Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think London commute towns are no better than Edinburgh for raising a family?

583 replies

JenXG · 10/12/2020 09:38

So basically DH and I are having a debate on whether to leave Edinburgh and move to a commute town outside London. (we have to stick with Edinburgh / London as working in financial sector but both of us would avoid London because of traffic/pollution/crowded streets).

The main reason for DH favouring those commute towns is that they seem to have loads of good schools for DS (4mo) to choose from compared to Edinburgh where there are only a few (or hardly any if his standard). He has high hope for DS. Also the A-level system is widely recognised across different countries (so potential for studying overseas) but the same cant be said for the Scotland system.

My worry is that we are giving up preferred lifestyle for a very small difference in schooling. I grew up in a big city and always need busy streets nearby. I understand some places such as Guildford will have its own town centre but there are still fewer things going on compared to Edinburgh. For example, there are a wide range of fine restuarants, several theatres & cinemas, pubs, etc in Edinburgh but living in Guildford we'd still have to go to London for a night out? I'd assume activities for young kids are more available in Edinburgh than in Guildford? E.g. Edinburgh has a zoo, lots of museums, and a coastline where you can do kayaking. Also Guildford is one of the busier towns as I understand. Some other commute towns are even quieter. So we'd highly likely end up travelling to London a lot which is not fun (I'm far more used to walking or driving a little bit to favourite places than hours of trains/tubes).

What do people think? I haven't been to many places in the southern area. Maybe I have misunderstood what life would be like there? Would you relocate if you were us?

OP posts:
SabrinaThwaite · 11/12/2020 10:02

[quote Jodri]@SabrinaThwaite last time I looked, three years ago, they didn’t make a distinction between EU applicants and Scottish applicants. Have they separated them out? If not, that number of 42 would be a combined number of EU and Scottish students.
Perhaps with us leaving the EU then they will be able to offer all those 42 places to Scottish students.[/quote]
No, they don’t separate them out, but given that the fee income is the same from Scottish and EU students then they should be treated on equal merits, ie the places go to the candidates with the most appropriate grades / work experience etc.

My neighbour’s DD went to the Dick a few years back - she had to work really hard to get all the necessary experience (as well as top grades).

Jodri · 11/12/2020 09:59

@SabrinaThwaite I can only see admission statistics for Edinburgh university on their web pages up to 2019 and it’s combined EU and Scottish applicants. Can you link to your information?

cologne4711 · 11/12/2020 09:58

Also, I feel like if we’re discounting things by buggy accessibility - Guildford loses it’s dry ski slope, surely

I didn't realise Guildford had a dry ski slope. Aldershot has one.

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 11/12/2020 09:52

Lived in Edinburgh as a student and it get very cold, a real cuts through you cold
Overall dry, not really too rainy. It does rain but not like Glasgow and the west coast where it statistically rains every other day

The scale of Edinburgh is great,it’s all walkable. Meadows in the middle. Portobello and Tranent beaches. I feel I’m in a film set when I’m in Edinburgh it’s so atmospheric

Jodri · 11/12/2020 09:49

@SabrinaThwaite last time I looked, three years ago, they didn’t make a distinction between EU applicants and Scottish applicants. Have they separated them out? If not, that number of 42 would be a combined number of EU and Scottish students.
Perhaps with us leaving the EU then they will be able to offer all those 42 places to Scottish students.

cologne4711 · 11/12/2020 09:35

@longcoffeebreak

Just how shit is the weather in Edinburgh? I currently live much further south in the Channel Islands and am considering a move.
I've not been to the Channel Islands in the winter but understand it's DAMP.

Jersey is about 500 miles south of Edinburgh - there is quite a difference in climate. I love Jersey but given the choice of Jersey and Edinburgh I would probably choose Edinburgh (the one downside for me not being the weather, but the tourists).

cologne4711 · 11/12/2020 09:30

Public transport especially the trains has been horrendous with train cancellations, overcrowded and breakdowns for many years even before COVID

I think that is a nationwide problem. SWR was terrible - and has now given back the franchise (it is negotiating a management contract now).

Remember the mess at princes street gardens after the hell that is the Christmas markets Oh dear! I visited in 2016 and loved the Edinburgh Christmas markets! It was right up there with the best of the ones in Germany. I did hear about the mess though.

SabrinaThwaite · 11/12/2020 09:07

There’s about 7 places available at The Dick Vet (I wonder if they still sing the song with the line ‘f the university’) each year for home Scottish students (1st degree so Scot.gov pick up the tab, got a degree already, you can pay your way) so competition is fierce. They are not shy that the market the target is fee paying and international.*

Really? Their website says the 2020 allocation was 42, with 30 for rUK and 35 for international / grad students.

Jodri · 11/12/2020 08:44

@midnightstar66 you are wrong. It costs my dd more to have her car in Edinburgh than it costs me elsewhere in the middle of nowhere in Scotland; car parking permit the most obvious one which was almost impossible to get staying in student accommodation and car insurance is higher. Good luck finding a parking place if you don’t have one that comes with your property.

