Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask which Panasonic Breadmaker?

87 replies

Ichangedmynameonce · 03/01/2021 10:24

I bought a cheap Argos breadmaker during lockdown and the bread is horrible. And the loaves are tiny.

Everyone says get a Panasonic- but there are loads of models.

AIBU to ask WHICH PANASONIC?
Please recommend or reject specific models.

I want:
Decent , tasty bread, including brown bread

A decent sized loaf, that will feed 5 of us.

Please don't recommend I do it by hand - I just don't have the time.

Thank you
ps I'm thinking the SD 2511 model


This thread is a bit old now so some of the suggestions may be out of date, but if you’ve landed here looking for bread makers, we’ve recently updated our best bread maker page with the top Panasonic models for your baking needs. We hope you find it useful. Flowers
MNHQ

OP posts:
lidoshuffle · 05/01/2021 09:14

A cake must come out a funny shape though? Tall and narrow.

SoupDragon · 04/01/2021 23:39

[quote 101namesforme]@UsernameSaved
Thanks for that, I hadn’t thought about the delay function for cakes.[/quote]
I imagine it uses less electricity for a single cake than a whole oven would. I've never used mine for cakes though.

NoWordForFluffy · 04/01/2021 17:59

I bought a second hand Panasonic SD255 on eBay for £7.99. It sadly died after about 14 months so we replaced it with an SD 2501. I had a 20% off Lakeland voucher so paid £120 for it.

We love it! We also buy large bags of flour. We've had Marriages' the last couple of times which was about £18 for 16kg on eBay.

The seed dispenser is great. As is waking up to the smell of fresh bread! 😋

101namesforme · 04/01/2021 17:42

@UsernameSaved
Thanks for that, I hadn’t thought about the delay function for cakes.

MyNameIsArthur · 04/01/2021 15:28

Here's a loaf that's just come out of our Panasonic SD2500. Dimensions are 7in x 5 in x 7 in roughly. This makes lovely delicious bread. Had no issues with it in the couple of years we have had it. Can't remember how much we paid for it though.

AIBU to ask which Panasonic Breadmaker?
AIBU to ask which Panasonic Breadmaker?
UsernameSaved · 04/01/2021 15:04

@101namesforme

I have never understood why people do cakes in the bread maker though. Surely as you have to do most of the mixing outside the bread maker, it’s as easy to shove it in the oven? Or am I missing something??
You can time it and make them whilst you are out or ready to come home. I wouldn't do that with an oven
101namesforme · 04/01/2021 14:35

I have never understood why people do cakes in the bread maker though. Surely as you have to do most of the mixing outside the bread maker, it’s as easy to shove it in the oven? Or am I missing something??

YoniAndGuy · 04/01/2021 14:34

@AlternativePerspective

I got rid of my bread maker in favour of a food mixer with a dough hook. Now I have a kitchenaid but I had a dualit before that.

The paddle shaped hole in the bottom of the bread is enough for me to never use a bread maker, not to mention the amount of space it takes up.

You can put ingredients into the stand mixer and leave for five minutes, kneed for a couple of minutes on a board, stick in a tin and leave to prove. And the quality is far superior to a bread maker.

Oh I know someone who used to do that.

Eventually gave up as no, the Panasonic bread is better and you don't have to clean the bloody food mixer every time AND the breadmaker fits into a smaller space-!

Oh dear Grin

AmadeustheAlpaca · 04/01/2021 14:28

The paddle spike is fixed and does stick out through the paper, but it doesn't affect the look of the cakes. The bread maker cakes probably wouldn't win any prizes for prettiness on Bake Off but they sure taste good.

movingonup20 · 04/01/2021 13:44

I have an Argos one (7 years old) and it makes amazing bread, it's the same size as every bread maker (except mini ones) I prefer however to make the dough in the bread maker and cook in the oven

PickAChew · 04/01/2021 13:31

No, that's fixed.

BaublesAndBawbags · 04/01/2021 13:23

@AmadeustheAlpaca

BaiblesandBawbags: I have successfully made cakes in my bread maker by lining the bread tin with baking paper, then putting the cake mix in. Can be a bit fiddly but the cakes turn out OK after baking. I think one of the reasons that Panasonic bread recipes turn out well is that they use basic yeast - Dove’s Farm is great - rather than the crappy sachets with flour improver in them. I love my Panasonic bread maker and it’s getting replaced with another one the second it breaks.
That's good to know! I'm probably asking a really stupid question but doesn't the paddle spike pierce the lining paper? Or can you yank that bit out too?
SoupDragon · 04/01/2021 13:23

not to mention the amount of space it takes up.

