Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be uncomfortable with kids being on screens all day?

65 replies

Bagamoyo1 · 22/12/2020 14:50

2 DSs, age 15 and 11.

Both football mad, so during term time, Covid permitting, their weekends are busy with training and matches half the time, so I don’t mind them playing Xbox the rest of the time.

Now it’s the holidays and they’re both just vegging in front of their screens. I know there’s not much else they can do, but I can’t shake the feeling that it’s just not healthy! It’s probably an age thing - I’m in my 50s and screens just weren’t a thing in my childhood.

They’ll go to the park maybe every couple of days, but the rest of the time they say the park is boring without a team to play with.

Should I stop stressing about it and accept that this is the way things are now? In normal times we’d be going on day trips but obviously that can’t happen now.

Neither of them are remotely crafty or artistic, and they don’t like reading.

Is this normal? Am I being too stressy?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LowBumsMum · 08/08/2021 17:06

@snookercue

people did used to be able to entertain themselves in their homes without screens in the past. Reading books, playing music, chatting to friends on the phone etc.

These are all activities that kids still do, just using their phone/iPad.

I think you’ve hit the nail on the head as to why limiting screen time is so difficult for me.

They’re socialising and spending time with friends
doing all the things that teens do but the medium is the screen.

The issue for me is that I feel they should move more, be outside, spend time with the family (but did I really want to spend time with my parents at 12 and 15?) and have more variety.

I’d still like all these things but your comments have made me realise that for me what they are doing on the screen is more important that how long they are spending on it.

That’s really helpful for taking the guilt away and helping me have a more mature conversation with them about balance and physically seeing their friends during the holidays as well as socialising online.

ladybee28 · 25/12/2020 17:13

Or is it, as I suspect, nothing to do with screens and everything to do with control, punishment and showing the little buggers who is the boss

Yes, that's exactly it. I only limit screen time because whips and chains are illegal.

Melonlover80 · 25/12/2020 17:03

@ChocolateCherrybomb

What is this strange aversion a lot of parents seem to have to "screen time". You do realise it is the arse end of 2020 and the vast majority of jobs involve "screen time". You going to phone your children's employer in the future and demand your kid stop work after an hour each day?

Or is it, as I suspect, nothing to do with screens and everything to do with control, punishment and showing the little buggers who is the boss.

Have you read anythingAbout impact of excessive screen time? On adults and children alike
ChocolateCherrybomb · 25/12/2020 16:48

What is this strange aversion a lot of parents seem to have to "screen time".
You do realise it is the arse end of 2020 and the vast majority of jobs involve "screen time".
You going to phone your children's employer in the future and demand your kid stop work after an hour each day?

Or is it, as I suspect, nothing to do with screens and everything to do with control, punishment and showing the little buggers who is the boss.

Melonlover80 · 25/12/2020 14:37

* We are about fifteen years out of date I think*

Same here and it’s brill as no temptation!

Melonlover80 · 25/12/2020 14:35

Key is... not to get the stuff in first place!

So my yr 6 son goes to friend and plays on x box.
Comes home and asks for one. I say you remember what I promised.... for your 12 birthday guaranteed.
And he heads out to play football.

My daughter year 3, not a bloody chance am I having her play computer games and never asks and none of her friends seem to play or have either. It’s all about sylvanians families, reading and playing “teachers”.

I don’t want them to feel left out, so from secondary school onwards, I’ll allow computer games in the house.

inquietant · 25/12/2020 14:14

Screens are not an issue in my house, they do use screens but very little, except for family TV viewing. We are about fifteen years out of date I think!

Other things they do are crafts, modelling, reading, board games, cooking, gardening. I still have to persuade them out of the house some days, in colder weather.

Oblomov20 · 25/12/2020 14:04

Have the same problem. My 2 play x box too much normally. It's my lazy parenting (that sometimes I'm ashamed of) that makes me normally think it's too much.
But since football (Ds2) and boxing (Ds1) has stopped last week, they are on it all the time.
Blush

Melonlover80 · 25/12/2020 14:01

@Littleyell

What would they do instead though? If it was summer and normal times I could understand. It isn’t though.
Really?

What did you do as a child?

Younger.... Read, played, kick about in garden, trampoline, role play games, play with dolls, card games

Older... read, kick about, listen to music

SuperCaliFragalistic · 22/12/2020 18:07

Mine are on screens too much and they're much younger. I don't like it but usually in the xmas hols they'd have friends over to play or we'd be visiting family or out at the theatre or pub. We go outside for a few hours every day but walking in the rain and mud is pretty tiresome. As are crafts and baking when you've been doing it for months. I'm hoping we can set some new goals and plans for the new year around improving the quality of our downtime- like learning an instrument or something.

Bagamoyo1 · 22/12/2020 18:02

Thanks everyone - I’m glad it’s not just me who doesn’t feel happy about it.

We were fairly late to get screens - DS1 was the last of his friends to get an Xbox - I think he was about 10. So we had many happy years of toys and Lego. And it was much easier to be strict when they were younger, because there genuinely were more alternatives. But you can’t really tell a 15 year old to play with toys.

It wouldn’t be so bad if it made them happy, but it really doesn’t . If they have a day of screens they’re both really ratty by the evening, and restless like caged animals !

In the end, today, they went to the park, and the atmosphere is much better as a result. I just wish I didn’t have to have the daily fight.

OP posts:
MustardMitt · 22/12/2020 17:49

Well, it’s the Christmas holidays and I’m still at work so I’m not fretting about it.

Anywherebuthere · 22/12/2020 17:42

Kids screen time is excessive these days and is considered normal. But you're not wrong to worry.

I've ended up limiting it for mine. Every so often I'l tell them to turn all screens off for a while. I dont set a time or anything.

For a bit they are bored and vocal about it, then they start communicating with each other about random things, they argue, they play games or make up their own games or decide to cook something (unfortunately mostly sweet food but oh well , they're learning another skill!)

After a while they all end up back on screens again but its fine. As they've had a break from it.

PTW1234 · 22/12/2020 17:40

I am a bit lose with screen time, DC is 7 and has a tv in his room, iPad and two games consoles he splits his time between....

We monitor for appropriate sites etc, but other than that we just let him crack on. He is an only child of two working parents, and he uses some of the screen time to chat away with his friends and play group games - mid week play dates are impossible (even without covid)

His iPad is now mainly used for audio books, music, reading, football news etc. So isn’t just playing mindless games all of the time.

Dads a gamer and I have a fairly techy career, and spend 9 hours a day behind 3 monitors and two phones.

DangerMouse17 · 22/12/2020 17:35

Completely agree with you @ladybee28 it's the continuous consumption of stuff. My ds often games and has something on his tablet playing at the same time...either netflix or a youtuber playing the game he happens to be playing Hmm

I have to tell him to choose one thing as his brain cant deal with all this input and multi-tasking!

MrsBlondie · 22/12/2020 17:33

Yep and home school in January means even school will be on a screen.

wigornian · 22/12/2020 17:28

I am quite strict, DS aged 12, 45 min limit on PS4 with flex of 15 mins. On a wet day a second 45 min allowed otherwise outside or reading. Limit TV to something specific and nothing after 8pm. Luckily DS loves reading!

snookercue · 22/12/2020 17:25

people did used to be able to entertain themselves in their homes without screens in the past. Reading books, playing music, chatting to friends on the phone etc.

These are all activities that kids still do, just using their phone/iPad.

ladybee28 · 22/12/2020 17:16

What if they were watching on the iPad 😂😂 doesn’t make much difference

The bit that bothers me is less the screen they're watching it on and more the kind of thing that tends to appear on said screens. Things that play on TVs tend (at least in our house) to be reasonably lengthy things that require extended attention and engagement.

What DSS watches on his tablet or mobile is rarely more than 8 seconds long and it's this slack-jawed scrolling while he consumes video after video not because he's interested or seeking something, but because it's being auto-fed to him.

That's the bit that's always bothered me – I see what I think is the impact, where he's completely unable to be without entertainment, in his own head. He cannot amuse himself or be with his own thoughts, because he's not had to since he was very small.

I watched an episode of The Herbs the other day (DP and I are from different countries and I was trying to show him old kids programmes from the UK) and I was struck by how incredibly slow-paced and meandering it was. No way DSS would stick with anything for that long – it's like his brain needs constant switching and changing.

So for me it's less the device that has the screen on it, and more what you're likely to find happening on that screen. If DSS sat through a whole movie I think I'd jump for joy – the only time I've seen him do it was his first time seeing Forrest Gump last year.

Bonsai49 · 22/12/2020 17:16

I used to say they could have technology after 3 - I’ve just realised that this year with all that’s been going on it’s slipped and it’s any old time of day . I drag them out for walks / to the playground / make cakes etc but they’re still on technology too much . I feel I should reinstate the old rule ... but at the mo don’t feel I can - OH is a key worker , always on calls and he doesn’t need the bundling / nerf gun fights that would be going on loudly when we’re home

3orangekissesfromkazan · 22/12/2020 17:09

Tier 4 here too...it's grim.

SpaceOp · 22/12/2020 17:02

Honestly, I can't even begin to get worked up about this at this point. It's cold, dark and wet and we're in Tier 4. At least when they're on screens they are also often interacting with friends - DD spent roughly 2 hours chatting and playing with her bestie this morning while DS has been on his playstation playing with mates off and on. DS is 9 and while he's allowed a fair bit of independence, most of his school friends are not allowed the same amount and don't live close enough for them to walk and meet each other in the park or whatever. He does have one local friend so on nice days the two of them will go to a park together (which is within restrictions as I understand it as it's two people from separate households for exercise).

We do try to initiate activities for them to do outside of screens - walks, chores, games etc - but I really am not stressing if they're doing screens more than other things.

BeyondMyWits · 22/12/2020 16:57

Would look at what needs doing and divide it between you. If parents are doing stuff 11 and 15 year olds can either do it to or be taught how. Tidying up, hoovering, cleaning the toilet, bath, shower screen, doing dishes, walking the dog etc are all jobs that get done before screen time here.

When they get up, make bed, tidy round room, sort clothes/pockets for laundry, make/lay out breakfast (including asking others if they want a hot drink etc), feed the dog, put down fresh water, dishes into the dishwasher... by the time that is all done they have earned some screen time. I was surprised talking with friends that 3 out of 4 of them just let the kids get up and go on devices. It does not have to be that way.

3orangekissesfromkazan · 22/12/2020 16:56

Yup...and Facebook is performance parenting at its very finest.

I'm really trying to focus on the fact that my kids are well fed, loved and generally seem happy..DD tells me often I am the best mum in the world..poor deluded child Grin

Feministicon · 22/12/2020 16:53

I also think people need to remember that anyone can say anything about themselves on here and not really have to prove it. My kids don’t have devices, or TVs or anything just a pet rock each. See I’ve said it so it must be true, go me! All the angst too about kids on screens when soooo many posters spend all bloody day on here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread