Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you have a Student Loan, what is the estimated time-frame of clearing it? Was it worth it?

184 replies

christmastreesparklex · 10/12/2020 17:24

Hi all

I graduated in 2013 and have £10,000 remaining on my student loan (Plan 1). I have calculated on my current salary that it will take me approximately 7 years (assuming a year out for maternity leave in the future) before I will have paid it off completely. On my current salary it is deducting approximately £150.00 each month, so definitely a noticeable deduction. The interest on the PAYE statements is currently 1.75%.

I am in two minds whether to start making additional payments to pay the salary off early to reduce the total amount paid due to the interest. I am also mindful that the earlier I pay it off, the higher my monthly salary will be in the future, particularly during the years I (hopefully) have children and nursery fees will be extortionate! I was looking for some advice if possible and also welcome a general discussion from those who also have a loan- if you are interested, you can calculate an estimate on when you will pay the student loan off via the link below:

www.student-loan-calculator.co.uk/

For those who don't mind sharing (AIBU!) what is your estimated time period for you paying off your Student Loan? Do you think it was worth the loan and would you have still gone down this route if you could go back in time? For me personally, I did a vocational university degree so I would not have been able to progress in my career without it, so I would say it was worth it! My DP does not have the same experience and is in fact in a completely different field which did not require any degree!

For those who have already paid their loan off, has it been noticeable on your monthly salary? I imagine it must have felt rewarding having made the last payment and finally free of your student loan!

I know with the Plan 2 student loans, the course fees and interest rates were higher and therefore; a considerable amount of students will not make the full payment in the time period before it is wiped. I suppose in this situation, making early payments would not be advised as you may end up paying more?

OP posts:
coldwarenigma · 11/12/2020 16:33

oooh..at the present rate, I may get it paid off by the time I'm...120...Grin
Seriously, low wages in retail, my age, later in life studying. Expect to get it written off eventually.

DebbieFiderer · 11/12/2020 16:00

Ah, yes, that makes sense. I'm grateful for this thread actually as it has prompted me to check, and it turns out I will repay them a lot quicker than I thought.

CarpetTime · 11/12/2020 15:50

[quote DebbieFiderer]@carpettime, they are definitely both being paid back at the same time, my statement says that £x was received from HMRC and split between the two loans (not an equal split, more goes to the plan 2 loan)[/quote]
Oh! I’ve worked out why that is as DSis is only paying back plan 1. If you earn over the plan 1 amount but below plan 2 then yes you only pay back plan 1. If you earn over the £26k then your repayment is split between the two. (DSis is on £24k Grin)

BarbaraofSeville · 11/12/2020 15:49

From those few posters who explained they will likely be paying off their loans until their retirement.. I think its ludicrous! Its not a loan its a life time commitment and most of that payment will be interest

But some people's payments will be very very low because they only earn just above the threshold - like the poster who is paying £12 a month. On her current salary, she only has to pay £12 a month, any additional payments are unlikely to pay her loan off quicker, just pay extra money for no reason. £12 x 12 x 30 (or 25 years, not sure how long these loans run for) is about £4300, so probably less than she borrowed. The interest is immaterial, if you don't expect to pay much of your loan off, they could be adding a million pounds a year of interest and you'd still pay the same amount in total.

Unless you view the SLC or the government (not sure who the money actually benefits) as a charity case, it's misguided to overpay.

In your case OP, if you have other debt that charges more than 1.75% interest, you'd be best off overpaying that first and leave the student loan running along with the basic amount.

Those on Plan 2 loans that expect to earn more might want to look at it differently as they might clear all their loans, but people on average salaries certainly won't, so they need to view it as a graduate tax, that should be paid if you're earning above average, but not if you're not. If you decide to work part time, be a SAHP or suffer an illness or injury that means you step down or stop working, any extra money you've paid is wasted.

Tippexy · 11/12/2020 15:47

[quote gillianan]@Tippexy have you ever applied for a mortgage??it's literally one of the first things they ask. how daft to think when asking your salary they wouldn't consider the fact that 9% of it is taken away alongside all other outgoings you have to list.[/quote]
9% of it isn’t taken away. It’s 9% over a certain amount - and the plan 2 amount that you can earn before deductions are made is even higher than plan 1!

DebbieFiderer · 11/12/2020 15:43

@carpettime, they are definitely both being paid back at the same time, my statement says that £x was received from HMRC and split between the two loans (not an equal split, more goes to the plan 2 loan)

muddledmidget · 11/12/2020 15:36

Graduated in 2006 with a vocational degree and £13k worth of loans. Paid off the final lump in June 2015 when they wanted to switch me to direct debit so I cleared the lump sum then, but I did overpay a few times over the years. The interest rate was quite a lot higher at one point, and once we sorted out housing I just wanted to pay it off, particularly as I knew I'd have to pay it all off as it would only be wiped at 60, so it didn't seem worth paying extra in interest. I think a lot of it depends on your housing situation though, it's cheaper than a mortgage!

