Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why consultants have a reputation of being so rude???

234 replies

staydazzling · 16/12/2020 14:13

Been in hospital a few days, nurses, midwifes, auxiliary, care staff all very keen to do their best in hard circumstances always trying to help, largely on time etc, I sadly couldn't say the same for the consultants /surgeons sadly not just in terms of taking literally hours to turn but also how i saw them speak to said, nurses, midwifes, care staff etc and patients.
I jokingly mentioned this to a relative who works cleaning and sterlising equipment, who said yes its well known sadly, your lucky if any move or say thank you for returned equipment, i just wondered why is this a thing, AIBU to wonder where did that culture of behaviour come from?

OP posts:
DougRossIsTheBoss · 17/12/2020 17:23

I'm not saying that no Dr did any wrong in Shrewsbury. I'm just saying perhaps consultants are not wholly to blame for that scandal.

DougRossIsTheBoss · 17/12/2020 17:22

Also does it absolutely follow that the people who should be in the jail cell are consultants?

Most NHS managers and chief executives are not from a medical background and they are legally ultimately responsible for the safety of services as a whole.

The vast majority of births are not attended by a consultant obstetrician at all. Midwives are independent practitioners. Should the local consultant be responsible for their culture and practice too?

It's like I said, and people disputed, earlier. The consultant IS held responsible in the mind of the public whosoever's is the failing.

DougRossIsTheBoss · 17/12/2020 17:16

Jail cell I don't know. Maybe. They would need to be convicted of gross negligence manslaughter in relation to a particular case or corporate manslaughter and be in a management role. It has happened.

Getting struck off by the GMC- more likely. I think one person was over Mid Staffs although many more were investigated and there was a lack of evidence.

staydazzling · 17/12/2020 16:50

I think in the light and in respect, of the Shewsbury, maternity scandal and the learning disability DNR scandal, that where some areas of the NHS are well regulated there are sinister pockets that obviously aren't. some people who should be sat in a jail cell that aren't. i wonder if anyone will see prison regarding Shewsbury.

OP posts:
littlepeas · 17/12/2020 14:27

My dad’s oncologist was the only truly awful bastard senior doctor I’ve encountered. I can’t believe he works with gravely ill people. The way he spoke to my dad was shocking.

Otherwise they’ve just been on a scale somewhere between incredibly lovely and polite, but not that friendly. The nicest overall was a female plastic surgeon, all paediatricians (met many as my dd was poorly as a baby) were nice.

Spidey66 · 17/12/2020 14:14

I've been in nursing 35 years. I only recognise this in one, and that was only some of the time.

oneglassandpuzzled · 17/12/2020 14:10

The Filipino Male nurses always called my father ‘Mr Tim’ instead of ‘Mr Smith’. It seemed a nice way to be respectful and warm at the same time. He liked it.

2020iscancelled · 17/12/2020 13:15

I’ve always had lovely consultants - some times they’ve been a little “direct” but you have to remember that they are often delivering bad news or trying to navigate the facts around people’s emotions - my first maternity consultant was very blunt. Not rude but blunt. Some people would possibly consider it rude I guess.

The rudest person I’ve come across was a senior nurse, but I think I caught her at a bad moment bc once I made noises about complaining and wanting to talk to the ward sister etc she was nice as pie.

Surely people are a bit of both and generally it comes down to what is going on in their mind at the time.

EdwardCullensBiteOnTheSide · 17/12/2020 13:10

I've not found this.

RosesAndHellebores · 17/12/2020 13:07

Oh I don't mind my first name being used in other environments. My accountant is Tony, my solicitor is Fiona but I suppose they are also now friends.

We always called the children's teachers Mr, Miss or Mrs but it notably became more informal the older they became and the more we paid. DH's former housemaster whom we got to know well sends us a Christmas card still but it's from Ian and Jane. DS however, still calls him Sir if he sees him, as he does because they come to our parties (when we can have them) and so he should.

RosesAndHellebores · 17/12/2020 12:59

You make an interesting point there @DougRossIsTheBoss and racism in all its forms is deplorable. What is interesting though is that my maiden name was forrin and I have an unusual first name (Hermione/Cressida genre) and as a child my recollection is that those who remarked on it and/or ridiculed it a bit were usually nurses and I still get comments now "ooh that's an unusual name? Where does that come from?". It has been incredibly tiresome all my life and also it crosses a boundary. It may be why I am sensitive about it and other issues of equality.

DougRossIsTheBoss · 17/12/2020 12:58

We all have these bright yellow dementia friendly name badges now and I am afraid I insisted mine say Dr surname. I really do not like patients using my first name. It just feels all shades of wrong to me.

It's not a power thing though. I'm not unfair about it. I don't want to refer to anyone who is not my friend by their first name or have them use mine. Not mortgage advisers, waiting staff, shop assistants, call centre people. None of them.

Beyond the initial introduction there surely isn't much call for using names when speaking 1:1 anyway. I abhor this constant dropping your name in whilst talking stuff that clearly is in the script at all centres 'well you see Doug' 'now I'll just put you on hold again, Doug'

Just introduce yourself politely at the start and then say what needs to be said.

parallax80 · 17/12/2020 12:48

Yes, I think we agreed on that above.

RosesAndHellebores · 17/12/2020 12:46

I don't have an issue @parallax80 with using a consultant's first name and them using mine (although I prefer Dr and Mrs when I am potentially vulnerable) but I have an issue with a Dr introducing themselves with title surname and assuming they may in that circumstance use my first name. They may not - they may address me as if I am their equal.

DougRossIsTheBoss · 17/12/2020 12:46

I do believe Drs should use patients surnames unless invited not to yes. I would agree with you on that.
What they call themselves is their own choice but in my opinion first names are not professional and I encourage my junior Drs not to do this.

I do have some junior Drs who do use Dr Firstname or Dr Shortened name. Usually Sri Lankan ones. I think it's a bit sad but it is usually a response to years of rather racist people making no effort to try to pronounce their name or even mocking or laughing at it.
I don't blame them for abbreviating under those circumstances.

One of my poor Drs his name didn't even fit on the name badge so people always addressed him incorrectly and this issue was not able to be rectified as 'computer says no' there are only so many characters allowed. He had to choose a short version against his will.

parallax80 · 17/12/2020 12:39

We are instructed by trust management to introduce ourselves as “hello, my name is Firstname” (off the back of the “hello my name is..” campaign, started by Kate Granger who was an oncologist and cancer patient).

Whether or not you agree with the campaign is one thing, but that may explain some of the “call me Paul’s”

EwDavid · 17/12/2020 12:37

I'm a MH nurse. I work regularly with consultants and they're just like anybody else with their individual quirks and styles of communication. I know I could never cope with the amount of pressure that they are under and the weight of that responsibility and accountability would keep me awake at night. I generally get on well with all of them and try not to take it personally if they're rude or less than personable.

RosesAndHellebores · 17/12/2020 12:30

@DougRossIsTheBoss quite right too. I have no wish to have anything other than a professional relationship with an HCP. I hope you agree it is very passive aggressive when Drs call the patient their first name whilst introducing themselves as Dr or Mr Smith. Usually I extend a hand and say I'm very pleased to meet you Mr Smith, I am Mrs Hellebores. Then they splutter and say "oh you can call me Paul". Just why?

Something becoming more common is the habit of younger Drs introducing themselves as Dr Mary or Dr John. One young lady at my surgery actually said "you can call me Dr Jane, my surname's really long and foreign and it's easier because none of you (yes she said you) patients can pronounce it properly. So in one interaction intimated I was both her subordinate (no attempt to call me Mrs Cressida Grin) and too stupid to pronounce her name. I have one of those quaint English names that isn't pronounced as it's written - along the lines of Cholomondeley - and in the 30 years I have been married have encountered no difficulty explaining how it is pronounced and if people get it wrong they get it wrong but never would I say "use something else because my real name will be too hard for you". It would be beyond rude.

parallax80 · 17/12/2020 12:23

I possibly am quite an old fashioned person though. I refer to my children's teachers as Mr/Mrs/Ms surname and to my own GP as Dr X which apparently most people don't these days.

