Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Driving to a&e is quicker than an ambulance

85 replies

Pinkerbells · 30/12/2020 19:36

I had to call 999 for my DP yesterday. (For context, it was for a reoccurring condition, and last time he had the same symptoms, he was in hospital for a month, had 2 emergency ops and spent most of his time in icu.)
The ambulance came pretty quick with 3 crew members. They did the observations and decided that yes indeed he did need to go to hospital. The conundrum came in the fact that it would be quicker for me to drive him the 30 minutes to a&e than for him to go in an ambulance, as once they got him there, unless his condition worsened, they would have to sit with him in the ambulance for 3-4 hours waiting for him to be admitted. This would make 3 crew and an ambulance unavailable for this amount of time!

I drove him in and dropped him off, and he got seen in 20 minutes. Not 3 hours, or even 1 hour. 20 minutes!!!!! Xmas Shock

AIBU to be gobsmacked by the the whole situation, (apart from the 20 minutes, that was awesome). Don't get me wrong, I understand things have to be different because of covid, and I know the NHS are really really struggling. But surely there is a more efficient way of processing patients that frees everything up quicker than that

OP posts:
1990shopefulftm · 31/12/2020 05:38

I had bad chest pains once and rang 111 as I wasn't sure if I was overreacting and should speak to an out of hours GP or go to a&e.
I didn't have classic heart attack symptoms and had had a very short loss of consciousness, they wanted to send me an ambulance for a half mile journey so I got DH to drive me instead.

The triage nurse saw me almost straight away and quickly established it definitely wasn't a severe cardiac event, so I would question 111 again if they offered me an ambulance but many people wouldn't question 111s advice so I don't think it's always a patient's fault.
It turned out it was a very small rib fracture causing the pain so would have been a wasted ambulance trip.

maddening · 31/12/2020 05:21

It is ridiculous that the system requires the ambulance to sit in the a&e queue with the patient.

Shaniac · 31/12/2020 01:45

Agree op its shocking and i hate that you cant criticise without someone saying you should drive yourself. I needed an ambulance a year ago. I had a major hemmoridge and lost 5 pints of blood in 30 minutes. I was told i was high priority i waited way over an hour for it to show up (i live 10 minutes from the hospital). When they arrived they said they had to wait in the hospital until they had more ambulances so that paramedics could stay in the hospital. And yes people told me at the time i should have got a taxi. Confused

LoveMyKidsAndCats · 31/12/2020 01:40

With broken arms that needed operating on and painful crohns flare ups. Think I'd only call an ambulance if they were unconscious. My poor kids 🙈

LoveMyKidsAndCats · 31/12/2020 01:38

I would have drove him rather than call an ambulance out. I've taken my kids to a&e in the back of taxis a good few times.

lljkk · 30/12/2020 22:43

After about a 90 minute way, I was just starting to drive DH to hospital (50 minutes away by car) when ambulance arrived. He wanted to wait for ambulance because he was in agony & they had morphine. He basically ran for the ambulance when he saw it arriving. He had 3 types of painkiller in the ambulance before he got to hospital.

Said only the gas & air really touched the pain. Morphine & IV paracetamol no good.

Dislocated shoulder, btw.

knackersknockersknickers · 30/12/2020 22:39

Honestly - the more people who understand how desperately the nhs is struggling and needs an overhaul without is causing death or disability, the better.

Nhs is underfunded and drowning in bureaucracy. Most staff are trying their best in shitty situations.

FrankiesKnuckle · 30/12/2020 22:31

Make that about 80% and you'd be almost right.

cherrypie790 · 30/12/2020 22:25

DH took me in by car last time I had a flare up of a chronic condition..... GP always sends me in to have bloods/ECG done just in case. They've always seen me straightaway when I've said I have chest pain - never felt the need to call an ambulance, in fact because we're so rural we can be there by the time they've got out to us.

It makes me very angry watching the "Ambulance" show on BBC1 that people in London seem to treat it like calling a taxi. At least 50% of the calls seem complete wastes of time.

catinb00tz · 30/12/2020 22:21

*job

catinb00tz · 30/12/2020 22:21

I should have said earlier I wasn't criticising paramedics. I know they do an amazing jib. Just so overstretched.

dingoesatemybaby · 30/12/2020 22:16

YANBU.

It has happened to us before. When we called an ambulance for my DD, I went in with her and DH followed in the car. I say followed, he went a different way to avoid traffic and arrived 15 minutes before the ambulance. It wasn't blue lighted though to be fair.

vanillandhoney · 30/12/2020 22:15

It sounds like they were politely trying to tell you that you didn't need to have rung an ambulance in the first place.

Newpuppymummy · 30/12/2020 22:08

Almost always quicker to drive to A&E. I would only call an ambulance for risk of life situation if I could drive

superram · 30/12/2020 22:08

Maybe the ambulance crew thought you should have taken him-which you did, which proves you shouldn’t have phoned for it in the first place and people like you are the problem. Hth.

willstarttomorrow · 30/12/2020 22:07

I think the point off 999 and A&E is slightly misunderstood. Late DH had a heart condition. On the first occasion they saved his life, unfortunately on the second despite everything he died.
Many years ago I was a nurse working in A&E then specialised in Intensive Care and Accute Cardicac care. Ambulance to recovery room then theatre followed monitored care in acute situations is amazing in this country. Hopefully most people will not need that.

Gibble1 · 30/12/2020 22:05

I had to take DS to ED in September with an acute asthma attack. We live 15-20 minutes away from our local hospital. I knew that it could and most likely would take over an hour for an ambulance to arrive had I called one so I took the decision to drive him there myself as he was deteriorating fast.
I did have a bit of a panic on our way round to the entrance from the car park though (couple of hundred yards) as he was becoming more and more unwell and I knew that I would have to leave him to run and get help if it was required as he is simply too big for me to pick up and carry in now.
I was very lucky that he was able to make it round under his own steam and then sat on the bench while I rushed in to ask reception if I was able to bring him in without a mask on.
Anyway, they were amazing and he was treated within 5 minutes of being through the doors- including having a portable X-ray.
Had I called an ambulance and waited, he may have died while waiting, and would have certainly needed admission to ITU.
However, I made this calculated decision based on sound clinical knowledge, knowledge of the system, knowledge of our town and local traffic conditions, observation of his rapid deterioration and the knowledge that my colleagues would know it was urgent if I turned up with him- they recognised his name, looked out into the waiting room and saw us immediately.
Sometimes it is far quicker to drive yourself but it is also a big risk if it’s a life threatening emergency. God forbid it ever happens again I would probably ask a neighbour to take us so I could deal with him if he suddenly had a respiratory arrest.
God I’ve frightened myself again now.

thetemptationofchocolate · 30/12/2020 22:04

It would be quicker to drive I'm sure. I expect a friend of ours wishes he could have driven his wife into A&E when she'd had a stroke. Sadly she was unconscious and he couldn't get her down the stairs & into a car by himself. There was no ambulance available and they waited hours for help to come.

StopGo · 30/12/2020 22:02

I went to a hospital yesterday evening simply to drop off a requested item for my DM who is on a Covid ward.

The queue of ambulances was 20+ deep, they were outside A&E and in the general car park. There was a significant queue of people on the footpath outside A&E standing in the cold to find out if they were ill enough to even be seen.
I'm truly glad your DH got seen in a timely fashion but many more didn't.

Livingmybestlifenow · 30/12/2020 21:51

I imagine the difference is that if he walked into A&E and his condition was serious enough to warrant immediate monitoring and treatment triage would have picked that up and he would be a priority. Had he arrived by ambulance that care would be provided by the paramedics who have access to monitors, fluids, O2, defibrillator etc. so he would be considered in safe hands until they had time/space to deal with him. My younger brother spent 5+ hours in an ambulance doing exactly that outside Barnet hospital on Boxing Day suffering from Covid complications then was admitted into ICU.

Alternista · 30/12/2020 21:40

I dunno, if I lived that near and he was well enough to walk into a&e I just can’t imagine ever calling an ambulance over driving him in, not even in normal times, never mind now!

Once there he would have entered the same triage system as everyone else. The fact that he was seen within 20 minutes makes me think the crew just wanted you to take him so they could go onto another call tbh.

RedMarauder · 30/12/2020 21:38

I live 15 minutes walk away from an A&E so yes it is quicker for a neighbour to knock on my door or vice versa and get driven to there.

Yes you can end up taking the person to the wrong hospital as it isn't a major centre for particular conditions, but apparently my local hospital unlike a couple of others doesn't refuse to treat patients they will just transfer them as soon as they can.

QueenOfPain · 30/12/2020 21:37

@lyinginthegutterstaringatstars

Actually, you couldn’t be more wrong. Ambulance services have lots of different pathways and protocols to make sure that everyone isn’t just being dumped at A&E as a default. Including “on scene discharges” or speaking to the GP and dropping the patient there instead, calling the OOH GP and arranging for a prescription instead, and a new thing by some ambulance services is with elderly care home residents, is to call through to ED before leaving the care home, and speak to a Consultant to discuss the clinical history, PMH etc, the Consultant will the make a decision about whether the patient can come to ED or not, based on the likelihood of any meaningful treatment being offered.

HibernatingTill2030 · 30/12/2020 21:31

Surely if he was able to (I assume) walk in and sit in the waiting room to be seen (albeit quickly), then the ambulance wouldn't have needed to wait so long to get him in? I was under the impression that the ambulance crew take people into the waiting room if able/don't need a bed space.

Hope your DH is OK.

MushMonster · 30/12/2020 21:23

Unfortunatelly I do not think this is a new thing for ambulances, at this time of the year. Even pre-covid. They had ambulances waiting in mass outside the hospital and you could not get one to pick you up, when I broke my ankle in 2017 (my DH had to drive me there. My ankle was badly dislocated, that was why we called the ambulance, it was turning blue when we decided to risk the trip, and I had no pulse on it when we arrived). Another patient in my ward broke her hip in the bathroom. Elderly woman. On the bathroom floor in her house, she had to wait 5 hours for the ambulance. Third one had to walk in the snow with her daughter and little grandson with a broken and dislocated wrist. Again, no ambulance available. All this around Boxing Day. Apparently is the busiest time, they said.
We are running on very scarce resources on beds and ambulances on a normal day. You do not really realise this till you are in it, when you most need it.
I can imagine how covid has affected this.
You did the right thing and they adviced you right.
We do seriously need to through more resources into the NHS.
I hope he is doing well Flowers

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.