In complete contrast to those food mixers which famously take up no space at all 😂

Haffiana · 04/01/2021 13:18

@Elphame

Panasonics are amazing and last for ever.

I won't bother giving you my model number as it's now 25 years old but still going strong. I occasionally look at the fancy new ones that have jam making options etc but I just can't justify a replacement

Mine is also 25 years old and has a raisin/nut dispenser AND makes jam! Grin It is an SD253 and looks to be more or less the same as the current newer models.

Mind you, why anyone would want to make jam in a breadmaker is utterly beyond me...

TheDogsMother · 04/01/2021 12:52

Thank you @101namesforme, that's great advice. I also wfh so can attend to the different stages. I need to get a bit more ambitious with the different dough types and extend my repertoire.

ShutTheFuckUp123 · 04/01/2021 12:51

Another vote for the Panasonic here. I have been using the SD 206 for well over 20 + years, its brilliant but obviously does less than the machines you get today. Its been used almost every day since we got it, it looks a bit worse for wear but it still going great.

101namesforme · 04/01/2021 12:48

@TheDogsMother
The machine does the first prove and then I shape and prove again. With rolls it’s only for 20-30 mins while the oven heats, with a loaf it is longer.

Pittas are ideally proved for 15mins but can go straight in the oven I find.

I wfh anyway before covid so it’s easy enough to do the quick stages but would be a pain if I worked outside the house.

Elphame · 04/01/2021 12:48

Panasonics are amazing and last for ever.

I won't bother giving you my model number as it's now 25 years old but still going strong. I occasionally look at the fancy new ones that have jam making options etc but I just can't justify a replacement

MyNameIsArthur · 04/01/2021 12:47

We have a Panasonic SD2500. Is great. been very reliable these past couple of years. Lovely bread. I have a loaf on the make now. Will post photo later.

AIBU to ask which Panasonic Breadmaker?
Gobbycop · 04/01/2021 12:41

I've got the base model, 2500 is it?

Waited a while for it to drop to around £80-90.

It's brilliant, never had a duff loaf. I hardly wash it either. Just turf it out ready to go again.
I've heard that keeps the non stick coating good.

Purplewithred · 04/01/2021 12:39

Oh and you definitely need to buy the yeast regularly (the bread maker yeast, not fresh yeast), it doesn't last long once the pack is opened.

Purplewithred · 04/01/2021 12:37

I have the SD2501 and it's so good I have to hide it away so I don't make and eat a loaf a day.

Matthews Cotswold Crunch makes a fabulous granary loaf.

I'm planning on having a go at brioche (just the dough) today.

AmadeustheAlpaca · 04/01/2021 12:35

BaiblesandBawbags: I have successfully made cakes in my bread maker by lining the bread tin with baking paper, then putting the cake mix in. Can be a bit fiddly but the cakes turn out OK after baking. I think one of the reasons that Panasonic bread recipes turn out well is that they use basic yeast - Dove’s Farm is great - rather than the crappy sachets with flour improver in them. I love my Panasonic bread maker and it’s getting replaced with another one the second it breaks.

TheDogsMother · 04/01/2021 12:31

Another Panasonic user here. I previously had Russell Hobbs and the results weren't a patch on the loaves I get from this one. Again my only dud loaf was when I forgot to put the water in !

@101namesforme When you make rolls and pitta the bread maker does all the kneading/proving then you take the dough out, form the shapes and bake ? Or do you prove after you've taken the dough out of the machine ?

AlternativePerspective · 04/01/2021 12:28

I got rid of my bread maker in favour of a food mixer with a dough hook. Now I have a kitchenaid but I had a dualit before that.

The paddle shaped hole in the bottom of the bread is enough for me to never use a bread maker, not to mention the amount of space it takes up.

You can put ingredients into the stand mixer and leave for five minutes, kneed for a couple of minutes on a board, stick in a tin and leave to prove. And the quality is far superior to a bread maker.