Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
Badwill · 05/01/2021 01:22

Social mobile is much *easier to achieve.

Badwill · 05/01/2021 01:20

To me Irish education could never be superior as almost all schools are catholic. It's abhorrent that parents are forced to indoctrinate their DC in state schools in this day and age. There isn't a single non/multi-denominational school in my entire county. I often hear plaudits tossed about for Irish education but I struggle to see how this could be so when DC are presented with Jesus as fact and I assume aren't properly instructed on evolution/science as it goes against the ethos of the school?

In regards to class though, social mobility is much greater to achieve in Ireland. I can also attest to a diversity of backgrounds in school. My friends were the children of solicitors and academics who lived in huge houses with housekeepers to factory workers and cleaners who lived on the roughest council estate in town. I remember I had to take a sociology module at an English university when I was 18 and I honestly had no idea what they were talking about! The British class system was a whole new world to me.

BlackBucketOfCheese · 05/01/2021 01:18

Just came on to say “notions”

I was about to do the same.
It always cracks me up that British people are astonished that people in Ireland actually come from a different country, which isn’t just England with a nicer accent. Confused

burleycha55i5 · 05/01/2021 01:18

@MissMarks

Haven’t read all the posts but worth remembering the north and south are really quite different- class is very obvious in NI, particularly as there are grammar and secondary schools! And the Irish speaking schools in Belfast are most definitely not posh or elite or anyway comparable to a private school!
Hmmm I'm from NI, went to a grammar school, so did my sisters and some of my many cousins, but others went to high schools We were all the same class, whatever that was. The school we attended had nothing to do with class.
freakyfairy · 05/01/2021 01:15

There's three levels for each paper. Foundation, ordinary and higher. Most do a mix of ordinary and higher. All sit the exams at the same time for the whole country

To get into university you have to Pass the ordinary level or higher level maths, english and Irish. (You used to have to pass a foreign language but they have changed that) then you must also have at least 6 subjects (most students do 7 or 8) done fo more.

But yes if you get the points for your first choice then it's yours (except for few courses that MIGHT require an interview) I can't give examples of those because I'm not sure but I am vaguely aware there are a few that interview.

Pre Covid the leaving cert is completely anonymous and independent. Teachers have no say or input into the exams and they are marked externally (somewhere up the country).

MissMarks · 05/01/2021 01:12

Haven’t read all the posts but worth remembering the north and south are really quite different- class is very obvious in NI, particularly as there are grammar and secondary schools! And the Irish speaking schools in Belfast are most definitely not posh or elite or anyway comparable to a private school!

Norfolker · 05/01/2021 00:53

I like the sound of your leaving certificate. Every child does the same paper or is there levels?
But it's points that count & the brightest or most prepared do well. Basically anyone from any school can do which degree course they want if they get the allocated points? It's not connections or nepotism?

OP posts:
LizzieAnt · 05/01/2021 00:50

@Norfolker
There are schools teaching through Irish at post-primary level, but fewer than at primary level. 8.1% of children were educated through the medium of Irish at primary level in 2018/19 (includes Gaelscoileanna and Gaeltacht/Irish-speaking areas). 3.6% were educated through the medium of Irish at post-primary level.
The Gaelscoil in my local area is not elitist in the slightest. It's not hard to get into either.
People who are interested in Irish send their children there, but others send their children there because it's the nearest school. So the reasons vary.
As a pp mentioned, you can get extra points by doing exams through Irish at leaving cert level.

jewel1968 · 05/01/2021 00:31

I have a couple of snobs in my family with lots of notions. They are worse than any snob I have met in UK.
My experience of Irish education was not good. Very restrictive, uninteresting and way too broad. My experience in UK is through my kids but they learn way more interesting stuff than I did. And the way Irish was taught - with a fervour that put the fear of God in you. Admittedly that was a few years ago now.... But I do have some more recent insight from nieces and nephews and friends...

