Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why consultants have a reputation of being so rude???

234 replies

staydazzling · 16/12/2020 14:13

Been in hospital a few days, nurses, midwifes, auxiliary, care staff all very keen to do their best in hard circumstances always trying to help, largely on time etc, I sadly couldn't say the same for the consultants /surgeons sadly not just in terms of taking literally hours to turn but also how i saw them speak to said, nurses, midwifes, care staff etc and patients.
I jokingly mentioned this to a relative who works cleaning and sterlising equipment, who said yes its well known sadly, your lucky if any move or say thank you for returned equipment, i just wondered why is this a thing, AIBU to wonder where did that culture of behaviour come from?

OP posts:
Letshavesometea · 17/12/2020 04:10

I've had dealings with a few and have found they were more blunt and straight to the point, than rude. Though very efficient regarding testing and care which is what I care about the most. One I came across seemed to be excellent at his job but very blunt as if he simply didn't have the time and was spread thin between others in the clinic.

FangsForTheMemory · 17/12/2020 03:59

I used to have a consultant whom I also knew in a professional capacity. While I was his patient he was charm itself to me. To work with, he was appalling.

Lofari · 17/12/2020 02:41

You get arseholes in all walks of life.
The consultant we see for my DD is lovely. Professional, but takes the time to make her smile and chat with her too.
The consultant we see for my DS I had to report. She was beyond unprofessional and really affected my mental health.

Pyewhacket · 17/12/2020 01:26

I have to work with them and some can be real so-and-so’s, especially surgeons. Saying that, the guy who runs our part of the hospital ( I work in critical care ) is the opposite, he always has time to talk to and encourage even the most junior staff. But yes, I’ve been shouted at and been referred to as just a “bum wiper “. You have to have a. thick skin sometimes. It’s the patients that count and I’ve seen surgeons save the life of somebody run-over by a cement mixer.

RightYesButNo · 17/12/2020 01:23

I’m not sure, but perhaps I can offer a unique point of view.

I have a condition that means I often end up in A&E for a certain kind of blood test as it has to be drawn from an artery and is the only way to ensure things are all right when I’m poorly. So I end up seeing just about every consultant from the local neurology department eventually when they’re doing their “turn” either covering A&E or the hospital, at one time or another. But THEN, I usually end up seeing them at some point in the regular neurology office, during the treatment of my condition. So I see the difference between when they’re working A&E and hospital on-call versus when they’re doing regular neurology appointments and the same consultant can be a completely different person. I mean, of course; an 8-9 hour day of appointments with a scheduled lunch, versus maybe a 24+ hour on-call shift for strokes and all sorts with possibly not even time for the toilet, are going to produce very different attitudes. I had one consultant not recognize me (I wasn’t offended) even though he’d seen me less than a week previously.

When I’m dealing with a consultant, I always ask myself: are they being rude, or just blunt? Are they being rude, or just short? Are they being rude, or just seem exhausted? Yes, I understand they have a duty of care to me, but they’re human as well, so unless they’re truly being arseholes, I try to be a bit understanding. And obviously, some of them are just arseholes, and that’s life, like any other profession. If they’re intentionally demeaning or misogynistic or cruel, though, of course there’s no excuse, and I would report them just as I would anyone else.

DougRossIsTheBoss · 17/12/2020 01:02

If he really has lied about qualifications then the GMC will be interested. That is exactly what people get struck off for. It's pretty easy to ring up and report and info on a website is easily provable one way or another.

PALS will always take and investigate a complaint. I mean they investigated a complaint that my 'dress was too bright and hurt the persons eyes' on one occasion. I mean I doubt the person was satisfied with the outcome but it was investigated. Literally no complaint is ever dismissed wholesale.

The mention of website makes me wonder if this is private practice though which will have less accountability structures than NHS on the whole. GMC still applies to all.

LightDrizzle · 17/12/2020 01:01

Oops! Malcolm Levene*

LightDrizzle · 17/12/2020 00:58

Can I shout out for Professor Malcolm Levine being an absolute darling? As well as being terribly august. It’s been at least 15 years since we last saw him but I will never forget his kindness in very dark times.
It matters and it makes a difference.

SleepingStandingUp · 17/12/2020 00:57

I know quite a few consultants have answered all of any of you work at BCH, you rock. The rest of your are alright 😂

dhisreadingmypostsagain · 17/12/2020 00:53

I've met a fair few and I'd say I've only met one real arsehole he's in women's health and honestly shouldn't be, he's lied on his website about his surgical skills and seems above the law when I complained about his conduct in my appointment. I literally can't get anywhere in the system to listen to a serious complaint.

LightDrizzle · 17/12/2020 00:48

My own experience has been very different. I’ve met lots of consultants as the parent of a very ill neonate and later very disabled complex child; as a patient myself; and more recently ferrying my elderly mum to many and varied appointments. I’ve found consultants to be disproportionately nice with excellent interpersonal skills.
I thought the old Sir Lancelot Spratt type was extinct.
My worst experiences have been with a small minority of ward nurses and non-nursing ward staff. I’ve found the more senior the nurse the better in general, even to the extent of doing menial tasks to make patients comfortable when less qualified ward staff refused (getting pillows, or cereal for patients who’ve missed meals through being off ward through no fault if their own). I’ve occasionally felt junior doctors have reacted defensively to questions I’ve put to them and been prickly, which I think is borne of insecurity. I was never questioning critically but in order to understand, I think more experienced and confident doctors get this and I have been very grateful for the time these very busy people have taken to explain .

Summerdayshaze · 17/12/2020 00:44

I love them. Never had a bad one. From psychiatrists to oncologists to surgeons.

lovelemoncurd · 17/12/2020 00:42

They can be difficult and can be good fun too. I worked as a senior sister and matron for a few years and some of the hardest days were when I had to battle with consultants. However, when I was leaving the very ones who had given me the hardest of times were the ones asking me to stay. They quite often just want the best for patients but quite often would forget that we are all on the same side.

trixiebelden77 · 17/12/2020 00:37

We’re people, the same as anyone else. There is a range of behaviors, as with any other group of normal people.

I find the idea that doctors are a specific type really odd. Why would we not be people with a range of characteristics?

As it happens, by far the worst and rudest behaviour and the worst incidents of bullying I’ve witnessed in 15 years have not been from medical staff.....

Goodness sneakysnoopysniper, I’m sure you were met with rounds of applause and shouts of ‘huzzah for the truth teller’ for that outburst which definitely happened and isn’t at all a fantastical retelling of you being very much less bolshy in reality.

thosetalesofunexpected · 17/12/2020 00:31

@DougRossIsTheBoss.

Hope you get well soon.
Take care of yourself DaffodilBrewCake

olympicsrock · 17/12/2020 00:27

I am a senior registrar in surgery in a specialty where little thing matter hugely. I make a point of being kind and polite to colleagues and patients. Occasionally I get a bit Curt with junior doctors if they have been lazy ( rare) or not done something really important that has endangered my patient. I really care about my patients and get annoyed if Patient care is not excellent.
Like everyone else there are good doctors and bad doctors but no one is at their best when stressed or overworked.

SleepingStandingUp · 17/12/2020 00:20

Exactly @jacks11. People are rude, some are now ride by a sense of superiority or power but they're probably still be rude if they were making your coffee in the local cafe.

I had a sonographer so rude he nearly got smacked by me AND my lovely nurse.

Acidrain · 17/12/2020 00:16

The only consultatant I have ever dealt with saved me and my sons life. He was a grade A prick it felt like but he saved our lives, so I wasn't to bothered about his bedside manners at the time.
Spoke to him later after the operation and thanked him for saving our lives and he was still a tosser but all the same, still grateful.

sneakysnoopysniper · 17/12/2020 00:13

A few years ago I was advised by surgery to go to A&E because of low blood count. All the lower level people who attended to me had a name tag with their position and introduced themselves. They also told me what they were about to do (take blood, do an ECG etc). So no complaints about any of them.

At a later stage a young man in a short overall appeared and started ordering everyone about. He hardly spoke to me. Then it became apparent that they were intending to admit me. I was quite angry and asked the young man his function. He said he was the A&E consultant.

I told him "Well what happened to professional courtesy? You could have said, Hello Im MR X the A&E consultant, and we think it would be best if we admitted you because XXX. Instead you have not even introduced yourself or explained the procedure."

He appeared open mouthed at being spoken to like this, especially when I went on to inform him that I did not consent to being admitted and insisted on coming back the next day fort whatever treatment was needed.

My nephew then proceeded to inform him that his aunt had several degrees, including a Ph.D and was probably better qualified than he was.

Why do these people think they are gods? If they want respect then they should behave in a courteous and professional manner.

jacks11 · 17/12/2020 00:12

Helplessprocastinator

I think you may have been very lucky then, to work in such a harmonious place. I think it is extremely unlikely that of all professions involved in healthcare, it is only doctors- and in deed, even within that profession mainly one group (consultants) who have been rude. I think it’s a bit of generalisation and, frankly, unfair.

I’ll admit a possible bias as I’m a consultant- I have many flaws (as do we all) but I don’t think rudeness is one of them. I think, like most professions, there is a spectrum of personalities with a spectrum of strengths and weaknesses- rudeness being one of them. I think it’s a lazy generalisation that only doctors are rude.

Of course, I have met the odd rude consultant in my time. I have also met a number of rude nurses, a couple of midwives who were renowned for being difficult and one clinical pharmacist was known for being “tricky” when I was a junior doctor. I’ve also encountered sonographers, physios, lab staff, HCA’s, porters and people working in medical records who were definitely rude. I am astounded that you work in an NHS setting and the only people who are anything but lovely or wonderful to you and everyone around them has been a consultant.

IdblowJonSnow · 17/12/2020 00:07

No one can say all consultants are rude, of course.
However, I've met more than my fair share over the years and a disproportionate amount were extremely arrogant and superior in their attitude.

As for being super busy, well many of us are, it doesn't give anyone the right to talk down to someone, particularly if they are ill/elderly/anxious/vulnerable etc., which many patients seeing a consultant would be.

I think many have had years of people looking up to them as it's such highly regarded position and become entitled and arrogant.

SleepingStandingUp · 17/12/2020 00:05

And in balance I've had the odd god damn awful nurse and a snarky anaesthetist

yelyah22 · 17/12/2020 00:01

I worked with consultants professionally and the two I saw most often were both really rude, but we worked in addiction services and I got the feeling they were being rude about the clients rather than generally.

But in a personal setting every consultant I've ever met was lovely. Even the surgeon! 😏

SleepingStandingUp · 17/12/2020 00:01

I've had lots of experience of paediatric surgeons and consultants rather than adult ones. I'd say the surgeons are worse for their attitude. I owe them my son's life, several times over so i don't mean that disrespectfully but it's true. I've seen a surgeon ball out a nurse for the patients l not being on the state they wanted them in front of not just me the parent but other staff. Yet he let me stand in his office and scream and shout at him without uttering a word in rebuttal or in anyway it affecting our care.

I had one consultant on Picu who everyone knew was a total bitch and she was an insensitive frigging cow to the parents too. Yet we got admitted to PICU 10 months later under less life and death circumstances and she remembered us, came over to say hi, comment on how well he was doing (she'd stood at the Ned of my bed reading off a tick list of possible consequences of a genetic diagnosis when he was 4 weeks old, had told me to stop crying and pull myself together rather harshly when he was still in the night not live days, had balled out junior doctors for DS being too sedated etc) and yet was here, genuinely thrilled to see us.

So I think sometimes it's just about what side of them you see. We have some truly lovely consultants

ThatsAllFolks · 16/12/2020 23:55

Nearly all of the ones I met have been rude. Maybe they don't see me as a person? I fear for the vulnerable.