Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let her fail her GCSEs

195 replies

Newpuppymummy · 01/01/2021 13:34

My 15 year old (y11) is doing basically no revision. She’s laying about doing whatever she wants despite all my best efforts to motivate and help her.

I have offered to sit with her, help make a written plan is, help test her r on things and she’s just not interested and resists everything.

Part of me feels like I want this more than her. I don’t know whether my best option is just to leave her to it and learn the lesson that you have to put work into things to get good results. This goes against my normal parenting strategies but I am at a loss with her.

OP posts:
Lampzade · 01/01/2021 15:38

Op, you are not the only one .
My ds has all the material / equipment, space to study , but decided that he couldn’t be bothered to study for his GCSES .
If I left it to him, he would do absolutely nothing except to play on his PS5 all day.
During the holidays I helped him prepare a time table .He studied between the hours of 10 am and 5pm with breaks.
I know that some posters say that you should let them fail, but I think my ds just needed a kick up the backside

BluebellsGreenbells · 01/01/2021 15:35

GCSEs aren't everything and sometimes mucking them up motivates some people to do better at A level

There’s loads of a levels you can’t do without maths and English
Some a levels need a set grade to even be considered to do that.

Things have changed

donewithitalltodayandxmas · 01/01/2021 15:29

My ds is the same just not motivated he has online next week as school are providing online for all of then so hoping this motivates him a bit more. Also supposed to be doing mocks and has real btech , but then also he hasn't actually covered all subjects yet either with all missed time
He has done a little bit but not much , but I am not overly motivated with life either at moment so get where he is coming from in some ways

randomer · 01/01/2021 15:23

Its very easy for me to say ( through the other end of this) but I wonder if the work hard, pass your exams thing holds true anymore?

littledrummergirl · 01/01/2021 15:22

My dd is year 11. I picked a good time when she was amenable to advice and planned a timetable with her. The first thing we put in was school, meals, hobbies and family time (we put one hour aside three times a week for games). Dd then added in tv programs that she likes. The time that was left was allocated to homework and revision. We then added in the subjects so that all were covered.
This was all done in half hour slots where dd was to revise for 20 minutes then have a ten minute break before moving to another subject. We tried where possible to put one she didn't enjoy followed by one she did and meant she did every subject twice over the week.
We also broke down the topics into red, amber and green. Green being what she felt confident in and red the ones she didn't feel she understood. Every week she has amended the timetable topics so she is covering all of the red ones.
I've then left her to revise as she sees fit. Breaking it down has helped her to see that it's not as daunting as she first thought, if she wants to alter the timetable to fit her day better she can.
Over the holidays she had three days off over Christmas and has been working to a timetable she created for the time away from school.

Helping her to create the timetable made such a difference.

Ilovenewyear · 01/01/2021 15:21

Offer a reward in exchange for grades!

OhGingleBells · 01/01/2021 15:18

My mum absolutely dragged me through my GCSEs. She would read my revision guides and make flash cards and test me, drilled me on my notes, made timetables, emailed my teachers, watched videos with me, wrote essays with me, She definitely cared more than I did and put more in far more effort in than I did.

It worked - I had failed/scraped passes in the mock exams and passed all of the actual GCSEs, some pretty well.

I couldn’t revise alone - not enough motivation, too overwhelmed by all the stuff I didn’t know. Easily distracted by the stuff I liked and bored by the stuff I didn’t. Sometimes she made things fun with songs or silly memory things and sometimes she would absolutely refuse to let me not do anything. It was exhausting for everyone but I guess I was passive enough that I would sit there and let her drill me until I could do it.

When it was my brother’s turn to do GCSEs, he pretty much did everything alone and did extremely well.

I wouldn’t say it inspired me or changed me as a person - I can still be pretty unmotivated and hate doing things alone. I don’t think I was emotionally mature enough for GCSEs and so I had to be treated and trained like a child. Obviously I am incredibly lucky to have a mother that did that for me and it certainly wouldn’t work for everyone but if your daughter does care on some level and is just overwhelmed and anxious or a bit lazy and unmotivated you might be able to get her through them.

I think you have to ask yourself if it is more important that you get her through them at whatever cost, bearing in mind that she won’t develop as much independence or work ethic or whether you think she would be better off getting on with it and realising that actions (or lack of!) have consequences.

Good luck.

Peanutbutterblood · 01/01/2021 15:15

Does she really need pushing? I did very little revision for GCSEs, passed them all no problem which shocked a lot of people as I had been so laid back. I upped my game at a level though because I knew I needed to but I did it all off my own back.

ThanksItHasPockets · 01/01/2021 15:13

Do you have any family or friends with a year 12? She might not be receptive to the message from anyone but a near peer probably has the best chance.

Hankunamatata · 01/01/2021 15:10

My parents essentially kept me in house to study for GCSE. I had to stay in spare room and study. TV was removed from upstairs and wasnt phones in those days. They were tough. But I got good gcses which I'm eternally grateful for. After gcse mum said enough was enough and let me control what I did. So I did my a levels and failed them in spectacular fashion. Taught me valuable life lesson. Resat and went to uni. GCSE are vital and I would push my DC through them then step back.

I'm forever grateful my parents forced my study through gcse as they are hardest to resist imo.

Worriedandabitscared · 01/01/2021 15:07

It really depends on the child, I didn't do any revision and got Cs and Bs so she may not fail per say

Crystal90567 · 01/01/2021 15:05

Past rates are rock bottom at the moment and going down this year, if they have them at all. Don't force her nose to the books.
She'll be fine.
Mental health is far more important and I bet she can read, write, spell and do ks2 maths. Youd be surprised how many yr 11 cant - that's your 1, 2s and 3s. 4 is a pass. Old grade C.
The persistence of the middle class to get all As is madness and unnecessary.

Ohdoleavemealone · 01/01/2021 15:05

My parents pushed me to revise so much for my GCSEs that I sat staring at walls alot of the time.

I did much better with my A levels where I was left to my own devices.

Heyahun · 01/01/2021 15:04

I’d leave her alone you can’t force someone to study!
My parents were always very relaxed with me I didn’t do a huge amount of work/revision! I did fine, passed everything! Didn’t want to attend a big uni - I did a community college course, then managed to do a degree at the end of it - had my degree by 21 - was just a different route but it worked for me!

Then you have friend who was essentially locked in her house for months forced to study constantly and have no social life - she did get better grades than me - went to a big university - had dropped out before the end of the first year and never went back!

You can’t force it - she will take her own path and figure it out

Labobo · 01/01/2021 15:04

Her year group has been so badly affected by Covid. Must be so hard to get the focus and momentum back after such extended disruption.

I'd probably have one more gentle go at motivating her. Say how hard it is for her particular year group and how understandable it is that her motivation has gone. Then maybe say that it's not her fault but it could affect her future and you think she deserves better. Offer to help her do short revision sessions with breaks and then go over what she's studied with you. If she really won't, tell her it's up to her, but mocks may be what her final marks are based on, and let her know if she changes her mind and wants to focus that you will help if she needs support in any way.

EngTech · 01/01/2021 15:02

Reality has a habit of catching up soon enough, you can only do what you can do 👍

Davespecifico · 01/01/2021 15:01

If she’s capable of doing GCSEs, she won’t fail, she’ll most likely just not do as well as she could. She’ll be able to use everything she’s retained from lessons.
Not ideal at all but not the end of the world.

oakleaffy · 01/01/2021 15:00

I meant to say A levels he went straight to taking A levels rather than GCSE’s which is quite a leap.

oakleaffy · 01/01/2021 14:59

If she isn’t interested, there’s nothing you can do.

She’ll have to learn the hard way.

Chap I knew bombed all his GCSE’s and re took in his early 20,s

Maths, Chemistry, biology and Physics.. and got top marks and got into the course he wanted at a good university.

He said he wasn’t ready to study as a teenager.

Bluesmartiesandpandapop · 01/01/2021 14:52

You can try to encourage her, be there for her for academic health and emotional support. But ultimately she may fail the January exams. I would not see that as her failure though, it's a consequence of her adverse experiences this last year, and if you give her time and not too much pressure but lots of support then she will hopefully flourish when the situation improves. An extra year at college, or whatever, would be a much better response than a child who cracks under the pressure. I know people who have resit exams much later, and others who have never resat their exams and it's not harmed their lives. I've also seen people have nervous breakdowns and psychotic breaks because of the pressures of college, university etc. If she can get through this with failed GCSEs but self esteem and hope and joy then she will have succeeded not failed.

TillyTopper · 01/01/2021 14:50

I actually left both of my DS to it when it came to GCSEs. They had been working well, but really slackened off in the final year (play games, laying around etc). I decided that I was running myself ragged keep chasing them, offering help etc and it was causing arguments.

I sat them both down, told them that they needed to knuckle down and do their work if they wanted to achieve anything. I warned them that I would no longer be chasing them, if they wanted help they just had to ask and I would certainly do whatever I could to help. I told them that if I continued to push them I felt I was doing no favours as they'd have to learn to do it themselves for A Levels and at Uni anyway. Actually they did pretty well, although not as well as I thought they could have achieved if they had actually done some work. I think it's probably affected their chances as they didn't get grades they were capable of, nor did they get A Level grades they were capable of, hence one didn't get into a RG Uni. But I stopped stressing and made it their problem.

fastandthecurious · 01/01/2021 14:48

I remember I did this over the Christmas holidays before my GCSE's. Thought I'd be fine as I'm naturally academic and never struggled before. Did my mocks in January and got C's and D's and was mortified at myself. It gave me the kick I needed and I came out with A* and A's in everything. Let her fail her mocks and with any luck she'll realise.

TatianaBis · 01/01/2021 14:46

@Elieza

I was offered money on a sliding scale for an A B or C grade. That helped me.

I didn’t earn much pocket money as my family werent rich so the offer of a few extra quid made me totally ramp up my studies as I’d never had much spare money and I knew they must be serious about me doing well or they wouldn’t have offered me the thing they didn’t have much of. So I tried to do them proud. Got four A a B and a C. Happy ending.

Some will say that’s a bad idea yada yada, but in future work (in a job) = reward (pay).

So I figure work (revision) = reward (cash).

So it’s not that different to the reality of life. If you can afford to offer that type of encouragement just now.

I was also encouraged to save some. Which I did after buying shoes and bits and bobs I wanted.

Bribery worked for me as a kid too. I once learnt a concerto movement in a week for a new pair of shoes.

But it would be called incentivisation or goal oriented learning now.

mam0918 · 01/01/2021 14:45

not everyone learns through revision, Im dyslexic (although not greatly obvious) and it doesn't help me at all as I cant take notes in class and struggle to read text books as such attempting to read large text blocks or bad note makes me MORE likely to make mistakes.

I memorise things in real time as I hear them and hated alway being penalised for not revising, at school some insisted I cheated because I didnt 'revise' but always passed but whats normal for some people isnt for all and that style of learning doesnt work with me.

wildraisins · 01/01/2021 14:34

I think the best way to respond to this varies so much for each individual. It really depends on your daughter's personality and you know that better than anyone. Is she likely to respond to harsh rules or will that just make her rebel more? Will she respond if you try to talk to her without nagging, but as an adult? How about her friends - are they revising? Could they have a study group together?

As other people have said there is usually a way. Teenagers are often rebelling against parental influence in one way or another so you have to find a way that makes her feel like an adult and gives her control, whilst helping her see how important this is.

Failing that... if she's a little immature for her age and needs some external motivation... a money reward or gift for doing well could have its place ;)

Swipe left for the next trending thread