Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why consultants have a reputation of being so rude???

234 replies

staydazzling · 16/12/2020 14:13

Been in hospital a few days, nurses, midwifes, auxiliary, care staff all very keen to do their best in hard circumstances always trying to help, largely on time etc, I sadly couldn't say the same for the consultants /surgeons sadly not just in terms of taking literally hours to turn but also how i saw them speak to said, nurses, midwifes, care staff etc and patients.
I jokingly mentioned this to a relative who works cleaning and sterlising equipment, who said yes its well known sadly, your lucky if any move or say thank you for returned equipment, i just wondered why is this a thing, AIBU to wonder where did that culture of behaviour come from?

OP posts:
DuchenneParent · 16/12/2020 17:48

We see three different consultants for my DS. One is our local consultant, one is at a world leading clinic for his condition we have to travel to, and the other is a also a very well regarded professor we see for a clinical trial he is on.

Ironically, the local consultant we see completely fits the bill you are talking about and honestly can come across as quite rude and dismissive. OTOH, the other two, who should have all the more reason to think themselves 'superior' because they are well known in their field, are absolutely wonderful, down to earth and kind people.

DougRossIsTheBoss · 16/12/2020 17:45

When we have a vacancy and are looking to employ a new consultant we very likely know them or know someone who knows them because it's a small world.

If they are known to be an arsehole we'll try to give them a swerve because the rest of us have to work with them so fellow consultants and hospital mangers generally do prefer to employ people who are pleasant.
For our own sake as well as for patients.

I have known some clever Drs who effectively did get blacklisted for arsey behaviour as trainees and found it hard to get consultant appts but the reality is that if you are qualified someone is going to employ you because we don't have any spare trained consultants!

These days there is a lot more feedback with appraisal and revalidation so you'd hope that people with poor communication skills would get that feedback and improve.

DougRossIsTheBoss · 16/12/2020 17:38

Yeh I think if you are not nice you are probably hugely talented or something to compensate or why would anyone employ you?

I know colleagues who have a bit of a shit bedside manner but are really really clever and skilled and colleagues who are absolutely charming and delightful and loved by all patients but I privately don't rate them clinically (not incompetent or anything just not as good as some)

Obviously I am clever and skilled and charming and not in the least bit arrogant as you can tell Wink

Sirzy · 16/12/2020 17:37

Ds is currently under five consultants and all are different levels of amazing

I can only think of one of very very many he has seen that hasn’t been lovely

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/12/2020 17:35

I think sometimes you see them once and think they are a bit humourless or distant.

I had one like this, but as I’ve got to know him he’s got a really dry sense of humour and is lovely.

Bubblewhatbubble · 16/12/2020 17:35

Yes, @DougRossIsTheBoss, you can have some Flowers as well. Get well soon.

PrawnofthePatriarchy · 16/12/2020 17:31

I worked with consultants and professors for quite a few years and I IME most of them were charming ans lovely. The ones who weren't really stuck out.

This makes sense when you consider that getting promotion in medicine is partly linked to whether your bosses and colleagues (and your patients Grin) actually like you.

DougRossIsTheBoss · 16/12/2020 17:29
Grin
Audreyseyebrows · 16/12/2020 17:29

I’m really lucky to work with a number of amazing consultants.

oneglassandpuzzled · 16/12/2020 17:28

🦞 for @DougRossIsTheBoss

DougRossIsTheBoss · 16/12/2020 17:25

Why thank you 🙏

MonkeyPuddle · 16/12/2020 17:23

@DougRossIsTheBossWinefor you.

viques · 16/12/2020 17:23

The worst one I ever met was at a one stop breast clinic. I saw about four doctors that morning, three of them were lovely and recognised they were seeing a room full of very worried women. Mr Scan did not say hello, did not speak to me, explain what he was doing, or what he could see as he wizzed his scanny thing over my suspect breast. Eventually the nurse leaned over and told me I could leave, I made sure I went right up to Mr Scan as he looked at his screen and said, “ thankyou for seeing me, it’s been really lovely to meet you” . He looked confused, I don’t think he thought women with lumps on their tits could speak. The nurse smiled and winked at me.

It was a cyst btw. One of the nice people drained it.

OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 16/12/2020 17:22

Weird that how some people are nice and others aren’t?
I had a lovely consultant, he’s retired now sadly, but always had time, if he saw you in the department he’d stop and chat to you by name (amazing as he’s a world leader in the field and incredibly busy). My mums orthopaedic and Gaston consults on the other hand were a pair of walking stereo type. Rude, dismissive, patronising.

DougRossIsTheBoss · 16/12/2020 17:22

I think that is true that you need to project confidence and maybe that looks arrogant sometimes

No-one wants the consultant to look/ be unsure of the decision in an emergency or serious scenario. It's been debated, opinions vary then all eyes turn to you 'what's the decision'. You have to say confidently 'this is the plan'

I mean you should ideally do that after you have listened and by consensus but if there's no time then they just need to do as you say and not ask qs.

Sometimes I do not believe in myself as much as I put out but it would be damaging for the team to know that.

Sedlescombe · 16/12/2020 17:12

There is a certain ring of truth to that joke about what’s the difference between god and a consultant ...god doesn’t think he is a consultant. In practice they have all the same foibles as the rest of us both good and bad and the nature of the role demands a huge level of confidence in your own judgement. Easy to see how that can tip over into arrogance in some

DougRossIsTheBoss · 16/12/2020 17:11

We are definitely accountable

To the GMC ultimately
To the hospital trust as our employer
And the chief executive, medical director and head of department underneath that
Work rate and outcomes are increasingly scrutinised as well as patient satisfaction
We are required to collect patient and colleague feedback for revalidation and to have annual appraisal
Whilst there is a fair bit of freedom (as surely there should be for very highly trained people) If you are not practising to NICE guidance, up to date evidence and local policy them questions will be asked.

Things are a lot more regulated than they were 5 or 10 years ago.

malificent7 · 16/12/2020 17:09

I work in a hospital and most are lovely and excellent at teaching/ explaining things.

Bubblewhatbubble · 16/12/2020 17:09

@DougRossIsTheBoss
I can imagine that's true. I was rather thinking of a male consultant intimidating an obviously under-confident, conscientious and anxious woman registrar, which seemed pretty unfair.

Bubblewhatbubble · 16/12/2020 17:06

@BeautyGoesToBenidorm
That's truly shocking. I get that it must be a particularly difficult and stressful specialty (and underfunded and without necessarily a lot to feel optimistic about) but given how sensitive patients are in that situation it's inexcusable to behave like that.

SummerBaby2020 · 16/12/2020 17:04

My consultant was actually amazing when I was pregnant I can not recommend him enough.

With everything that’s happened this year I had no midwife appointments apart from my booking in app. As this was my first baby and knew about the no midwife apps, he always made me feel at ease, had me laughing, spoke to me like a human not a pregnant lady, called me several times not for anything other than to check in and see how me and bump were doing was there anything I needed or did I need him to explain anything and when I had my dd, he was doing the rounds on the ward and came and seen us both. Absolutely amazing guy and every other women I’ve spoken to who has had him has said the same. They are definitely not all bad.

Googlebrained · 16/12/2020 17:03

I guess that short of doing something actually dangerous or incompetent, they're not really accountable to anyone. For some people that makes them arrogant and unbearable.

Also the training doesn't help, they start off as the lowest of the low, and it takes a lot of ring kissing and hard graft before they reach the top. Meanwhile they may encounter unpleasant consultants themselves and think that's how they're supposed to be.

DougRossIsTheBoss · 16/12/2020 17:01

Having a hopeless junior Dr is very stressful because

A) you have more work yourself because you have to keep a close eye on them and invest time and effort bringing them up to standard

B) you constantly fear they may make a bad error and at the least damage your reputation, cause complaints or worst harm someone so you are on edge watching out for it

If they are really bad and are under some kind of GMC conditions or local conditions then a tonne of paperwork and assessments are required (good thing for patient safety, bad thing for efficiency)

OTOH if you have good trustworthy juniors it is marvellous. Either way you can only keep them for 6 months and then it's Russian roulette who you get next.

I am generally not known for shouting but some icy sarcasm or just resigned sighing may happen if under pressure and not very good junior ballses something up that I have to rescue or just doesn't do the job at all.

BeautyGoesToBenidorm · 16/12/2020 16:57

I used to work with a consultant psychiatrist who was a complete and total arsehole. 'God complex' doesn't even cover it - he was utterly vile.

Diagnostically, he was excellent. Yet never a day went by without at least 3 service users leaving his office in tears.

HollyandIvyandallthingsYule · 16/12/2020 16:54

This has never been my experience, and I have had a lot of dealings with hospitals.

Every consultant without exception has been great. Can’t say the same for nurses or doctors, although on the whole they, too, have been great.