I stay almost equidistant between Edinburgh and Aberdeen but it takes me much longer to drive to Edinburgh and I go the long way round to Aberdeen. Public transport especially the trains has been horrendous with train cancellations, overcrowded and breakdowns for many years even before COVID. I vowed never to use the trains again after a horrendous journey which involved someone falling down the steps at hay market with a full cup of costa coffee scolding everyone in the area then cancelled trains and finally being squashed like sardines in a tin, standing up all the way to through Fife.

Yeah great if you never wish to travel outwith the safety confines of the refined cultured metropolis that is Auld Reekie. Let’s face it Edinburgh literary stinks with the breweries and it’s not a smell I like.

Get real and get over it, Edinburgh’s englightenment was centuries ago. All the festivals and the culture which I bet the vast majority do not have access to apart from the token craft session or play put on in Pilton, are very damaging to the infrastructure of the city (so said Edinburgh city council). Remember the mess at princes street gardens after the hell that is the Christmas markets.
Some Hooray Henry is making stacks out of the so called ‘culture’ on show in Edinburgh and you are falling hook, line and sinker. waken up. You are really valuing a place to live on the leisure activities available and what you can pay.

There’s about 7 places available at The Dick Vet (I wonder if they still sing the song with the line ‘f* the university’) each year for home Scottish students (1st degree so Scot.gov pick up the tab, got a degree already, you can pay your way) so competition is fierce. They are not shy that the market the target is fee paying and international.

PortraitOfAWoman · 11/12/2020 08:00

15 pages and barely anything back from the OP Hmm

@JenXG hello ? [waves]

What's your budget?

Do you prefer north, south, east or west of London?

You could end up looking at anywhere from Peterborough to Sevenoaks- all within an hour on the train of London. And there is Cambridge too as others have said.

There's Hitchin, Letchworth, Esher, Claygate, Woking, etc etc- all with prep schools or close to some.

But IMO you are being a bit odd to choose a town based on a prep school as a means of hot housing your 4 month old son into Oxbridge. He may decide to be a plumber - and nothing against that but you have no idea if he is academic or not. Your DH sounds, frankly, barmy.

There are some excellent state schools around too for primary age kids and many families where I am only transfer to private for secondary age. And going to a public school even if Eton or Harrow is not an automatic entry to Oxbridge. You both need a reality check.

Fennelandlovage · 11/12/2020 06:58

If you are both in the financial sector do your wages allow you to consider private school in Edinburgh which I understand opens up sending your child to a school that teaches English curriculum. So you could have the best of all worlds.

midnightstar66 · 11/12/2020 06:49

Yes Edinburgh is a nice city but I find it difficult to get to, I only live an hour away, and expensive to get around as it’s very expensive to have a car.
I was a student in Edinburgh in the 1990s and enjoyed it but not so much now when I visit my dd who is studying there.

I live in Edinburgh- my car costs the same as if I lived in the middle of nowhere, and I'm walking distance from the city centre. That's an odd and sweeping statement. Yes some will need a residents permit (I don't) but if fettes is an easy option for OP then I doubt a parking pass is going to break the bank. I find it very cheap to get around as the public transport network is vast and efficient, a day ticket is excellent value and includes the tram.

midnightstar66 · 11/12/2020 06:33

My dd attends a good state primary in Edinburgh. The high school is much lower in the rankings due to the primary to private trend for some in this area. It's not unknown at all for a child to go to oxbridge. DD's best friends brother and his pal from down the road who just went to the local high are both at Cambridge now. It's less popular of course as others have mentioned due to the fact uni is free and unconditional places can be given after 5th year exams. As others have said there are some very good uni's here - did t price William go to at Andrew's? If OP's DS wants to be a vet for example then Edinburgh vet school is above Cambridge in the rankings anyway. Imagine if you moved just for oxbridge then he decided he was moving to Edinburgh for that (and it needed to be paid for unlike if the move hadn't happened) It would be very strange to decide where to love based on aspirations for 4 month old who could take any path.

Scottishskifun · 11/12/2020 01:27

I would stick with Edinburgh any day of the week (I originally grew up in London now live in Scotland).

I would also curb your husbands my child will apply to Oxbridge attitude now.
You have no idea what or where your child will want to study and at the end of the day it's your child's choice!
For instance I was accepted to St Andrews for my undergraduate but I chose to study in Wales instead my choice despite my dad's objections at the time!

You probably find many of the Scottish private school went to St Andrews!

Changechangychange · 11/12/2020 01:18

You would be fucking mental to leave Edinburgh for Guildford.

oldshoeuk · 11/12/2020 01:14

I can't and won't criticise Edinburgh, it's a lovely city, but what you've said does fit the Guildford stereotype and I've known a few.

Personally it's the weather and Europe connections that sell the South Coast for me. Consider Winchester too, or maybe Leatherhead (too quiet?). There's more than just Guildford and certainly if you have the budget it's where the public schools have the reputation.

