Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
LizzieAnt · 05/01/2021 10:00

@Danu2021 In certain cases (eg dyslexia) you can apply for exemptions from Irish, and also other languages I believe. NUI has these exemptions in place anyway (I think).

Danu2021 · 05/01/2021 10:00

@HeyGirlHeyBoy

That's an awful pity. Has he hope or an exemption from Irish at all? Does he have to do a modern language to LC? If not can he not do pass Irish and not count it towards points?
I'm not sure what to do. I would like to spare him the torture of transition year (he's on the spectrum but it only shows up when he's out of his comfort zone. I know he should step out of his comfort zone gradually but not in a forced way. Transition year would be too much for him) but I was wondering if I could let him skip transition year somehow and work on Spanish. I don't think the school would be behind that plan. Even though, they've met him, they know that he is not going to be a good candidate for transition year!
Danu2021 · 05/01/2021 09:57

I know, I honestly thought there were about 5 of them.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 05/01/2021 09:53

Wow those ET secondaries have sprung up quickly m, the first one wasn't long ago.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 05/01/2021 09:52

That's an awful pity. Has he hope or an exemption from Irish at all? Does he have to do a modern language to LC? If not can he not do pass Irish and not count it towards points?

Danu2021 · 05/01/2021 09:50

oh to my surprise there are 19 ET secondary schools.

Danu2021 · 05/01/2021 09:46

@teaegg there are a growing number of ET secondary schools now. My son is at one. A lot of parents love it for primary but then return to the traditional models for secondary. I should name change now as they are rare enough that im outing myself.

i worried a little that my dc1 would be othered at her single sex catholic school but she has not been at all. None of the students care at all. She has had a great education. Leaving cert aside. She has been happy and made lovely friends. The chaplain is the only nun there now but she sounds like a strong woman living in the real world. My leg waxer told me she got a flat tyre, and who should pull up in her car and change the tyre for her, that same school chaplain.

My only issue with the irish education system is that it is too broad at lc level. My son cannot scrape a d in a foreign language. And that will affect his chance of success at 3rd level.
He is nearly 15 and already im hoping that he will be able to stay enthusiastic through the knock backs of it mattering so much that he cannot speak a word in any other language besides his first. He is v good at maths though and his sister was doing honours maths lc with him the other day and he was enjoying it. I feel it's unfair that he will have doors slammed in his face because he cannot pass irish or spanish. Oh well i cant worry about this right now. Worry about one child at a time.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 05/01/2021 09:46

I agree, the bible wasn't even mentioned a lot but I think that's actually quite Catholic! Our head nun was formidable and very pro strong women. She was a former high level hockey player, ran a school of 1000 girls with hugely mixed backgrounds and certainly didn't expect us to become wives or even nuns. She could be a pain but we got a great grounding there.

TeaEgg · 05/01/2021 09:30

I had a standard convent school education in the late 70s and 80s, was taught by nuns in about half my primary classes, and with nuns as heads at both schools, and I can honestly say that, despite the prominence of religion in that education, it was pretty sophisticated compared to the Biblical literalist stuff DS was exposed to in his Cof E village school in England. The nuns did not teach Genesis as fact, and no one, not even the fanatical, elderly Sr Martin, who’d spent her life on ‘the missions’, ever said anything like ‘The Bible is beautiful because every word is literally true.’

I get entirely that not all C of E schools are like this, but I was taken aback that an Evangelical vicar (a young man) was able to have this impact in the 21st century, particularly in a very ethnically/cu,rurally-mixed school where many kids were Hindu, Sikh and Muslim. I’m assuming that if he had different C of E leanings, so would the school.

When we returned to Ireland, we sent DS to an Educate Together.

Danu2021 · 05/01/2021 09:18

😯😯😯 @Badwill

SkylightAndChandelier · 05/01/2021 08:53

There's definitely indicators - although in my experience not of class as you'd think of it in England, more of what your religion is, where you're from etc. (places in Dublin 5km apart have tremendously different accents and expectations!).

So if I said for example that at my kids school they do Hockey - that would tell you a lot more about it if you know Ireland than if you don't.

TheKeatingFive · 05/01/2021 08:08

I assume aren't properly instructed on evolution/science as it goes against the ethos of the school?

What total bollocks. You’re embarrassing yourself by spouting such claptrap.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 05/01/2021 08:05

Brother is a science teacher. Yes, they teach evolution Hmm

wellthatsunusual · 05/01/2021 03:09

By classes within the grammar schools I mean that one grammar is viewed (although often incorrectly) as the 'posh' one and a neighbouring one as the 'normal' one.

wellthatsunusual · 05/01/2021 03:07

@MissMarks

Burleycha- you may well have all been the same class but the vast majority of grammar schools in Northern Ireland are much more middle class than secondary schools- especially those with attached prep schools. A quick comparison for example of free school meal entitlement between a neighbouring secondary and a grammar demonstrates this- in the town I am from the grammar has less thank 1% and secondary more than 40%.
For added complexity ,in areas with more than one grammar school you often have 'classes' within the grammar schools.

Having said that, as a previous poster mentioned, it's very common for siblings to attend different schools, so I'd agree that on an individual family level the school attended doesn't say anything about class divisions even if statistically some schools are more middle class overall.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 02:46

Apologies to anyone from Carlow - I'm just joking.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 02:45

[quote LizzieAnt]@Hatstrategicallydipped
Well, tut!
Kerry has a good few inter-denominational schools as it happens Grin[/quote]
Apologies. Grin (I'm a secret fans of the Healy-Raes!) I've no idea what county she lives in, in 2021 that doesn't have a single non-denominational school? Offaly? It's Carlow, isn't it? Gotta be Carlow.

Cheeeeislifenow · 05/01/2021 02:38

The lady in question has also given her kids Irish names spelt in a ridiculous way (not the normal way the names are usually spelled). I get the impression it was to look good on the schools application form. She said all the kids in dc's class have Irish names so I'm thinking it's a subtle MC marker?!

What an obnoxious attitude you have. People are going back to the traditional spellings of Irish names now because we really don't care if british people can pronounce them. The UK spent long enough trying to eradicate the Irish language but never fully succeeded.

This with bells on. I hope more people send their children to gaeil scoils and give their children traditional Irish names. We are reclaiming what was taken.

LizzieAnt · 05/01/2021 02:28

@Hatstrategicallydipped
Well, tut!
Kerry has a good few inter-denominational schools as it happens Grin

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 02:01

I think Badwill needs to go to confession. I think she has committed blasphemy on here.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 02:00

There isn't a single non/multi-denominational school in my entire county.

Where da fook do ya live? The arsehole of Healy-Rae country or something?

Deadringer · 05/01/2021 01:56

Badwill of course evolution and science are not taught in Irish Catholic schools, sure aren't we all descended from Adam and Eve? Hmm

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 01:53

@freakyfairy

There's three levels for each paper. Foundation, ordinary and higher. Most do a mix of ordinary and higher. All sit the exams at the same time for the whole country

To get into university you have to Pass the ordinary level or higher level maths, english and Irish. (You used to have to pass a foreign language but they have changed that) then you must also have at least 6 subjects (most students do 7 or 8) done fo more.

But yes if you get the points for your first choice then it's yours (except for few courses that MIGHT require an interview) I can't give examples of those because I'm not sure but I am vaguely aware there are a few that interview.

Pre Covid the leaving cert is completely anonymous and independent. Teachers have no say or input into the exams and they are marked externally (somewhere up the country).

Just to correct some of this. Only the three core subjects are offered at three levels which are Irish, English and Maths. The rest are offered at Ordinary Level or Higher Level. To compare, a A1 at Ordinary level only equals a C3 (?) I think at Higher Level.

Points for Higher level subjects used to be

90-100% - A1 - 100 points
85-90% - A2 - 90 points
70-85% - B1- 85 points
etc etc. (or something similar)

For Ordinary level subjects
A1 - maybe 50/60 points?

Your top 6 subjects points-wise are all that can get you into 3rd level education. It's all done through an algorithm - purely exam based and none of the alleged copying of essays that was suggested.

So the points for medicine/veterinary will all be above 500 points - meaning that you'll need a lot of A's - all at Higher level. Trinity for anything has high points - Trinity Law, Trinity Medicine, Trinity Psychology - all requiring more or less 6 straight A's.

You get bonus points for Higher level Maths.

What Ireland is brilliant at exporting however is its engineering graduates. The points for those courses are less (more places, less demand). But we seem to produce a lot of exportable graduates! Who eventually move back, but they go and make their money abroad a bit for a while. We also export our teachers and our nurses!
We do hold on to our IT graduates and have a lot of Head Offices for Apple/Amazon/Facebook etc. based in Ireland (the IT Head Offices at least).

Ireland has some fantastic courses which make people quite employable.

There are alternative routes to success through trade apprenticeships for the more logically minded (can't think of how best to describe their brains as I don't have one lol).

It is extremely competitive for the 'elite' courses. Trinity Law, Law at UCD, Medicine at Trinity etc. Medicine in Galway may come in 10 points lower some years, so some study at Galway. I know somebody who did medicine there. Now a consultant. ;)

LizzieAnt · 05/01/2021 01:31

I often hear plaudits tossed about for Irish education but I struggle to see how this could be so when DC are presented with Jesus as fact and I assume aren't properly instructed on evolution/science as it goes against the ethos of the school?

Of course science and evolution are taught properly!
Did you go to school in Ireland yourself Badwill?

MissMarks · 05/01/2021 01:30

Burleycha- you may well have all been the same class but the vast majority of grammar schools in Northern Ireland are much more middle class than secondary schools- especially those with attached prep schools. A quick comparison for example of free school meal entitlement between a neighbouring secondary and a grammar demonstrates this- in the town I am from the grammar has less thank 1% and secondary more than 40%.