Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
WildIrishRose1 · 04/01/2021 22:52

@TheKeatingFive the Educate Together primary schools seem to be very popular atm, with socially ambitious parents, although they do go some way to solving the problem of some over-subscribed Catholic primary schools not accepting non-Catholics.

TheKeatingFive · 04/01/2021 22:36

Same as Belvedere and co, though you could argue that Blackrock is world in itself.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 04/01/2021 22:30

@TheKeatingFive

Where do you place Blackrock?

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 04/01/2021 22:29

@RosesAndHellebores

Yes, I would agree. There is a hidden snobbery within those communities. I know that world and I have found a lot of snobbery and ‘pull’ going on there.

TheKeatingFive · 04/01/2021 22:06

In certain parts of the country sending kids to the Gaelscoil is a middle class marker and I wouldn’t be surprised that people think the spelling makes a difference.

But its not universal. Upper middle class Dubs from Catholic backgrounds don’t seem to go in for it so much. The Gonzaga/Belvedere types I’m talking about.

Like all class markers, is very nuanced when you get into it.

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 21:51

The impression she gave was that it would look impressive on the application form for the Irish speaking school they wanted the dc to attend. She said herself she didn't really like it & as I said up thread her DH & herself freely admit they have no love of the language & haven't spoken it since secondary school. It seems to be "the fashionable" school in the area.. I googled an example - Orla perfect acceptable spelt the typical Irish way they would use Orfhlaith (not real names by the way)

OP posts:
TaraRhu · 04/01/2021 21:48

@thevassal absolutely! Other parts of the U.K. are far more equal. I found the English students at uni really didn't know how to deal with the ones from other parts of the U.K. They couldn't 'place' us - especially the ones from the south. They were also really snobbish about ones with northern accents. It's ridiculous that people still think This way. No wonder we have a government made up of old Etonians who have no concept of what it's like to grow up without a silver spoon in your mouth.

TheKeatingFive · 04/01/2021 21:39

Both families had property in Ireland and lived principally in the UK. One went to Downside and one went to Ampleforth.

Would they have identified as Irish though? I would doubt it.

RosesAndHellebores · 04/01/2021 21:26

Hmm. I had a couple of boyfriends from fairly wealthy Irish families in the very early 80s. Both families had property in Ireland and lived principally in the UK. One went to Downside and one went to Ampleforth. I'd have said they and their friends and families were far more class conscious than the Young Farmers and Army boys I knew who went to Stowe, Harrow, Sherborne, etc! Can't make assumptions on such a narrow association I suppose and it was a long time ago. But unlike some of the earlier posters have said they really seemed to care about status.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 04/01/2021 21:16

I always thought A level was like 1st year in college level, say for history or English, a different level. The A=C doesn't compute and absolutely I loved the variety, that was my problem deciding what to do afterwards!

scubadub · 04/01/2021 21:14

@caperplips it's not that it's worth a C. A leaving cert vs an A level is equivalent of 2/3 as an A level is done in more depth (apparently) we do less depth but a broader range. And I may be biased but I prefer that. The idea of giving up maths or English at age 16 astonishes me!!

caperplips · 04/01/2021 20:16

It's fascinating that even with our 'middling' level of education & our leaving cert A's only being the value of an A level C apparently, in 2019 Ireland came 4th for education in OECD rankings & 3rd out of 27 EU countries for literacy levels...

thevassal · 04/01/2021 20:03

@TaraRhu

Just to say Scotland is very different class wise too. I'm a 'middle class ' Scott but people down here have no concept of such a thing. The English class system is quite unique. For a start any sort of 'accent' puts you into a lower class. As a result I frequently get asked if I was the first generation of my family to go to uni.... er, no. Plus the difference between richest and poorest in England is enormous. It really polarises things.
I was going to say OP is conflating 'England' with UK. A lot of the things you've mentioned as being influencing the Irish perception of class will apply to Scotland and Wales too.

For example, neither Scotland nor Wales have any grammar schools, and only a tiny tiny number of private schools - there are lots of counties in Wales where there is only state school provision, no other option. I think this makes a big difference when 99.9% of children in a local area will go to the same school no matter how much their parents earn or how educated they are.

I never really had any idea of class markers or such until I went to university and mixed with English students - I was aware that some of my classmates had bigger/smaller houses than others but no real idea of the middle/working class signifiers. Even now I have a real mix of friends within the same group, some of whom are working in professional (traditionally MC) jobs and others as teaching assistants, retail assistant managers etc whereas I get the impression in England people tend to stick to their 'tribe.'

