Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Michael Jackson, veto?

206 replies

InkyPinkyPonky95 · 02/01/2021 21:56

It's up to you to decide whether you think MJ is a pedo or not, everyone is entitled to come to their own conclusion... but I think he was guilty and it's kind of ruined his music for me.

I won't storm out of a restaurant if one of his songs comes on! but I won't play his music myself because I can't separate his music from how disgusted I am by him.

That being said, for those that do believe he is guilty do you now veto playing his music? Has it ruined his music for you too? Or have you found a way to compartmentalise your feelings about it?

Side note: I understand not everyone thinks he's guilty, that's fine! Completely up to you to decide what you think. Not here to judge, just to hear other people's feelings.

OP posts:
Frankola · 04/01/2021 22:48

His behaviour with children was dangerous and inappropriate. He wasn't found guilty in court but we all know sometimes, for lots of reasons, justice does not prevail (OJ?!)

I loved his music but cannot listen anymore. I cannot ignore my beliefs enough.

I'm shocked that people seem to be defending or diminishing his actions due to his childhood. Yes, its commonly understood that childhood environment forms behaviour. Yes we know that those abused often become abusers but that does not get anyone off the hook. It does not reduce the damage they have caused. As an adult with an understanding of the world and moral code those people make a choice. He made a choice.

lunasunshine · 04/01/2021 21:58

@Russellbrandshair

I'm in two minds about this but as a PP said, would you accept a payoff to keep quiet if your own child had been abused?

I’m sorry but I really don’t get this argument because it ALSO APPLIES TO MJ!
If someone accused you of molesting a child and you were completely and utterly innocent you would surely be outraged and why would you pay them off? If you’re innocent there will be no evidence whatsoever to incriminate you. Him paying them off indicates his guilt to me. It’s exactly what R Kelly did to his victims- paid them off to keep quiet and they were scared because he had far more rich, powerful lawyers than them so they figured there was no hope of challenging him. There is a world of difference between a free court appointed lawyer and one of the best criminal defence attorneys in the country.

In the US if the chances of proving a criminal case are low (and the district attorney feels not enough to convict) then a civil case where compensation is paid is the next step. So this is not entirely unusual.
Remember that most rapes also don’t make it to criminal court due to lack of evidence but it doesn’t mean they didn’t happen.

@Russellbrandshair

In the 1993 case, Jordan Chandler’s father tried to sue MJ for $20million. MJ refused to pay this and his private investigator sent a counter offer for $1million. Evan Chandler refused this and expected MJ’s team to come back with a higher offer. They refused and reduced their offer to $350,000. When they realised that MJ wasn’t going to pay them any higher, Evan Chandler tried to go back to the original $1million, but MJ said no. His investigators also said that they only engaged in the negotiations to show that Evan Chandler was trying to negotiate for money over his son’s “abuse”. Michael could have easily bought their silence at this stage and prevented the whole thing from becoming public, but he didn’t.

Civil complaints are usually filed/heard following the completion of criminal cases. In this case, the Chandlers were pushing for the civil case to be heard BEFORE the criminal case. MJ was put in a very difficult position. If he took the civil case to court, it would have harmed his criminal case because it would give the prosecutors a huge advantage and they would have heard his defence in advance, therefore they would have been able to study it and tailor it accordingly. There are many other reasons that I won’t bore you with, but basically if MJ would have gone into a civil case with the Chandler family, it would have severely damaged his right to a fair trial, so on the advice of his layers he very reluctantly “paid them off” for an undisclosed sum.

Once the civil trial was settled, the Chandlers could have proceeded with a criminal case against Michael Jackson and have him locked up for good. Well, they didn’t. They took the money, refused to co-operate with the authorities and decided not to proceed any further. Jordan Chandler, the alleged victim, sought emancipation from his parents and never spoke to them again a year after this case was settled (aged 15).

Ironically, the law that allowed the civil case to be heard ahead of the criminal case was changed as a direct result of what happened in this case. An accuser now cannot pursue a civil case before the criminal case.

This is why the Gavin Arvizo case went to a criminal trial. And, after a lengthy court case with one of the most aggressive lawyers in town (who detested Michael and was desperate to see him locked up), MJ was found innocent on all counts. There was not one shred of credible evidence.

