Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Driving to a&e is quicker than an ambulance

85 replies

Pinkerbells · 30/12/2020 19:36

I had to call 999 for my DP yesterday. (For context, it was for a reoccurring condition, and last time he had the same symptoms, he was in hospital for a month, had 2 emergency ops and spent most of his time in icu.)
The ambulance came pretty quick with 3 crew members. They did the observations and decided that yes indeed he did need to go to hospital. The conundrum came in the fact that it would be quicker for me to drive him the 30 minutes to a&e than for him to go in an ambulance, as once they got him there, unless his condition worsened, they would have to sit with him in the ambulance for 3-4 hours waiting for him to be admitted. This would make 3 crew and an ambulance unavailable for this amount of time!

I drove him in and dropped him off, and he got seen in 20 minutes. Not 3 hours, or even 1 hour. 20 minutes!!!!! Xmas Shock

AIBU to be gobsmacked by the the whole situation, (apart from the 20 minutes, that was awesome). Don't get me wrong, I understand things have to be different because of covid, and I know the NHS are really really struggling. But surely there is a more efficient way of processing patients that frees everything up quicker than that

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bunnyfuller · 29/12/2022 01:33

In 2019 a few weeks after a heart attack I went into unstable angina. En route to the hospital (I was ok to talk) the paramedic said I was the most serious call she had attended in about 6 months, and so many people misuse 999 and A and E.

Gronkle · 29/12/2022 01:09

Zombie thread Dec2920

lljkk · 29/12/2022 01:07

they would have to sit with him in the ambulance for 3-4 hours waiting for him to be admitted.

Faster to be seen if walk in than if ambulance arrival has been true for decades (2001 story), it's not just a 2022 thing that ambu-conveyed patients wait outside & the ambulance can't depart.

Jackonary · 29/12/2022 00:59

We drove a family member to hospital as he was ill but we didn’t realise how badly. I wish I had called an ambulance so he could have been assessed/moved more safely by trained professionals.

ILoveeCakes · 29/12/2022 00:33

I went to hospital the other week.

A woman came in with her husband and was banging on that they'd waited 4 hours for an ambulance then drove down.

I'm sure I wasn't the only one thinking that they perhaps should have driven down to begin with.

Wetblanket78 · 28/12/2022 23:44

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

crosstalk · 31/12/2020 16:54

Surely it depends on the circumstances and where you live? And also the time of day it happens, whether you have neighbours, family etc?

Covid has made it a great deal worse because even triage takes longer. Paramedics can't simply go back out again before deep cleaning and changing PPE. Every little thing takes longer.

In my previous neck of the woods you'd be lucky to find a taxi able to take you most of the time - most had contracts for school runs or shopping trips or parties, so you had to book them three days ahead. And that was a small market town in the South. No Uber even in large towns. and cities in the county.

If you live alone it's a problem only solved by an ambulance. If you live with someone and neither of you drive or don't drive well at night and you either don't know or can't contact your neighbours, ditto. If you live in a very rural spot you will possibly need an air ambulance though some can't fly at night.

Mia1415 · 31/12/2020 14:59

My DS has severe asthma and I've had to rush him to A&E over 30 times. I've always driven him as its the quickest way for him to get emergency treatment I've never even considered calling for an ambulance and he's always been seen immediately.

billy1966 · 31/12/2020 14:53

A few emergency situations with children over the years, never considered calling an ambulance as I was able to drive the child in question directly there and that was the quickest way to get them to medical care.

In all instances we were seen very quickly.

MatildaTheCat · 31/12/2020 13:56

My BIL had a heart attack recently. He called an Uber which arrived in 2 minutes and got him to hospital in 10 minutes. At the time I was a bit aghast because frankl, having a cardiac arrest in an Uber isn’t ideal. Now I guess it was a good decision.

And yes, he did know he was having an MI and made that judgement on that basis.

CJsGoldfish · 31/12/2020 13:49

They are always going to tell you "no, no, you did the right thing" whether calling was warranted or not. Or maybe I watch 'Ambulance' too often.

Calling an ambulance simply because you 'don't drive' is ridiculous.

Whammyyammy · 31/12/2020 11:48

Ambulances should only be used if an emergency, A woman I know has used ambulances 3 times for herself and daughter, as she cannot drive!!!
Her excuse is that she cannot afford a taxi and ambulances are free and that's what they are there for..... no wonder the NHS is on its knees

MothExterminator · 31/12/2020 11:35

I think that unless there is some massive holdup (like it may be now) that you will be seen at the “right time” as in when triage seems it necessary to be seen if you arrive in an ambulance.

Our family has “used” ambulances twice. Once when I collapsed due to heart issues and had a blood pressure of 60 over 40 or something like that. I have very vague recollections, but I was on a drip of something and very grateful to be there. I was then waiting in A&E for about an hour or two (whilst being checked on multiple times) before being admitted first to the A&E beds, then to the cardiac ward.

On one of the worst days of my life, my then 4 year old had a very bad fall, hit her head and vomited multiple times. The ambulance came quickly, blue lighted us to hospital and she was taken straight into the A&E where a whole paediatric team was waiting to assess her. Luckily she was fine (was admitted for two nights).

I think anyone trying to game the system is an idiot and depriving people who desperately need an ambulance of necessary medical attention.

lljkk · 31/12/2020 11:16

I have always thought that arrival by ambulance was more likely to delay onward treatment than accelerate it, for reasons Fallox gave. The myth that ambulance means faster entry to A&E is extremely widespread, though.

MothExterminator · 31/12/2020 08:29

I think there are way too many people who have absolutely no clue about what ambulances and the A&E are there for. I was in the A&E with DS and suspected appendicitis (he couldn’t stop screaming). Next to us was a family who had brought their son in as they were concerned that he was overweight. I believe they have changed the triage now and those cases are sent to a walk in centre a block away.

I was in the A&E with a heart arrhythmia and a ridiculously low blood pressure and almost passed out in the waiting room (they were amazing, I was seen really quickly for an ECG and then taken straight to majors). There was a family there who was insisting that a lady was seen for a condition that was non life threatening and had been ongoing for weeks. They were politely, but firmly told to book an appointment with their GP.

And for the avoidance of doubt, it sounds like the OP did exactly what she was told to do.

randomsabreuse · 31/12/2020 08:10

We ended up with an ambulance last year with then 1 year old with Chickenpox, sky high temperature not responding to Calpol and interesting lung sounds (textbook crackles). The hospital/ambulance service decided it was best we came in by ambulance (having been checked and paramedics also heard lung sounds) so we could go straight to a cubicle rather than spreading Chickenpox around the waiting room. Much less convenient for us as we then had no car with us to go home so DH had to come along with other DC at 4am once the lung stuff had sorted itself out...

Fallox · 31/12/2020 07:55

If you were the person in charge of triage and you had a whole heap of people waiting which would you prioritise?

2 people with the exact same symptoms.
One is in an ambulance,lying on a bed having had some form of medical review, sats are monitored and is with medics. Probably has had some meds

Or number 2, sat on a chair in a waiting room with no monitoring, unknown sats and no investigation.

Obviously a heart attack in an ambulance is going to be prioritised over lower priority walk ins.

It seems silly that an ambulance has to wait but the only other option is that the ambulance leaves you a waiting room without handing over. That seems like a massive black hole where important things/whole people get missed.

ivechangedname · 31/12/2020 07:51

@Stepintochristmas

I occasionally watch Ambulance on BBC and at least half of the call outs don't actually need an ambulance. If the patient is breathing and can walk to a car or taxi without bleeding to death then they shouldn’t be wasting resources. We need an education campaign to remind people what the emergency services are actually for.
It’s not so simple though . My mum has a poorly controlled seizure disorder - frequently has them in public , for insurance purposes 99% of businesses eg shops, supermarkets insist on calling 999 . They can last a very long time - eg she can be on the floor over an hour .

Which means we get seen by an ambulance - who most of the time help her off the floor, check her obs and into the back of a taxi home .

She must have been attended by an ambulance hundreds of times now as she’s been this way forty years .

I don’t know what the better solution is - apart from only going out of the house when absolutely essential but what kind of a life is that? I cant pick her up on the floor - she goes completely limp - or stop the seizure once it’s started . Social work aren’t interested, GP says don’t worry - just ring 999, it’s what they’re there for . We don’t have any alternative really . It’s difficult to know what to do . Have tried to hold off before but then mums been 90 mins on the floor in eg Tesco with everyone staring and staff questioning why you won’t just ring an ambulance ... it’s so bloody hard to know what to do .

NellWilsonsWhiteHair · 31/12/2020 07:45

@Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov

If only ever call an ambulance if I thought someone needed medical attention before I could get them to a hospital. It's the same triage system regardless of how you arrive.
Yes - I am not a healthcare professional at all, but this has always seemed obvious to me and I don’t understand why people often don’t get it. (Am a non driver and DC1 was a wheezy toddler, so we had a number of nighttime cab trips to A&E.)
Stepintochristmas · 31/12/2020 07:39

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

MichelleScarn · 31/12/2020 07:31

@Lemonpiano
I really am not sure what you mean here? Emergency departments are already shit at seeking and obtaining patient consent (unless you're unconscious/incapacitated, consent is still essential before anything happens, it's not an optional bonus), let's not encourage them to be even more abusive in the name of saving a minute or two.

Are you alleging a&e staff are being abusive and doing things against peoples will?

AnotherVice · 31/12/2020 07:24

And funnily enough the people that tell us they have no way of making their own way to hospital always manage to find someone to bring them home Hmm

AnotherVice · 31/12/2020 07:22

You were lucky to get an ambulance OP. The ambulance trust I work for were so busy a couple of days ago we were responding to 999 calls that came in 25hrs previously. Yes you read that right people. You have no idea how bad it is out there.

TheFairyCaravan · 31/12/2020 06:00

I wouldn’t have called an ambulance in the first place if he was well enough to be driven in, especially in these times.

DS2 is a nurse in A&E. Every night shift he’s been on his week there’s been at least 20 ambulances waiting outside when he’s arrived at work.

GrumpyHoonMain · 31/12/2020 05:53

They were telling you, in a polite way, that although your husband’s illness is serious enough to be admitted to A&E it’s not a life or death emergency. And it’s not ok to call an ambulence unless it gets to that stage.

For life and death emergencies no paramedic will begrudge you calling an ambulence, ever.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.