Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Final decision - remaining childfree or not

160 replies

TheIceTree · 28/12/2020 13:15

I have recently turned 40. I have never really experienced the feeling of wanting kids as such. When I was younger I assumed that the desire might hit me at some later point, but it never really did. But now I am slightly questioning my decision, as I’m in the last chance saloon (or perhaps already too late, I realise) in terms of age.

There are some good solid reasons why remaining childfree would seem to be the best plan. I am a fairly classic introvert – I like quiet time and space to myself. I don’t feel ‘maternal’. When I see babies I don’t want to hold them or anything. In general, I don’t particularly enjoy the company of children, based on spending time with nieces/nephews and friends’ children. I also just can't picture myself doing things like baby talk, or singing nursery rhymes, or role play games. Due to all this, I fear I may be bad at parenthood, or that it would be a case of surviving rather than thriving.

We also love travel and I would certainly dislike limitations being placed on this part of our lives, post-Covid.

It feels like I’ve answered my own question. But something is making me question if I’m missing something – I guess essentially it is a kind of FOMO. I do like the idea of having an adult child when I’m older (but don’t like the idea of the stages in between). I also like the idea of a meaningful ‘project’ for the next phase of our lives. I fear that later in life we may regret having no children, but equally I’m aware that a certain proportion of people do, to some degree, regret having children, (and that would be worse in my opinion). I also suspect I’m the type of person who might regret it, for the reasons above.

I’d love to hear thoughts from anyone who felt very conflicted about this issue, and either remained childfree, or went on to have a child.

OP posts:
Notreallyhappy · 29/12/2020 17:46

I have a ds..love him to bits I have a dss, love him too. But roll back 23 years and no way. No-one tells you how thankless and hard work children are

Badwill · 29/12/2020 17:32

I think you are very wise to give it such thought - I wish I had! In your circumstances I wouldn't do it. I have two DC. Planned and very much wanted, no financial worries, family support etc. but I've found the early years excruciatingly difficult a LOT of the time. It can be very over rated having children IMO. Very boring, frustrating, exhausting, draining.

I do love them dearly and as they get older and less physically needy I'm enjoying it more, (I'm also a major introvert and having them hang off me all day long used to give me the rage!) but it's still more work than joy. I too think I'll be a much better parent to older DC and was never a baby person but hopefully I won't have fucked it all up before then!

The thing about parenthood is you literally can't tell who's going to be good at it and who's going to crumble until it's happened. So many people have surprised me for good and for bad (including myself - I thought I'd be a brilliant earth mother type Blush) You could be an amazing mum who completely thrives... it's just weighing up if it's worth the risk of the alternative.

Good luck whatever you decide.

Zezet · 29/12/2020 17:20

Sorry, and to be clear: I get on great with her and I don't fault her for not being maternal. I'm just trying to make the point some people really aren't and that's okay.

Zezet · 29/12/2020 17:19

My stepmum never wanted kids enough to be willing to give up everything she would have needed to give up. And, frankly, I can see it now with my own kids - she doesn't have much in the way of maternal instincts (great with animals though).

She ended up having adult (step)children after all but she doesn't regret not having had any of her own.

PerveenMistry · 29/12/2020 16:59

@LoveMySituation

I would stay as you are OP. I've never wanted kids. Until something biological hit me, and I was unable to think straight, until the body had achieved its goal. Then the desire went. The night I gave birth, I remember lying watching him sleep, thinking 'I've made the biggest mistake ever' And so it has proved to be. It has decimated my life, I'm a shadow of my former self, everything about my life I hate, and I don't feel that love other people feel for their kids. He will never know any of this, and he seems happy. But I regret it ever day. And then I feel guilty. The self hatred(for doing this to myself) has given me is off the scale. I'm sure I'm an extreme example, but I'd stay free if I were you

Sorry you are in that situation. It must be grim.

Mittens030869 · 29/12/2020 16:09

I wasn’t broody before I got married, unlike my DSis and some of my friends, who always knew they wanted DC and several of them! I wasn’t even that great at relating to kids.

But when my DH and I got married, I knew I really did want DC. I turned out to be infertile and we adopted our DDs. It’s been really hard a lot of the time but I’ve never regretted it.

But I always did know it was what I wanted, I didn’t need an internal debate to come to that conclusion. Having kids can be really hard, so if you’re really not sure you want a child, I’d say don’t do it.

LoveMySituation · 29/12/2020 15:32

I would stay as you are OP. I've never wanted kids. Until something biological hit me, and I was unable to think straight, until the body had achieved its goal. Then the desire went. The night I gave birth, I remember lying watching him sleep, thinking 'I've made the biggest mistake ever' And so it has proved to be. It has decimated my life, I'm a shadow of my former self, everything about my life I hate, and I don't feel that love other people feel for their kids. He will never know any of this, and he seems happy. But I regret it ever day. And then I feel guilty. The self hatred(for doing this to myself) has given me is off the scale. I'm sure I'm an extreme example, but I'd stay free if I were you

Abouttimemum · 29/12/2020 15:12

Hi OP. I never wanted children, then I lost my grandparents in a very short space of time and my sister had my nephew at the age of 40 (I have two other older nephews who I am very close to also) and I started to get FOMO and thinking about the next chapter of our lives together, and family roots and the like. I was very conflicted but we decided to start trying at the age of 36 or 37 with a bit of a ‘if it happens it happens’ sort of attitude.
However, conceiving was not a straightforward process and we did have some loss, and my pregnancy and birth with DS was difficult. There’s a few times I wished we had not started on the journey. He’s here now though, almost 2 and I absolutely love him with everything I have, I do not regret it for a second, although I know some people do.

Here’s a few things:

  • I really dislike babies. Even now, I mean they’re cute etc, but they aren’t for me. Even after having DS I still don’t particularly want to hold other people’s babies. DS was a difficult baby and I didn’t like the newborn phase at all but quite frankly you just get through it and it’s over in no time!
  • I’m not even really keen on toddlers. Once my nephews were old enough to take them away and do fun things with them I started to love it so I always thought if I could get through the first few years I’d be fine (I’m a bit of a kid that loves theme parks etc) DS is a toddler now and actually he’s loads of fun, more so than I imagined, as terrible as that sounds. We do things that I forgot that I loved, and spend loads of time outdoors. He’s hilarious.
  • I like my job but I’m not particularly career focused. I have a good, well paid and flexible job and I’m currently working 3 days a week, and will most likely go back full time when DS goes to school. I was quite ready for a year off!
  • We are financially comfortable and having one child has had minimal impact on our financial situation.
  • We still do whatever we want to do and DS fits in, he’s been on holidays, he comes with us for meals, etc, long walks (Pre covid)
I miss the cinema. We never really went to the pub or are big drinkers so that’s not something I miss. I do look forward to watching films with him when he’s older.
  • sadly I do think I have changed as a person. I worry incessantly about him and his future and his health and welfare. Which makes me more anxious generally where previously I was quite a relaxed laid back person.
  • I have a very supportive DH who has been 50% involved with everything. I would never have got through the newborn days in one piece without him and vice Versa. It’s a team effort. He absolutely dotes on DS.
  • our relationship has improved, we have been together for 20 years prior to DS arriving and I did worry slightly as we are so close as a couple, but DS has been a great addition.
  • DS sleeps, which means we get our evenings together each night (aside from the odd rough night with illness) and we alternate bedtime so that if we have our own things we want to do then we are free to do them. We worked very hard on DS sleep at the age of 4 months because it’s the one thing I wanted to get right. Some babies just don’t sleep though sadly.
  • I hate meal times at the moment, it’s just slow going, and the fact that it’s usually one phase after another means I feel like I’m always a step behind, and at the moment it’s meals!

So there’s a few things from me, there’s probably other things I’m sure. There are pros and cons i think. At the age I’m at, I have child free friends who love their lives, some that regret not having children, and friends with children who regret having them. Then people like me who wouldn’t change a thing.
I think I was at the right point in my life where I was ready and thought a child would bring more to my life rather than take away from it, which has been realised for me.

I’m only having 1 though!

PerveenMistry · 29/12/2020 14:45

*I disagree with those who say you should only have kids if you have a “burning desire”. I never particularly wanted kids, wasn’t (and am still not) anyone’s idea of “maternal” and didn’t particularly like other people’s babies. Was 38 and in a relatively new relationship when I became pregnant - we decided to go ahead with it and I am SO glad we did.
*

The planet in 2021 is way too overpopulated to have people reproducing by happenstance. ALL decisions to add another human being to its burden should be carefully considered, planned and prepared for.

VetOnCall · 29/12/2020 13:47

Ugh sorry, there were paragraphs when I typed the above out on my phone!

VetOnCall · 29/12/2020 13:46

I completely get your post OP, I'm a bit younger than you (not much!) and child free by choice. I also have never felt broody or had maternal feelings or urges, but the older I get I do sometimes wonder if I might like it - I think I would like to have an older child but not a baby/toddler/preschooler. Deep down I know that it's just not for me though, and I have enough good friends and family with children to have a good idea of what it's like. I love my freedom, my career, adventure travel, sleep, our high disposable income, and my fitness and exercise is hugely important to me. The daily grind drudge work of cleaning, laundry, cooking, play parks, school runs etc. just isn't for me. That said, we have 5 dogs that I adore and don't begrudge doing anything for, so I know it's different if it's what you really want. I'm happy with my life as it is, I don't feel like there's anything missing or that I need anything to 'be the making of me' as a PP said, I'm ok as I am Grin DP is ambivalent - more on the side of no but if I really wanted it he'd do it. We'd be good parents, we're both good people, responsible, caring etc. any child we had would be loved, but I'm 99.9% certain we'll stay as we are.

tinselvestsparklepants · 28/12/2020 23:50

This was me. Next year I'm starting as a mentor to care leavers. Can't wait. A chance to do something useful, build a relationship with a young person etc, and I have an eye on fostering in the future. Suits me far better than having one "of my own." Never liked babies but adore young adults - oddly enough I'm fiercely maternal towards that age but not younger - don't know why but hope to make the best of it.

Chuckleknuckles · 28/12/2020 23:35

If you’re really torn, and it doesn’t sound like you are, do one if two things.

  1. Flip a coin, that’ll tell you all you need to know.
  2. try for 6 months, if it happens, great, if not enjoy your life of spontaneity and disposable income.
Ginandplatonic · 28/12/2020 23:33

I disagree with those who say you should only have kids if you have a “burning desire”. I never particularly wanted kids, wasn’t (and am still not) anyone’s idea of “maternal” and didn’t particularly like other people’s babies. Was 38 and in a relatively new relationship when I became pregnant - we decided to go ahead with it and I am SO glad we did.

Having my kids has been the best thing I have ever done. That child is now 20, and has 3 siblings. It was difficult at times but I have never regretted it - watching them grow and become their own people has been the most rewarding experience of my life. We continued to go out for dinner, the theatre, travelling - doing all the things we did before.
Sometimes differently, and it takes a bit more effort, but it’s possible.

I think maybe because I never had the “burning desire” I also didn’t have long standing expectations and fantasies of motherhood, and perhaps that’s a factor in avoiding the resentment and disillusionment others on here describe?

NataliaOsipova · 28/12/2020 22:58

I was not a “kiddy” person. I am still not (don’t like other people’s kids at all, to be honest). But having my own has been fantastic; definitely the best thing I’ve ever done. I do think it’s almost impossible to understand ex ante how you will feel about your own child. (Just a personal perspective, of course - not sure if it’s helpful....)

OutComeTheWolves · 28/12/2020 22:49

Honestly I bloody love my kids, they were very much wanted and they are easily the best decision I've ever made. I was lucky enough to have very easy pregnancies and they're pretty nice kids. I had my first fairly late on so had done a fair bit of partying and travelling before I had them. Yet still in spite of all of that there's days when it's really really hard work, when I miss my old life, when I think I'm a shit mum and when I question whether I did the right thing.

I think society would be greatly improved if the pressure was removed from women to have kids, if it wasn't just something that's expected of us. And instead it became something that we only persued once we decided that we really really wanted it. There'd be a lot less neglected children and a lot less women who find themselves sleepwalking into a situation that they only realise they didn't want once it's too late.

Pregnancy and motherhood has taken a toll on my body, my career, my social life, my relationship, my sleeping habits, my hobbies and my finances and I've aged terribly but I don't mind (most of the time) because I really wanted this. My advice to you is if it's not something you're desperate for, then don't do it - go out and travel, party or whatever it is that you'd love to do instead. The child free people in know who are in their fifties and sixties have an amazing life and a lot more extra cash than anyone else I know.

TheIceTree · 28/12/2020 22:24

@blueleonburger

Thank you for at least carefully considering whether to bring life into the world. Most do not.

I don’t have children and in my early twenties was against it for a lot of the reasons you mention. But now I’ve changed my mind because instead of “do I want children?” I asked “do I want a family” which made me think differently because if I were honest with myself I couldn’t imagine getting old with DH and not having independent adult children. What also helped was that I realised it was my duty to be a role model to my future children and keep pursuing the life I wanted in terms of lifestyle, career etc. No, one can’t have it all but you can bloody well try and adapt. I met a few mum role models who managed to do just this and it gave me confidence to ttc.

You say something feels missing. I think you need to really reflect on what that is exactly. Is it children or something else? Don’t underestimate this pandemic has affected us all and I wonder not being able to do the things you enjoy, like travel, has made you think this way? If you conclude children are not for you you can have a very happy and fulfilling life still.

Thank you. I do think the pandemic has affected my feelings. It's not a good time to be making any important decisions, with everything so out of kilter.

An added factor is that my dad received a terminal diagnosis this year and is in end of life care. I have been helping my mum a lot with various things (equipment, navigating the care system and funding, moral support, and small but important things like getting supermarket delivery slots). I think this situation has influenced my feelings with regards to having an adult child later in life, because I can't imagine how difficult my mum's situation would be without any of the support that my brother and I have provided (although I realise that having a child in no way guarantees any such support).

OP posts:
TheIceTree · 28/12/2020 22:07

@HarrietPotterska

What about your DH? How much does he truly want them?

I'm not saying you should have kids for him, but, realistically, if he wants them (even deep down) then it could prove to be an issue in your relationship

He is happy either way, he'll get behind either direction.
OP posts:
HarrietPotterska · 28/12/2020 19:13

What about your DH? How much does he truly want them?

I'm not saying you should have kids for him, but, realistically, if he wants them (even deep down) then it could prove to be an issue in your relationship

surelynotnever · 28/12/2020 19:11

Don't do it. You are right. It is not for you. Its won't be fair on the kids either. There are many ways to have a good life. You live yours.

Vates · 28/12/2020 19:06

I wouldn't reading your post. I sometimes get caught up in the fantasy of having children too but realistically know I wouldn't cut it as a Mum. I am a loving person but also value my free time immensely and I am most happy having plenty of sleep. I direct all my love to my Nephew. I am not anti-children at all but I am very awkward around them, friends kids, etc. I really feel for Mums or Dads whose children are screaming or upset but hate the sound.

You have to separate the fantasy from reality. I don't know it personally but seeing my Sister completely & utterly shattered was hard (not that I was any help, have never changed a nappy mostly because I don't want to, lol. I would rather clean to help instead). You can have meaningful relationships as an Auntie and to your friend's children too.

Tehmina23 · 28/12/2020 19:00

In my case I'm 44 and have strong maternal feelings but I'm unable to have a baby for several reasons...

Sometimes I see a small baby and feel heartbroken or I look at my friends daughter and I think, I could have had a daughter like that...

But the reality would probably have been different for me as I'm unable to come off my psychiatric meds so the baby could have been born disabled, most likely the poor thing would've been born addicted to my meds, I'd be at high risk from my epilepsy as well as serious mental illness.

I have no nieces or nephews sadly, and I'm single too. I doubt I'd be able to adopt or foster.

OP you're not in my situation at all but you don't sound as if you really want to have a baby?

christmassausage · 28/12/2020 18:53

I should add that after I became a step mum we had our own son too

christmassausage · 28/12/2020 18:52

I've name changed for this because admitting this is tricky - No one can make this choice for you and I know it's a bloody hard one.

I never wanted children until I met my ex husband and became a stepmum. Then I did - almost overnight at the age you are now. Looking back however I had a very very rose tinted view of parenthood.

We divorced and I was then a single parent - the strain of being parents meant we stopped focussing on each other - being a single parent, not what I planned although it was my decision to end the marriage.

Given the chance to make the decision again,,,,i would remain childfree. However and it's a big however, I can't imagine my life without my son. And if I hadn't done it, I think I would have always yearned for the experience. But Jesus it's hard so I think you need to be very sure.

All the best with your choice. It's yours and others will always have their views. There is no right or wrong choice, just different choices

Bourbonbiccy · 28/12/2020 18:36

It really doesn't sound like it's right for you. I felt the same until I hit 30 then changed and really wanted a child. If you don't have the urge, don't do it, it's tough at times.

Swipe left for the next trending thread