Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you have a Student Loan, what is the estimated time-frame of clearing it? Was it worth it?

184 replies

christmastreesparklex · 10/12/2020 17:24

Hi all

I graduated in 2013 and have £10,000 remaining on my student loan (Plan 1). I have calculated on my current salary that it will take me approximately 7 years (assuming a year out for maternity leave in the future) before I will have paid it off completely. On my current salary it is deducting approximately £150.00 each month, so definitely a noticeable deduction. The interest on the PAYE statements is currently 1.75%.

I am in two minds whether to start making additional payments to pay the salary off early to reduce the total amount paid due to the interest. I am also mindful that the earlier I pay it off, the higher my monthly salary will be in the future, particularly during the years I (hopefully) have children and nursery fees will be extortionate! I was looking for some advice if possible and also welcome a general discussion from those who also have a loan- if you are interested, you can calculate an estimate on when you will pay the student loan off via the link below:

www.student-loan-calculator.co.uk/

For those who don't mind sharing (AIBU!) what is your estimated time period for you paying off your Student Loan? Do you think it was worth the loan and would you have still gone down this route if you could go back in time? For me personally, I did a vocational university degree so I would not have been able to progress in my career without it, so I would say it was worth it! My DP does not have the same experience and is in fact in a completely different field which did not require any degree!

For those who have already paid their loan off, has it been noticeable on your monthly salary? I imagine it must have felt rewarding having made the last payment and finally free of your student loan!

I know with the Plan 2 student loans, the course fees and interest rates were higher and therefore; a considerable amount of students will not make the full payment in the time period before it is wiped. I suppose in this situation, making early payments would not be advised as you may end up paying more?

OP posts:
Willfiasco · 10/12/2020 22:43

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

Why would you want to pay it off early?
Interest. It get bigger the longer you have it.
ListeningQuietly · 10/12/2020 22:37

asdf
Not many people average a £66k salary like you though Smile

TaraR2020 · 10/12/2020 22:36

I haven't checked my projections recently so I can't remember...I have two loans though, one under the old plan and one on the new.

I don't regret a penny - both degrees have been the most fulfilling part of my life.

Trickyboy · 10/12/2020 22:35

Took out loan aged 57.. for first degree.. will graduate aged 61.. retire at 60 on a pension of £23k.. income will increase at pension age (66 for me) .. will never have to pay back .

Nonamesavail · 10/12/2020 22:35

Got mine after 2012. Not earning enough. Probably won't now.

Asdf12345 · 10/12/2020 22:31

Graduated 2014 with £35k plan one loan (1.1% rate not 1.75%).

Should be paid off by the end of the tax year. My income fluctuates but in the last two years payments have ranged from £250 a month to £800 a month which I am looking forward to keeping.

ListeningQuietly · 10/12/2020 22:27

OP
It is a 9% graduate tax
not a loan
it is expected than only 40% will be paid off in full

as I say, making extra payments is pointless
if you earn enough to pay it off, do so
but you pay 9% of your salary
whether your debt is £1000 or £100,000

DivisionBelles · 10/12/2020 22:25

Graduated in 2013 and have about £22k owing split across Plan 1 and Plan 2. I'm 48 and pay around £30 a month so I'll never pay mine before it gets written off. I don't even think about it tbh.

christmastreesparklex · 10/12/2020 22:24

From those few posters who explained they will likely be paying off their loans until their retirement.. I think its ludicrous! Its not a loan its a life time commitment and most of that payment will be interest!

Students are sold the dream and they come out feeling deflated with little job opportunities unless fortunate having studied a vocational degree / be fortunate to land a job. Even then a large percentage of students don't end up finding a role in their chosen field and times are getting tougher.. yes they dont have to start paying it back until the threshold is reached but you would expect most graduates who have dedicted time, money (earning potential lost) and effort etc would hope to be able to earn within 5 years of graduation more than the threshold!

Sorry I have turned my own thread into a moan thread and this is not my own situation but I feel so sorry for those coming out with degrees over the last few years!

OP posts:
DieSchottin93 · 10/12/2020 22:06

Doubt mine will ever be paid off, I haven't earnt enough to start making any payments. In fact I think my loan is now worth more than my average salary. Yay for minimum wage Sad I'm Scottish and went to a Scottish uni though so my loan is relatively small compared to a lot of other posters here.

SockQueen · 10/12/2020 21:59

I graduated in 2009 with a plan 1 loan, for living expenses only apart from one year's tuition fees (which were ~£1100) - I started in 2003 so initially fee loans weren't available.

I am going to finish paying it off in March next year. Would have paid it off a couple of years ago but mat leave + going part time reduced my rate of repayment. I think because I've always had the deductions made, I don't miss that part of my salary. It'll just be a nice bonus when it's done!

ListeningQuietly · 10/12/2020 21:55

Student loans are a 9% graduate tax

extra payments will NOT affect the standard 9% deduction

therefore only fools do that

Ginfilledcats · 10/12/2020 21:53

My dh has just paid his off after 11 years - has ~£400 more a month now.
Large chunks of his was paid off when he was in a previous job earning bonuses. He's now a high earner.

I earn half as much, graduated 9 years ago and still have like £22k to pay off. Feels like I'll never pay it off and I earn a decent wage?

audweb · 10/12/2020 21:49

Graduated in 2004, paid it off last year via my salary so there were plenty years where I didn’t pay back much, and I had a baby as well. However overpaid by 1400, which I got back in time for going on holiday so that was nice. It was worth it. I couldn’t be in the job or career I am in as you need my particular vocational degree to practice.

Morgatty · 10/12/2020 21:47

I graduated in 2011, only paid off a small amount, highly likely it will be wiped rather than being paid off.

Redredwine2020 · 10/12/2020 21:45

I have £37721.25 student debt to date on a plan 2 loan. I can't see how I will ever pay it off

MyDucksArentInARow · 10/12/2020 21:42

@tealcoat7 you don't get what I mean. I'm saying I dislike that the interest rate is set so high because there are people going to uni for no reason. If degrees like yours and mine were charged a reasonable interest rate then you wouldn't need to earn crazy amounts to pay yours off. You will be the most penalized group. With 65k of debt and a high interest rate you will pay much, much, much more than the amount you borrowed if you go into a high earner bracket. Your loan balance will go up for years before you earn enough to out pace it and it starts coming down. The compound interest will be insane. Yes it gets wiped off, but on your salary trajectory you'll still, most like, pay significantly more than you borrowed. The reason the interest rate is so high is because there are too many people doing pointless degrees where they aren't for a career or genuine academic rigour or enjoyment of a subject. They go on to never earn above the threshold and never repay their debt. I think the debt shouldn't be wiped off at 30 years. I think you should pay it off until retirement, then it is recovered from your estate. On the condition the interest rate is something more reasonable, and it's actually a fair price for the education and salary advantage or academic enjoyment it got you.

No one should struggle to pay off a plan 2 loan if it was actually worked out fairly.

In an ideal world, uni would still be free with only a maintanence loan. But it's not because uni is not done right. Its seen as a path for anyone. I'm not saying uni shouldn't be accessible, I'm say uni shouldn't be seen as the path for any tom, dick or Harry that wants to doss around for 3 years. Go to uni because you have a purpose and need to go. Go to uni for the joy of academics.

Since it can't be free, I also believe that an employer should have to pay off the student loans in return for x years sevice (progressively) if they make it a requirement in the job spec to hold a degree.

WhoLettheCatOut · 10/12/2020 21:37

I graduated in 2003 and started paying back from salary in 2005. In 2012 I took out a mortgage with enough left to pay off my loan so I did that. There wasn't a huge amount left but I just wanted it gone and it took me hours of admin every year as they miscalculated my repayments literally every year which lost me half a days work to sort out! To be honest if it wasn't for the faf I would have left it as the interest wasn't awful.

tealcoat7 · 10/12/2020 21:25

You’re right OP on plan 2 they add on 5.6% interest before you even graduate 🤣

ShinyMe · 10/12/2020 21:19

I graduated in 96 and will never pay mine off. I had very early terms and conditions because I'm very old, and could earn almost double what I earn now before I pay it back. I think it gets written off either when I'm 50 or 55, so not long to go now!

christmastreesparklex · 10/12/2020 21:14

@maddiemookins16mum whilst i dont entirely disagree with you and i get your frustration but I think its the interest rates, not so much under plan 1 but definately plan 2. People end up owing thousands and thousands of pounds more than they ever actually borrowed!

Correct me if I'm wrong anyone but even if you don't meet the threshold to pay the loan back or even a small amount the interest still builds up each month so when you do earn enough you have a lot of money to pay.

It doesnt help that you're not only funding the course itself but to actually live for 3 or more years, its not possible to work full time and study to fund your lifestyle so people have no choice but to borrow money!

OP posts:
gillianan · 10/12/2020 21:11

if you know you're earning enough that you will definitely have to pay it off then yes pay it off as fast as you can, as its just a normal loan with interest. it took me 7 years I think. felt great to be free of it and the extra money was available just at the right time for house purchasing and kids.

lastdayofjuly · 10/12/2020 21:04

I graduated in 2013 and paid off my last chunk of student loan last month! Over the moon to no longer have to pay approx. £450 a month.

I had to do my degree for my profession. Luckily being Scottish I paid no university fees so my loan was only for four years' accommodation, bills and food.

I do hear the advice generally is not to put paying off your student loan debts early ahead of paying off other higher interest debts (e.g. credit cards, mortgage etc.)

buzz91 · 10/12/2020 20:56

I graduated in 2013 and have barely paid any off, think with interest it’s now more than it was originally. At first I didn’t earn enough and just when I would have I went on mat and now work part time, so only pay any back when I get a bonus

maddiemookins16mum · 10/12/2020 20:51

How can people not pay back loans, it’s a farce. A colleague of mine has a huge SL, has no intention of ever earning enough to have to pay it back.

Swipe left for the next trending thread