Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's OK to be a teen mum?

712 replies

veganmegan · 30/12/2020 21:51

NC. I rarely start threads on here but I have a question (hope that's OK). My little sister is seventeen and she welcomed into the world a lovely little boy in November. Since announcing his birth on social media, she received a handful of messages from former "friends" Hmm saying "Always knew you were a slag, you'll never get a proper job now, do you even know who the father is" (or words to that effect).

So really fucking abusive bullying behaviour. They also said something about her now having to move to a council estate (?) and about "babies shouldn't have babies" (which I guarantee is just a direct quote from someone's judgemental parent).

They're also teenagers so I'm not necessarily holding it entirely against them (as you say all sorts of silly stuff when you're young) but given they're pretty middle class kids who I don't think have even met someone from a council estate, or a teen mum other than my sis, I'm wondering where all of these preconceived stereotypes come from.

She's decided to block them now after my convincing so hopefully there won't be any more online bullying, but I'm wondering who thinks these things? Where does this idea come from? Is this an idea you instil in your own kids, if you're a parent?

I just really feel for her if I'm honest. She's so happy to have her wee baby, but people continuously perceive her as a "slag" solely because she had a baby young. I don't even really know how to support her, just really pisses me off and simultaneously upsets me on her behalf.

OP posts:
Wheresmykimchi · 03/01/2021 16:45

@Ideasplease322

This thread is odd. Now going to university is a negative and having children very young makes you more mature and successful.

I am not in any way saying everyone who goes to university achieves success, but all available statistics show they have better career outcomes on average than those who don’t.

It is just silly so throw out a few examples of some people you know and claim this means going to university is a bad idea.

If Some of the comments on this thread Reflected reality, he government would close all i situates other higher learning and suggest instead of GCSEs our children have a baby. Apparently it leads to greater maturity.

No it isn't

I never said going to uni is a bad idea. Never once. I loved it , in fact I've gone back for a third go! I also didn't say it makes you more mature.

What are 'better career outcomes'? I know a couple - a handyman and a nurse. He makes more than she does.

My point is, what I am trying to do is provide balance for the posters who would be 'devastated' and 'heartbroken' if their children had babies young.

It appears on this thread it's OK to use anecdotes and personal feelings to make points but only if it's anti teenage mums.

veganmegan · 03/01/2021 16:43

It is just silly so throw out a few examples of some people you know and claim this means going to university is a bad idea.

(To my knowledge) nobody has said that though? There's been anecdotal experience mentioned on all sides of the field.

OP posts:
Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 16:41

This thread is odd. Now going to university is a negative and having children very young makes you more mature and successful.

I am not in any way saying everyone who goes to university achieves success, but all available statistics show they have better career outcomes on average than those who don’t.

It is just silly so throw out a few examples of some people you know and claim this means going to university is a bad idea.

If Some of the comments on this thread Reflected reality, he government would close all i situates other higher learning and suggest instead of GCSEs our children have a baby. Apparently it leads to greater maturity.

veganmegan · 03/01/2021 16:39

I have a Mickey mouse degree ...two in fact grin

I have one that I hoped would be a serious degree, but alas I too am part of the Mickey Mouse degree club it seems Grin

I will be supporting my DSis through getting her degree though, I think I might try and point her towards the OU and see what she thinks of that.

OP posts:
Wheresmykimchi · 03/01/2021 16:36

@veganmegan

Anecdotally, I know far more people my age (nearly 30) with Mickey mouse degrees feeling unfulfilled in and unrelated job. My friends who had children young are living much more successful lives.

I hear that, and I find your use of "Mickey Mouse degrees" an interesting turn of phrase! I think from what I've read + some experience, being a teen mum seems to be a make or break experience, in that it can either damage your potential due to additional responsibility, or make you more determined to find success.

I have a Mickey mouse degree ...two in fact Grin

I'd certainly say my pals who had kids young re more mature and have hd better relationship success than us.

veganmegan · 03/01/2021 16:34

Anecdotally, I know far more people my age (nearly 30) with Mickey mouse degrees feeling unfulfilled in and unrelated job. My friends who had children young are living much more successful lives.

I hear that, and I find your use of "Mickey Mouse degrees" an interesting turn of phrase! I think from what I've read + some experience, being a teen mum seems to be a make or break experience, in that it can either damage your potential due to additional responsibility, or make you more determined to find success.

OP posts:
Wheresmykimchi · 03/01/2021 16:23

@veganmegan

I don't know if it really counts given I'm a recent uni grad, but there are quite a few people in my year who are now unemployed / not finding anything they're passionate about. This is probably worsened by lockdown, but I don't think it's unheard of for people to get degrees in lieu of parental pressure and then have no idea what to do next.

There's not really any next natural step (other than working).

Anecdotally, I know far more people my age (nearly 30) with Mickey mouse degrees feeling unfulfilled in and unrelated job. My friends who had children young are living much more successful lives.
veganmegan · 03/01/2021 15:12

I don't know if it really counts given I'm a recent uni grad, but there are quite a few people in my year who are now unemployed / not finding anything they're passionate about. This is probably worsened by lockdown, but I don't think it's unheard of for people to get degrees in lieu of parental pressure and then have no idea what to do next.

There's not really any next natural step (other than working).

OP posts:
Kendodd · 03/01/2021 15:11

Well theres two completely separate things going on here.
Is it ok to be a teen mum?
I would say, no, wait until at least 20 when body and mind are a bit more mature (I know life happens though)
The misogyny is a completely separate issue and is NEVER ok, there is no excuse for it and should never happen.

Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 15:05

I have an urge to send a careers advisors to this cluster of university graduates who have been unemployed for years and who all deeply resent their parents for forcing them into this situation.

How did you daughter meet this group? Had they all bandied together into some sort of support group? I imagine them sitting around in a community hall and you daughter stumbling in accidentally - thinking it was a baking class, and making friends with this sorry little group.

It would be a great movie - triumph over adversity. Your daughter helping them overcome their poor choices- holding their hands while the have flash backs to ucas forms and students union😂😂😂

Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 14:52

It seems a huge coincidence that you know so many young people in this specific situation!

I don’t know anyone who went to university who isn’t working. Yes there are variations in success levels, and one or two aren’t in graduate jobs.

Did all these floundering unemployed graduates go to the same university and do the same course? It sounds like there is something very very wrong here.

On average the unemployment rate for non graduates is double that Of graduates. So this group of young people are really bucking the trend.

Are you sure you aren’t biased in this?

Oliversmumsarmy · 03/01/2021 14:45

Oliversmummy was comparing her daughter to some fiends. It is ridiculous

I was comparing the non graduate people I know with graduates I know through Dd.

Most of the ones who did get a degree at the insistence of their parents haven’t worked in years.
They seem to come out of university and flounder. They don’t want to go back to square 1 as they feel too old and too overly qualified so end up on benefits
A lot didn’t want to go to university and had a path they wanted to follow but now seem to have lost their way which I think is really sad

Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 12:56

@HibernatingTill2030

Surely it depends what you study at university? Eg, law and medicine more likely to have on average higher earnings at 30+ than someone who went straight into work at 16/18 or who studied at uni, for eg fine art, and then got a job in a completely unrelated field (again, averages, sure there are exceptions)
Well yes, of Course it’s based on averages. I did say this in my post. University is not the be all and end all, and many people who didn’t go to university have had very successful careers, in the same way that university does no in any way guarantee a high earning job.

Studies have shown creative arts students don’t tend to earn more that those who didn’t go to university, and there are fairly low margins for English, communications and philosophy.

However overall university graduates earn on average more during their careers than non graduates, and the returns are greatest for subjects like economics, medicine and architecture.

My point was I don’t think there is any need to be concerned about graduates maturity levels and home ownership potential in general. Oliversmummy was comparing her daughter to some fiends. It is ridiculous,

Grapewrath · 03/01/2021 12:37

I worked with teen parents for a long time in a medical capacity. I csn assure you that even when they live with parents they don’t require much support other than the odd meal or break like any other new mum. They very much get on with looking after their own baby independently within the family home. Many rent homes with older partners. Very few need social services intervention or similar.
I have also worked with older parents and many need extra support. It is rarely based on age. In my personal experience teen mums have fewer expectations and just get on with things, they are more easy going . Older parents ( professionals especially) put a lot of pressure on themselves to be perfect and can also really struggle with the major change in their life.
The majority of the teen parents I worked with are successful adults to be fair

HibernatingTill2030 · 03/01/2021 12:32

Surely it depends what you study at university? Eg, law and medicine more likely to have on average higher earnings at 30+ than someone who went straight into work at 16/18 or who studied at uni, for eg fine art, and then got a job in a completely unrelated field (again, averages, sure there are exceptions)

Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 12:25

Oliversmumsarmy I am not sure what your argument is?

You are more worried about the future of people who went to university because they are less mature and less likely to be home owners?

This seems to be based on a small group of your child’s friends.

While of course people who go to university enter the world of work later, and arguable enjoy extra carefree years while studying, they also on average earn more than their counterparts who didn’t progress with education (just averages of course, and many examples can be cited where this hasn’t been the case).

However I don’t think you need worry about cohorts of people in their twenties because they have be forced from tertiary education. I am sore it will all work out😂

Oliversmumsarmy · 03/01/2021 11:00

I imagine the numbers of 17 year olds in stable marriages and buying their own homes must be tiny

Probably pretty non existent given you can’t get a mortgage till you are 18.

Agree that some did have older bfs. I.e 18 years old when they were 16/17.

HibernatingTill2030 · 03/01/2021 10:42

@Oliversmumsarmy

Even the 16/17 year olds are going to need some kind of support, either from social services or their parents- they can't just take out a tenancy

What about their husbands or partners?

I know several people who have married at 16/17

Both parties under 18? I would imagine the number of married couples, both under 18, who are financially independent is very, very small. Single figures.
SnuggyBuggy · 03/01/2021 10:33

I imagine the numbers of 17 year olds in stable marriages and buying their own homes must be tiny.

Oliversmumsarmy · 03/01/2021 10:32

Even the 16/17 year olds are going to need some kind of support, either from social services or their parents- they can't just take out a tenancy

What about their husbands or partners?

I know several people who have married at 16/17

Oliversmumsarmy · 03/01/2021 10:29

SnuggyBuggy*

Well given that the average age for buying a house is 30 and I believe its similar for a first marriage the number of teenagers in the sort of stable situations that children do best in must be low

With the gig economy and high property prices the last thing I'd want for my DD is additional hurdles to independence

I think that going to university actually impedes the ability to buy a house before the age of 30.
The fact that it is the average age means that as many people below the age of 30 buy their first property as above it.

My Dd who works in the gig economy was a teenager when she bought her first place (a tiny run down flat in a run down area miles from where we all live)
Being in the gig economy doesn't stop you buying.
From just looking at dds friends and peers it is those that went to university who I would worry about rather than those who didn’t.
I see a difference in maturity levels
Otoh looking at dds large group of friends and work colleagues more people by the age of 25 have bought their first place and seem to have got their life sorted who didn’t go to university.
By 25 the ones who did go to university are still struggling to find a job or are being paid a low salary in the hope that one day things will come good but then are missing out on buying a place that by the time they can, prices will have risen so will be on a similar level to those they could have bought 10 years earlier. IYSWIM.

By the age of 30 one guy dd knows will have not only paid off his current mortgage but also the loan on his business premises.

Even a carpet fitter I know who is 22 has bought his first flat with his younger gf and we are in the SE.

HibernatingTill2030 · 03/01/2021 10:18

This idea that all teenage mums live at home and are on their own and parents need to take responsibility for the baby as well as their own child is quite wrong

Given that teenager covers 13-19, it's not a massive reach, is it? only the ones aged around 18-19 would be legally allowed to be fully independent. Even the 16/17 year olds are going to need some kind of support, either from social services or their parents- they can't just take out a tenancy.

LouJ85 · 03/01/2021 10:18

*If I walk out of my house at 2am/3am down the dark road, I believe I'm placing myself at unnecessary risk of danger. Nobody should attack me...but why put myself in such a position.

Being sensible and assessing risks...is not the same as victim blaming.*

I do have to agree with your last statement. I think this term "victim blaming" gets trotted out a lot on here. In this case, I think you're right. Assessing risk is a natural part of life and being responsible for doing so in your own life doesn't make you "to blame' necessarily if things go wrong.

If I decided to take a chance and cross a road with my eyes closed, I'm increasing my own risk of being hit by a car. That's poor risk assessment on my own part, and no one else's. Would the driver be entirely at fault? Maybe he or she would be blamed a little for not reacting sooner, who knows. But equally, was that good risk assessment on my part? Absolutely not.

So I do see the point here.

SnuggyBuggy · 03/01/2021 10:07

Well given that the average age for buying a house is 30 and I believe its similar for a first marriage the number of teenagers in the sort of stable situations that children do best in must be low.

With the gig economy and high property prices the last thing I'd want for my DD is additional hurdles to independence.

TheOneLeggedJockey · 03/01/2021 10:02

This idea that all teenage mums live at home and are on their own and parents need to take responsibility for the baby as well as their own child is quite wrong.

Mmm, I don’t think it’s quite wrong, I think it may arguably be just marginally wrong - because let’s be honest, it definitely does apply to a significant cohort of teenage Mums.