Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why consultants have a reputation of being so rude???

234 replies

staydazzling · 16/12/2020 14:13

Been in hospital a few days, nurses, midwifes, auxiliary, care staff all very keen to do their best in hard circumstances always trying to help, largely on time etc, I sadly couldn't say the same for the consultants /surgeons sadly not just in terms of taking literally hours to turn but also how i saw them speak to said, nurses, midwifes, care staff etc and patients.
I jokingly mentioned this to a relative who works cleaning and sterlising equipment, who said yes its well known sadly, your lucky if any move or say thank you for returned equipment, i just wondered why is this a thing, AIBU to wonder where did that culture of behaviour come from?

OP posts:
LakieLady · 16/12/2020 16:54

@Sexnotgender, in 10 years I've seen 3 different orthopaedic consultants and they have all been lovely. Approachable, polite, friendly and when I have seen them interact with other staff, they have been respectful.

Bubblewhatbubble · 16/12/2020 16:51

Incidentally, as a patient and relative of patients, I've encountered some very snappy and unhelpful nurses rather than doctors. Some have particularly little time for patients with mental health problems -possibly forgiveable in a physical health setting, but a few in a psychiatric inpatient unit where I was visiting!

DougRossIsTheBoss · 16/12/2020 16:50

It is the consultants ultimate responsibility for all decisions life and death included. That is the worst most stressful thing about it.
I mean it's accepted. It's what we are paid for but it is a huge responsibility.

Whoever else makes a mistake nursing staff, junior Drs whoever the consultant is in charge of the care and expects to be held responsible.
If it's external conditions that are the issue you'll be asked why did you not whistle blow or refuse to work or somehow improve things.
If it's someone junior who makes a mistake then why did you not train and/ or supervise them correctly?
If it's the patient themselves who was reckless even then why did you not predict that or explain to them properly or discharge them too soon?

The buck will always stop with the consultant and often the Trust (whilst making supportive noises) will throw them under the bus if a major incident occurs.

Maybe that's why we are not always mega cheery?

The fear of a huge COVID outbreak has been a constant worry for me since Feb to add to the usual fears that something bad could happen. It has been like an extra looming stress all the time for months and months. It has definitely affected my level of cheeriness at work.

Bubblewhatbubble · 16/12/2020 16:44

I work in a hospital (admin) and have done for many years, having got to know plenty of doctors. Most of the junior ones are pretty polite and humble (and if they aren't, it really doesn't look good for when they are more senior!). As a broad generalisation, consultant physicians are generally more pleasant than consultant surgeons, and the consultant oncologists I've encountered have been universally kind, patient and compassionate (fortunately given what they are dealing with). Yes, the female surgeons I've known have been particularly nice people, and one is one of the kindest people I've ever known. Most consultants are pleasant to patients at least (to their faces anyway). I often think nurses and receptionists get a tougher time from the doctors than those of us in back offices - largely because by the time they are interacting with us the pressure has usually subsided a bit. The worst behaviour I've seen has been from consultants to junior doctors who they feel aren't up to standard or are bothering them unnecessarily. I don't think I've met one that I'd describe as an out-and-out arsehole. The one with the shortest fuse was never nastily personal, just very impatient under pressure and always visibly contrite later. The one I like least has never been actively unpleasant to me, I've just seen him be icily sarcastic to others, but even he can be fairly friendly on occasions.

Krazynights34 · 16/12/2020 16:42

I’ve met far too many consultants because of my situation (stillbirth with first DD and nearly lost my life), numerous other surgeries and paediatric consultants.
I’ve never ever found one to be rude.
Some are amazing.
On the other hand, the consultant that was my “favourite”, who was wonderful etc etc touched me inappropriately and has ruined my faith in the medical profession, the NHS and has cost me a fortune in therapy

Slightlyunhinged · 16/12/2020 16:40

I imagine it is like any profession - you get good ones and bad ones. That certainly is backed up by my own experience. I have encountered some lovely consultants, although I do remember one who swept into the consulting room, white coat flying, surrounded by his acolytes - students I imagine, but he never actually told me who they were - and told me that my health problems were all due to childbirth and nothing to worry about. He got a bit shirty when I told him that the last time I had looked I hadn't actually had any children. His acolytes were all smirking though!

OverTheRubicon · 16/12/2020 16:34

My lovely consultant nearly killed me. Brusque and rude consultant saved me life and sorted me out completely.

It's not all about people skills, and having relatives who are nurses as well as consultants, all are stretched but often consultants have far greater responsibility as well as physically impossible tasks, it's an insane amount of stress, especially right now.

Give people a break.

formerbabe · 16/12/2020 16:31

The last one I had to see for my dd was pretty brisk and charmless, although completely professional and competent. The latter matters more to me.

bigbluebus · 16/12/2020 16:31

I remember when DS was a baby and had severe eczema, which the GP couldn't get under control, we decided to go privately to see a dermatologist. The GP recommended someone at the local private hospital whilst at the same time telling me who to avoid on account of his poor manner and attitude. When I remarked that surely he wouldn't be rude to his private patients she replied " don't bank on it". When I rang to make the private appointment there was a 6 week wait to see lovely consultant but rude consultant could (not surprisingly) fit us in the following week!

CMOTDibbler · 16/12/2020 16:30

I get to meet a huge number of consultants through my work, all over the world.
For some of them, they come across as rude/uncaring just because they are trying to juggle a huge amount of technical information about their patients diagnosis and treatment and are trying to sort all of that out along with many other patients.
Some need to have an absolute laser focus on their job because it is the only way to be - you don't want a neuro interventional radiologist who is thinking about anything else, and tbh its not a speciality you go into if you are a people person.
Some have just told people bad stuff so many times that it almost is self protection, or they forget that it is someones life (other HCPs aren't immune, I met a number of midwives who were totally lacking in empathy about miscarriage, it was just normal to them).
And some are just rude people.
And some are absolutely lovely, genuinely fighting everyday for their patients, and working insane hours to improve outcomes

Viviennemary · 16/12/2020 16:28

It seems to have become a sort of tradition now.

staydazzling · 16/12/2020 16:27

Oh god surgeons!, my eldest, after i had specifically asked in my notes for no male medical students! a surgeon strolled in after id had a propess, with a male med student to feel an engaged baby on a higher bmi Angry yep, no please or thank you, hands on my vag area, husband not in the room Angry, i paged the midwife and said do not let him near me again, i was shaking AngrySad

OP posts:
Bells3032 · 16/12/2020 16:23

Between my family and myself i have dealt with hundreds of consultants. only two would i say were rude. Doctors are humans, some are great and some of assholes like in any other career

ethelredonagoodday · 16/12/2020 16:22

I have quite a few friends who are hospital consultants and who are lovely, fun people in a personal capacity. I'd be hard pushed to imagine they're awful professionally but you never know! I do know though that even before COVID they were all spread extremely thinly, trying to do their best in difficult circumstances. They all work ridiculous hours and are extremely dedicated to their jobs, all whilst also trying to be good parents, further their careers, and avoid being sued!!! So if they are occasionally stroppy I can understand why.

iwasacceptableinthe80s · 16/12/2020 16:21

@DougRossIsTheBoss this was nearly 30 years ago, and it was stopped around that time. I think it was an old traditional perk that one or two used to blatantly abuse.

HelplessProcrastinator · 16/12/2020 16:16

I work in a department in the NHS that has involvement with most clinical departments. Most consultants are great, ED are the nicest in my experience. A few are so rude and borderline bullies that I absolutely dread dealing with them. I’m told by the nurses their patients love them. I don’t but the autism excuse. They must have been polite to their superiors when they were coming up through the ranks so why so rude when they hit consultant?

The majority of consultants I deal with are great, a few are rude. I never come across rudeness from nurses, lab staff, AHPs, pharmacists etc.

Ginfilledcats · 16/12/2020 16:15

I've found, that much like regular people, some are rude and some are not. Some have superiority complexes it's true, but that's true of some people in any walk of life 🤷🏻‍♀️.

WillSantaBeComingToTown · 16/12/2020 16:07

A fair number probably have undiagnosed autism- clever and very focused but lack social skills- often under diagnosed particularly in women.

MrsSugar · 16/12/2020 16:05

Hmm.... I’m a secretary to one and I wouldn’t say this was true. As in all jobs u get some rude/arrogant people but that’s life I get.

Used to be an old joke... what’s the difference between god and a consultant ?
God doesn’t think he is a consultant lol

But overall I’d say most consultants I’ve worked with are very nice and appreciative of all other staff

MonkeyPuddle · 16/12/2020 16:05

I think it’s much of a muchness across different sectors with seniority and entrenched hierarchy. I used to be a scrub nurse in theatres and 99% of the consultants were lovely. Demanding, to the point, expected high standards and efficiency, it could come across as rude, but frankly they were doing an incredibly specialised job with utterly soul destroying work loads plus additional responsibilities so I generally cut them massive slack if they were a bit sharp tongued during surgery occasionally. Because if I was a patient I would want a consultant with the same standards.
Saying that, if they were repeatedly rude/brusque then I would inform them, I have a lot of respect for the level and duration of study and experience they have but I won’t be spoken to like shit.

ChocBeforeCock · 16/12/2020 15:55

But honestly I think it is like any job. You will get a range of people with different personalities and manners

Exactly. I think saying consultants are rude is a really lazy generalisation.

I’m married to one, a surgeon working all the hours God sends at the moment to get as many of his operations (mainly cancer) as possible done with reduced lists available. I do hope he isn’t rude to his patients, but he has barely seen his children for weeks so he can provide the best care he can in difficult circumstances. So if he is rude, I’m sure he would be in a much better mood if he cancelled operations that wouldn’t finish before 6 so he got home on time and was less knackered, but I doubt his patients would want that.

I’ve only been treated by a handful of consultants and some were more personable than others, but none have been rude. I don’t doubt that some are rude, as with any profession.

DougRossIsTheBoss · 16/12/2020 15:53

Wait I can get lobster!!
No-one ever told me that

My usual lunch is nothing at all
I've been doing 16:8 way before it was a thing just because I am not organised enough to bring lunch and don't have time to buy it.
There's always something that seems a higher priority than eating.

There hasn't been a staff dining room at all at any hospital I've ever worked in. There's just a roped off area to sit in with the same food options that the general public have and the same prices as far as I know.

ashmts · 16/12/2020 15:50

Because they're the most senior clinicians. It's not even active rudeness, consultants just don't tend to acknowledge staff that are junior unless they're working with them. Like someone returning clean equipment, there's no need for the consultant to interact with them so they likely won't. The NHS is so hierarchical. I'm a HCP and occasionally a consultant would approach me with a query but otherwise we just exist in the same space.

You do get rude/arrogant ones and you do get lovely ones. Most are somewhere in the middle.

CorianderQueen · 16/12/2020 15:50

My consultants have always been very polite and understanding.

However my sisters a doctor and says most of them are self important arseholes because there are two types of people who do medicine - those who want to help others and those who want status. The latter often grow into what she calls Dr Dickheads.

Sinful8 · 16/12/2020 15:38

@iwasacceptableinthe80s

I think the God complex is fairly common. An ex of mine is now a consultant, and although I'm not still in touch with him, I do know a member of the senior nursing staff who worked with him on wards and in theatre. He said my ex has a reputation as a real cunt. When I knew him he was lovely, very mild mannered and not at all arrogant. I also know someone who was a chef at one of the biggest hospitals in the Uk about 25 years ago. It's probably not the case now, but at that time, the rule was that the surgeons and consultants could demand to be prepared absolutely any food. If they wanted lobster, they got lobster, served in a private dining room. Outrageous really.
Of course that's the rule...Hmm