Things are not as black and white as they seem.

maddiemookins16mum · 04/01/2021 20:14

He is really not played as much these days.

Russellbrandshair · 04/01/2021 19:53

I'm in two minds about this but as a PP said, would you accept a payoff to keep quiet if your own child had been abused?

I’m sorry but I really don’t get this argument because it ALSO APPLIES TO MJ!
If someone accused you of molesting a child and you were completely and utterly innocent you would surely be outraged and why would you pay them off? If you’re innocent there will be no evidence whatsoever to incriminate you. Him paying them off indicates his guilt to me. It’s exactly what R Kelly did to his victims- paid them off to keep quiet and they were scared because he had far more rich, powerful lawyers than them so they figured there was no hope of challenging him. There is a world of difference between a free court appointed lawyer and one of the best criminal defence attorneys in the country.

In the US if the chances of proving a criminal case are low (and the district attorney feels not enough to convict) then a civil case where compensation is paid is the next step. So this is not entirely unusual.
Remember that most rapes also don’t make it to criminal court due to lack of evidence but it doesn’t mean they didn’t happen.

knittingaddict · 04/01/2021 17:33

@tisnotthedamnseason

Can we all please stop saying 'child pornography' it's offensive and inaccurate. The correct term is child abuse images. It's not porn.
I know. I listen to lots of podcasts and the US ones all seem to still use that phrase. Makes me wince every time I hear it.
ElizaLaLa · 04/01/2021 15:37

Lots of producers and executives are rapists or exploiters so there's a high chance all mainstream music has been worked on by a nonce.

But I don't listen to MJ anymore.

tisnotthedamnseason · 04/01/2021 15:36

Can we all please stop saying 'child pornography' it's offensive and inaccurate.
The correct term is child abuse images. It's not porn.

knittingaddict · 04/01/2021 15:31

@SapatSea

What to do about vetoing bands ? e.g Paedophile Ian Watkins of the Lost prophets (who I never listened to, but I wonder do any of their old fans).

I feel the Rolling Stones are tainted by Bill Wyman (Mandy Smith) especially, Roger Daltrey of The Who has made homophobic comments and Pete Townsend had child porn on his computer. Julia Holcomb has stated that Steve Tyler(Aerosmith) got her guardian rights signed over to him when she was 14 so he could take her across state lines (he was 27), Jimmy page (Led Zep) and underage groupies, kidnapping Lori Maddox. So many alleged wife beaters out there who were in bands e.g. Ringo, Lennon, Ike Turner... If you are rich and famous it doesn't seem to affect your career too much especially if the abuse is "historic" with the excuse given about the prevailing attitudes of the time (e.g. 60's, 1970's) often lauded as if it makes you more macho and "rock n roll."

Only listen to female artists? It's a thought.
SapatSea · 04/01/2021 15:28

What to do about vetoing bands ? e.g Paedophile Ian Watkins of the Lost prophets (who I never listened to, but I wonder do any of their old fans).

I feel the Rolling Stones are tainted by Bill Wyman (Mandy Smith) especially, Roger Daltrey of The Who has made homophobic comments and Pete Townsend had child porn on his computer. Julia Holcomb has stated that Steve Tyler(Aerosmith) got her guardian rights signed over to him when she was 14 so he could take her across state lines (he was 27), Jimmy page (Led Zep) and underage groupies, kidnapping Lori Maddox. So many alleged wife beaters out there who were in bands e.g. Ringo, Lennon, Ike Turner... If you are rich and famous it doesn't seem to affect your career too much especially if the abuse is "historic" with the excuse given about the prevailing attitudes of the time (e.g. 60's, 1970's) often lauded as if it makes you more macho and "rock n roll."

contrmary · 04/01/2021 15:24

I don't listen to his music, but neither have I deleted the few songs of his I have from my collection.

To be honest I was always uncomfortable listening to his music, even though some of it was quite acceptable. In the 90s there was lots of speculation regarding his paedophilia, and that's before you start on all the Wacko Jacko stuff like his face, dangling a kid out of a window, and the obscene self-satisfaction of the History album (which, thinking about it, came with a photo of a naked child - presumably him - in the booklet).

But it's undeniable that as soon as I hear one of his songs I immediately think "nonce" in the same way I do when I hear Gary Glitter. (Funnily enough, the same happens when I hear Steps - that whole Ian Watkins/"H" confusion was enough to taint them too.)

waterlego · 04/01/2021 15:22

Exactly knitting

Chanjer · 04/01/2021 15:21

I don't know if he's guilty and in the grand scheme of things I don't actually care

I love (some of) his music and have never had an opinion or interest in him or his personal life, or any other celebrity or any other person I don't personally know really

knittingaddict · 04/01/2021 15:20

There is none waterlego.

waterlego · 04/01/2021 15:15

Even if you thought ‘Leaving Neverland’ was bullshit, as some clearly do, Jackson himself said that he invited children to share his bed with him. In what universe is that ok?

Would you allow your child to share a bed with a man to whom they were not related? At the adult’s request? I really hope not. I can’t conceive of any innocent explanation for an adult to make such a request.

ViciousJackdaw · 04/01/2021 15:05

I'm in two minds about this but as a PP said, would you accept a payoff to keep quiet if your own child had been abused? We'll never know the truth so I'll err on the side of caution - I won't turn the radio off if he comes on but his music isn't something I would play if other people could hear it.

As for Mozza, I'm truly disappointed by the old bigot. I magpied his solo CDs but still listen to The Smiths a lot because of Johnny Marr.

Coldilox · 04/01/2021 14:49

Oh and the innocent til proven guilty thing doesn’t wash. I’ve seen dozens of rapists walk free from court, any countless others never get there in the first place.

My abusers have never been proven guilty. Doesn’t mean they weren’t.

Coldilox · 04/01/2021 14:41

I’ve never been a fan so wouldn’t choose to listen anyway (other than some early Jackson 5). But I believe he was guilty, so would never play his music.

He was an abuser who used his wealth and power to silence his victims, he even got them to believe they weren’t victims for a long time. His behaviour isn’t all that special, it’s pretty typical of abusers. The only thing that sets him apart is his fame.

lunasunshine · 04/01/2021 14:28

@Notimeforaname I’m so glad to hear that Smile

Have you watched Square One on Amazon Prime? It goes into detail about the 1993 accusers. Very, very interesting!!

lunasunshine · 04/01/2021 14:24

@Cokie3 I’d love to know what ‘blatant evidence’ you know about?

Notimeforaname · 04/01/2021 13:15

Yes lunasunshine I feel the same as you. Love MJ .
Looking at his huge portrait on my wall as we type..Smile

Proudboomer · 04/01/2021 13:13

I believe he was guilty and would never play his music now. I believe he exploited his fame to abuse children and get away with it. I don’t want to listening to music that pays royalties to an abusers estate.

lunasunshine · 04/01/2021 13:08

I think he is innocent and still listen to his music. It’s genius and timeless.

However, he was heavily exploited and ripped apart by the tabloids so I can understand why people who haven’t done their research would think he is guilty. The public were obsessed with the “Wacko Jacko” image and, the crazier the stories, the more the newspapers would sell which lined the pockets of the tabloids very nicely.

FYI, the “documentary” Leaving Neverland is a big pile of shite and has more holes than a swiss cheese.

Even in death, Michael Jackson continues to be exploited for his money.

FuckTheLemons · 04/01/2021 12:26

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the OP.

Emmelina · 04/01/2021 09:20

The high weak voice was put on, there are videos out there of him talking. He has a stereotypical deep black man’s voice. Would his natural voice have encouraged parents to leave their sons with him? No. I’ve no doubt there was a lot of ‘professional’ manipulation going on. If you don’t stay at my house/drink this alcohol/bathe with me naked, I’ll tell everyone you’re impossible to work with and because I’m Michael Jackson they’ll take me at my word and you’ll never dance professionally/act again!
Naive and innocent? Did you listen to the lyrics of the songs he sang?

ZoeTurtle · 04/01/2021 09:18

I don't listen to him anymore. I wouldn't walk out of a restaurant that was playing one of his tracks, but I'd turn over the radio if I was in control of it.