Also look forward to your child (and you) getting older, are you going to maintain the same social pace? I have so many friends who barely remember what a theatre or restaurant is for lack of time and energy.

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 11/12/2020 00:55

Lol, you’re one of those parents obsessing about Habs,City,Highgate for an unborn baby.
All mapped out You’ll peruse brochures,study school destination,seek out tutors
How Cliched

Janegrey333 · 11/12/2020 00:50

@ImNotMeImSomeoneElse

Also the attitude that everything here is perfect

Oh we are very aware everything isn't perfect. But we are working on it 😁

But there's no way I would live somewhere that I could see no positives in. I feel that if someone can't see anything positive in an amazing city like Edinburgh, that's entirely a reflection on them rather than on the city itself. If all someone can talk about is what isn't perfect, then that's all they are looking for. And I, and most people on this thread to be fair, choose to see the good. I find it makes for a more enjoyable life, personally.

Oh and really, saying Scots students aren't interested in Oxbridge is ridiculous

Interesting. Weren't you saying the exact opposite, a few pages back?

Excellent response. And well spotted.
Janegrey333 · 11/12/2020 00:46

@SabrinaThwaite

Oh, and I’m sceptical because this particular poster claims to live in the New Town on this thread, yet on a thread from a couple of days ago they live a mile from the nearest town 🤔
Hmmm. Call me suspicious but the thread has that sort of vibe...
hopingforonlychild · 11/12/2020 00:41

@HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee we are overpaying mortgage by close to £1000 per month. DH thinks Habs isn't good enough, which is ridiculous! but yeah some men can be v stubborn! He is from a RG uni but I was from the same uni and I don't have these ideas.

Actually I thought that Londoners leaving London for Edinburgh/Bristol/Manchester was a thing! But there are more jobs in finance in edinburgh i think. Its a different type of londoner. Sure moving to Surrey/Bucks/Kent is more common as you don't need to find a new job often, but do have the commute and the season ticket. I still can't get over the idea of paying £5k per annum for PUBLIC transport, its not something that enhances your life,it just gets you from A to B. Plus its a sunk cost, at least if you buy a more expensive house, there is a possibility of recouping your cost when you sell up. There is no way of recovering season ticket costs and even travelling in 2-3 times a week is the same as buying a rail season ticket. I don't think its that great for family life either, having to pay £5k for rail fares and having to endure rail delays. Surely the extra hour spent reading with Mum is far better for cognitive development. Living in zone 5 of london isn't my cup of tea either as you get the house prices and none of the city buzz.

Which is why londoners who like city life prefer to just find a new city where they can afford to live near where they work and edinburgh is one of the nicer cities in the UK imho.

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 11/12/2020 00:14

I’m simply saying St. Paul’s & city you need to plan and hope child is able enough
What of you have a girl btw? CLSG a and what?
TBH It’s a not choice often touted...mmm Edinburgh or London? What shall I do?
Because different countries different lifestyles attitudes etc
I

Corcory · 11/12/2020 00:11

There is absolutely no need to go to England to study A levels, can all be taken in schools in Edinburgh. My children have perp schooled in Scotland and senior schooled privately in Edinburgh. Most do the English system A level courses if that's what you want. There are co-ed like Fettes or Loretto plus single sex like Merchiston or St Georges. Then there are Watsons, Edinburgh Academy, Heriots, and Stewarts Melville etc. If your 4mth old is such a genius then surely could get a scholarship and a bursary if money is a problem.

hopingforonlychild · 11/12/2020 00:08

@HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee we wouldn't be having a child for a good few years and cos i am the realist, we live in an area in London with very good state schools - 3 Outstanding Primary and an Outstanding Secondary as a backup in case we can't afford school fees when the time comes.

But I have been thinking edinburgh may be a good option as edinburgh privates are a lot more affordable than London privates, and we can buy a far larger flat than in London (and can also rent the london flat out). Like the OP, i love cities (and being near to amenities and public transport) but the fact is that a big house/flat in London zone 1-3 near outstanding schools is a million pounds and pouring all that money in your primary residence doesn't seem worth it unless you are actually a multi-millionaire. I have looked at guildford and don't think its that different price-wise tbh.

I think you can be either a town person, a rural person or a city person. Someone who would be happy in guildford would be either a town/rural person. It doesn't sound like OP, maybe OP's husband is a town person which is why he suggested guildford. As a londoner, my perception that people who are happy in the Home Counties are people who really value big cars and big houses and being segregated from poorer members of society (as it is almost impossible to live in London and not be within a few miles of council flats)..

Scbchl · 10/12/2020 23:58

My brother is in a finance role. They moved down to London for his work and stayed in Seven oaks. They didn't last a year until they transferred back and my niece is at private school in Edinburgh now and doing really well.

CherryPieface · 10/12/2020 23:50

Just to say you can study A levels in Scotland, I left school after my Highers and did them at FE college. I then went to uni in England - a good uni too OP - fancy that!

I hope your OP chills out soon.