Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Money Matters

130 replies

Norealclue · 04/01/2021 00:30

I would like to know what others think of something which has caused me some doubts about the right way to handle this situation.
I had come into some money and I was deciding what to do. Having been in some sticky situations myself over the years I thought I would share some of this money among my DC. 2 DC have accepted what I proposed for them. The other 2 DC have reacted very differently from their siblings.
1 DC when I started thinking about this told her DH all about what I had said. I paid out the money for the first part and then it came to the second part. I had said I would give a certain amount. Then her DH inserted himself into the conversation and tried to get more money. I am told that since he is married to my DC it is his business. My DC knew that I was unhappy with this but did nothing. I think that since the money is mine he has no right to discuss what I do with that money.
Another DC asked for more money than I had mentioned but that the extra was to be a loan which would be paid back in instalments. The instalments were paid for a while then stopped. This DC will not get another penny from me because that one has gone NC probably to evade repaying the loan. Lesson learned!
AIBU to expect to be able to discuss financial matters with my 1 DC without her DH butting in and wanting more.

OP posts:
Norealclue · 04/01/2021 12:58

@sst1234 - thank you, you seem to see it very similar to my own view. It is obvious now that no matter how much I give it will never be enough or right in their eyes. Your comment is so kind it brought a tear to my eye. Thank you

OP posts:
Brogues · 04/01/2021 12:57

Could you maybe type the actual problem out rather than the strange riddles? You can change the figures or item so it isn’t identifiable IRL ie I offered DD £50k for a house deposit then £50k after a further five years time to pay a chunk off the mortgage I’d say SIL could have a valid point in joining in the conversation by for example saying it would help them more to have a higher deposit and lower monthly payment.

Norealclue · 04/01/2021 12:55

@CaptainVanesHair I didnt shut up shop because my DC discussed the money I gave with her DH. I was unhappy that there was discontent with the amount I was giving in 2 DC. I didnt have to give anything. I wanted to make their lives easier. I am unhappy with 1 DC for not repaying a loan as promised. I am unhappy with 1 DC because her DH asked me for more money and she allowed it.

OP posts:
Norealclue · 04/01/2021 12:49

@Lightsontbut the way the money was dealt with was done by agreement. There was no demand by me to buy this or that. It was a question of what would they want that would help them the most and they both thought the same thing and it was helpful for them.
I have had financial discussions and dealings with the DC with the DH many times in the past and there was never a problem until this DH came on the scene. I was a lot less vocal before they were married but he seems to think being married to my DC gives him a say in my life. I dont think that is right. I did say that I might be old fashioned in my views on men who dont work while living off a female. I would not dare to make any noise about the standard of child and home care.
@Apollo3 It seems strange to me that I can not discuss finances with my own relative without it going on to people who are not related to me. SIL is married to my DC not me and should realise the difference. I will keep it in mind that I should not discuss anything with my DC if I dont want it to be common knowledge. There are too many people IRL making decisions about what to do with money who are not my relatives. Financial confidentiality seems a thing of the past.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 04/01/2021 12:48

Your children sound like sharks and the son in law a parasite. Keep your money, you won’t get any thanks anyway.

CaptainVanesHair · 04/01/2021 12:39

Shutting up shop because your daughter talked to her spouse seems a bit ridiculous.

Surely you either gift part 2 to the waiting DD, say no to the requests for more. And then everything is equal bar the NC child, which you just have to write off.

Or, you gift part 2 + increase for them and the teenagers to even it up with what NC child has.

Controlling it isn’t making life easier for any of your children. Giving a gift without conditions will.

Elbels · 04/01/2021 12:37

I don't think you're unreasonable to give your children money

I don't think your daughter is unreasonable to discuss money with her husband.

I think your son in law is unreasonable to ask you for more (if that's what happened).

I do think you're unreasonable for speaking in riddles :) just say I gave my 4 kids a house deposit (if that's what it was for).

Norealclue · 04/01/2021 12:34

@Cocomarine the teens are mid teens not young teens. The pre-schooler comes under another group. The conduct of two out of four DC has made me wonder what to do for that group. I was not trying to control anything and there was an agreement on the two part issue. It was all agreed then one DC changed things with the loan. I really thought I could trust my own DC. The other DC with the DH changed things with him inserting himself into a situation between me and my DC. I do not think I need to discuss money with any in law. This may not do much for my relationship with my DC but you disregard the point that I am unhappy with how they have carried on in this and I thought they would have realised this was between me and them individually and jointly among my DC.
@museumsandgalleries666 I think I will have to even up the amounts because I want them all to be equal. I will put it in writing so that there can be no doubts even once I am gone. I am grateful that you have said "itis lovely of you to give them all money". They way it looks from 2 of 4 DC is that I have done something drastically bad and even on here I am being told that I am controlling. That really is not the case at all. I have no power, nor do I have the deviousness of some of those who have involved themselves when it is not their business.

OP posts:
Apollo3 · 04/01/2021 12:29

Is it unreasonable of me to expect to be able to discuss matters with any of my DC without it being disclosed to others? I didn't want my plans to be discussed with the various partners

Of course its unreasonable, and the fact that you can't see that suggests that there is a lot more to this story.

Lightsontbut · 04/01/2021 12:26

I've found the info really confusing but as far as I can tell you did not gift the money directly you said you would gift it if they spent it on something you approved of, such as a house. I think the SIL DH might actually have been communicating with you that the amount you gave is not enough to buy a house and wondered whether there was any chance that you could give more. I think he might have had this conversation with you as your DD finds these conversations difficult and controlling.

I can't understand the issue with SIL DH not working. It's very outdated to expect a man to work whilst accepting female SAHP. Are you also saying that he does not care for the children at all despite being alone with them when his wife is at work? They must be quite young so is this a neglect issue which you have reported?

Ideasplease322 · 04/01/2021 12:25

This is a bit confusing, and I am not sure if there were conditions attached to the money.

However the son in law should not have asked for more money, they as a couple should either have accepted it with thanks or said no thank you.

museumsandgalleries666 · 04/01/2021 11:50

It's unreasonable for the husband to interfere, he can have whatever discussions he wants with his wife, but not with you. Tell your daughter it's a big fat NO to an increased amount and simply refuse to engage with her husband.

If you decide to even up the amount to 3 of 4 and write off the debt to #4 let them all know what you've done and why.

It's lovely of you to give them all money.

Cocomarine · 04/01/2021 11:49

It was really silly to say that two children accepted the amount - making it seem like you were reasonable - when they were young teens Confused

Why isn’t your pre-schooler getting a share?

It sounds like you trying to be pretty controlling with the money. Which is your choice - it’s your money. But don’t expect that to do anything for your relationship with your adult children 🤷🏻‍♀️

Norealclue · 04/01/2021 11:39

@BarbaraofSeville Each of the DC got £x. Two are not old enough for big purchases being mid teens. One DC got £x and asked for a loan of £y. That means that one DC got £y (minus a few payments) more than the rest and I dont see that will ever be paid as that DC is very close to a persistent and lifelong debtor.
The two were helped to make their own lives a bit easier. Whether the partners enjoyed that or not was not my main concern. It was all about making life easier for my DC.
I had not thought about trying to influence the DC with the DH to leave him and set up alone. Now that this is a thought I have heard complaints about him from my DC but I say nothing because I know that would not be a good idea.

OP posts:
herechickchickchickchick · 04/01/2021 11:29

@Mustbe3ormorecharacters

“Cant you just draw a line under the sand”

Grin

Two metaphors in one feeling generous lol
Norealclue · 04/01/2021 11:27

I have never told anyone at all my exact situation with regard to money in any shape or form,not even professionals like solicitors or bank people. I have always been private whether skint or not so skint. I knew the horrors of being skint and wanted to help.
A line has now been drawn in the sand. The Bank of Mum has shut up shop. It upsets me to think my DC are struggling and I am not.

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 04/01/2021 11:23

Are you saying 1 DC already owes you money, so you've given them less to account for that?

Eg 3 DC got £10k but one only got £5k because they owed you £5k from money you loaned and they didn't pay back? That would seem fair enough.

Whether or not your son in law pulls his weight as a SAHP is a separate issue but he shouldn't be interfering with the money and certainly not asking for extra. Are you saying you want your DD to leave him and use the money to set up by herself? That also seems fair but it's up to her whether she does this. She lives with him day to day so knows more about whether he is doing his fair share.

I agree with others that your posts are confusing but it is unclear whether you are hiding a backstory or if it's just the way you express yourself.

Mustbe3ormorecharacters · 04/01/2021 11:22

“Cant you just draw a line under the sand”

Grin
herechickchickchickchick · 04/01/2021 11:16

Cant you just draw a line under the sand now and tell them no more money is coming their way an spend it on yourself ?

user1497207191 · 04/01/2021 11:12

Your caused your own problems by having discussions/dialogue with any of them. You should have made your decision about what to give them, and given them that amount. No need for them to know how much you received, how much you've given the others nor what you intend to do with the amount you've kept.

By talking to them about it, presumably telling them how much you got and your own plans for using it, etc., you've opened the door for them to want more.

Brighterthansunflowers · 04/01/2021 11:08

Yes YABU to expect your DC not to discuss financial help from you with their partner.

And yes you do sound controlling and I strongly suspect the backstory is very relevant here

Twickerhun · 04/01/2021 11:02

It would be very unreasonable of you to expect to daughter not to discuss financial issues with her DH. He shouldn’t talk to you or try to influence you but you have to let them discuss things as a couple.

Norealclue · 04/01/2021 10:55

It seems then that I got this all wrong completely.
The two who accepted what I had thought was good for them are mid teens so not the right age to make bigger purchases.
The two who have been problematic are in their 20s. Both changed partners. The one who got a "loan" has a partner who said nothing either way. The one with the DH who wanted more I think is a bit more forward than I would be myself. It concerns me that he seems to think he has a say in what I do financially. My own DC would benefit the most from what the money was for.
I could be very old fashioned in thinking that it is out of order that a female works a lot of hours while a male does nothing (i.e. does not really do the housework and DC side of things and can not keep a job). I thought Mumsnet were dead against "cocklodgers". He has no real boundaries not just about money, he also told me about an aspect of their sex life! I expect they would have sex especially if there are DC but it is not something I want to know any details about. I just dont think the way he speaks about things is right but DC does not see this.
I realise now that the cure for all this is not to put forward any more money, I regret having gone into this, not to be mean but because of all the trouble it has caused. I just wanted to make life a little easier for my DC.

OP posts:
Valkadin · 04/01/2021 02:52

You made a mistake in promising x amount but giving it in parts so they always knew they had more coming. It creates an expectancy.

It is obvious you do not like your son in law. I do understand why if you do not like someone you don’t like the thought of them benefitting from your money but if we don’t like our children’s partners it’s just tough really. You have the choice of giving to dc or skipping a generation and giving to grandchildren instead.

Money cannot be given with any condition and even if you buy an item instead of giving cash it can be sold.

Norealclue · 04/01/2021 02:27

@Notimeforaname Whether they are able to make financial decisions is in many ways questionable. They are not unintelligent but are heavily influenced by others.
It may be looking as if I am controlling but actually I was trying to ensure that my DC got the amount I wanted to give them and for a purpose that they chose. If they had changed their minds or not liked their choices I would have asked well you refused 1 decided on 2 but dont like it now so what is choice 3?
@FlappingFanny you are so very near in your statement and I certainly did not want to be providing for what you may think is a throwaway suggestion. This was a matter which was of great concern. We all know that Class A drugs (and others) are all consuming and removes logic and decency

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread