Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's OK to be a teen mum?

712 replies

veganmegan · 30/12/2020 21:51

NC. I rarely start threads on here but I have a question (hope that's OK). My little sister is seventeen and she welcomed into the world a lovely little boy in November. Since announcing his birth on social media, she received a handful of messages from former "friends" Hmm saying "Always knew you were a slag, you'll never get a proper job now, do you even know who the father is" (or words to that effect).

So really fucking abusive bullying behaviour. They also said something about her now having to move to a council estate (?) and about "babies shouldn't have babies" (which I guarantee is just a direct quote from someone's judgemental parent).

They're also teenagers so I'm not necessarily holding it entirely against them (as you say all sorts of silly stuff when you're young) but given they're pretty middle class kids who I don't think have even met someone from a council estate, or a teen mum other than my sis, I'm wondering where all of these preconceived stereotypes come from.

She's decided to block them now after my convincing so hopefully there won't be any more online bullying, but I'm wondering who thinks these things? Where does this idea come from? Is this an idea you instil in your own kids, if you're a parent?

I just really feel for her if I'm honest. She's so happy to have her wee baby, but people continuously perceive her as a "slag" solely because she had a baby young. I don't even really know how to support her, just really pisses me off and simultaneously upsets me on her behalf.

OP posts:
lalafafa · 31/12/2020 01:40

Disgusting they’re calling her a slut. I can’t imagine any of my daughters teen friends having babies, you’re starting life on a back foot. Those posters who are saying they’re doing well now after a teen pregnancy are in the minority,

Nancydrawn · 31/12/2020 01:35

@ciderfromalemon

I imagine a lot of those statistics are also tied up in social background and other factors rather than being solely down to age? A lot of the people I know who became teen parents were from poorer/deprived backgrounds already, less value on education etc.
Of course. And there are many exceptions to the rule, as indicated by the very happy anecdotes on this thread. That said, it creates serious structural problems and requires remarkable resources (be they personal, financial, or familial) in order to overcome them.

I have huge respect for those who have made this situation work. But the reality is that is is a struggle for many.

HeyMister · 31/12/2020 01:34

My sister was 15 when she had her first, she got a lot of shit for it as well (as did us siblings - I was once spat on) but she was the most amazing teen mum ever. You could not fault her.

Teen mums will always get shit thrown at them, sadly its just one of those things. As long as she's a good mum.. she gets the last laugh..

FlyNow · 31/12/2020 01:28

I think you are putting together two unrelated ideas OP.

  1. is teen pregnancy a good idea and 2) should you bully people online. The first question is irrelevant, the issue here is that people are bullying your sister online. They could have chosen any reason to do it. Society's attitudes towards teen mums being different wouldn't have stopped them, they would have just chosen another topic like looks, made up rumours, intelligence, anything.
ciderfromalemon · 31/12/2020 01:25

I imagine a lot of those statistics are also tied up in social background and other factors rather than being solely down to age? A lot of the people I know who became teen parents were from poorer/deprived backgrounds already, less value on education etc.

notanadultyadult · 31/12/2020 01:19

As a teen mum myself (I had my dd at nearly 18, she's 18 herself now) it's disappointing to read so many of the negative views on this post. I thought the world had moved on from stigmatising young mums in this way. Some of the comments and stereotypes would be seen as unacceptable if they referred to someone older, with everyone saying no one deserves an opinion on the pregnancy other than the pregnant woman herself.

The comments from her so called friends out-stands me and by going no contact with them I don't think she would be loosing out on anything. As others have said interesting the dad hasn't experienced the same.

For those saying you would be mortified or heartbroken and from the way some posts have come across, even ashamed, all I can say is, I would have those feelings towards you if you were my mum. It implies the pregnancy is some sort of failure in life, which it's not. Life doesn't always go as we planned. I do however understand being concerned for your dd being a young mum, or your ds a young dad, as it means they can face some obstacles, but becoming a parent is challenging at any age. Any decent parent worries about their child's happiness and future.

However older mums don't have it plain sailing either and can face just as challenging times such as infertility, relationship breakdowns, pnd or mh issues or financial hardship etc when it comes to having children, the list is endless.

Just because you are a certain age doesn't lead to being a better parent or having a less challenging time or being better equipped to deal with a dc.

I feel there are benefits to being a younger parent just as there are to being older. There isn't a right way or a wrong way, just a different way.

Would I change things? No. I've got a beautiful, intelligent daughter who is doing so well, who I have the closest relationship with. I have all the 'normal' expectations in life - lovely family and friends, good education, always worked and a decent job, car, own home and a long term relationship and both dd and I are very happy with our lot!

Cherrysoup · 31/12/2020 01:18

How does it make someone a slut?? Bizarre.

IMO, which I accept isn’t going to be everyone’s opinion, I think being a teen is too young. I’d rather wait, live life a bit first, explore options. I’d be worried that a young girl been coerced into sex, which is probably naive of me, I’m sure some teen mums were desperate for a baby, in fact, I’ve known a couple over the years who did just desperately want to be mums, maybe not for the right reasons, but hey, each to their own.

A big worry, bar a possible lack of emotional maturity, would be how the teen is going to provide for the baby, both financially and practically.

Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 01:16

@Nancydrawn

Her friends are dicks.

However, "Research has shown that teenage pregnancy is associated with poorer outcomes for both young parents and their children. Teenage mothers are less likely to finish their education, are more likely to bring up their child alone and in poverty, and have a higher risk of mental health problems than older mothers. Infant mortality rates are 60% higher for babies born to teenage mothers. As children they have an increased risk of living in poverty and are more likely to have accidents and behavioural problems." (from Nuffield Trust)

and

"New analysis of the Millennium Cohort (MC) survey finds that teenage mothers were over three times more likely to be poor than mothers in their 30s, the odds of a low birth weight baby was 40 per cent higher for a teenage conception, teenage mothers were 50 per cent more likely to be depressed and 100 per cent less likely to breastfeed. We also know that teenage mothers are less likely to complete their education and more likely to be out of employment and to live in poverty. The children of teenage mothers are more likely to experience these disadvantages and twice as likely to become teenage parents in their turn." (from Joseph Rowntree Foundation)

Personally, I grew enormously from 16 to 26. It was a decade of real discovery, both of myself and of the world: travel, education, friends, love, etc. Missing that would have made me a far different person, and I suspect a far less happy one.

Conversely, my friend had children from 17-30 and has a degree , a business and a very happy marriage.

I am pushing the same milestone age with a chin of dickhead men and all the travelling in the world (which I did) didn't make me as happy as she is. I'd love her life.

Horses for courses.

donewithitalltodayandxmas · 31/12/2020 01:16

I will add I also know of several teen mums who have done very well for themselves but many of them have a supportive family around them and that helps
Your sister wants and obviously loves her baby and has a supportive family around her, so she needs to ignore other shallow minded people and just enjoy her little one

Heartlantern2 · 31/12/2020 01:13

100% less likely to breastfeed. 100%?? That can’t be right, surly?

Nancydrawn · 31/12/2020 01:12

Her friends are dicks.

However, "Research has shown that teenage pregnancy is associated with poorer outcomes for both young parents and their children. Teenage mothers are less likely to finish their education, are more likely to bring up their child alone and in poverty, and have a higher risk of mental health problems than older mothers. Infant mortality rates are 60% higher for babies born to teenage mothers. As children they have an increased risk of living in poverty and are more likely to have accidents and behavioural problems." (from Nuffield Trust)

and

"New analysis of the Millennium Cohort (MC) survey finds that teenage mothers were over three times more likely to be poor than mothers in their 30s, the odds of a low birth weight baby was 40 per cent higher for a teenage conception, teenage mothers were 50 per cent more likely to be depressed and 100 per cent less likely to breastfeed. We also know that teenage mothers are less likely to complete their education and more likely to be out of employment and to live in poverty. The children of teenage mothers are more likely to experience these disadvantages and twice as likely to become teenage parents in their turn." (from Joseph Rowntree Foundation)

Personally, I grew enormously from 16 to 26. It was a decade of real discovery, both of myself and of the world: travel, education, friends, love, etc. Missing that would have made me a far different person, and I suspect a far less happy one.

