Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's OK to be a teen mum?

712 replies

veganmegan · 30/12/2020 21:51

NC. I rarely start threads on here but I have a question (hope that's OK). My little sister is seventeen and she welcomed into the world a lovely little boy in November. Since announcing his birth on social media, she received a handful of messages from former "friends" Hmm saying "Always knew you were a slag, you'll never get a proper job now, do you even know who the father is" (or words to that effect).

So really fucking abusive bullying behaviour. They also said something about her now having to move to a council estate (?) and about "babies shouldn't have babies" (which I guarantee is just a direct quote from someone's judgemental parent).

They're also teenagers so I'm not necessarily holding it entirely against them (as you say all sorts of silly stuff when you're young) but given they're pretty middle class kids who I don't think have even met someone from a council estate, or a teen mum other than my sis, I'm wondering where all of these preconceived stereotypes come from.

She's decided to block them now after my convincing so hopefully there won't be any more online bullying, but I'm wondering who thinks these things? Where does this idea come from? Is this an idea you instil in your own kids, if you're a parent?

I just really feel for her if I'm honest. She's so happy to have her wee baby, but people continuously perceive her as a "slag" solely because she had a baby young. I don't even really know how to support her, just really pisses me off and simultaneously upsets me on her behalf.

OP posts:
Wheresmykimchi · 03/01/2021 21:05

@Ideasplease322

‘That's not what I meant.

My response was that I think scot free is a non expression.’

I am sorry, I may be a little thick, but I really don’t understand what you mean. You said it was anecdotal? How does that relate to the use of the expression Scot free - and surely that is an

You may be making a fiendishly clever point here, but I am really lost.

Well, Scot free is an umbrella term. Meaning what? Where do fathers escape responsibility other than anecdotally?
Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 19:43

‘That's not what I meant.

My response was that I think scot free is a non expression.’

I am sorry, I may be a little thick, but I really don’t understand what you mean. You said it was anecdotal? How does that relate to the use of the expression Scot free - and surely that is an

You may be making a fiendishly clever point here, but I am really lost.

Buttercup54321 · 03/01/2021 19:18

I love this xx

Wheresmykimchi · 03/01/2021 19:10

@TeaEgg

But that's better info in a thread like this, surely. Real people tales. Not statistics from a book.

That is the kind of nonsensical statement I would hope that the first year of a university degree in many subjects would disabuse you of, quite apart from any other value it might have.

Anecdotes on an anonymous internet forum where we could all be inventing tales of teenage mothers we know who ended up heading the Sunday Times Rich List really don't trump huge amounts of peer-reviewed research on adverse health, educational and social outcomes for teenage mothers.

For example. ..

On a thread about DP behaviour for example, do you see more people popping up witvh their own experiences and advice, or with stats?

Wheresmykimchi · 03/01/2021 19:09

@Ideasplease322

The fact that there is so little research available on the impact on boys would suggest the impact is marginal. However if you have evidence to the contrary I would honestly be really interested. It would be refreshing to see the trend has changed.
That's not what I meant.

My response was that I think scot free is a non expression.

Wheresmykimchi · 03/01/2021 19:08

@TeaEgg

But that's better info in a thread like this, surely. Real people tales. Not statistics from a book.

That is the kind of nonsensical statement I would hope that the first year of a university degree in many subjects would disabuse you of, quite apart from any other value it might have.

Anecdotes on an anonymous internet forum where we could all be inventing tales of teenage mothers we know who ended up heading the Sunday Times Rich List really don't trump huge amounts of peer-reviewed research on adverse health, educational and social outcomes for teenage mothers.

No - but they are more relatable to teens than research they can't see.

Sorry to disappoint but I've got three degrees and I teach , and it hasn't been 'disabused' Confused yet.

Just my opinion. We've all got one.

Imapotato · 03/01/2021 17:50

@Ideasplease322

You should tell her that😂😂. You are just better than her😂
Off to tell her now! 😂

In all honesty we both have strengths and weaknesses. She is better at academic writing than me, and I’ll get her to proof read my essays, but I have more health care experience so helped her by looking over her personal statement and suggesting changes. Also I’m older so advise her on general life stuff. We actually get on very well. 😁

Imapotato · 03/01/2021 17:47

I suppose I meant there was an implied criticism of your sister, because you had kids and a house you were better than her, But as you say you have very different life paths

No criticism, My sisters great and she picked the path that felt right for her at the time. She now questions herself whether it was the right one. She would have always gone to uni, but I think she wishes she hadn’t had such high flying ambitions and had just done the AHP degree initially.