Biscuitz · 11/12/2020 15:36

@MyDucksArentInARow Apprenticeships are exploitative that’s why I’d never encourage someone to take one. Young people should be paid properly for the work they do and companies should invest in their future workforce.

dsaflausdhfiushdfakdsf · 11/12/2020 15:26

@ListeningQuietly

dsa Student loan counts as a reduction of income for mortgage purposes.

The amount you repay is tied to what you earn now what you owe
so paying bits off early
is UTTERLY pointless
as it will not affect your "affordability criteria"

I think we are misunderstanding each other.
PerfectPinecone · 11/12/2020 15:18

You need to look at the full picture. Do you have any other debt with a higher interest rate I.e mortgage. If so it's best to overpay on that rather than your student loan.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/12/2020 15:18

@maddiemookins16mum

How can people not pay back loans, it’s a farce. A colleague of mine has a huge SL, has no intention of ever earning enough to have to pay it back.
Because that's how it was set up. It allows those who can't afford to pay to back the opportunity to still gain a degree.

Those who can do, according to the T+Cs of the time.

www.gov.uk/repaying-your-student-loan/when-your-student-loan-gets-written-off-or-cancelled

It's 30 years before it gets written off now - for most!

lurker101 · 11/12/2020 15:12

Great news @mumtobabygilrl good to know where you stand 😊

lurker101 · 11/12/2020 15:11

@HappyChristmasTreeRex if it’s listed as a deduction on your payslip, they didn’t need to ask because it’s there for them to see. That’s what our mortgage company did.

HappyChristmasTreeRex · 11/12/2020 15:09

@MaskingForIt I understand that, however they did not ask about it and did not even write down which loan I was on or even that I had one. I asked specifically if they wanted details and they said no and told me it was irrelevant. Perhaps our circumstances are not the same as others, I don't know, I just know this was our experience.

gillianan · 11/12/2020 15:07

@ListeningQuietly
when did anyone say the amount mattered?

MaskingForIt · 11/12/2020 15:05

@HappyChristmasTreeRex

Our mortgage company were not interested at all in my student loan. I would only pay it off if you think you cannot save that money in another way, putting it aside gives you more flexibility.
They're not interested in it in terms of debt, but anything that reduces your income has an effect on what you can borrow. £150 a month on a student loan is £150 a month that can’t go on a mortgage.
ListeningQuietly · 11/12/2020 15:04

gillian
I am an accountant.
I sign references for clients getting mortgages.

The AMOUNT of student loan is not relevant.
because it does not affect the amount of repayment

gillianan · 11/12/2020 15:02

www.onlinemortgageadvisor.co.uk/mortgage-affordability/student-loans-and-mortgages/

"Can you get a mortgage with student loans?

Having student loans shouldn’t prevent you from being able to get a mortgage, although lenders will take the debt into account. Unlike other debt, student loans don’t appear on your credit report but, depending on the level of debt you have to repay each month, have a student loan couldimpact affordability checksevery lender carries out."

HappyChristmasTreeRex · 11/12/2020 14:58

Our mortgage company were not interested at all in my student loan. I would only pay it off if you think you cannot save that money in another way, putting it aside gives you more flexibility.

gillianan · 11/12/2020 14:55

@Tippexy have you ever applied for a mortgage??it's literally one of the first things they ask. how daft to think when asking your salary they wouldn't consider the fact that 9% of it is taken away alongside all other outgoings you have to list.

mumtobabygilrl · 11/12/2020 14:46

Oooh I've managed to get in touch with the (thanks to this post for the kick up the backside I needed to get back in touch with slc) graduated 2005 and still have 5k left to pay. That will be approx 3 years at current rate of pay

ListeningQuietly · 11/12/2020 14:41

dsa
Student loan counts as a reduction of income for mortgage purposes.

The amount you repay is tied to what you earn now what you owe
so paying bits off early
is UTTERLY pointless
as it will not affect your "affordability criteria"

dsaflausdhfiushdfakdsf · 11/12/2020 14:36

To the people saying they don't get taken into account for mortgage purposes, I can confirm that they do.

You have to declare your full income and outgoings for the mortgage provider to assess affordability.

E.g. net income of £2000

£500 outgoing on car
£500 outgoing on bank loan
£100 outgoing on student loan

You might struggle being approved for a mortgage with a rate of £600 a month with a 40 year term because that would leave you with only £300 a month for bills/living costs, which isn't realistic. They won't lend to you if they think you might default on the payments.

In example above, the student loan has a minor impact (the car and bank loans are the big hitter) but it DOES come into play, and for those who are on the knife edge of being approved or rejected, it can tip you over the wrong side.

VestaTilley · 11/12/2020 14:13

Definitely worth getting the loan/degree. I work in a related field to my degree and didn’t have a wealthy family so needed the loan to live on and later pay towards the fees.

Still paying it off, about £150 quid a month or so. I’m sure I’d appreciate having that money per month (I’m 34) but would just stick it in savings.

No point paying it off early in my view.

Tippexy · 11/12/2020 14:09

@gillianan

they do get taken into account on financial viability for mortgages. as they're an outgoing.
No, they don’t. They really don’t.
Swipe left for the next trending thread