Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you have a Student Loan, what is the estimated time-frame of clearing it? Was it worth it?

184 replies

christmastreesparklex · 10/12/2020 17:24

Hi all

I graduated in 2013 and have £10,000 remaining on my student loan (Plan 1). I have calculated on my current salary that it will take me approximately 7 years (assuming a year out for maternity leave in the future) before I will have paid it off completely. On my current salary it is deducting approximately £150.00 each month, so definitely a noticeable deduction. The interest on the PAYE statements is currently 1.75%.

I am in two minds whether to start making additional payments to pay the salary off early to reduce the total amount paid due to the interest. I am also mindful that the earlier I pay it off, the higher my monthly salary will be in the future, particularly during the years I (hopefully) have children and nursery fees will be extortionate! I was looking for some advice if possible and also welcome a general discussion from those who also have a loan- if you are interested, you can calculate an estimate on when you will pay the student loan off via the link below:

www.student-loan-calculator.co.uk/

For those who don't mind sharing (AIBU!) what is your estimated time period for you paying off your Student Loan? Do you think it was worth the loan and would you have still gone down this route if you could go back in time? For me personally, I did a vocational university degree so I would not have been able to progress in my career without it, so I would say it was worth it! My DP does not have the same experience and is in fact in a completely different field which did not require any degree!

For those who have already paid their loan off, has it been noticeable on your monthly salary? I imagine it must have felt rewarding having made the last payment and finally free of your student loan!

I know with the Plan 2 student loans, the course fees and interest rates were higher and therefore; a considerable amount of students will not make the full payment in the time period before it is wiped. I suppose in this situation, making early payments would not be advised as you may end up paying more?

OP posts:
UrAWizHarry · 12/12/2020 19:56

@sbhydrogen

I don't have a student loan (never went to uni) but I don't see the point in spending more money interest, so I'd chuck as much as you can at it. I recently paid off my 3 year car two years early and that extra money in my bank account every month is SO good.
This is terrible advice. Depending upon your loan type a student can actually end up paying more by overpaying on a loan which they would otherwise have written off.

Student loans for many are, in effect, a graduate tax.

ListeningQuietly · 12/12/2020 18:25

@sbhydrogen

I don't have a student loan (never went to uni) but I don't see the point in spending more money interest, so I'd chuck as much as you can at it. I recently paid off my 3 year car two years early and that extra money in my bank account every month is SO good.
but the repayment through your salary is NOT affected by the reduction in the balance
sbhydrogen · 12/12/2020 18:23

...Unless you put some extra money in some investment, so your return there is greater than the interest owed over a long period of time 🤷‍♀️

sbhydrogen · 12/12/2020 18:21

I don't have a student loan (never went to uni) but I don't see the point in spending more money interest, so I'd chuck as much as you can at it. I recently paid off my 3 year car two years early and that extra money in my bank account every month is SO good.

MustardMitt · 12/12/2020 17:33

@FAQs

The amount taken from your salary is taken into account when applying for a mortgage!
Only in as much as they’re interested in your net salary.
vanillandhoney · 11/12/2020 21:47

I'll never pay mine off. I took out 9k and I think it's at about 16k now? I've paid back around £200 overall Grin

I never earned enough to pay off anything more than that.

ZolaGrey · 11/12/2020 21:34

@ListeningQuietly

So you essentially wasted 7.5k on a debt that they won't chase and you're unlikely to ever be eligible to pay back... When I did my degree we got
  • free tuition
  • maintenance grants
  • housing benefit in the holidays
  • unemployment benefit each summer

Nowadays kids get

  • £9250 per year bill for tuition
  • £6000 per year bill for the same rooms I stayed in
  • no benefits
  • no grants

I know what students get now. I am one.

Northernsoullover · 11/12/2020 20:58

@FAQs

The amount taken from your salary is taken into account when applying for a mortgage!
I won't get a mortgage without my degree. I would never earn enough. Choose your degree wisely.
ListeningQuietly · 11/12/2020 20:56

So you essentially wasted 7.5k on a debt that they won't chase and you're unlikely to ever be eligible to pay back...
When I did my degree we got

  • free tuition
  • maintenance grants
  • housing benefit in the holidays
  • unemployment benefit each summer

Nowadays kids get

  • £9250 per year bill for tuition
  • £6000 per year bill for the same rooms I stayed in
  • no benefits
  • no grants
ZolaGrey · 11/12/2020 20:44

@ProfessorofCunning

Graduated 2000, and paid off loan by 2008. It was ‘only’ £7.5k though. Even though to this day I’ve never had a salary where I had to make a contribution, I did so because I didn’t want it coming back to haunt me for whatever reason.

So you essentially wasted 7.5k on a debt that they won't chase and you're unlikely to ever be eligible to pay back...

FAQs · 11/12/2020 18:26

The amount taken from your salary is taken into account when applying for a mortgage!