I think my point is that for some people being a young parent is no bad thing. But for others it would not be the right choice.

Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 17:44

You should tell her that😂😂. You are just better than her😂

Imapotato · 03/01/2021 17:42

So just to make it clear I would support my dds with any path they chose. It’s they’re lives, but I don’t think that being a teen parent is necessarily a worse path, IF it’s a path they are happy with and they are prepared for what they are getting themselves into. Most of my fellow young parent friends and I are now qualified/qualifying in our chosen fields and have given our children a good standard of living.

Despite our different paths dsis and myself are likely to be at the same point in our careers by our mid 40s. Dsis will have been qualified for more years, but I am likely to progress quicker once qualified as I already have many years of experience in my work place (as an unqualified, but trusted and well respected member of staff) where as dsis will be starting from scratch.

Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 17:39

I suppose I meant there was an implied criticism of your sister, because you had kids and a house you were better than her, But as you say you have very different life paths.

but do the comparison when you are both thirty - you still won’t have started your qualification and she will be moving up the career ladder.

In any case, we aren’t really arguing because I was imp,y making the point that university In the main offers better employment OutcomeS and earning Potential. You clearly agree.

UpI have been arguing about pregnancy at 17 not being an ideal oth - you were an adult.

Imapotato · 03/01/2021 17:33

Your sister is still very young - it doesn’t seem a fair comparator?

I was comparing us age for age, so seems fair to me.

Will you advise your children to have children while they are under 18, and put if university based on your and your sisters experience?

In a word, no. I think succeeding as a teen mum has a lot to do with personality, probably more than level of support. I had very little support, but I am the sort who just gets on with things, I’m not really phased by much. I believe one of my dds would actually be fine as a teen mum, she is very much like me, the other (the more academic of the two) I don’t think Would do so well. So while I wouldn’t actively encourage it, I would be pretty unconcerned if dd2 announced she was pregnant as a teen, she would cope, just roll with it and I’m sure do an amazing job. I would be more concerned about dd1, she has a plan for life and would be devastated. I actually don’t think she would choose to keep it, and I would support her with whatever she wanted.

Also I was 19 and 22 having my dds, I left home at 17 and I didn’t feel too young. I know it doesn’t work out so well for everyone. But from mine and many of my friends experiences, we can do just as good a job of bringing up our kids as older parents and have never needed to be ‘supported’ in the way many people imagine young mums needing support.

TeaEgg · 03/01/2021 17:26

But that's better info in a thread like this, surely. Real people tales. Not statistics from a book.

That is the kind of nonsensical statement I would hope that the first year of a university degree in many subjects would disabuse you of, quite apart from any other value it might have.

Anecdotes on an anonymous internet forum where we could all be inventing tales of teenage mothers we know who ended up heading the Sunday Times Rich List really don't trump huge amounts of peer-reviewed research on adverse health, educational and social outcomes for teenage mothers.

woodhill · 03/01/2021 17:15

I think the cost of buying housing has become more unobtainable for most young people with dc or not

Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 17:12

The fact that there is so little research available on the impact on boys would suggest the impact is marginal. However if you have evidence to the contrary I would honestly be really interested. It would be refreshing to see the trend has changed.

Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 17:10

Okay - my statement that boys are in the main not impacted By teenage pregnancy. Not anecdotal, I have read research on this But it was a number of years ago so will need to find it.

But if I remember correctly it was comparing the number of under 18 year olds who drop out of full time education beciase they become parents. I think there were so few males it wasn’t statistically significant.

It may have been American, and is probably a decade or more out of date, but I don’t think the trend will have changed significantly over the years and across the ocean.

But I will see if I can find the article online.

Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 17:04

@Imapotato

My much younger dsis 22, has just applied for a masters to train in an AHP profession, as she has realised she will struggle to get a job with her current degree. She is still living between uni residence and our parents house. She has a partner, but he’s just finished uni and is struggling to find work.

At 22 I had 2 kids and owned my own home. I hadn’t been to uni, but we worked hard and my kids have had a nice life. Now in my mid 30s I’m am doing a degree apprenticeship (So still getting paid my usual wage) to become qualified in an AHP profession with very similar earning potential as the profession my sister is training for.

If my sister wants kids she’ll have them mid career (as the child of older parents she doesn’t want to be one herself). My kids are in their teens. At 45 it’s pretty likely we’ll be earning the same.

So which path is better? She may have more freedom in her youth, but she won’t be able to live it up too much if she wants to save for a house deposit. By the time I’m 40, my kids will be adults, so I’ll be able to please myself.

Will you advise your children to have children while they are under 18, and put if university based on your and your sisters experience?

Your sister is still very young - it doesn’t seem a fair comparator?

I am not saying everyone should go to university, it’s not right for everyone. I am saying pretending. It leads to unemployment and an inability to own a house is just wrong.

I am also not saying that having kids in your twenties is a bad idea, and I am saying having children when you are under 18 should be avoided If possible.

It happens of course it does and those girls should be supported.

Wheresmykimchi · 03/01/2021 17:01

@Ideasplease322

People will always cite the person they know who has succeeded. And of course lots of people go on to have happy, successful lives. It’s not he end of the world by any stretch.

But if teenage (and I mean under 18) pregnancy was such a good Thing, why would so many resources be dedicated to reducing it around the world?

But that's better info in a thread like this, surely. Real people tales. Not statistics from a book.

We aren't saying it's a good thing. We are attempting to bring balance which was made uneven by the 'devastated and mortified' brisgade.

Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 17:00

People will always cite the person they know who has succeeded. And of course lots of people go on to have happy, successful lives. It’s not he end of the world by any stretch.

But if teenage (and I mean under 18) pregnancy was such a good Thing, why would so many resources be dedicated to reducing it around the world?

Wheresmykimchi · 03/01/2021 16:59

@Ideasplease322

Oh come on now, there are decades of research of the impact of teenage pregnancy on educational outcomes and school dropout.

Are you serious? Do you think this topic hasn’t been researched? The majority of the i,sect is on the teen mothers.

I'm talking about boys getting off 'scot free'.
Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 16:57

Oh come on now, there are decades of research of the impact of teenage pregnancy on educational outcomes and school dropout.

Are you serious? Do you think this topic hasn’t been researched? The majority of the i,sect is on the teen mothers.

Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 16:53

But i do of course think young parents should be supported, and as a society we should do all we can to ensure they have as many options and opportunities as possible.

Because No matter how much we educate kids about birth control accidents will always happen. It shouldn’t be the end of the world.

Wheresmykimchi · 03/01/2021 16:53

@Ideasplease322

Better career outcomes in terms of chances of finding employment and tryout earning potential when in employment.

All averages of course, and there will be exceptions to those averages.

I haven’t used any anecdotal evidence and I am not ant teenage mums.

I do think it is something that should be avoided, and that girls should be educated about birth control to reduce the likelihood of accidental pregnancy. I think having a Baby at 17 makes life more difficult for girls While he dads largely get off Scott free.

And I think education And/or training opens more doors And provides more options for young people.

I Know university isn’t the right path for everyone, but it doesn’t make it more likely that you will be unemployed.

' And I think education And/or training opens more doors And provides more options for young people.' but I didn't say that?

'I do think it is something that should be avoided, and that girls should be educated about birth control to reduce the likelihood of accidental pregnancy. I think having a Baby at 17 makes life more difficult for girls While he dads largely get off Scott free.' that is anecdotal.

Imapotato · 03/01/2021 16:52

My much younger dsis 22, has just applied for a masters to train in an AHP profession, as she has realised she will struggle to get a job with her current degree. She is still living between uni residence and our parents house. She has a partner, but he’s just finished uni and is struggling to find work.

At 22 I had 2 kids and owned my own home. I hadn’t been to uni, but we worked hard and my kids have had a nice life. Now in my mid 30s I’m am doing a degree apprenticeship (So still getting paid my usual wage) to become qualified in an AHP profession with very similar earning potential as the profession my sister is training for.

If my sister wants kids she’ll have them mid career (as the child of older parents she doesn’t want to be one herself). My kids are in their teens. At 45 it’s pretty likely we’ll be earning the same.

So which path is better? She may have more freedom in her youth, but she won’t be able to live it up too much if she wants to save for a house deposit. By the time I’m 40, my kids will be adults, so I’ll be able to please myself.

Ideasplease322 · 03/01/2021 16:51

Better career outcomes in terms of chances of finding employment and tryout earning potential when in employment.

All averages of course, and there will be exceptions to those averages.

I haven’t used any anecdotal evidence and I am not ant teenage mums.

I do think it is something that should be avoided, and that girls should be educated about birth control to reduce the likelihood of accidental pregnancy. I think having a Baby at 17 makes life more difficult for girls While he dads largely get off Scott free.

And I think education And/or training opens more doors And provides more options for young people.

I Know university isn’t the right path for everyone, but it doesn’t make it more likely that you will be unemployed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread