Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if you have a Student Loan, what is the estimated time-frame of clearing it? Was it worth it?

184 replies

christmastreesparklex · 10/12/2020 17:24

Hi all

I graduated in 2013 and have £10,000 remaining on my student loan (Plan 1). I have calculated on my current salary that it will take me approximately 7 years (assuming a year out for maternity leave in the future) before I will have paid it off completely. On my current salary it is deducting approximately £150.00 each month, so definitely a noticeable deduction. The interest on the PAYE statements is currently 1.75%.

I am in two minds whether to start making additional payments to pay the salary off early to reduce the total amount paid due to the interest. I am also mindful that the earlier I pay it off, the higher my monthly salary will be in the future, particularly during the years I (hopefully) have children and nursery fees will be extortionate! I was looking for some advice if possible and also welcome a general discussion from those who also have a loan- if you are interested, you can calculate an estimate on when you will pay the student loan off via the link below:

www.student-loan-calculator.co.uk/

For those who don't mind sharing (AIBU!) what is your estimated time period for you paying off your Student Loan? Do you think it was worth the loan and would you have still gone down this route if you could go back in time? For me personally, I did a vocational university degree so I would not have been able to progress in my career without it, so I would say it was worth it! My DP does not have the same experience and is in fact in a completely different field which did not require any degree!

For those who have already paid their loan off, has it been noticeable on your monthly salary? I imagine it must have felt rewarding having made the last payment and finally free of your student loan!

I know with the Plan 2 student loans, the course fees and interest rates were higher and therefore; a considerable amount of students will not make the full payment in the time period before it is wiped. I suppose in this situation, making early payments would not be advised as you may end up paying more?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
friedmanadam · 07/12/2021 12:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

UrAWizHarry · 13/12/2020 13:29

[quote FudgeSundae]@ListeningQuietly it’s not rubbish advice. If you have a profession and you know you will pay off your loan 20 years before it’s written off, paying more interest because “P45s can turn up any time” doesn’t make sense. I could see I would pay mine off within 2 years and we needed the income more than the capital because childcare was tight. Plus banks are paying a lot less interest than my loan was charging.

Agreed that if you might not pay off your loan it’s not worth it, and that will be the case for many /most. But not for everyone![/quote]
It's bad advice to simply state it's always better to overpay on it.

Most graduates will never pay their loan off. By overpaying graduates then end up paying more than they would if they had just paid the minimum and let the loan be written off. And it's a very valid point that if someone loses their job/ goes on maternity leave or whatever that they will have wasted even more money if they had overpaid.

Baws · 13/12/2020 10:37

@Theworkwitch
Sorry to scare you. It will depend on whether your old loan has been sold. Mine was sold to Honours student loans. They have a horrific reputation and quite rightly so in my opinion. There are numerous posts on the Martin Lewis site about them and some people are fighting them. In my case I decided not to as I only had 1400 left to pay and I didn’t want the additional legal costs or stress. I am still angry about it though. I’m hoping to start overpaying the personal loan I took out to pay it off from February onwards (when my new style loan has been paid off) so hopefully I will be student loan debt free by the end of next summer!

beautifulmonument · 13/12/2020 10:33

2008-2018is obviously 🙄

beautifulmonument · 13/12/2020 10:32

I paid mine off in about 10 years 2008-2918ish. It was a real struggle to afford the ridiculous amounts they expected me to pay (different calc as I was working abroad) and I had to borrow to pay it! But at least I don't have to deal with the fuckers any more.

Theworkwitch · 13/12/2020 10:02

@Baws I have the same as you I think: old style mortgage loans and then a newer style loan. I've never been asked for a penny and your post terrifies me!

Baws · 13/12/2020 09:25

@Theworkwitch
It was because I had two different styles of student loan owned by different companies; one old which was a set amount and then the new style where a percentage of your wages are taken. I did 5 years in higher education overall (2 the first time and 3 the second time 5 years later) I complained to anyone who would listen but there was nothing anyone could do. The current amount is so high because I was forced to take out a personal loan because they demanded the whole outstanding amount last month (even though I was paying the full amount on time each month!) Apparently they had reviewed all old loans and mine was one of the ones where the full balance was due immediately. I decided to take the personal loan over 12 months just to get rid of it ASAP plus I only have 2 more payments until my newer style loan is completely paid off.
I hope this makes sense!

Nogoodusername · 13/12/2020 09:13

It took me about 18 years to pay off. I didn’t have a huge amount left when I had my first baby, but two lots of maternity leave and then part time hours meaning the amount I repaid dropped significantly, added a few more years onto the repayment term

lurker101 · 13/12/2020 09:06

@FudgeSundae it very much depends on how much the interest is going to be - my remaining loan will charge an average of £100 interest/year (once total interest payable is averaged over the remaining term) at current interest rates until I have mine repaid, so it personally wouldn’t be worth me paying it off to save that amount of interest, as the value of the capital is more important and the flexibility that if things were to change with my personal circumstances

FudgeSundae · 13/12/2020 08:36

@ListeningQuietly it’s not rubbish advice. If you have a profession and you know you will pay off your loan 20 years before it’s written off, paying more interest because “P45s can turn up any time” doesn’t make sense. I could see I would pay mine off within 2 years and we needed the income more than the capital because childcare was tight. Plus banks are paying a lot less interest than my loan was charging.

Agreed that if you might not pay off your loan it’s not worth it, and that will be the case for many /most. But not for everyone!

custardbear · 13/12/2020 07:47

I borrowed around 10-12k between 1995-2000. I did a PhD straight afterwards so didn't start paying it off til well after that because the amount I had to earn before I had to start paying it back was always a bit more than I was on -
One year my salary was 50p below the threshold so got off that year lol 😆
I think it took around 10'years then to finally pay off in 2019 ish it was just one of the billsI had a month really so didn't pay much attention to it, definitely worth it for me

Theworkwitch · 13/12/2020 07:44

Just to say that I graduated when you did and have received many settlement offer letters over the years, but they are absolutely not a demand for payment.

BarbaraofSeville · 13/12/2020 06:53

This company decided that the outstanding amount was due in full last month so I had to take out a personal loan to cover it. I’m currently paying £410 a month on student loans which is around 17% of my monthly wage

Surely they can't change the terms you signed up to like that?

Did you take independent advice before you started repaying something you hadn't contractually agreed to?

I've never had student loans (I went part time as a mature student and my employer paid the fees, I highly recommend it) so don't know about this, but I'd suggest looking on Moneysavingexpert because they're very good with advice on fighting off debt collectors trying to extract money from people who don't actually owe it.

Theworkwitch · 13/12/2020 04:08

@Baws

This doesn't sound right at all!! What the hell happened??

cachedelete · 13/12/2020 04:07

Since 2002 I've only had a couple of years when I've exceeded threshold and even then only paid off the interest earned in a year. I don't expect to ever pay it off and don't think about it- wasn't an issue for mortgage as I wasn't paying anything towards it.

DP (met at uni) paid his off a couple of years ago - but has used the same degree to much better effect ;-)

Baws · 13/12/2020 00:53

I graduated in 1998 and should have paid that one off by October 2021. 😳 My ‘new style’ loan will be paid off at the end of next month. Under the terms I originally signed up for my old style one would have been written off after 10 years of me earning under the threshold but it was sold to another company. This company decided that the outstanding amount was due in full last month so I had to take out a personal loan to cover it. I’m currently paying £410 a month on student loans which is around 17% of my monthly wage! 😳

Sparklesocks · 12/12/2020 22:33

Just checked and I have about 12k left which I should in theory pay off in another 8 years - oof. I graduated in 2009, a decent chunk of interest has generated.

I wouldn’t overpay personally, it’s not like a mortgage etc and it doesn’t affect your credit score (although mortgage lenders may take it into account as part of affordability checks). But as @Scottishskifun says it’s good to keep an eye on it.

I have some friends who don’t meet the threshold or do just barely and most likely never will pay it all back.

Scottishskifun · 12/12/2020 22:25

It took me 10 years to clear mine (15k) I wouldn't say there is much point overpaying it unless you are near paying it off but definitely keep an eye on it and not just the annual statement do your own sums.

The reason being is if you only have say £500 on it and would finish paying it off in April then due to the way they do them in the tax year (all funds have to be cleared by March BTW) they will keep charging you until the P60 comes through (usually around aug/Sept) and then you have to prove that you have over paid and claim it back all while still paying!

I nearly got caught by this and thankfully had enough money in savings to just pay the last £500 in Feb as a one off payment and cleared it before the next tax year started. I would have otherwise overpaid by about £1500 by the time it got to them stopping taking payments.

CakeRequired · 12/12/2020 22:16

Mine was worth it as it got me in the door quicker than other people managed. It wasn't worth it for the educational basis, as not much of what I learnt has actually been helpful. Grin

I just don't think about it. I pay it off each month from my pay, I don't even know what I owe to be honest. Its not a big deal in my mind as it was necessary, kind of like my mortgage. The other loans I have get more of my attention, although they were necessary too but they have higher interest rates.

gillianan · 12/12/2020 21:44

yeah ok love, keep throwing your money away. my debt is long gone and i saved a fortune paying it off early instead of the additional 10 yrs interest I could have had added.

ListeningQuietly · 12/12/2020 21:41

[quote gillianan]@vanillandhoney if you know you are earning enough to have to pay it back and will likely do so before the cut off point, then its very wise to Pay it off as early as possible and save on interest.
its only not wise if you aren't going to ever pay it off.[/quote]
Utter rubbish advice
as the repayments are linked to earnings not debt
and P45s can turn up any time
and stop payments right away

gillianan · 12/12/2020 21:34

@vanillandhoney if you know you are earning enough to have to pay it back and will likely do so before the cut off point, then its very wise to Pay it off as early as possible and save on interest.
its only not wise if you aren't going to ever pay it off.

Athinginitself · 12/12/2020 20:13

Graduated in 2003..I'm not sure how long I have to go maybe around 3 years, would have been a lot shorter but I have only been able to work p/t for the last 8 years due to health issues. Will be glad to see the back of it now!

vanillandhoney · 12/12/2020 20:11

@sbhydrogen

I don't have a student loan (never went to uni) but I don't see the point in spending more money interest, so I'd chuck as much as you can at it. I recently paid off my 3 year car two years early and that extra money in my bank account every month is SO good.
Very poor advice.

The less you earn, the less you pay back. By overpaying, you could actually end up paying back MORE money than if you just let it be taken from your salary.

PreRaphaeliteMotherhood · 12/12/2020 20:03

Graduated in 2015, should be paid off fairly soon. I did a healthcare degree though so no tuition fees and only basic loan rate. If I wasn’t already on my second lot of maternity leave, it would be done already I think.

Swipe left for the next trending thread