paying agents like every other school?! That's not publicised. Who is making up the massive shortfall?

WildIrishRose1 · 04/01/2021 17:53

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

WildIrishRose1 · 04/01/2021 17:50

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 04/01/2021 17:49

@Danu2021 do you think the private would be better or is it the CofI community you want?

I remember hearing that lots of pupils came from farming backgrounds and the families didn’t want them isolated at home so sent them to boarding school.

Danu2021 · 04/01/2021 17:43

@WildIrishRose1 thinks makes some people angry but from a church of ireland perspective it is harder to find a school that will take your child. I applied to Temple Carrig. No. I applied to Newpark. No. I can't afford the private school I went to myself.

Luckily the local catholic school (free) took my dc1 but at one point I was worried. Same story again for my second DC. If I had a bit more money I would have gone down the private school route I'm sure, but, I don't and they're both in good (state) schools.

It wouldn't break my heart if they did away with private schools but I can see why they exist.

If they did away with them tomorrow the govt would have to fully fund (as opposed to partially fund) 17 more schools? I think. I may not be understanding this correctly.

TheKeatingFive · 04/01/2021 17:43

Mind you, when I went to Trinity twenty years ago Shock there were plenty of catholics.

TheKeatingFive · 04/01/2021 17:42

I seem to remember that John Charles McQuaid (Catholic Archbishop of Dublin) banned Catholics from going to TCD at one point?

Yes absolutely. My FIL (product of a mixed marriage) had to apply for a special dispensation.

WildIrishRose1 · 04/01/2021 17:41

@TheKeatingFive

The other thing to say is that private schools are very good value for money in Ireland compared to U.K., so not totally out of reach for people.

And many of them were set up primarily to support minority religions, which explains how many Protestant ones are out there compared to prevalence in population.

Memories of the John Coolahan book on Irish education are flooding back!!

I find it interesting that a significant number of second-level schools in Ireland began as private schools, until Donagh O'Malley overhauled the system. There was always the VEC, but those schools catered for students who wanted a vocational education, rather than those who wished to go on to third level.

I seem to remember that John Charles McQuaid (Catholic Archbishop of Dublin) banned Catholics from going to TCD at one point?

Fifthtimelucky · 04/01/2021 17:40

@Notimeforaname

I read Mumsnet sometimes with my mouth dropping open - UK people are obsessed with class and being Middle Class. I actually don't think it's like that anywhere else

I feel the same. It seems like its everywhere here. Even if just mentioned for a second on a thread...its usually always there. Very strange to me.

I am nearly 60 and in real life I don't think I I've ever heard anyone mention it.

Mumsnet is obsessed with it!

TheKeatingFive · 04/01/2021 17:32

The other thing to say is that private schools are very good value for money in Ireland compared to U.K., so not totally out of reach for people.

And many of them were set up primarily to support minority religions, which explains how many Protestant ones are out there compared to prevalence in population.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 04/01/2021 17:30

@partyatthepalace

is that Irish education is more middling - without the highs and lows of the UK.

I think that is a good description.

I also agree that due to size/agrarian nature vs ind revolution, the influence of Commonwealth cultures and the crown/c of E link they do not compare evenly. That’s not a slight to Ireland rather the acknowledgment that it has a unique history that it has had to deal with (Church, language, immigration, colonial past, land issues).

TheKeatingFive · 04/01/2021 17:29

Oh it definitely exists. It is different though.

Firstly, the established aristocracy in Ireland (ROI) is tiny. It barely exists in fact, so that’s one big chunk taken out.

Secondly, there isn’t a huge amount of long established, generational wealth. This, along with a pretty good education system and reasonable uni costs makes social mobility much more possible.

Thirdly, there is a lot more social mixing across classes. This was the biggest different I noticed when living in the U.K.

Having said that, I am in south Dublin and most of my circle are privately school/trinity educated. There are clear class differences between those in rural towns/north inner city.

Oh and the other thing is that farmers are their own separate social class here when it comes to official classification. That says a lot about their importance in the country.

WildIrishRose1 · 04/01/2021 17:29

@HeyGirlHeyBoy

Or, a cynic would say, wildirishrose, that they're ensuring more government funded capitation grants!!
Just confirmed that Catholic fee-paying schools don't get capitation grants apparently. Protestant fee-paying ones do. I didn't realise this myself!
TeaEgg · 04/01/2021 17:28

@ganivet

I went to TCD. Try telling anyone who came through the Trinity Access Programme that Ireland doesn't have a class system. Try going to college debating with a North Dublin accent, and see how people react...
And I think a lot of the people who are insistent on class being a 'thing' and I don't think anyone has claimed Ireland is a classless utopia, just that poverty and inequality are less enmeshed with class shibboleths and markers than in the UK are Dublin-based and thinking primarily of Dublin, which can be spectacularly inward-looking.

My parents are a retired binman and a hospital cleaner, and I went to the local parish school in a traditionally working-class area for both primary and secondary, then on to university first one in my family to stay at school past fourteen and I was far from the only working-class accent in tutorials or at the debating society, or the only one who had barely left my county and not the country before then. My fees were paid in full and I got a maintenance grant, and won several scholarships. I'm sure some people staff and students thought I was a talking pig, but I certainly didn't wander around thinking I was some kind of prole anomaly.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 04/01/2021 17:26

Ah well that's different. I know some had the light bulb of upping the scholarship nos. ATO increase numbers and therefore funding overall. Not so tho if they could have feepayers instead.

WildIrishRose1 · 04/01/2021 17:24

@HeyGirlHeyBoy

Or, a cynic would say, wildirishrose, that they're ensuring more government funded capitation grants!!
Interesting point, but does the capitation grant cover the cost of a scholarship? The school I'm thinking of can fill its places many times over with fee-paying students.
OchonAgusOchonO · 04/01/2021 17:21

@Norfolker

The lady in question has also given her kids Irish names spelt in a ridiculous way (not the normal way the names are usually spelled). I get the impression it was to look good on the schools application form. She said all the kids in dc's class have Irish names so I'm thinking it's a subtle MC marker?!
What an obnoxious attitude you have. People are going back to the traditional spellings of Irish names now because we really don't care if british people can pronounce them. The UK spent long enough trying to eradicate the Irish language but never fully succeeded.
HeyGirlHeyBoy · 04/01/2021 17:20

Or, a cynic would say, wildirishrose, that they're ensuring more government funded capitation grants!!

WildIrishRose1 · 04/01/2021 17:20

@LadyfromtheBelleEpoque

"Are you seriously telling me that you think you don’t?"

No. I'm Irish.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 04/01/2021 17:18

Oh ganivet, something people can be complete shits, no doubt. That type of crap is an example of lack of class IMHO. It reminds me of a friend teaching in Mt Anville that got awful abuse from the girls because of her train tracks and because they 'couldn't understand' her accent. I don't even view that as a class system more the existence of total idiots. I must say the families I knew in my old private school were absolutely lovely and v deferential to us teachers.

WildIrishRose1 · 04/01/2021 17:17

"I also worked as an assistant examiner for the state exams and in order to qualify had to sit a specialist exam on the Irish education system".

I too have worked as as Assistant Examiner. When we studied for the H.Dip in Ed (as was then), the equivalent of a PGCE, all teaching students had to study the history of the Irish Educational System, ad part of the course. As I recall, I didn't have to re-sit this element when I applied for assistant examiner, as I had the H.Dip.

I agree with a PP that there is much more social fluidity in Ireland. Status is generally based on money, political power, etc; which I believe is different from the British Class system, being, as it is, a Monarchy?

I would also like to point out that most, if not all, fee/paying schools here have scholarship programs. I believe one school has nearly 25% of its intake given over to their access program? (I have to check that number) There may be some way to go yet, but at least they are trying to narrow the gap.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 04/01/2021 17:17

@ganivat

Although the North side includes Clontarf and Glasnevin, too?

I agree though - I imagine the travelling community have a very tough time due to the snobbery but I also imagine that a lot of that is across the class divide - not just the u/m clad.

I found it strange tbh, as I went to a very posh school in a very posh part of London and have no real accent and I think because of that many Irish couldn’t place me. I certainly experienced people assuming I was richer than I am and less privileged than I am - one interview they looked at me as though I couldn’t possibly understand their school (rural comp) - I interview for a South Dublin private and I got the feeling they thought I was a wrong for them.