Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's OK to be a teen mum?

712 replies

veganmegan · 30/12/2020 21:51

NC. I rarely start threads on here but I have a question (hope that's OK). My little sister is seventeen and she welcomed into the world a lovely little boy in November. Since announcing his birth on social media, she received a handful of messages from former "friends" Hmm saying "Always knew you were a slag, you'll never get a proper job now, do you even know who the father is" (or words to that effect).

So really fucking abusive bullying behaviour. They also said something about her now having to move to a council estate (?) and about "babies shouldn't have babies" (which I guarantee is just a direct quote from someone's judgemental parent).

They're also teenagers so I'm not necessarily holding it entirely against them (as you say all sorts of silly stuff when you're young) but given they're pretty middle class kids who I don't think have even met someone from a council estate, or a teen mum other than my sis, I'm wondering where all of these preconceived stereotypes come from.

She's decided to block them now after my convincing so hopefully there won't be any more online bullying, but I'm wondering who thinks these things? Where does this idea come from? Is this an idea you instil in your own kids, if you're a parent?

I just really feel for her if I'm honest. She's so happy to have her wee baby, but people continuously perceive her as a "slag" solely because she had a baby young. I don't even really know how to support her, just really pisses me off and simultaneously upsets me on her behalf.

OP posts:
NYNY211 · 31/12/2020 11:59

@YouBoughtMeAWall

single mums are rife

Half of all marriages end in divorce. Higher rate for second marriages I believe, and for relationships that aren’t marriages. Having a child is a huge strain on a relationship and often is the catalyst for separation. So chances are If you have a child you’ll be a single parent at some point. That’s nothing to do with teenagers.

Yes. But perhaps you have finically security and CMS. These factors are less like at 17.
Liverbird77 · 31/12/2020 11:58

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

HibernatingTill2030 · 31/12/2020 11:57

Generations ago I think couples made it work and today it’s a lot more complex

Generations ago, martial rape was legal, domestic violence was hushed up, women were discriminated against in almost every walk of life and unmarried mothers were sent away in shame to quietly have their kids and have them adopted out. They didn't make it work, they were unable to split- practical and societal reasons.

YouBoughtMeAWall · 31/12/2020 11:57

single mums are rife

Half of all marriages end in divorce. Higher rate for second marriages I believe, and for relationships that aren’t marriages. Having a child is a huge strain on a relationship and often is the catalyst for separation. So chances are If you have a child you’ll be a single parent at some point. That’s nothing to do with teenagers.

NYNY211 · 31/12/2020 11:56

@Isthatitnow

Just because you know of one of 2 people who became teen mums doesn’t mean we should be encouraging this and making out it’s wonderful and an easy task

The OP was looking for support and reassurance that her sister would, more than likely, be OK. I am quite sure she understands that at 17, her sister will have her work cut out and may well need additional support she wouldn’t have needed at 25. Discussing the fact that there can be a positive outcome to teen parenting is not encouraging young people to get pregnant. There are plenty of 35 year olds who will struggle to have as positive an outcome to their child rearing as many teens.

My comment was in response to another posters comment and that wasn’t you. However I’m happy to listen to both sides... I’m not going to pretend to you though just to keep you sweet. No we are not a disease and that’s why I included myself because I didn’t want you to think it was a dig at single mums. Let’s not pretend though.

This isn’t a competition. Are you arguing being a young mum your putting yourself in a position where you are less likely to start studying and finish it.... have you not read my posts at all? I said my mother had me at 17. She was a good mother to us all (4). However she never studied and she wouldn’t want me or my sisters to have a child at 17 like her. Your kidding yourself.

The fact that someone is calling someone a slag at 17 on fb is very immature I’ve already commented on this at the start of the thread!

SnuggyBuggy · 31/12/2020 11:52

The statistics surrounding teenage mothers would be very different if teenage motherhood occurred at equal rates across different backgrounds and social groups.

TwilightSkies · 31/12/2020 11:46

Generations ago I think couples made it work and today it’s a lot more complex

Women weren’t allowed bank accounts or jobs and were trapped in horrible, abusive marriages.
They weren’t making a choice to ‘make it work’. There was no choice.

Isthatitnow · 31/12/2020 11:43

single mums are rife

Single mum is not catching. We are not a disease. And whilst I get we shouldn’t aspire to be single mums, it does not mean others can call us slags or condone us to council housing and minimum wage jobs.

I have single mum’d for over 12 years and heard it all. People can’t stand it when we do it well. It challenges the status quo and scares people. I have yet to have one person in those 12 years suggest my ex is anything other than An Amazing Man. He isn’t, not by a long shot, and it is time that we started to challenge the misogyny and bias that exists in our society around single parenting, poverty and parents.

Isthatitnow · 31/12/2020 11:37

Just because you know of one of 2 people who became teen mums doesn’t mean we should be encouraging this and making out it’s wonderful and an easy task

The OP was looking for support and reassurance that her sister would, more than likely, be OK. I am quite sure she understands that at 17, her sister will have her work cut out and may well need additional support she wouldn’t have needed at 25. Discussing the fact that there can be a positive outcome to teen parenting is not encouraging young people to get pregnant. There are plenty of 35 year olds who will struggle to have as positive an outcome to their child rearing as many teens.

NYNY211 · 31/12/2020 11:35

@Isthatitnow There’s pros and cons to both. Now single mums are rife and I say that as a single mum myself.... it’s just the norm now.

Todays society is disposable and everything is easily accessible.

NYNY211 · 31/12/2020 11:30

@CherryRoulade

No indeed you can’t compare 26 to 16/17. That’s why the “they used to have children younger argument falls a bit flat. They really didn’t. Even in 1930s only 20% had children under 20 years of age. Well over 60% were over 25 years old.

Teenage mothers are less likely to finish their education, are more likely to bring up their child alone and in poverty, and have a higher risk of mental health problems than older mothers. Infant mortality rates are 60% higher for babies born to teenage mothers. As children they have an increased risk of living in poverty and are more likely to have accidents and behavioural problems. So, no, it’s not a good idea and not OK.

Ahhh yes I see what you meant.

Yes I agree with you. I never suggested otherwise. I’m not sure why your going back 1953/1930s. None the less it’s true what your saying it isn’t ideal.

Isthatitnow · 31/12/2020 11:28

Generations ago I think couples made it work and today it’s a lot more complex

Generations ago, weddings were all but forced on young couples who got pregnant. Whilst I am sure many of those worked out just fine, the suggestion that in the past, people somehow worked harder at marriage is utter bollox. What actually happened in the past is that people lived in abusive relationships, with partners who were next to useless, refused to work, gambled or drunk family monies, slept with other people etc etc. The stigma of single parenting lead many, many women to remain in situations which today we consider untenable. Thankfully, changing attitudes and a welfare state now mean that people are not trapped in miserable and often dangerous situations all in the name of decency.

Please think twice before coming out with the ‘people used to work at their marriages’ shite. It might be your sister, cousin, friend or colleague in desperate need of some support to remove themselves from a difficult situation. Better single than dead.

RaspberryCoulis · 31/12/2020 11:27

Your sister's friends sound horrible and there is never any justification for that level of spite and nastiness.

However, becoming a parent at SUCH a young age, without completing your education, with no work experience behind you, no way of supporting the child, and very little chance of the relationship with the father being stable and long-lasting is a very, very poor choice and one I would be devastated if my own DD thought was a smart move.

Teenage mothers are far more likely to live in poverty. (Despite all the people who are no doubt on this thread saying that they had triplets at the age of 15 and went on to get a PhD from Oxford and a six figure salary in investment banking by the age of 22).

ciderfromalemon · 31/12/2020 11:26

@Member869894

Candlestick the depressing statistics about teenage.mums are about social.background, surely? I'm a single mum and the statistics on their children aren't great either but mine are all well, happy and balanced individuals. Having a baby as a teenager can be a delightful positive thing with the right support and background. Yes of course it has its challenges but it needn't be the end of the world and certainly not the heartbreaking disappointment that you would have it be.
Yes social background is definitely a huge factor. If you look at the minority of teenage mothers from middle-class and more advantaged backgrounds then those statistics won’t be accurate at all.
NYNY211 · 31/12/2020 11:25

@Oliversmumsarmy

I have known 3 people who had babies in their teens and all seem to be doing well.

If anything better than those who have waited till their mid 30s to conceive.

They had all completed their families by 25 and then have/had a clear 40 years of uninterrupted employment.
One went and did her degree and became a midwife, one started her own business and one climbed the corporate ladder starting at the bottom.

If I had my time again I think I would definitely look at having children in my teens. To me it makes more sense than waiting till you are in your 30s

I don’t know weather you are being serious or not with this post.

Just because you know of one of 2 people who became teen mums doesn’t mean we should be encouraging this and making out it’s wonderful and an easy task.

They’re many elements but a key observation I have noticed is background and your support network these things are usually needed especially to study something like midwifery or nursing. It’s long hours and you tend to have a lot of placements. Also you can’t work much so you would have little money as a student and being a teen mum to a baby.

I know of someone too who had a baby at 16 and she is now a high up social worker doing very well however I don’t think this is the case for the majority of teen mums tbh.

YouBoughtMeAWall · 31/12/2020 11:22

Actually I’ll edit that to say “there is a lot of missing out when you become a mum as a teen.” Becoming a teen dad didn’t affect my ex in the slightest Grin

YouBoughtMeAWall · 31/12/2020 11:20

There is a lot of missing out when you become a parent as a teen. Speaking as a teen mum.

Oliversmumsarmy · 31/12/2020 11:18

I don’t think at 17 there is any missing out. You can still do al of these things, you are just not maybe doing it in a certain order.

Whammyyammy · 31/12/2020 11:14

Don't think there is a right or wrong age to have children, more concerning having children when much older, as might not be fully able bodied to care for.

At young ages I'd have concerns about the finance side of things, and would feel that for me personally a 17 year old would be missing out on things their peers are doing, such as travel, education, career etc.

But if she's happy and can support and raise a child then good for her.

Her friends are twats

Oliversmumsarmy · 31/12/2020 11:06

I have known 3 people who had babies in their teens and all seem to be doing well.

If anything better than those who have waited till their mid 30s to conceive.

They had all completed their families by 25 and then have/had a clear 40 years of uninterrupted employment.
One went and did her degree and became a midwife, one started her own business and one climbed the corporate ladder starting at the bottom.

If I had my time again I think I would definitely look at having children in my teens. To me it makes more sense than waiting till you are in your 30s

Member869894 · 31/12/2020 10:57

Candlestick the depressing statistics about teenage.mums are about social.background, surely? I'm a single mum and the statistics on their children aren't great either but mine are all well, happy and balanced individuals. Having a baby as a teenager can be a delightful positive thing with the right support and background. Yes of course it has its challenges but it needn't be the end of the world and certainly not the heartbreaking disappointment that you would have it be.

Nonamesavail · 31/12/2020 10:50

@FluentlyExasperatedMadam

A month after my 16th birthday I became pregnant with my son. I'm now 33 and he is a lovely 16yr old young man who I'm proud to say is my son ❤
Exactly the same. From posts I read here I actually think I had a better time than some people.
BiBabbles · 31/12/2020 10:49

Not everyone has the luxury of being able to wait. Do we punish those who can't for their biology?

My great grandmother went through menopause at 25 and is said to have had what we now call POI, my grandmother had major fertility problems at the same age, it's really rare in my family for women to have biological children after 30. I was diagnosed with it at 28 (though 5 years later, it turned out to be a misdiagnosis which makes me curious about the rest of my family). There are a lot of adopted children among my aunt and female cousins.

Yes, it can add pressure to think of these things younger, especially if that's held up as the best you can do, but absolutely none of that, biologically or socially, makes it less risky for someone to go through pregnancy and parent as a teenager. There is no evidence that POI or any other reproductive disorder makes it safer to have a child as a teenager compared to the general population or that their biological development is going faster to compensate for the top of the fertility window being earlier than others. The body is still in development and pregnancy is a huge tax on it. Some get through great, but the higher risks - and those who get hurt by them - shouldn't be ignored whether or not a medical condition was involved just because the risks don't hurt everyone.

It's not punishment to recognize that it's much riskier even with atypical medical situations involved - biology isn't trying to punish us even if it feels that way and the pressure can have major consequences. I had a friend who had a similar medical and social to me and she died from pregnancy-related complications at barely 16. Her biology didn't punish her, her biology did all it could with a partially developed reproductive system and an overtaxed body. The only punishment I can see is from those who made it seem like a great and the only acceptable option.

I agree that abortion is a personal choice and should always be; however, all the evidence - physically and mentally - is that the costs are far far less for the vast majority compared to a pregnancy going to term, whatever the result of a pregnancy going to term is. While we cannot predict all outcomes, the two cannot really be compared when it comes to the risks involved and saying there are costs of both is disingenuous to the likely costs involved.

Look it's not ideal to have a baby as a teen. It's not ideal either in your 40s. But would you say it is not OK to have a baby in your 40s? No, because saying so is unhelpful judgement and prejudice. Well, same goes for teen mums.

I'd say having a child a in your 40s is riskier than in the late twenties, early thirties though it's not until the very late 40s that the risks become even close to being comparable to the teen years (over 45 is still less risky than under 20). People choose to take risks, the benefits may play our in their favour, recognizing there is a need to balance that isn't the same kind of value judgement as calling someone names or violence (I had both as a teen mother).

Risks aren't bad, some of the best things in life involve risk, but the research around the social circumstances that make teen pregnancy desirable to some shows more a society failing teenage girls in so many ways. All of us with great stories of it doesn't change that the most common contributing factors involve lack of resources, poor self image, and social pressure to either keep a pregnancy and/or for an idealized version of love that even when our relationships work, doesn't play out that way. We can't really compare that to 40somethings which generally involve life circumstances with no suitable relationship and/or career choices delaying the option.

altiara · 31/12/2020 10:43

@veganmegan
When I had my DC (although 14 years ago) there was a sign up in the GP surgery about support groups for young mums. Maybe she could check with her HV if there is something like this locally.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 31/12/2020 10:39

@Candlesticking how do you know that she needs financial support? A 17 year old can claim UC if they have a child.