OuiOuiKitty · 05/01/2021 00:23

@NothingIcando

That's funny you should mention the Irish speaking schools. The lady is was speaking about has her kids in one, they had their names down from birth Both her & her DH laugh about the fact that neither of them speak the native language but love the school.. I wouldn't be able to cope not knowing the language. They're very brave!

Yes this is my sister. Had her kids names down from the birth and even had the children baptised despite not believing in god or having any faith (at the time it was a requirement to get into an irish school. I dont think this is the case anymore though). But it was all for 'the look' the school is miles away.
They are in long hours wrap around care and get home very late because of the distance. It makes life so difficult for them but sure...they look the part,dont they?

This sort of nonsense and stereotyping about gaelscoils annoys me. My children go to a gaelscoil(one now to a gaelcholaiste) and none of this applies. We moved to the area the April before my eldest was due to start and he got a place in no problem, all children who apply tend to get in. We chose it because it was the only multi denominational coed school in the area. The school is beside a local council estate and lots of kids from there go there. There is nothing elite about it.

Again we chose Gaelcholaiste even though it is 25km away because it is the only multi denominational secondary in the area. The other schools led with religion plays a very important role here and that's not us. We are in a hurling county and the other secondaries push sport a lot, my ds isn't sporty so the school with lots of science and computer clubs which is the gaelcholaiste suited him best.

It's nothing to do with looking the part and everything to do with selecting the right school environment for our children with the bonus of them becoming bilingual and learning to love their language in a way that I never or their father ever did.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 05/01/2021 00:22

There is a problem maybe in areas with high populations of young families. You'd get into our two local ones fine. Tho best if you've been to an Irish preschool. Yes there are secondaries also. We had a place and after a bit of thought, declined it.

SionnachRua · 05/01/2021 00:22

@Norfolker

Out of interest why are the Irish speaking schools so hard to get into & what are the advantages of attending one? Are they only for primary or is there second level Irish speaking schools too?
There are primary and secondary Irish language schools, yes.

Tbh I think a lot of it is that they are somewhat 'exclusive' without having the accompanying price tag. You're less likely to find children with additional needs or children of foreign nationals in a Gaelscoil. Ime anyway from the ones I have visited/worked in.

I also think they are trendy and no doubt some of the parents are into Irish. Higher points if you sit exams through Irish as well.

Norfolker · 05/01/2021 00:18

Out of interest why are the Irish speaking schools so hard to get into & what are the advantages of attending one? Are they only for primary or is there second level Irish speaking schools too?

OP posts:
HeyGirlHeyBoy · 05/01/2021 00:09

So funny re BOJO BESS

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 05/01/2021 00:08

Really, always think of Santy as quite a country thing! I've learned a lot today! Yes so true re West of Ireland. I went on Erasmus with some lovely English students way back but when I think of it I see now they looked at me as some kind of cute 'say that again' entertainment at times, while many of them didn't know we had our own currency and flag etc! Hmm

N0tthe0nlyfruit · 05/01/2021 00:03

@HeyGirlHeyBoy Santy is a REALLY Dub thing to say! Working class Dub.

I find it very peculiar when visiting England that it's assumed that Ireland is classless and that we all hail from a West of Ireland type cultural background. I'd a helpful guy point me to "the Catholic side" of a large English graveyard when I was doing family research- my ancestors were C of E and Methodist!

TheKeatingFive · 04/01/2021 23:57

AFAIK One of Boris Johnson’s daughters is a student at Trinity.

Yep, she’s doing BESS I believe. My colleague’s son is in class with her. I gather she tries to lie as low as possible. 😆

MadameMiggeldy · 04/01/2021 23:54

@harrietm1987

Oh and re trinity and the private school stats, a lot of posh brits send their children there. I worked with an OE who went there having missed out on an oxbridge place, so that could influence the numbers - it’s not just for Irish people.
AFAIK One of Boris Johnson’s daughters is a student at Trinity.
MadameMiggeldy · 04/01/2021 23:52

@SkylightAndChandelier

I can - whilst the classes are still 30 (mine are in a national school), there is a teacher and an assistant in every class

This is very rare in Irish schools ime. Well, not the 30+ bit but an assistant in each class isn't common.