MustardMitt · 11/12/2020 18:19

I don’t know how much I owe but I’m also plan 1. I didn’t start paying it back for at least five years after I graduated.

I have lots of debt that I’d clear before this, but if I didn’t have that debt yes I think I would overpay into my loan.

MsJudgemental · 11/12/2020 18:03

People worrying about paying it off and this stops people from lower-income families going to university. Think of out as a student TAX, a percentage that you pay when you earn enough, the balance of which gets written off after a certain amount of time. Why would you want to pay the government money you don't need to?

ListeningQuietly · 11/12/2020 17:58

Modern student loan interest rate is currently 5.6%
www.gov.uk/government/news/student-loans-interest-rates-and-repayment-threshold-announcement

and as kids are incurring up to £60,000 in a standard 3 year degree
they would be MAD to pay more than the 9% mandated

alphabetsoup1980 · 11/12/2020 17:58

I will never pay mine off! ! (32,000) I've either never earned enough or been on three maternity leaves. 😂😂 I'm now on M6 teaching salary but working part time ! I'm at peace with it 😊

ChristmasFluff · 11/12/2020 17:55

Wow, I'm in awe at the high salaries that must be going on here, to be looking at being done in 7 years!

Had I had to do a student loan (I didn't, I'm from the days of grants), I'd never have paid it off(allowing for inflation). I doubt DS will ever pay his off, as history degrees don't tend to bring the money rolling in.

I think so long as you have no other debt, then it's clearly better to pay it off sooner to avoid interest. But student loans are usually really low interest, so if you were having to use any other credit, then it wouldn't make sense to pay it off?

fussychica · 11/12/2020 17:31

DS has a Plan 1 for his main degree and a Plan 2 for his post grad. Unfortunately you have to pay them off in tandem. The Plan 2 loan though much smaller has a far higher rate of interest so it would have been nice to get rid of that one but it's not worth forking out the cash from his savings as he needs it for a deposit if he buys a property.

doctorhamster · 11/12/2020 17:21

I owed about 16k when I graduated in 2002. Earned enough to have a small amount deducted from my salary for a few years, then had DC and became a sahm. I used to get a yearly statement from them but haven't for years now. I have no idea what my account number is and I can't find it via an email address because I didn't have one when I took the loan out in 1998 Confused

ProfessorofCunning · 11/12/2020 17:17

Graduated 2000, and paid off loan by 2008. It was ‘only’ £7.5k though. Even though to this day I’ve never had a salary where I had to make a contribution, I did so because I didn’t want it coming back to haunt me for whatever reason.

EnPoinsettia · 11/12/2020 17:16

I paid my loan off early. On the one hand, I felt a definite sense of emotional relief. On the other hand, I took some time off work the following year to care for a terminally ill relative and that period would have been easier had I had more savings. That said, other relatives chipped in to help because they appreciated what I was doing, and it might have been more difficult to make the decision to do it had I not been debt-free.

UrAWizHarry · 11/12/2020 17:10

A student loan is not like any other form of debt. You only ever pay a small (relatively) % of your wage on repayment. If you stop earning enough to repay it, you don't repay it.

Given that a majority of people will never repay their loans before they are written off there is a strong argument to scrap the system entirely and just move to a graduate tax, and therefore remove the confusing and stigma of accuring debt in order to pay for higher education.

MyDucksArentInARow · 11/12/2020 17:03

@Biscuitz whilst some may be exploitative, many are not. Especially degree level ones. My DP did one to get his degree, was paid a fair salary throughout and was in a much better position financially and skill wise than if he'd gone to uni. Same as an old school friend of mine, she's leaps and bounds ahead of anyone else career wise because she got 4 years of experience whist doing her degree and is now very successful.

doctorboo · 11/12/2020 16:50

@christmastreesparklex I remember reading on the Martin Money site that it’s actually not the beat idea to pay your loan off early. I don’t remember the ins and outs of the reasoning but they’d done an in-depth breakdown of it all.

Youcunnyfunt · 11/12/2020 16:49

I'm on Plan 1. Although my savings accounts earn basically nothing right now, I still don't think it's worth repaying it early. I only have about 5 months of payments left - I'm looking forward to the extra cash when it's paid off next year! It's equivalent to my monthly food bill. I think right now it's more sensible to have the extra savings in the bank ready to access if I need it for an emergency. With covid and all that shizz.
I have switched to the direct debit scheme so it's not possible to overpay on my last payment.

Ratatcat · 11/12/2020 16:36

If you’re thinking about mat leave don’t be at it off faster. It was very helpful to see contributions drop to 0 when I was on 0 pay. You never know what the future holds especially if you are yet to have children. Putting the money into savings would be much better use than overpaying student loan. That said, the day I paid mine off was lovely.

Swipe left for the next trending thread