Danu2021 · 04/01/2021 19:59

[quote LadyfromtheBelleEpoque]@Danu2021 do you think the private would be better or is it the CofI community you want?

I remember hearing that lots of pupils came from farming backgrounds and the families didn’t want them isolated at home so sent them to boarding school.[/quote]
Well, I was happy with local state catholic schools for my own dc but I am not The Ambassador for all Cof I people so ... I can't really denounce private schools too much ykwim? Like I'm not religious but not anti-religious either.

I feel a bit of a loser (half joking) reading that private school types stick together throughout their lives. I have not got one single ''private school type'' friend who is in my life regularly. My friends are all either abroad! single parents like myself, went to state schools. So I mustn't have that shiny glossy posse private schoolness about me. Oh well. BUT, not to be boo hoo about my non glossiness, I think it's more that I didn't go to university and I ended up a single parent on benefits. That's never glossy! I work now. Any boyfriends I've ever had have not been private school types. That type doesn't like me! Confused

2021willbetheyear · 04/01/2021 19:50

I never thought about it before but it is true that the privately schooled tend to hang out together for life. I went to Trinity and I remember in my first week being stunned and amused by how the first or second question asked would be “what school did you go to?” That was how people classed each other. I went on to a profession that would have a high proportion of privately schooled people but now I think of it I’m friends with very few of them, although I get on well with quite a few - my friends throughout the years have all been from the country or the North. I don’t think that means the privately schooled are of a different class to me though - we have the same education and income.

SunniCameHomeWithAVengeance · 04/01/2021 19:50

I've actually been sitting here thinking about how far the Irish Education system has come in the last few centuries. From schools being formed illegally in ditches and hedges to a system held in high regard throughout Europe. Its something for us to be very proud of.

LizzieAnt · 04/01/2021 19:48

Ah, okay then Smile

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 04/01/2021 19:45

@LizzieAnt

Sorry, that was lazy of me - I meant I don’t really have a Cockney accent.

LizzieAnt · 04/01/2021 19:33

@LadyfromtheBelleEpoque
I found it strange tbh, as I went to a very posh school in a very posh part of London and have no real accent....

I'm sorry, I know this is off the point, but I'm genuinely curious how anyone could think they have no accent?
Especially when they're living and working in another country...

HiGunny · 04/01/2021 19:09

@tttigress

Do you actually have any figures on the Irish private school situation? I don't but the Irish professionals I know all attended private schools, so I would have thought it is fairly wide spread.

Did a bit of googling, and apparently 30% of Trinity College Dublin's intake is from a private school background: www.universitytimes.ie/2020/01/fee-paying-students-are-three-times-more-likely-to-attend-top-universities/

So I doubt Irish state schools are utopian.

Are grind schools classified as private schools in this though? I went to Trinity and there would have been lots of students in the higher points courses that went to a grind school for 6th year.
Wbeezer · 04/01/2021 18:54

Sorry about typos, didn't have my glasses on.

Wbeezer · 04/01/2021 18:53

Interesting thread, however id just lije ti gently point out that most posters are referring to the British sytem or the UK system when its not universal, the Scottish system has always been seperate and is much more like the Irish system than the English IMO, no A-levels for a start and far fewer private schools, no testing in primary schools, i could go on. Unfortunately its not as good as it once was, its been tinkered with & dumbed down, i think but that's a whole other thread..

LadyEloise · 04/01/2021 18:51

Private secondary schools in Ireland get some funding from the state.
Private primary schools in Ireland get no funding from the state.

There is definitely snobbery in Dublin
@CP26 put it so well in her post at 17.00
The private school educated tend to stick together throughout their life.

However there is also a meritocracy and I think Donogh O' Malley, the Minister for Education and his government at the time, along with the civil servants involved did the Irish a great service when they introduced free secondary education for all.
It has made such a huge difference re equality.

FiveFootTwoEyesOfBlue · 04/01/2021 18:39

@FoodieToo

I find the way you talk about 'class' on here really strange . People just don't do that in Ireland. You would be laughed at ! In fact when I read threads on here such as 'what class am I if I shop in M and S ?' etc. I am always waiting for someone to come along and take the piss totally but it doesn't happen !!
Brits never say in real life what people write on here. It's an anonymous forum where people post what they would never say to friends or family. Except for ridiculing very upper class people, or saying that's a bit 'chavvy'.
CayrolBaaaskin · 04/01/2021 18:36

One thing I do have issues with in Ireland is I find it a bit intolerant to minorities. I say that as an ethnic minority with close family in Ireland. Of course there is racism everywhere but I do think as a general statement, the UK is more advanced in such matters.