I guess I really fell on my feet when we moved here then! Lucky they had space (children moving in and out of the school is very rare, I just happened to call at the right time). The school does have a high proportion of special needs students (covering a wide variety of needs from physical to behavioural to educational), perhaps the head is just extremely good at juggling staff, because children are regularly taken out in groups to work on their needs (always in groups so no child feels singled out) too, but it's very, very rare that there isn't two adults in a class from my experience (less so I suppose as you get to 4th class up). There's often 3 in my youngest's class because one of the children is having some difficulties and often has a one to one with them.

ROI schools have access to qualified teachers whose sole purpose is support of SEN (formerly resource teacher/learning support now all called Special Education Teacher). This is done mostly through targeted withdrawal. PISA ranks literacy here quite highly relative to other countries. Maths and Science are a bit lower if I recall correctly from memory.
  • that school was definitely an outlier- most wouldn’t have a TA or support staff in class other than a SNA.
HeyGirlHeyBoy · 04/01/2021 23:48

Lol@Santy! I didn't think a Dub would say that!

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 04/01/2021 23:47

m.independent.ie/life/family/learning/should-private-schools-still-receive-state-aid-26520115.html this would suggest your fact is wrong wildrose, Mt Anville is Catholic, as is Blackrock I think? Their subsidies are listed here.
I think the high level of burn out in first 5-10 years of English teachers says a lot about the system too. We don't tend to have that turnover here.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 04/01/2021 23:42

You see a long day like that is not seen as a plus for very young children, just convenient for parents. So perhaps we have different priorities!.
Wildrose, I'll have to look that up about the funding, can't make sense of it.

Chuckleknuckles · 04/01/2021 23:30

For those saying the Irish school system is superior, I am not sure it is, certainly not in the primary system. I say this as an Irish person, educated partly privately in Ireland with an English child in a catholic primary school here. From the day they started in Reception, they’re at school from 8.30-3.15. Breakfast clubs and after school clubs (til 6.30) to make it easier for parents. Lots of extra curricular activities, a foreign language and an instrument all from day 1. All books and materials are provided. Hot 3 course meals at lunch time rather than a soggy sandwich you’d make yourself. Trips abroad in Year 6. Holidays that are well staggered rather than 8-12 weeks in the summer.
I don’t think the Irish system is any worse than the UK system per se but of what I’ve seen of the UK system, I think it’s pretty fantastic and I think my daughter is getting a better education than I got in a fairly regarded school in South Dublin. I hear of people on mumsnet discussing the chronic underfunding of education in the UK. I haven’t seen evidence of that at all and my child goes to what I think is a phenomenal school and it costs us precisely nothing at point of use.
That said, I’ll absolutely be sending her to an independent secondary school whereas in Ireland I’d have no problem sending her off to Muckross or Coláiste Isogáin (sp) or the like.
I think there’s definitely a middle class in Ireland but it’s certainly more fluid. I know of a doctor married to a train driver and an investment banker married to a plumber and no one thinks that’s odd, re all members of the same golf club. Here in the UK, you wouldn’t see it as much. My mother in law is a snob (and not a big fan of the Irish, still not over the fact that her son didn’t marry a Home Counties woman) and she is absolutely obsessed with social class. Ridiculously so. Is embarrassed we don’t send our child to prep school. Tuts when I say Santa (and positively clutches pearls when I say Santie!). I just roll my eyes at her. She’s a specific breed. There are a lot of them though but luckily they’re a dying breed, I think.

TheKeatingFive · 04/01/2021 23:02

Yeah absolutely.

WildIrishRose1 · 04/01/2021 22:54

... even though, historically, most primary schools were run by the Catholic Church. They had some power, back in the day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread