Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ring doorbell hell!

437 replies

Biddums · 16/12/2020 16:25

Hi all,

My neighbors door is right next to mine with only a brick between them. They have just got a ring doorbell (2 days ago) and I hate it!

Not only is the noise bloody annoying but it's covering my door. There is no way they can set it up to not cover both doors, they are just too close.

I don't like the fact whoever comes to my door is now on their bell cam. I also feel uneasy about the fact my kids will be on there, because you know kids leave the house, my house!

I'm pissed off that anything I buy, like a new TV, they will see and be able to have a good nose. Because they can rewatch and bloody pause.

So I need Mumsneters help. How do I go about this? Do I talk to them? How do I word it? How do I tell them that the bell they paid for has got to go? Do I offer to pay for it?

What if they say no? Do I have a leg to stand on here?

Or do I just get a family member with face covered in the night to nick it and smash it? Yes ring do replace nicked bells but not unlimited. I could get it nicked time and again.

AIBU here? Should I just accept that this is the way now? People videoing your door and kids? Idk I just feel they were wrong to get it without asking if I minded.

Funny enough a family member asked me if I wanted one about a year ago and I said no because it would invade my neighbors door.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
PerkingFaintly · 16/12/2020 18:01

prh47bridge, I have been wondering about the efficacy of making Subject Access Requests under data protection legislation to Amazon and to the owner of any Ring doorbell one encounters.

Surely if we, Joe Public, start doing that, the Ring system will collapse under its own weight?

Amazon are slurping so much data about random passer-bys and people approaching Ring doorbells without signage, they won't be able to cope. Individual users will have less data on their hands – but even less clue about how to meet data protection legislation.

Amazon would be forced to massively reduce the scope of their system.

Fluffybutter · 16/12/2020 18:00

One , why would they be interested in anything you get delivered ? And two, you get two base plates and one is angled so they could use that one as it shouldn’t show your door and if it’s that loud they also have a volume so can put it on the lowest setting if you ask.
We have one but our house is detached and no one opposite as I hadn’t really thought about it filming the neighbours .
I hate the outside child so I’ve it on the lowest setting as only the ones ringing it need to hear it .

Plzhelpme56 · 16/12/2020 18:00

Mine picks up movement of neighbours, not looked at the footage once. I just don't care enough. Also you can create a privacy screen, so all your side is blacked out. Easy.

Beautifulbonnie · 16/12/2020 17:58

I love how the answer is either talk to them

Or get someone to engage over and over again in criminal activity and nothing in between!

On top of that you’ve put that your get your brothers to nick it and written it on the net!

Crankley · 16/12/2020 17:57

I don't know much about Ring doorbells. Do they record a) only when someone presses the bell, b) if it responds to movement, ie people walking up the path or c) all the time?

If a) it woudn't concern me - unless they're running a business from home, most bells don't get rung more than a couple of times a day, if at all. If b) that's more annoying because it will be picking up all the comings and goings to/from your house. c) is unacceptable.

If b) or c) I would ask them if they would please fit it the other side of their door and explain why. If no luck install a camera directed towards their front door. This may be illegal but may get the message across before you're forced to remove it. Alternatively, start planting some fast growing bamboo along the fence.

greenlynx · 16/12/2020 17:57

I wouldn’t like it too and I’m not sure that it’s legal. I would check with Cutizens bureau and online and only then to talk to your neighbors.
OP is right, it is invasion of privacy. Her neighbors will basically know her family routine. At the moment they could see what’s going on only IF they are near the door/windows but with the bell they are basically alerted every time when something happens. OP might have a visitor she doesn’t want neighbors to know, she might accidentally have a private conversation on mobile near the door, she might be in the situation when she needs to confirm her date of birth or medical information. Now she needs to be on alert every time she goes to her own front door, it’s not right.
I don’t want my neighbors to know details of my life. I’m not drug dealer or psychopath but I don’t know them that well to be sure that they are not. People go on holiday, leave keys for relatives in a safe place, have sensitive conversation over mobile. They don’t want other people to know about all these. People are entitled to privacy and considering OP has children, her concerns are even more valid.

StatisticallyChallenged · 16/12/2020 17:57

We have one, but we're a detached house so not invading anyone else's privacy

Dh put out some halloween decorations, including a witch at the door that had some dangly fabric. Everyone time there was a breeze, it set off the motion alert. Perhaps a Christmas equivalent could be found? They might then turn off the motion alerts

ImPrincessAurora · 16/12/2020 17:55

A couple of things.

Yes it records sound.

Yes the chime is annoying. You can change it to one of 30 or so choices.

It’s actually a brilliant burglar deterrent. I’ve caught someone scoping out my house, looking directly at the ring doorbell and running off!

Most people have the notifications limited to doorbell only because otherwise it’s bloody annoying. So they wouldn’t be looking at any recordings of people walking in and out of your house unless it sets off their doorbell.

Also most people will have the duration of the recording limited, to say 20 seconds because otherwise it massively drains the battery. So they won’t be recording hours and hours of your front door.

PerkingFaintly · 16/12/2020 17:55

Yeah, sod your neighbour looking at the video, it's Amazon which is collecting and processing the video of your front door and all the other front doors which have Ring. Your neighbour gets to view Amazon's video – the set-up is that way round.

What's more Amazon does have the resources and incentive to process that data. In this case it will mostly be your neighbour, as they are the one with the app. Broader insight into your neighbour's life can be sold onwards to advertisers – who can be selling anything from soap powder or can be selling political messaging.

Amazon's Ring logs every doorbell press and app action
www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-51709247

Welcome to surveillance capitalism, folks.

Drives me slightly barmy that some people are running round panicking that Bill Gates is trying to inject them with microchips (not really happening), while being completely oblivious to highly intrusive amassing of personal data like this (which is really happening).

VenusClapTrap · 16/12/2020 17:55

My friend has one of these and it recorded footage of a ghost. Not joking.

prh47bridge · 16/12/2020 17:54

I haven't read the whole thread but there is a lot of incorrect advice in the bit I have scanned.

A Ring doorbell is subject to the same laws as a CCTV system (assuming the camera is enabled). They must have a clear and justifiable reason for capturing images of people outside the boundary of their property. They need to be able to explain why capturing images is more important than invading your privacy and that of others. They should have a sign telling people that they are being recorded and explaining why. They need to be able to show that they are storing the footage securely, only keeping it for as long as it is needed and deleting it regularly.

If you make a subject access request they must provide all information they hold about you, including identifiable images. They must also delete any images of you if you ask them to do so.

Take a look at ico.org.uk/your-data-matters/domestic-cctv-systems-guidance-for-people-using-cctv/ for all the details.

ThePlantsitter · 16/12/2020 17:53

I don't know what you can do OP but I just wanted to say I completely agree with you and understand why you don't like it. Even if they were the most trustworthy people alive and you liked them you wouldn't necessarily give them details of your comings and goings throughout the day, but they are basically keeping track of them anyway. Seems some people have got so used to not having any privacy they don't understand why anyone else would want it. For me it's about 'peaceful enjoyment' of your home and they are messing with it.

notapizzaeater · 16/12/2020 17:53

We've a ring camera (detached no privacy issues) but tbh I don't look at the footage unless someone asks on our village group if anyone saw anything on Friday at 3am. The rest of the time I just ignore the recordings. I do t need to see milkman, postman Etc

Leaannb · 16/12/2020 17:53

@Biddums

Gosh, so they record sounds too?

So not only am I watched on my own doorstep, I can't talk out there now as well.

I'm going to knock their door in a bit and tell them it needs to go. Not sure how it's going to go. But I guess that's the first step.

So annoyed over the whole thing. Oh and no this is not because I have nothing better todo. I just care about privacy. As I said, I declined getting one because it would invade my neighbors. Although from most of the replies here, they would not give a shit if I was videoing them anyway or listening to their chat outside.

Be prepared to be told to get fuck. You can't control this
FairyFairy · 16/12/2020 17:52

@Throwntothewolves that is awful and incredibly selfish of them.

Henio · 16/12/2020 17:52

My nan has one so I've played with the settings a bit... it won't necessarily be saving the videos, you have to pay a yearly subscription to playback videos that have been saved and they may have also turned off motion sensors so they only get notifications if someone actually presses the bell not if you just walk past. Hope this puts your mind at ease a bit, I'm not sure there's anything you can do

CausingChaos2 · 16/12/2020 17:50

They shouldn’t have set up to record your property as well. It should be covering the boundaries of their own home, not yours. Can you put up a fence between the front doors?

Throwntothewolves · 16/12/2020 17:49

We have one but live in a detached house so it only covers our property and the path/road beyond it.

This story won't fill you with hope, but recently I dropped something off at the local Women's Aid offices which are in a residential street in a converted terraced house. The private front door immediately next to their door (the set up sounds like you've described) had a ring doorbell. I can't believe that is ok with Women's Aid as women attending for help will be clearly visible on it as they have to pass that door. I didn't feel comfortable and I wasn't there for help so I can't imagine how those who've asked for help feel. I stood with my back to it and hood up, I don't know who lives there or what they might do with the recordings they have. Then again maybe they get unwanted visitors kicking off or causing damage as a result of being next to Women's Aid.

If Women's Aid can't do anything about it than I doubt you'll have much luck, sorry.

Funkyfriends · 16/12/2020 17:48

@AcornAutumn you don’t, but it seems that OP has assumed that the neighbours are making a video collection of the comings and going’s of her front door.

AcornAutumn · 16/12/2020 17:45

@Funkyfriends

Are you sure that they are filming though. The “CCTV” option is an extra that you have to pay a monthly subscription for. We have a ring doorbell but without that function so it’s essentially the same as someone who spent the entire day looking out the front window.
How do you know anyone is telling the truth?
AcornAutumn · 16/12/2020 17:45

@FrazzledChip

No advice but I sympathise. Husband bought a similar security thing for our house and I hate it. He's not at all controlling but now he can now monitor every time I leave the house, every rushed school run, everything. I know he's not watching it constantly and he rarely mentions it but it doesn't sit comfortably with me.
Um, it’s your house too?
Funkyfriends · 16/12/2020 17:43

Are you sure that they are filming though. The “CCTV” option is an extra that you have to pay a monthly subscription for. We have a ring doorbell but without that function so it’s essentially the same as someone who spent the entire day looking out the front window.

NoProblem123 · 16/12/2020 17:43

Smash it tonight and report back.

FrazzledChip · 16/12/2020 17:43

No advice but I sympathise. Husband bought a similar security thing for our house and I hate it. He's not at all controlling but now he can now monitor every time I leave the house, every rushed school run, everything. I know he's not watching it constantly and he rarely mentions it but it doesn't sit comfortably with me.

Biddums · 16/12/2020 17:43

@willowrosenburg, no I have not asked but I would not trust them anyway. I will speak to them later.

As I have said our doors are right next to each other. Would you not watch a video of someone going up to your door? If your phone pinged and you could see someone by your door would you really not look? You are clearly in the minority in that. Because people tend to want to see what's going on when their attention gets drawn to it and it's there to see.

The camera would have to be blocked out by more then three quarters to not cover my door and path. Again it's a shared path so would be a problem.

OP posts: