Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask which Panasonic Breadmaker?

87 replies

Ichangedmynameonce · 03/01/2021 10:24

I bought a cheap Argos breadmaker during lockdown and the bread is horrible. And the loaves are tiny.

Everyone says get a Panasonic- but there are loads of models.

AIBU to ask WHICH PANASONIC?
Please recommend or reject specific models.

I want:
Decent , tasty bread, including brown bread

A decent sized loaf, that will feed 5 of us.

Please don't recommend I do it by hand - I just don't have the time.

Thank you
ps I'm thinking the SD 2511 model


This thread is a bit old now so some of the suggestions may be out of date, but if you’ve landed here looking for bread makers, we’ve recently updated our best bread maker page with the top Panasonic models for your baking needs. We hope you find it useful. Flowers
MNHQ

OP posts:
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 04/01/2021 12:25

I've had a couple of Panasonics over the last 10 years, I just bought the "standard" one with the seed dispenser and it's been fine. The recipes that come with it work fine.

If loaves come out small and flat that may be the yeast - I've found doubling the sugar helps when the yeast tub has been open for a while. And I misread a rye bread recipe and added 2 tablespoons of sugar instead of 2 teaspoons and the loaves came out risen instead of hollow so I've kept to it! The Panasonic has a separate paddle for making rye bread by the way.

101namesforme · 04/01/2021 12:22

Yes we also do a lot of rolls and also pitta bread regularly.

101namesforme · 04/01/2021 12:21

I now have a Panasonic SD-ZB2502BXC which was £179 this summer. It replaced an ancient SD255 which I got second hand about ten years ago!

I echo that Panasonic bread makers are so much better than others. With other brands I usually ended up giving it away as it didn’t get used. This doesn’t get used as often as it did initially but is still used every week. We like the French dough recipe best but bake it in the oven.

I’d definitely recommend.

Cactusowl · 04/01/2021 12:20

I have a Panasonic SD2511. It has many settings but I tend to use a bag of wrights bread flour mix and use the dough setting so I can shape and bake rolls.

lidoshuffle · 04/01/2021 12:13

@YoniAndGuy

Oh and you get a massive recipe booklet with loads of info and a million recipes with different size options.

We use whatever flour is available - as folk have said, they're really forgiving on everything.

Never had a bad loaf.

I did once have a bad loaf when I forgot to put the water in! GrinGrin
BaublesAndBawbags · 04/01/2021 12:11

just another vote for the Panasonic - not sure what model ours is but we've had it for about 5 years and the only time it's produced a duff loaf was the time I omitted to add the water.

I tend to make white loaves as there's a fair amount of resistance to roughage in this house, and find a tbsp measure of powdered milk (as per the Carrs recipe on the bag) makes all the difference.

New Year's resolution is to experiment with some of the 8 million recipes in the Panasonic booklet - although some seem a bit useless: I can't work out how you'd line the tin effectively for cakes, even with the kneading mechanism removed. Anyone done that with success?

SoupDragon · 04/01/2021 12:08

Something to bear in mind is that if you make anything other than a M sized loaf, the loaves are taller than average and slices might not fit in your toaster. The loaf size only alters the height (obviously! 😂)

Voyager54 · 04/01/2021 12:03

Hi OP The recipe that I posted it one that has been gradually crafted over the years and the yeast currently being used is Fermipan very reasonably priced considering the little that you get from other sources.

I would not use Spelt flour in the breadmaker did not work for me.

Ichangedmynameonce · 03/01/2021 20:26

thanks everyone for taking the time to comment- think I understand the point of different models better now.

thanks @haffiana and @YoniAndGuy for the detail

OP posts:
IloveJudgeJudy · 03/01/2021 17:00

I also have a Panasonic. I think it's the 2051/2501 (can't be bothered to get up and check. Anyway, it has a timer which is really important. I had a different make before, just to check that I would actually use it.

The Panasonic makes so much better loaves.

NotMeNoNo · 03/01/2021 16:40

There's a reason they get good reviews. Any of them will probably be ok. Ours is old now but was the basic/ white model. With a raisin box. The SD2511 will be fine.
We had a cheaper breadmaker before, the Panasonic is in another league.

FlyingByTheSeatof · 03/01/2021 16:31

I've considered getting a Panasonic many many times and probably will at some point

FlyingByTheSeatof · 03/01/2021 16:29

Sorry that's meant to be in answer to not getting a bread maker but still having a fresh loaf ready for the morning

FlyingByTheSeatof · 03/01/2021 16:28

I make my dough the night before with first prove and then the second prove is slow overnight in the fridge ready to pop straight in the oven in the morning.
You can pop it straight in from the fridge to a hot oven or if you want leave it for an hour before hand.

Rockbird · 03/01/2021 16:20

My Panasonic must be at least 15 years old but it's still going strong. I keep looking at shiny new ones but there's nothing wrong with the one I have.

Janek · 03/01/2021 16:05

I've never had a bad loaf either - I've had my Panasonic bread maker nearly thirteen years, and I'd replace it the second it broke.

When we bought ours, and when I've looked to see what I'd replace it with, there always seemed to be two current models - the one with the seed dispenser and the one without. But the one without will beep to tell you to add the seeds yourself if you ask it to (I never have!).

wowfudge · 03/01/2021 16:02

I bought a Panasonic SD-256 from Facebook Marketplace for £10. It makes great bread. If you are adding extra ingredients you have to do so manually, but for £10.

YoniAndGuy · 03/01/2021 15:59

Oh and you get a massive recipe booklet with loads of info and a million recipes with different size options.

We use whatever flour is available - as folk have said, they're really forgiving on everything.

Never had a bad loaf.

YoniAndGuy · 03/01/2021 15:58

Ok we had the ?SD2501 I think, until it finally gave out after about 8 years service used every day!

Now we have the SD2511. I would get this, for sure. It will do everything you need. The seed dispenser option is great. The bread is always good.

Sadly no, there is for whatever reason a massive difference between panasonic and other makes. The bread tastes like bread, and nice bread at that, rather than slightly cakey 'breadmaker bread'.

And they last for years so frankly it's a really good investment if you use it regularly, because you will save money on bread UNLESS your idea of bread is a wet supermarket ready-sliced 20p abomination.

There are 3 loaf sizes you can go for for each recipe. We always do the smallest and it's a good sized loaf. So no issues there I'm sure.

YoniAndGuy · 03/01/2021 15:54

@Mumisnotmyonlyname

Frankly I'd just get the Russell Hobbs £65 one. They all do the same job, pretty much.
Not in a million years sadly. It's extra money well spent.
Haffiana · 03/01/2021 15:44

@Mumisnotmyonlyname

Frankly I'd just get the Russell Hobbs £65 one. They all do the same job, pretty much.
They really, really don't.

According to Which pretty much all the Panasonics are good. Just choose one with the programs you think you will use and which is in your price bracket.

I make mostly wholemeals, usually with some honey rather than sugar (because it smells amazing when baking mostly!), a handful of whatever seed or nut I want to use, and a big spoonful of tahini rather than oil or butter. Occasionally I use raisins and fresh rosemary as well, or cranberries or some coconut or eggs or whatever.

I use Doves yeast - most supermarkets sell it. Keep packet in fridge.

The thing that sets a Panasonic apart from all the shite cheaper models is that they are SO forgiving. I don't really measure anything except yeast flour and water, add everything else by eye (OK, a pretty experienced eye!) and it always comes out great.

Canadian flour tends to have more selenium than EU hard flours, but flours really are different - try several and find one you like.

Spelt is tasty but because it is higher in gluten may need a shorter program otherwise it rises too quickly and falls again before baking starts. Spelts are beginning to be standardised now, so you won't have the rollercoaster of each bag behaving differently like the old days!.

You certainly don't need flour improver (mostly vit C) unless your bread machine is dreadful and cannot produce a risen loaf without it - I personally prefer bread without.

UnaOfStormhold · 03/01/2021 15:41

I don't know why but the Panasonic ones do seem to be consistently better. The key considerations to think about are whether it has a hopper for seeds/nuts etc (handy if you want to make bread with bits in, particularly on the timer, and a separate yeast dispenser (good if you're regularly putting it on overnight). There are other factors (some do sourdough bread for instance) but I'd say those are the most important for what you need.

Flour quality does make a big difference too - we get 16kg bags from Shipton mill which are good value.

PickAChew · 03/01/2021 15:37

The programs do make some difference to taste and texture. If I have some slightly duff white flour, I use the wholemeal cycle for a longer prove which gives a nicer crumb.

If I just want dough, for rolls or enriched breads, I use my kitchenaid mixer as the clean up is much easier.

PickAChew · 03/01/2021 15:32

I'll not recommend mine, as it's an old model but it's well worth going for the one with the seed dispenser as it tends to have other refinements, too, whatever generation you get.

Ichangedmynameonce · 03/01/2021 15:31

thanks all.

I have considered just making the dough and sticking in the oven, as I make decent pizza dough with it, but really I just want the bread ready. I will experiment a bit more perhaps.

OP posts: