Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why consultants have a reputation of being so rude???

234 replies

staydazzling · 16/12/2020 14:13

Been in hospital a few days, nurses, midwifes, auxiliary, care staff all very keen to do their best in hard circumstances always trying to help, largely on time etc, I sadly couldn't say the same for the consultants /surgeons sadly not just in terms of taking literally hours to turn but also how i saw them speak to said, nurses, midwifes, care staff etc and patients.
I jokingly mentioned this to a relative who works cleaning and sterlising equipment, who said yes its well known sadly, your lucky if any move or say thank you for returned equipment, i just wondered why is this a thing, AIBU to wonder where did that culture of behaviour come from?

OP posts:
noworklifebalance · 17/12/2020 11:13

Whilst they are not god, they are certainly interfering with the course of nature. This goes for nurses, midwives etc, too and this is bound to mess with your head. The consequences of decisions can be immense. May explain why midwives are also mentioned as being very rude.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/12/2020 11:07

I find the consultants at children’s A and E the best in the world.

unmarkedbythat · 17/12/2020 10:38

There are 12 consultant psychiatrists at my place of work and 9 of them do indeed think they are Very Special and Important People. That said, I would trust each and every one of them with the care of my children, my husband, myself if I needed it, and can forgive a little arrogance and impoliteness because when it matters they will work their Very Special and Important behinds off and I have seen the pain behind the façade of arrogance when a tragedy happens. You need a certain level of confidence to be a consultant.

RosesAndHellebores · 17/12/2020 10:15

Penultimate para: all too often those within the NHS think they are providing a free service. It is only free at the point of delivery

RosesAndHellebores · 17/12/2020 10:09

I have met some lovely consultants and some absolute stinkers. On the whole in percentage terms I have met far more rude nurses than Drs or consultants, midwives being the very worst. Paradoxically, I'd say that registrars have on the whole been ruder than consultants. I shall never forget three in particular:

The first in a cli ic when ds was a baby and seemed to have intractable asthma "you all turn up late and now you are all here at once". I wasn't late but did walk out and have him referred privately to The Brompton. Best thing I ever did so actually she did me a favour.

The second in hospital with 7 month old dd who had bronchiolitis who stood over me demanding to know how much milk she was taking and would not accept that I couldn't possibly know how many ounces she was drinking as breaststroke didn't work like that. I saw her again in clinic weeks later and she remembered me. At that time I hadn't been without sleep for three days and was able to have a sensible conversation about the fact that breasts weren't calibrated.

The registrar when I was being induced with dd who came to examine me and put down a tray with instruments and when I said, if you are going to mechanically break my waters as well as examine me I wish to have a conversation about it first who said "if you think you know more about this than me I won't touch you"and walked out. To be fair the midwife was very apologetic and suggested the shifts would change soon and the next one was nicer. As it was my waters ruptured naturally a few hours later.

One consultant really got my goat though. DD had a gynae problem and I had her referred privately to supposedly the best gynae consultant in the area. The hospital website said clinic hours were 4pm to 7pm and I asked for an appointment as late as possible because I worked full time (that was one reason we had private cover). The hospital rang back the next day to say that Miss x didn't like having her time wasted so if patients didn't book in before me they would move dd's appointment forward. Such a last minute change was not possible for a professional parent and they just said it was the consultant's rule not theirs. Therefore I rang her secretary on the number quoted on the BUPA website and was bollocking for calling her as she was an NHS resource and didn't have time to waste on Miss x's private patients. I cancelled and found another consultant at a neighbouring private hospital - an absolutely delightful woman. What took the biscuit was that just post surgery the other hospital phoned me to say Miss x wanted to know why I we hadn't attended and why we had wasted her time. I had cancelled the appointment. I did write a letter of complaint and actually got a very nice and apologetic reply saying she would review her practices. However of concern was the fact that she was also a member of the local hospital's senior leadership team.

Overall I think there is an imbalance in the way the NHS is set up and it doesn't necessarily always benefit standards of customer care. It is free at the point of delivery and there is therefore no impetus for NHS staff to always be polite because at the end of the day they are not reliant on the patient paying the bill. I work in the public sector but know if I were as rude as hip's sometimes are my job would be at risk. DH spent the majority of his career as a commercial lawyer and I know that had he been as rude as many HCPs are his client would not have settled their bill.

And finally as so many Drs are on this thread, please use patients' names. If you introduce yourself as Dr or Mr or Miss please do not expect me to afford you the courtesy of a title when invariably you and your staff use my first name and do so without asking. Of course my first name may be used but only if you invite me to use yours. To do otherwise is an act of passive aggression and it is embedded further when the staff around you call you Dr or Miss or Mrs and in the same breath use my first name. No patient is subordinate to any Dr and all stakeholders in care should be afforded equality. It is a situation that underpins poor service and considering how much the NHS spends on equality & diversity and the trees that are felled in its name to facilitate report after report leaves me agog that a simple matter of basic courtesy continues to prevail.

We have a home in France and it is a much better system. In all our interactions there there has never been the air that one must be grateful for a free service - because it isn't. Money changes hands but all to often those within the NHS think it is only free at the point of delivery.

Having said all that I have met some excellent and wonderful drs and equally make a point of ensuring a thank you letter is sent when care has been very good and services have been delivered well.

Elsiebear90 · 17/12/2020 08:58

I work with them, most of them are okay, some are really nice, some are horrible, they’re very different with their own patients though, very pleasant, polite, compassionate, can’t do enough for them, with (some) staff they see as not worthy of their respect I.e. nurses, technicians, radiographers etc., they’re rude, abrupt, have no patience, hypercritical, unprofessional at times, patronising etc.

I don’t think it’s stress since they can turn it off and on, I think it’s narcissism tbh. If they don’t care whether you like them as there’s nothing in it for them either way, they don’t treat you with respect. Their “niceness” is something they perform for certain people when it benefits them, like their own patients and other consultants.

parallax80 · 17/12/2020 08:58

FWIW my mum still doesn’t realise I’m a doctor...

(I’m a dual qualified anaesthetist / intensivist)

dontdisturbmenow · 17/12/2020 08:58

What I dread when I see a new consultant or GP is when they assume I'm totally ignorant of medicine and my health condition and treat me like at year old wasting appointment time telling me things I already know.

I get that with any new GP until they get to know me and it becomes more a case of me 'what can I do for you today' and we can go I to discussing the details of my circumstances. It's more difficult with a consultant who I only see once.

Some are great though and will start the consultation by listening, other will look at their notes, and either do the examination without saying a word or will just indeed just say things I know already which feels a complete waste of my time.

DougRossIsTheBoss · 17/12/2020 08:57

Well as I said in my first post consultant is a grade of Dr

So some anaesthetists are consultants and some are not (because they are staff grades or trainees)

That's why the whole premise of this OP is just weird. It suggests Drs are OK until the day they make consultant and then become arseholes. Plus it lumps a tonne of different specialties together as being all the same.
If you didn't realise anaesthetists can be consultants what about pathologists? Radiologists?

There is no logical explanation for OPs assertion

What is more likely is
Some consultants are lovely and some are horrid
You expect consultants to be superior and intimidating so you find them so (I know this because people started to treat ME differently when I became a consultant or are surprised to find I am one)
You believe outdated Lancelot Spratt stereotypes from the 1950s
You recall instances that fit with this popular narrative and not those that don't.
You have expectations that don't fit with the consultants job role eg OP does not appear to get why the consultant might be less available on the ward than the HCA

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/12/2020 08:55

I’ve only ever met delightful anaesthetist. All lovely.

When l had Dd by section the anaesthetist was just so so lovely.

ApolloandDaphne · 17/12/2020 08:51

My friend is a consultant diabetologist. She is very lovely, however heaven help you if you are not sticking to your treatment plan! She can be stern when she needs to be.

SleepingStandingUp · 17/12/2020 08:48

Somewhere

SleepingStandingUp · 17/12/2020 08:48

Exotic

SleepingStandingUp · 17/12/2020 08:47

My favourite one ran away to see here exotoc like Dubai 😭

LikeTheFruit · 17/12/2020 08:46

Definitely fit into consultant category. Sorry, general population are usually unaware that anaesthetics are doctors too (and a lot of hospital staff too) become a little wearing after a while.

SleepingStandingUp · 17/12/2020 08:44

I knew they were doctors but hadn't put them in the consultant category.

LikeTheFruit · 17/12/2020 08:42

@SleepingStandingUp

And in balance I've had the odd god damn awful nurse and a snarky anaesthetist
Anaesthetists are consultants too. Still doctors.
Imapotato · 17/12/2020 07:23

I work in a hospital in an AHP role. In my experience, consultants are humans, some are nice and some are not so nice, just like the rest of the population.

The consultant on our ward currently is a bit grumpy. I know he strikes fear into the heart of the junior doctor working with him. He’s always been polite to me though and as far as I have noticed he’s not bad with the patients either. Just a bit scary to the doctors working under him.

Oysterbabe · 17/12/2020 07:09

My DD's consultant is a miserable cow. She's been treating her since she was born and now she's 5. I don't think l she has spoken to her once, only speaks to me about her. Everyone else at the hospital is great with engaging with her but not her consultant. Maybe I'm expecting too much that she should actually talk to her patient. She also snapped at a nurse and sent her scurrying away when she was just trying to do her job.

inquietant · 17/12/2020 07:08

I have worked with this sort of staff and I would say there is a tendency towards being 'difficult'. They were all different, ranging from lovely to Shock.

If someone is the top x in the region, they do have more scope to be rude without fear of getting sacked.

I am, sadly, more replaceable!

phoenixrosehere · 17/12/2020 07:03

They are a mixed bag but the ones I met during my first pregnancy put me off consultant-led care for my second one. The team I was under was rude, things were done without my consent wasn’t even asked. Others a part of the same team coerced me into an induction that wasn’t needed nor should have been mentioned (found out after I reported my care) and when I did question it and ask for more evidence of its necessity beforehand all I was told was that I was killing my baby by not going through with it despite all my tests coming back normal. It ended in an emergency c-section and a blue baby which we also weren’t told until we told them our experience. He is a SEN child. Another one yelled at us because she wanted my room while in labour even though no decision had been made or the one who yelled at my husband in front of me and other hcp because he asked her a question that I couldn’t ask (was in the middle of an contraction). I heard she was pushed into early retirement. Heard from other women that they had similar issues with consultants at the same hospital.

Second time around, had one consultant ignore my notes (if he even bothered to look at them) to try to coerce me into taking a test which I knew all about from my last pregnancy and had issues with. I had talked to the consultant midwife who had agreed it was better to take a different test which would have been more accurate. Funny enough, the consultant midwife and I had just discussed the seminars they were having about consent and pregnant women being able to make their own decisions. Thankfully, the rest of the consultants I did encounter were amazing. They listened, offered alternatives, and pregnancy was smooth compared to the last one.

user1494050295 · 17/12/2020 06:53

What’s the difference between God and a consultant? God doesn’t think he is a consultant

OverTheRainbow88 · 17/12/2020 06:36

I’ve got a heart consultant who is lovely and friendly and funny. However, when he talks to other workers it’s pretty bantery and can come across as quite arrogant, IMO.

Scolha · 17/12/2020 06:18

Depends. Some of them are really stressed and overworked.
The consultants I work with are really lovely and so passionate about what they do, I really admire their work. One even gave me her spare lunch delivery a couple of times.

PhilCornwall1 · 17/12/2020 04:38

I've seen a few consultants in my time and it's been a bit mixed.

I had surgery about 4 years ago and the Consultant was an arrogant prat who treated people like shit. Took great pleasure in telling him he was.

The consultant that removed my thyroid was really nice and just different to any I'd seen before. My GP knew him well and said the hospital saw him as a bit of a maverick and didn't know how to handle him. He smoked like a train in his office and did his own thing. He was also well known for being a brilliant surgeon.

The consultant I see now (well did until the gift that keeps on giving came along) is a very nice person too. He treats you as an equal, listens to you and never rushes you. My wife came to my last appointment and he gave her just as much of his time as me. I can't speak highly enough of him. Top man!