Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How does the Irish middle class compare to ours

566 replies

Norfolker · 04/01/2021 13:13

My sister in law is from the Republic & she says the class system in Ireland is there but less obvious than ours.. Not as many private schools but more subtle markers.
She also thinks their state education system is far superior so private schooling is unnecessary. Any Irish on here want to elaborate? I found it interesting.
YABU there is no difference between UK & ROI. Exact same class system no difference in markets.
YANBU different traits contribute to the Irish middle class system

OP posts:
IceIceBebe · 05/01/2021 16:23

Nothing makes the famine excusable but I avoid talking about history (even though I studied a specialist Irish history course at university inc the Land league, trade unions, etc)

If you studied it properly you should know that there was actually no famine. A famine is where there is no food, there was plenty of food, it just was kept from the people who needed it, purposefully. British landowners continued to have a rich and varied diet as their tenants starved to death outside, and they continued to export vast quantities of food.

There is a reason why its not called the famine in Irish, only in English, because it was the English that caused it and called it a famine to avoid responsibility. In Irish its called an gorta mor, the great hunger.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 16:23

I'm actually dumbfounded at the utter arrogance of your post LadyBellewhateveryouare.

IceIceBebe · 05/01/2021 16:19

It is not, as people suggest, that they don’t know the history - it is just often easier to play dumb

Ah come on now, that's pure bollocks. It generally is because they don't know the history" Have you seen any thread on here about Brexit/the border? Half the people can't name the country properly, don't know where the border is, don't know which bit is NI, don't understand why NI "can't just join ROI, that'll solve the border issue"!

The sheer scale of what most Brits don't know about Ireland is immense.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 16:19

@LadyfromtheBelleEpoque

I think this whole discussion illustrates really well why a lot of Brits won’t engage in conversations about Irish history. It is not, as people suggest, that they don’t know the history - it is just often easier to play dumb. Other people view the history through the lens of expansion, progress, etc and just won’t get into a conversation.

Nothing makes the famine excusable but I avoid talking about history (even though I studied a specialist Irish history course at university inc the Land league, trade unions, etc).

Your post illustrates why the Irish continue to loathe your way of thinking. It absolutely beggars belief!

Right. Can we get back to the coat from Dunnes?

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 16:17

@Hatstrategicallydipped

I’m glad, Hat. The amount of times I hear it mentioned/read it on here it made me wonder. The whole empire history is complex and I think the perspective on teaching history in the UK is designed to give an overview, history of Kings and Queens, Parliament/Magna Carta and the rise of state vs monarchy (Cromwell). Trade and the empire are part of that, of course but there were more complex governances in some places (for example, The Raj) and there is no one unifying historical ‘thought’ on them that could be delivered across the country W/o simplifying many important issues (Partition of India is one).

CremeEggThief · 05/01/2021 16:16

Remember as well that due to lack of work opportunities, (which led to waves of emigration in the late 19th century and throughout the 20th century) it was quite normal for well-educated and well-qualified people to end up spending prolonged periods of time out of work and/or on the sole. So I was never aware of any stigma surrounding that, growing up. I'm not saying it wasn't there at all, but in my particular area in the 1980s and 1990s, I had no awareness of it, and I regularly accompanied my mum, dad and auntie to the dole office or the rent allowance office in my teens.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 16:15

Expansion and progress? So say I live next door to you? I want to expand and progress! So I build an extension to my house which goes onto your property. Is that fair, reasonable, logical, legal or even moral?
No it fucking isn't.
Don't fucking come on a thread with loads of Irish posters telling us that it was the UK wanting to expand and fucking progress.

At whose expense?????????????/

caperplips · 05/01/2021 16:14

@LadyfromtheBelleEpoque I also studied history & I'm particularly keen to hear more of your thoughts on how we (or others) might view our history through the lens of progress & expansion?

TeaEgg · 05/01/2021 16:13

@LadyfromtheBelleEpoque

I think this whole discussion illustrates really well why a lot of Brits won’t engage in conversations about Irish history. It is not, as people suggest, that they don’t know the history - it is just often easier to play dumb. Other people view the history through the lens of expansion, progress, etc and just won’t get into a conversation.

Nothing makes the famine excusable but I avoid talking about history (even though I studied a specialist Irish history course at university inc the Land league, trade unions, etc).

Let me assure you that, having spent 20 years teaching at English universities, a total ignorance of Irish history — including events well within living memory for anyone over the age of 40 — is alive and well.

And not just history — the numbers of people who had no idea there was a unionist population in NI until the DUP started propping up the Tories, boggled my mind.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 16:11

It is not, as people suggest, that they don’t know the history - it is just often easier to play dumb. Other people view the history through the lens of expansion, progress, etc and just won’t get into a conversation.

And we don't really give a fuck to be honest.

CremeEggThief · 05/01/2021 16:10

What I loved about primary school growing up in Ireland was that everyone got along. It didn't matter if you were the daughter of a doctor or someone who had been unemployed all their lives, you could still be the best of friends.

At secondary school, the differences started to appear and there was less mixing between these groups. That said, a family friend of ours who hasn't really gone to school properly since he was 13 or 14 and has worked sporadically all his life, is still very good friends with the son of a doctor. I'm not sure that would happen much in England.

LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 05/01/2021 16:09

I think this whole discussion illustrates really well why a lot of Brits won’t engage in conversations about Irish history. It is not, as people suggest, that they don’t know the history - it is just often easier to play dumb. Other people view the history through the lens of expansion, progress, etc and just won’t get into a conversation.

Nothing makes the famine excusable but I avoid talking about history (even though I studied a specialist Irish history course at university inc the Land league, trade unions, etc).

Danu2021 · 05/01/2021 16:06

@HarrietPotterska id guess you'd be welcomed by 95% of people and you could build a great life, make friends, integrate completely, and then one day you'd be walking down the street thinking about what you were going to have for dinner and then some random scumbag would shock you to the core with a vile comment. I was reading experiences of non white irish people on fb a while ago and we just cannot get rid of that small percentage of racist fuxkwits.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 16:05

@jewel1968

It wasn't the UK that tried to eradicate the Irish language I'm sure it was the nuns. I still have the scars and not memory of the language. PTSD though ..Grin
Er yes, it was the British.
SkylightAndChandelier · 05/01/2021 16:04

I’m in Kerry and kids play hockey in the local mixed secondary school. I don’t think Hockey is quite the elitist sport you think

I didn't say elitist - that was entirely a (class-based) spin you put on it - just that it's a type of school/certain areas where a school will do hockey, and another type where they'll do hurling, there are some fair enough based guesses you could make - as another poster did.

The thought of either of my children wielding a stick around their friends to whack a ball as hard as they can is terrifying to me, so thank god they do neither!

IceIceBebe · 05/01/2021 15:49

It wasn't the UK that tried to eradicate the Irish language

It was.

jewel1968 · 05/01/2021 15:43

It wasn't the UK that tried to eradicate the Irish language I'm sure it was the nuns. I still have the scars and not memory of the language. PTSD though ..Grin

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 15:13

The Irish are quite accustomed to emigrants. Everyone has a few in their family who have emigrated. You might not be too welcomed if you have the paw out expecting to be fed (which nobody has, but the Irish have to FEED any visitors - it's a thing - we put that expectation on ourselves!!), so they can sometimes be reluctant to meet the forriners. Most are normal people though.

NothingICanDo · 05/01/2021 15:11

OuiOuiKitty
It's nothing to do with looking the part and everything to do with selecting the right school environment for our children with the bonus of them becoming bilingual and learning to love their language in a way that I never or their father ever did

Sorry I didn't mean this was the case for all!

I meant in my sister's case...she openly did it because she's desperate to get away from her working class roots. She's not a very nice person.
And as someone said way up thread...people like my sister are known for doing this when they want to be in with a more ''MC looking crowd ''

When I was growing up I had 2 friends who were sent to Irish speaking secondary schools after our regular Primary school. Both said it was because their parents didn't want then to grow up speaking/acting like the rest of us. (We were all good kids) One girls Mam told her if she stayed in our school she would be pregnant at 16. She was pregnant by 16...in her Irish school Hmm

This kind of snobbery is disgusting. My sister feels nothing but embarrassment when she looks at us, her family.
But I guess we new feel the same way looking back at her...she must be as thick as two short planks to think like this.
I feel sorry for her children shes a nasty piece of work who cares only about climbing a social ladder.
And to her...Gealscoil is getting them all one step closer. How exciting for her

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 15:10

Oh - misread. Yes, absolutely apply for your Irish passport! Why wouldn't you!!!
Go back and see your Mum's side of the family too.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 15:08

Harriet - have you any part of Ireland in mind? Perhaps where your Mum is from? Or one of the cities?
If you can get your children involved in Irish culture, you'll fit in. Music, dance, singing, GAA etc.

IceIceBebe · 05/01/2021 15:05

It does sound good RE the education! Maybe it's time for me to apply for a passport (my mum's Irish). What are people's experiences of people of colour and racism? My dad's black Cuban so I'm mixed race

I'm white irish so can't speak personally, but I live in a rural village and the schools are incredibly mixed. My daughters school has kids that are from (or whose parents are from) all over Europe, Eastern europe, India, Sr Lanka, Pakistan, China, Malaysia. various African nations...and even a few British people Grin. I know some of the parents and people talk very positively about their experience of living in Ireland.

NowellSingWe · 05/01/2021 15:04

Anyway to me (and the people I grew up with) hockey is just a sport like any other.

Hatstrategicallydipped · 05/01/2021 15:02

It's all fields there, you know? grin

I suppose it's consoling that we can call Boris the leader of the Commoners. Haha.

NowellSingWe · 05/01/2021 15:02

@Apollo3

I am agog- what does hockey signify please?

Hockey is very much a notions/D4/rich people signifier. If you said you played hockey at school we can guess you probably went to Mount Anville or Teresian or Sackville etc.

Thank you Apollo3 and others. There is a parallel of this in England too: Where I live now (v large city in English Midlands) hockey is seen as a private school sport. I work in an outstanding leafy girls' comp, and they don't do hockey because they have no pitch. The hockey clubs locally are filled with children who attend fee paying schools, or whose parents aren't from UK. Where I grew up (the wild North...) at my "sink" comprehensive school girls did hockey and netball, boys rugby (league not union) and football, all did cricket and athletics in summer term. My friend who teaches PE is actually a hockey specialist, but also comes from the Northern wilds. Even more bizarrely, at my own school we sometimes did lacrosse, which even most fee paying schools don't offer these days. Malory Towers it was not!
Swipe left for the next trending thread