Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's OK to be a teen mum?

712 replies

veganmegan · 30/12/2020 21:51

NC. I rarely start threads on here but I have a question (hope that's OK). My little sister is seventeen and she welcomed into the world a lovely little boy in November. Since announcing his birth on social media, she received a handful of messages from former "friends" Hmm saying "Always knew you were a slag, you'll never get a proper job now, do you even know who the father is" (or words to that effect).

So really fucking abusive bullying behaviour. They also said something about her now having to move to a council estate (?) and about "babies shouldn't have babies" (which I guarantee is just a direct quote from someone's judgemental parent).

They're also teenagers so I'm not necessarily holding it entirely against them (as you say all sorts of silly stuff when you're young) but given they're pretty middle class kids who I don't think have even met someone from a council estate, or a teen mum other than my sis, I'm wondering where all of these preconceived stereotypes come from.

She's decided to block them now after my convincing so hopefully there won't be any more online bullying, but I'm wondering who thinks these things? Where does this idea come from? Is this an idea you instil in your own kids, if you're a parent?

I just really feel for her if I'm honest. She's so happy to have her wee baby, but people continuously perceive her as a "slag" solely because she had a baby young. I don't even really know how to support her, just really pisses me off and simultaneously upsets me on her behalf.

OP posts:
YouBoughtMeAWall · 31/12/2020 00:52

I don't want to fund through taxes other people having children before they have contributed a penny or anything else to society.

Then don’t. Move to somewhere where they don’t support people when they fall on hard times or need a bit of a safety net.

The amount of UC available to support these families is very high.

That’s because the cost of living is very high. If the government hadn’t sold off all their council properties and failed to replace them then people wouldn’t be stuck paying extortionate rent to private landlords. You clearly haven’t a clue what you’re talking about. so yeah, you can shut up.

Heartlantern2 · 31/12/2020 00:51

That’s starting to not be the case actually! Teenage pregnancy, even in the poorer/ lower class? (Sorry I don’t know what we used to be called) have had a a huge reduction in teenage pregnancies...and continues to drop.....wonder why that is? Maybe because times are very different now.

Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 00:50

@spongedog

I know women who worked from 16-23/4, then got married and had children and never worked again in their lives.

I also know women who had children at 16 then started work again at 23/4 and worked for years and still are, or went back to uni and trained as teachers/doctors.

Your point?

Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 00:48

@TheOneLeggedJockey

Isn't that because, if we want to go down the stereotype route, most "middle class" people have more support and education?

You just have to read through threads on here to see the torment grown women still go through at not going through with the pregnancy.

I'm not quite convinced that many "decide" to be a teen Mum. But I know many who pulled their socks up, got on with it and went on to be fantastic parents.

I think in some ways that says more about your "lower class" girls tha you'd let on.

TheOneLeggedJockey · 31/12/2020 00:46

@veganmegan

Bringing rape into the equation is bizarre. Nowhere has it been mentioned as a factor when asking your 'questions'. Except towards me as a way to be antagonistic.

No, there was a discussion of rape and sexual assault of teenage girls on previous pages - especially how they are still considered "slags" even if they didn't voluntarily consent to sex. You can ignore the mentions of rape if you'd like to, but no amount of having smart / responsible children can protect them from that (though I genuinely wish it could). It's not "bizarre", it's a genuine risk factor for teen pregnancy.

Contraception is accessible to MY children who have been taught that it is not optional if you choose to have sex as a teen, it is the responsible choice.

I am very glad that you make contraception accessible to your teens. Unfortunately, no contraception (that I know of) is 100% effective and so there is still a risk of pregnancy.

But even if you do get accidentally pregnant, you absolutely, categorically do not have to go ahead with the pregnancy. Many (all?) of your posts seem to be pointedly ignoring this.

I think there is definitely somewhat of a class issue at play (and I’m not British, just FYI). I tend to think educated, yes, middle class girls (because teens are girls) generally won’t decide to go on to be a teen Mum.

spongedog · 31/12/2020 00:45

@YouBoughtMeAWall

Well isn’t that just fine and dandy that we are funding all this via UC.

Oh do shut up.

No you shut up. Don't be so rude if someone else has an opinion different to yours. Perhaps read and learn?

I don't want to fund through taxes other people having children before they have contributed a penny or anything else to society. The amount of UC available to support these families is very high. A good friend of mine found herself in the same position as OP's sister. Her DC (under age 20) get over £1000 pcm paid for rent through UC. Whereas their peer group at uni are expected to pay £000's in rent to private landlords through loans. There is no rush to have children and we really do need to keep educating teenagers about contraception.

So to answer OP - no I dont think it is really OK for teenagers to have children, but what is really not OK is for your DN to be called names. That is bullying. i do wonder if it was male or female "former" friends?

AlexaShutUp · 31/12/2020 00:41

Well, I voted YANBU because the abuse that your dsis has been subjected to is awful, and she certainly should not be called a slag or any other term of abuse just because she has a child at a young age.

Having said that, I don't agree that it's really "ok" to have a child in your teens, and personally, I would feel like a failure as a parent if this happened to my daughter. I absolutely don't think teen mums should be condemned, but I do pity them enormously. I don't think it's ever desirable to have children at such a young age, for either the parent or the child, even though I'm sure there are some young mums who do an amazing job of parenting.

I wouldn't express this view in real life, but you did ask the question so I am sharing my honest opinion.

Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 00:38

@Heartlantern2

Don’t apologise, I didn’t take it as you was being smarmy at all.

I was just continuing the discussion and answering the question. Hope the question didn’t come across rude? Which then made you think I was retaliating? As it was not at all.

I do sometimes wonder if I write aggressively? I just write how I speak, but I do speak in a very slow tone. That clearly doesn’t come across though! 🤦🏼‍♀️

No, not at all. I just read it back and thought I sounded rude!
SenorFrog · 31/12/2020 00:37

My mum was pg and got married at 17, she had my sister at 18. She got comments about being too young, being ruined and not having a clue about looking after babies properly. My sister is 58 now and my parents have been married 60 years next year. I was 34 when I had my first and 38 my second. If I'm half as good a mum as she is I'll be bloody proud.

That said, I would never chose being a teen parent for my own dc, it can wait.

elkiedee · 31/12/2020 00:36

Both my aunts were teenage mothers, my mum didn't have me until she was 25. My aunts both married the fathers - one of them split after a few years and 3 kids, the other is still with her husband 57 years later! Their DS1's partner also became a teen mum, though their DS1 (also my cousin) was in his mid 20s.

The comments are horrible.

As for council estates, I wish more teenage mothers and other families had a prospect of getting a secure home where they can bring up kids, and not be ripped off by an extortionate private rent.. Much better if the young mum (and dad if he's around) can go back to work and earn a wage that will actually cover rent and all the necessaries for the family. Better than living in overpriced and insecure private accommodation. I have a friend I really worried about for several years, but she's now had a chance to move out of London and remake her life. The pandemic is quite scary for her as she has serious health issues after years of very poor housing as a teenager and in her early 20s, but at least she and her family now have a bit more space to shield in.

I'm very conscious that I'm lucky to have my own home with a small mortgage by London standards, and to have family who could help me etc, but a lot of families here would be thrilled to have a chance of council or housing association accommodation.

Heartlantern2 · 31/12/2020 00:34

Don’t apologise, I didn’t take it as you was being smarmy at all.

I was just continuing the discussion and answering the question. Hope the question didn’t come across rude? Which then made you think I was retaliating? As it was not at all.

I do sometimes wonder if I write aggressively? I just write how I speak, but I do speak in a very slow tone. That clearly doesn’t come across though! 🤦🏼‍♀️

Xmassprout · 31/12/2020 00:33

They must be a bit dense to equate a teenage pregnancy with being a slag. You can conceive a baby through having sex just the once. That aside, I very much dislike the term slag.

I personally wouldn't have made a good mother as a teen. I'm a very different person now to what I was then. I also think the odds are stacked against you more being a teen mother. Saying that, that doesn't mean you can't be an excellent mother and provide an excellent life for a child. Becoming a mother when you're older doesn't automatically make you a better mother. Plenty of excellent teenage mums out there.

I would prefer my girls not to have babies that young. Purely because having children can have a huge impact on your career even if you're well established in your career. So it would be even harder if just starting out, or if still in education again its just harder. Plenty of people make it work though

Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 00:31

@Heartlantern2

I know the difference is

1, (I’m in the south east actually so don’t know if this is just here or country wide?) There are NO councils houses available...you will be out in emergency accommodation, which is a room in a building with a shared kitchen and there you will be for YEARS whilst you wait for a council house/flat to become available to you- there is just not enough council houses anymore!

2, benefits are so low nowadays. You used to be able to live off them pretty ok, but nowadays it’s hardly enough.

3, when the child is 5, you have to return to work- back in the ‘old days’ you didn’t. So now everyone needs a term time 10-3 job...so now there is a huge shortage and a job with those hours is like finding hens teeth.

4, Education, like courses and universities have to now be paid for.

5, cost of food, gas, electric has gone up compared to the 80’s whilst benefits have gone down

6, insurance costs for teenagers is a joke- they have no chance of buying a car and paying for that if they also have to support a baby.

It’s just so different now- it’s so much harder!!

Sorry Heart I wasn't being smarmy - I was genuinely asking. This is interesting reading .
Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 00:30

@CJsGoldfish

It's part of being responsible to not get raped? Also contraception is not easily accessible to everyone FWIW Bringing rape into the equation is bizarre. Nowhere has it been mentioned as a factor when asking your 'questions'. Except towards me as a way to be antagonistic. Not playing that game. Contraception is accessible to MY children who have been taught that it is not optional if you choose to have sex as a teen, it is the responsible choice. Not an 'accidental' pregnancy if one chooses not to use contraception and hardly a mature and grown up decision 🤷‍♀️
You're dodging the point here. Regardless of YOUR children, PP was pointing out that pregnancies can happen by accident - then what?

PS Contraception does fail. Seen that happen too.

veganmegan · 31/12/2020 00:28

And FWIW I'm appreciative of you answering the questions, but I'm still happy to disagree with your answers.

OP posts:
Fungster · 31/12/2020 00:27

@Heartlantern2

I’ve obviously not worded my post correctly. Firstly I have no intention of insulting or offending anyone.

My mum had me at a very young age- just to get a council house, so yes, my view or opinion probably is skewed on this subject.

However, I believe it was ok back then to be a teenage mum as there was so much help. You got a council place and benefits used to be a lot higher. Being a teenage parent now a days though is a completely different ball game and they will not fare as well as all the people on this post saying they was a teenage mum and did alright for themselves back in the 80’s or 90’s. Teenage mums now a days have it so so much more harder.

It’s practically foolish now- you get such little help, and if you don’t have family propping you up then it’s in no way going to get better for you, as the opportunities are not there like how they used to be for past teenage parents.

I completely agree. My parents got a council flat right away and the desire to "get out of the house" (their parent's) was definitely a factor. They simply would not get anywhere near that level of support were they to be teenagers in 21st century Britain. And they have done comparatively "well" all things considering - but if they had been 30 years younger I'd bet my mortgage that they'd have found life immeasurably harder.

What particularly saddens me is seeing how much that pattern has repeated itself. Of my mums siblings, they all had kids as teenagers. Those children - my cousins - by and large did the same. As did their children. One of my cousins became a grandmother at age 38.

That lost potential - because despite the tales of these superhuman teenage parents who now have mortgage free London properties at the age of 28, or scaled the heady heights of City finance with a buggy in tow, the chances of that kind of success is vanishingly small - makes me want to weep. One of my cousins in particular, was as smart as a whip and could have done anything with her life. Instead she's just moved from one "crappy" (her words) rental flat to another, working her minimum wage job to survive.

veganmegan · 31/12/2020 00:26

Bringing rape into the equation is bizarre. Nowhere has it been mentioned as a factor when asking your 'questions'. Except towards me as a way to be antagonistic.

No, there was a discussion of rape and sexual assault of teenage girls on previous pages - especially how they are still considered "slags" even if they didn't voluntarily consent to sex. You can ignore the mentions of rape if you'd like to, but no amount of having smart / responsible children can protect them from that (though I genuinely wish it could). It's not "bizarre", it's a genuine risk factor for teen pregnancy.

Contraception is accessible to MY children who have been taught that it is not optional if you choose to have sex as a teen, it is the responsible choice.