I do this too.

ElspethFlashman · 17/12/2020 12:20

If they don’t care whether you like them as there’s nothing in it for them either way, they don’t treat you with respect

Exsctly. One of our consultants is incredibly nice to his patients. I'm in the room, often enough. They beam at him. If one of his patients were on this thread right now, they'd be saying "Well Mr X is lovely, I can attest to that personally".

This would be the same guy that I've done countless procedures with, who never ever ever says my name or says hello to me. He knows my name, he just doesn't deign to say it. Who grunts when I have to ask him a question. Who never makes eye contact. Who ignores the existence of all nursing staff and who sighs whenever we have the audacity to ask him a question. Obviously we avoid asking him anything or really having to have any interaction at all, so I guess it's working for him.

So yeah, they pick and choose their manner all right.

And you know what? We're all stressed! I'm on my knees with staffing shortages and Covid! Stress is NEVER an excuse!

DougRossIsTheBoss · 17/12/2020 12:00

I introduce myself as Dr surname. I do not encourage patients to use my first name.

However I also refer to them as Mr/ Mrs/ Ms surname unless they request I use their first name (a fair few do these days)

It is a professional boundary issue. I am not their friend. It helps people to feel safer when being touched in an intimate fashion if the Dr is not overly pally I think. I do not engage my patients in conversation if we meet outside work for similar reasons and I do not welcome direct phone or email contact. Drs over the years have got in all kinds of trouble failing to keep relationships on a professional footing.

I possibly am quite an old fashioned person though. I refer to my children's teachers as Mr/Mrs/Ms surname and to my own GP as Dr X which apparently most people don't these days.

I find some formality reassuring.

minnie465 · 17/12/2020 11:49

What a massive generalisation!! All just human at the end of the day. I'm an AHP and also have a chronic illness. So plenty of interaction with all medical staff.

parallax80 · 17/12/2020 11:42

I’m sorry you have had what sounds like a series of bad experiences. There’s no excuse for being rude to people, and while none of us get anything perfect all the time, an apology is better than nothing.

I don’t think I’m in a minority particularly though. I can’t think of any colleagues who introduce themselves as anything other than “Firstname Surname”.

Perhaps it’s an anaesthetic thing? Or that particular departments develop an ethos of what is acceptable behaviour?

Of course I don’t see eye to eye on everything with my colleagues but as a group, we are polite and pleasant to our patients and other staff. And I would expect to have my ass kicked or at least be pulled up on it if someone found out I had behaved poorly towards someone.

RosesAndHellebores · 17/12/2020 11:32

I suspect @parallax80 you must be in a minority. The last time I attended paediatric A&E the very pompous consultant introduced himself as Dr xxxx and asked if I was "mum". Didn't so much consider using even my first name. He also treated the nurses as though they were his secretaries. Ghastly young man and it didn't help a situation involving dd's mh. He even told me I had given him permission to contact SS and in any event it wasn't possible to make a CAMHS referral without doing so. Interesting as SS later confirmed the hospital had made the referral at 4.06pm. I wasn't informed dd was at A&E until 5.48pm. So that particular rude and arrogant consultant was a liar as well. Although the CEO apologised personally that little bit and that particular gentleman's conduct was not satisfactorily dealt with. Whether it was behind the scenes I shall never know.

parallax80 · 17/12/2020 11:16

I introduce myself as “Firstname Surname” and address patients as “Title Surname”.

However, my trust also removed surnames from the ID badges of all staff working in A&E a while back because of a number of security incidents with staff being threatened / stalked / generally harassed at home as well as at work (usually for drugs).