Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think London commute towns are no better than Edinburgh for raising a family?

583 replies

JenXG · 10/12/2020 09:38

So basically DH and I are having a debate on whether to leave Edinburgh and move to a commute town outside London. (we have to stick with Edinburgh / London as working in financial sector but both of us would avoid London because of traffic/pollution/crowded streets).

The main reason for DH favouring those commute towns is that they seem to have loads of good schools for DS (4mo) to choose from compared to Edinburgh where there are only a few (or hardly any if his standard). He has high hope for DS. Also the A-level system is widely recognised across different countries (so potential for studying overseas) but the same cant be said for the Scotland system.

My worry is that we are giving up preferred lifestyle for a very small difference in schooling. I grew up in a big city and always need busy streets nearby. I understand some places such as Guildford will have its own town centre but there are still fewer things going on compared to Edinburgh. For example, there are a wide range of fine restuarants, several theatres & cinemas, pubs, etc in Edinburgh but living in Guildford we'd still have to go to London for a night out? I'd assume activities for young kids are more available in Edinburgh than in Guildford? E.g. Edinburgh has a zoo, lots of museums, and a coastline where you can do kayaking. Also Guildford is one of the busier towns as I understand. Some other commute towns are even quieter. So we'd highly likely end up travelling to London a lot which is not fun (I'm far more used to walking or driving a little bit to favourite places than hours of trains/tubes).

What do people think? I haven't been to many places in the southern area. Maybe I have misunderstood what life would be like there? Would you relocate if you were us?

OP posts:
Embracelife · 11/12/2020 14:08

"Scottish students are not interested in Oxbridge or overseas uni's"

What???
Scitland sends tens of 17 18 year olds each year to china for nine months under an exchange scheme

SabrinaThwaite · 11/12/2020 14:06

It’s nonsense to say that Scottish students aren’t interested in Oxbridge, Imperial etc - they are, but they weigh up an extra £30k to £50k of debt against attending universities like St Andrews, Edinburgh, Glasgow that are ranked in the world top 100.

I doubt that huge amounts of English students are rushing to overseas universities now either - loss of EU FoM and Erasmus will narrow the scope for many UK students now.

JenXG · 11/12/2020 14:03

@MissMarks

Haven’t read all the posts, but if your husband is concerned about schools- Northern Ireland gets the best academic results consistently in the UK. Minimal private schools but fantastic grammars. My children were at a private Edinburgh school deemed one of the best- but it is no where near at the level of the school they moved to here.
Thank you. Will take a look then. :)
OP posts:
HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 11/12/2020 14:00

Yes, I can see why you’d leave one of the worlds best cities.Because residents who are not interested in oxbridge or overseas uni, clearly not the right sort of people. You need to be amongst people like yourself who fret and plan a 4mth baby schooling via intensive tutoring and the progression to the “right” university

Of course Scottish students go overseas and to RG and/or oxbridge unis. But I expect you don’t want to hear that,as it doesn’t sit comfortably with your presumptions

JenXG · 11/12/2020 14:00

@mangoandraspberries

Currently live in London and have visited Edinburgh often (family there). Have also been to some of the commuter towns every now and then. Also work in financial services (banking).

Very different lifestyles imo. I wouldn’t move just for the schools - yes, they are very good, but I find it hard to believe there aren’t also v good ones in Edinburgh, esp if you can pay?

The only reason I would move (and what keeps me where I am), is if you or your DH could get a decent pay rise and/or much greater career potential by being within commuting distance to London AND you felt that would allow you to pay for better schooling or otherwise advantage your kids. We have looked at moving elsewhere in the UK and it’s always the pay cut we’d have to take and the more limited career options that stop us.

But also remember London life is more expensive, so the pay difference needs to be significant.

Thanks for the advice. I guess for finance sector London always offers more opportunities than Edinburgh. Cost wise, the fees of privates in Edinburgh are actually more expensive than those in the south. I know it's counter intuitive. I was a bit surprised when found this out. Housing is the biggest issue and well understood.

If it wasn't the pandemic we'd have to move to London sooner or later because of career progress. There are far fewer leadership roles in Edinburgh. But it seems more and more companies are letting employees work from home so it becomes possible to live in Edinburgh and work for a London-based office. It might reverse back after the pandemic tho.

OP posts:
Possums4evr · 11/12/2020 13:58

Lack of desire to go to Oxbridge being equated with a lack of curiosity about the world - I've heard it all now Grin
What will you do OP about the fact that your pfb will have very little experience of life outside of the cosseted little private school bubble you will raise him in? Or is that kind of "curiosity" not what you meant?

GoldenOmber · 11/12/2020 13:56

Not saying the lack of curiosity or ambition or whatever is necessarily bad since everyone is different. But that's probably not the attitude that we would encourage as parents.

Hmm

Better move quick, OP. It would be awful if your baby caught a lazy incurious attitude from our inferior Scottish babies at baby group.

MrsMoastyToasty · 11/12/2020 13:56

There are other cities which have finance jobs in England. Bristol for example has a big part of Lloyds Bank's services located there.
The trains from Bristol and Bath are full of people commuting to London (it takes about an hour and a half to Paddington). Both cities have similarities with Edinburgh. Bath's architecture is very similar. Bristol has green space in the middle of the city (Durdham Downs).

JenXG · 11/12/2020 13:51

@GreenlandTheMovie

Oh and really, saying Scots students aren't interested in Oxbridge is ridiculous. Students travel from all over the world to study at Oxford and Cambridge even though their own countries contain world renowned universities. If Scots students aren't willing to travel to another part of the UK, then perhaps we should be asking what is holding them back (compared to international students), not giving them a pat on the back and telling them they're wonderful for not going.
This.

In fact that the Scottish students are not interested in Oxbridge or overseas uni's almost helped me decide to leave anyway. We came from another country and our friends and families are all over the world. There is so much to explore in this world. Not saying the lack of curiosity or ambition or whatever is necessarily bad since everyone is different. But that's probably not the attitude that we would encourage as parents.

OP posts:
HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 11/12/2020 13:44

It’s Edinburgh not the polar icecap your heating wont be in 24/7
Day Schools you’ve got

Fettes
George Watson
George Herriot
Loretto in Musselburgh they offer a nursery to junior school route
They all offer A. Level and baccalaureate

JenXG · 11/12/2020 13:32

@mellicauli

It's true Edinburgh is a world class city. But the sad fact is once you have a 4 month old you might as well be in Guildford for all the use you get of those world class facilities. I mean, where's the buggy ramp to those underground streets?
Omg your reply almost made me cry. So true.

Yes Edinburgh is beautiful, cultural and has a volcano. But why would I want a volcano at my doorstep when I have a 4mo to look after.

As said in my original post, the most attractive aspect of Edinburgh is that things are within easy reach. If any place has comparable convenience and better school i'd swap Edinburgh for it. I don't care if it is the cultural centre of the world. That's what holiday destination is for, not home!

OP posts:
Embracelife · 11/12/2020 13:32

And some of kids from "top " schools do not get into oxbridge . Shock.
It isnt guarantee.
If it is hos path he wil get there whichever school
Try relaxing a bit more

PortraitOfAWoman · 11/12/2020 13:31

You need to be very very careful of what you and your DH wish for.

I have friends with science PhDs and who are very academic working in research. They moved somewhere to give their DCs a better education than state schools in central London. Their DCs rebelled, didn't go to uni and spent their 20s and early 30s bumming round the world, doing sweet FA.

You have NO IDEA what your son is going to be like and if your H is like when DC is 4 months, I feel terrified for your son's future.

You are taking pushy parents to a whole new level, assuming that money can buy results.

Having taught in private and state schools, and talked to hundreds of parents over the years, I feel very worried about your expectations.

Embracelife · 11/12/2020 13:29

It s not hoinh to be easier to attend an academic school.if at three he is diagnosed with autism orspeech disorder.
You havw good schools
In edinbuegh you have same in south east. It wontmatter
It wont matter if he doesnt get into oxbridge.
If he is good enough for oxbridge he csn get there from a ramge if schools.

VerlynWebbe · 11/12/2020 13:29

It sounds like you don’t like Edinburgh that much. Life down south is definitely different but maybe you need to give it a go. Britain’s pretty nice in most parts, I’m sure you’ll find your niche.

PortraitOfAWoman · 11/12/2020 13:26

. You'd either spend 6/700k on a 3bed Victorian flat in the city centre that require heating on 7x24 or 500k+ on a sorry-looking bunglow on a steep slope then stuck for 30 minutes+ on the way to the office. If you want a proper house with 'everything at your doorstep' i think we are talking about close to 1m mark.

Have you actually looked at house prices?
In Guildford you'd pay £700K+ for a fairly ordinary house and in reality far more.

Cambridge city centre is unaffordable unless you have close to £1M.
Even Trumpington which is close to the Perse School has new builds close to £1M.
Friend's house in Sevenoaks is worth over £1M for a 'nice family home' out of the town centre.

St Albans and other Herts small towns and villages, a detached house with 3-4 bedrooms is no less that £700K.

Also, even if your son gets a place at a prep school you do realise that entry to good public schools is via an entrance 13+ exam and no guarantee he could get a place.

Why is your DH so fixated with private education and putting your baby under pressure already? It's bizarre. I'm not convinced you are being honest or telling us the whole story.

Embracelife · 11/12/2020 13:25

Your ds is 4 months old
You have time to move later if needs be
You clearly have funds.
You dont need to map out a path to oxbridge now.
Wait and see
He may be a gifted ballerina and you prefer to moved close to royal ballet school
Or have severe dyslexia
Or may not be academic at all.
He may want to do drama.
Live where you like now and review in 6 years

JenXG · 11/12/2020 13:25

@Chumleymouse

By the time he’s 16 he might want to be a bricklayer or rock guitarist? 4 month old is a bit early to be deciding, or might hate school full stop. You both sound a bit odd to me. I’d rather live down sound , Scotland’s weather is shit .
Yes I get what you say. And I'm fine with him wanting to be guitarist or plumber as suggested in other posts. But surely it is easier to attend an academic school to start with (since admission to nursery/reception is normally easier) and quit once realise it's not right for him than the other way round?
OP posts:
Xenia · 11/12/2020 13:23

4 months is a good age to think about feeder prep schools and destinations of leavers in London / SE.

If your husband is not Scottish then may be the move to London is best. (I am from NE England and live in outer London)

We have a vast range of private and state schools from which to choose here.

TheWeightOfWords · 11/12/2020 13:21

How do you know your child will be bright? I know plenty of children from academic/Oxbridgy parents who aren't especially. He may develop difficulties, who knows what his interests will be? As others say, a lot of pressure and you lose a lot to gain not much (apart from weather).

JenXG · 11/12/2020 13:18

@midnightstar66

Why not stay in Edinburgh, save your money and the crazy long commute and send ds to fettes where he can do A levels (if he turns out to be academic - with that pressure he might totally rebel) 😆
If we decide to stay in Edinburgh, we might well have to go to Fettes. But I'm not sure if that's the right place for DS looking at the background of parents. Also majority of Fettes pupils are boarding but we arent considering boarding.

I don't get the 'save money' bit. I don't think buying a home at the 'right' place in Edinburgh is massively cheaper than in Guildford. You'd either spend 6/700k on a 3bed Victorian flat in the city centre that require heating on 7x24 or 500k+ on a sorry-looking bunglow on a steep slope then stuck for 30 minutes+ on the way to the office. If you want a proper house with 'everything at your doorstep' i think we are talking about close to 1m mark.

OP posts:
GoldenOmber · 11/12/2020 13:10

I think "you have to go to Oxford/Cambridge it is very important" is a lot of weight to put on a 4mo baby in the first place, without also adding "you have to go to Oxford/Cambridge, and we moved to a town we don't much like living in to slightly statistically increase your chances of doing this, NO PRESSURE."

JenXG · 11/12/2020 13:07

@myla1

Hi OP. Obviously, Scotland is highly likely to go independent in the near future (and who can blame them, frankly), so the key decision here surely, is what country do you want to live in? I wouldn’t be stressing to much about schools with a 4-month old. Confused

Having said this, I would move south like a shot - solely on the basis of warmer weather / more sunshine hours. That alone brings a different quality of life. Edinburgh is very austere, I find.

Guildford is Guildford. It’s a nice town yes, But quite a suburban feel. And, schools-wise (for a boy), you would be looking at the Royal Grammar which is fine but, I fear, not aspirational enough for your DH. Grin

If you really want to throw your hat into a tiger-parent-extraordinaire scenario, then please do join us here in SW London. But you will need to get him enrolled NOW into “the right” prep. Otherwise, how will he get into St Paul’s Shock He will be doomed!

I’m joking, it’s not really that bad (sometimes). But if you want access to the most selective independents, why are you thinking suburbia? Could I suggest Richmond, Barnes, Putney and thereabouts? Or Ealing, Parson’s Green, Fulham etc. Everything on your doorstep. Greenery and parks and the Thames is beautiful here. Some people move to Surrey and generally, they regret it or they just get too bored and come back. Both my neighbours did this and quite a few people I know actually.

Aspirational schools for the DH include - Kings Wimbledon, St Paul’s, Latymer Upper, Westminster, Hampton (super-selectives).

There are other schools which take the 98% that don’t get into the above. But do please bear in mind that even an “average” school will make somewhere like Fettes look like a holiday camp. Be prepared to bring your DS to an entrance exam and queue with 1,400 kids for 140 places in the school. Oh, and he will probably need to sit 5 separate 11 plus exams to get a place somewhere. And maybe sit 7+ or 8+ as well as 11plus.

Still keen.. ? Grin

No really - why Guildford particularly?

Good question!

I just used Guildford in my post as an example to explain my concerns on the small-ish scale of commuter towns....It was just a random pick. We were also looking at Kent and Cambridge.

Yes we've looked at Kings, St. Pauls, etc. The competition looks fierce. We don't want DS to go through that when he's quite young. I imagine the ones outside London are slightly better in terms of pressure (or am i wrong?). The other reason is that London is too busy and a bit cramped. Ideally we'd want a bigger house and some green field for DS to run around. But having read all the comments on Guildford, I think we need to take a closer look at London again.

Btw. 1400 candidates for 140 positions is not that bad compared to my experience (we are Asians :) ). If it was for myself not DS I'd give St. Pauls a go.

OP posts:
Janegrey333 · 11/12/2020 12:49

@AmaryllisNightAndDay

And I see that there is one to the south of Edinburgh too

I didn't feel the need to say so. The OP lives in Edinburgh and she already knows the amenites. You can see it from all over the city.

It is very odd that the OP hasn’t noticed it at all. There are two runs now and generally floodlit.
Janegrey333 · 11/12/2020 12:41

@VerlynWebbe

The lack of light is hard in winter. The kids are going to school and coming back in the dark these days. I bet Guildford has lower rates of SAD.
Doubtful. I’d actually feel sad to live in what amounts to a cultural vacuum.