I am very glad that you make contraception accessible to your teens. Unfortunately, no contraception (that I know of) is 100% effective and so there is still a risk of pregnancy.

OP posts:
WhatTiggersDoBest · 31/12/2020 00:24

I don't see the problem with it and if my kid got pregnant as a teen, I would support her completely just like my grandma did. Age of consent is 16 and people seem to forget the biological purpose of sex is to have babies. No other species in the world gets so precious about when to have babies and no other species uses contraception.
People always seem to need someone to stigmatize. It used to be unmarried mothers. Nowadays they've revised the words they use but not the sentiment, and they hate on teen mothers. Because people assume they're not married (or in a long term relationship).
People go on about how you can't travel in your twenties if you're looking after a baby. But no one ever says that to people who are doing a PhD through their twenties. And you can totally travel with kids.
I never travelled until I was married and in my thirties, because I couldn't afford to, so I'm a little sceptical of all this "young free and single" "you'll lose your freedom if you get pregnant" crap because it only applies to people who got dealt the right cards e.g. parental support.
Congratulations and good luck to your DSis, OP, I'm sure she's going to do amazing things in life especially with such a supportive sister at her side.

Heartlantern2 · 31/12/2020 00:23

I know the difference is

1, (I’m in the south east actually so don’t know if this is just here or country wide?) There are NO councils houses available...you will be out in emergency accommodation, which is a room in a building with a shared kitchen and there you will be for YEARS whilst you wait for a council house/flat to become available to you- there is just not enough council houses anymore!

2, benefits are so low nowadays. You used to be able to live off them pretty ok, but nowadays it’s hardly enough.

3, when the child is 5, you have to return to work- back in the ‘old days’ you didn’t. So now everyone needs a term time 10-3 job...so now there is a huge shortage and a job with those hours is like finding hens teeth.

4, Education, like courses and universities have to now be paid for.

5, cost of food, gas, electric has gone up compared to the 80’s whilst benefits have gone down

6, insurance costs for teenagers is a joke- they have no chance of buying a car and paying for that if they also have to support a baby.

It’s just so different now- it’s so much harder!!

CJsGoldfish · 31/12/2020 00:22

It's part of being responsible to not get raped?
Also contraception is not easily accessible to everyone FWIW
Bringing rape into the equation is bizarre. Nowhere has it been mentioned as a factor when asking your 'questions'. Except towards me as a way to be antagonistic. Not playing that game.
Contraception is accessible to MY children who have been taught that it is not optional if you choose to have sex as a teen, it is the responsible choice. Not an 'accidental' pregnancy if one chooses not to use contraception and hardly a mature and grown up decision 🤷‍♀️

veganmegan · 31/12/2020 00:22

You put what I meant much more succinctly than I did, @Wheresmykimchi ☺ I agree with you.

OP posts:
Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 00:20

There is a difference between not what you'd choose for your child and not OK though.

My mother would like to see me married with 2 children to a lawyer and living in a city in a posh house and doing something different to the job I do now, but my life is certainly OK.

As is being a mother, and I think to say that being a mum in your teens "isnt OK" is offensive, personally. It might be not what you'd choose, or encourage in fact, and I get that, but that's different.

gospelsinger · 31/12/2020 00:17

I remember my young teen DD seeing a family friend of about 16 with her DD. It worried me that she thought this was a lovely idea, having a baby when you were living at home with your parents. Of course I didn't tell DD that it was wrong or shameful, but I did try and explain the difficulties that came with having a baby so young and that it is better to wait until you are in a stable relationship with someone you believe will make a good father.

Icantrememebrtheartist · 31/12/2020 00:16

It also works the other way too.

I was 45 when I had my third and there was a woman of 26 having her third, had her first in her teens and she was very loudly chatting to another young mum about how she’s judged for having three so young, she then went on to say she thinks it’s disgusting that women over 40 are having kids, they’re too old etc etc... I sat there thinking the irony!

Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 00:15

Surely though it depends on your relationship?

Have a shifty through the threads on here about women in their 30s in horrendous relationships with kids.

I know men and women who had kids at 17, 18, 19 ten years ago who are going as strong as ever.

Heart - what do you think the difference is now from then?