BiBabbles · 31/12/2020 01:09

That sounds really rough for her, I hope she finds more supportive people like you to counterbalance that.

I married at 18, had my honeymoon baby a month after turning 19, he's now a lovely teenager - couldn't be happier with him most of the time. I got a lot of shitty comments for a few years and I actually found people who knew I was married (particularly professionals, people in the baby group) were far nastier than random people who didn't know either way. A bit of immigrant hate was thrown in there to.

I teach my children that having a child under 20 is very risky in many ways. I took a major gamble, I knew part of it but not all of it when I rolled the dice. In most ways, it's come up great for me - great marriage, lovely kids, life younger me couldn't have dreamed of - but not so much when it came to my health - at that age, a lot is still being built up and if you tap into it so heavily with pregnancy, issues are more likely to happen. Some get away with it, some like me seem fine until the cracks show up later, and some pay the price right away. Lifetime disability is highest in under 20s as are maternal deaths, before getting into the social risks of isolation, the pressure a child puts on relationships, the higher risks to both mother and child if another partner comes on the scene (from studies I've seen, the idea of stepparents being more violent has mostly been debunked, but there is a higher risk if it's not really a consistent relationship - a fling which too many early studies condemning as proof of how bad stepparents are - or the stepparent is particularly young, under 25).

I teach my children that life requires balancing risks, responsibilities, and benefits. I have thought maybe things would have been better if I could magically shift them all a few years later, I would have been so much calmer in their younger years and maybe my health would be better, but then my younger children wouldn't remember their uncle or grandparents, so many other things would be different too. I accept the risk I've taken, but I want my children to know better before they consider taking them. I want them to have more options and know their options more than I did. I didn't, I fully admit young me mostly thought that seems better than where I've come from which it was and still 1000% is and took a chance that this couldn't be worse. I was right, but I know others that have been really, really wrong.

I teach them to respect others, and I also teach them - particularly my daughters - to push back against the idea that the proof of how worthy and loveable they are as a person is whether someone will fuck them or marry them. It's not true of all young mother, but way too many of us - including me - started young because we wanted to be loved, that love would fix something in us, and a relationship - intimate or parental - is evidence that someone loves us. The latter two aren't true and caring for a child makes figuring all that out harder. I wouldn't trade my kids and those experiences for anything, not even my youthful health back, but damn do I wish younger-me could have had people who taught and cared for me better, who gave me something other than that family image of adult happiness with those who said I'd never get it because of who I am. My children don't have that weight, but there are other social messages they get that cloud their options from time to time. I try to teach them to see beyond that as best they can, telling my teenagers who they are now is not who they're going to be in ten years and few know in their teens who they'll be later, but they're taking steps towards it one way or another.

Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 01:06

Sorry OP we have completely derailed.

In answer to your OP, they sound like horrors. I'll never understand calling someone a slag, full stop ever, but particularly only because they had a baby. She'll meet some nice friends in time.

Fizzydrinks123 · 31/12/2020 01:05

Pregnancy is really, really easy for some - and all the discussion around difficulties becoming pregnant - no one likes to mention how easy it is for some - it is almost a taboo subject as someone's feelings may be hurt.

Lots of women will take risks and do not fall pregnant and some never fall pregnant unless using IVF- for some, one momentary risk and they become pregnant.

I'd not judge someone for being "caught" and having to make a life changing decision at a young age, it is a reality for lots of women.

Heartlantern2 · 31/12/2020 01:03

The only people who disagree with a benefit system are those who have no idea what the real world is like...that or no empathy!

I worked from the age of 16. Mortgage at 18. Always worked, I enjoy it. At 24 shit hit the fan and through no fault of our own (partner was in a car crash) we fell on hard times and relied on benefits for 8 months. I never had any intention of being on benefits, but there we was. It was the worst 8 months of my life! Because I was claiming benefits....nope! The aftermath however was the crux!! Getting OFF benefits was a MASSIVE struggle!! It’s like they try and keep you on them!! Hmrc destroyed my soul for some time.

Age 33. COVID-19 hit- savings were gone after 5 months, decided to hit the breadline and struggle with 2 children, as long as I could feed them and keep the house warm I was NOT claiming benefits again!! I chose to go hungry instead, there is a reason it’s called the “benefit trap”

If you think 1k is enough and too much benefits...that shows you only know half the story- it’s not claiming them, it’s the stake they tie you too. They take away a chance at a better life.

donewithitalltodayandxmas · 31/12/2020 01:02

I think its fine t have a child at what ever age you want as long as you can support your child and not he relying on the state or family solely
I know if one you girl who had several children and a couple her wider family have to bring up solely as she couldn't cope ,
Motherhood is hard at any age and I wouldn't encourage my dc to have them that young as there is a whole world out there if things to do first but these things happen and I would of course support them

Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 01:01

@TheOneLeggedJockey

Sorry, no, I’m not ‘on the wind up’.

I am heading out though, so won’t be responding for a wee while.

Drudgery and misery? Life limiting?

These are people's children we are talking about.

TheOneLeggedJockey · 31/12/2020 01:01

Sorry, no, I’m not ‘on the wind up’.

I am heading out though, so won’t be responding for a wee while.

TheOneLeggedJockey · 31/12/2020 01:00

And I just want to acknowledge OP - some of these responses (including mine) are probably making you feel very defensive of your lovely sister, and for that I am genuinely sorry.

You have asked for opinions though, and so, you are getting them.

It’s an issue people feel very strongly about - from both sides, that is for sure.

Flowers
lakesidexmas · 31/12/2020 00:59

I absolutely wouldn't want my teenage daughter to give birth to and bring up the product of a rape.
It would seem abusive to me to suggest that she should even consider doing so.

I consider this to be a separate issue to teen pregnancies in general.

Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 00:58

@TheOneLeggedJockey

But I know many who pulled their socks up, got on with it and went on to be fantastic parents.

I think in some ways that says more about your "lower class" girls tha you'd let on.

Mmm, if you think drudgery, martyrdom and life limiting choices are something to admire.

That’s starting to not be the case actually! Teenage pregnancy, even in the poorer/ lower class? (Sorry I don’t know what we used to be called) have had a a huge reduction in teenage pregnancies...and continues to drop.....wonder why that is?

Probably because more and more girls are realising there is more to life.

Good for them, they’re the ones I admire.

You have got to be on the wind up. What a vile post.
TheOneLeggedJockey · 31/12/2020 00:57

But I know many who pulled their socks up, got on with it and went on to be fantastic parents.

I think in some ways that says more about your "lower class" girls tha you'd let on.

Mmm, if you think drudgery, martyrdom and life limiting choices are something to admire.

That’s starting to not be the case actually! Teenage pregnancy, even in the poorer/ lower class? (Sorry I don’t know what we used to be called) have had a a huge reduction in teenage pregnancies...and continues to drop.....wonder why that is?

Probably because more and more girls are realising there is more to life.

Good for them, they’re the ones I admire.

Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 00:56

@CJsGoldfish - Yes, fine, but you are still not acknowledging the OP's point about rape, oddly.

As for your point 2, I'm not touching that. I'm really not.

CJsGoldfish · 31/12/2020 00:55

You're dodging the point here. Regardless of YOUR children, PP was pointing out that pregnancies can happen by accident - then what?
No, I haven't dodged at all. There are very few 'accidents' when contraception is used correctly but, should a pregnancy occur, abortion is a valid, and mature, option. That's 'what' 🤷‍♀️

PS Contraception does fail. Seen that happen too
Genuine contraception failure is uncommon despite all the anecdotal evidence on MN.

Being pregnant, no matter how it happened, does not mean you have to have a baby and it's often the less selfish and more mature choice to not go ahead

Wheresmykimchi · 31/12/2020 00:54

@Heartlantern2

That’s starting to not be the case actually! Teenage pregnancy, even in the poorer/ lower class? (Sorry I don’t know what we used to be called) have had a a huge reduction in teenage pregnancies...and continues to drop.....wonder why that is? Maybe because times are very different now.
At a guess? Without derailing?

Other alternatives have far less of a stigma (and rightly so).